WW XIV - Marvel & DC

Abigail WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

more than likely kilgrave. pplayed 1 card with mond control pf holly and this is ;ast role. real seer...dont come out

If Jake is Evil I called it off his first post.

WerewolfGM

Derry WW wrote: »

Werewolf Gods or GM

When I vote do I have to put in Derry or Derry WW

You can put in either sunshine

Nigel WW

Ah Jake!

My thinking

Steve is telling the truth

Kilgrave is one of Holly or Jake and controlling the other.

Why would the seer reveal so early

Steve WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

more than likely kilgrave. pplayed 1 card with mond control pf holly and this is ;ast role. real seer...dont come out

Or BJ at it again.... i jest bj

Phil WW

My #FFA1:

Katie
Jake
Wendy

I thought Katie's first post was odd:

Katie WW wrote: »

I have already figured out one username and their marvel/DC alter ego. This is going well, feel free to keep making "subtle" role claims

When I said that I was suss of Katie, this was the response:

Katie WW wrote: »

Well you are wrong and did you just make an obvious role claim?

Then just in case anyone had missed it, she drew attention to a potential role claim again.

Katie WW wrote: »

Why do people day one clearly go I am claiming this character. You would have to be completed clueless not to of seen that claim

And I'm bored with multiquoting already, it takes me too long.
So Jake is Kilgrave I think and Wendy's post about not having a backroom seemed a bit wolfy.

Nigel WW

Steve still appears to be telling the truth, his story makes sense. Sure a lynch will sort it out.

Nigel WW

Nigel WW wrote: »

Ah Jake!

My thinking

Steve is telling the truth

Kilgrave is one of Holly or Jake and controlling the other.

Why would the seer reveal so early

Though I thought Kilgrave was someone else, hmmmmmm.

Abigail WW

Steve WW wrote: »

Never thought of that... that would be an epic play... but remember, hulk is only a bad thing if you're a wolf.


Seriously do not get hung up on the hulk thing. Its clear in the op that he is a good rolled player. Similar to someone being senile and unable to remember their role.

In the next movie Hulk is trying to kill Thor.

Ewan WW

Nigel WW wrote: »

Ah Jake!

My thinking

Steve is telling the truth

Kilgrave is one of Holly or Jake and controlling the other.

Why would the seer reveal so early

I agree.
Steve has nothing to gain by coming out as Jessica Jones - and everything to loose as his game ends immediately.
The only thing would be that Kilgrave has him under mind control, but his early posts on the thread really do lay the foundation for him to be Jessica Jones (it's my favourite Marvel show).

I have voted for Steve on the lynch form now.

Abigail WW

Nigel WW wrote: »

Though I thought Kilgrave was someone else, hmmmmmm.

You still think I'm a wolf?

Conor WW

Derry WW wrote: »

Werewolf Gods or GM

When I vote do I have to put in Derry or Derry WW

You should have a thread in the back room to put in your kill orders

Nigel WW

Abigail WW wrote: »

You still think I'm a wolf?

I never thought you were a wolf, you just seemed more suss than others (and Im sticking to that for now)

Gertrude WW

Steve WW wrote: »

Or BJ at it again.... i jest bj

Naughty Steve :P Give us an FFA there for ****s and giggles (even though we will hang you from the neck until death regardless later)

Abigail WW

Nigel WW wrote: »

I never thought you were a wolf, you just seemed more suss than others (and Im sticking to that for now)

You stick to whatever makes you happy.

Nigel WW

Ill post my FFA soon, just thrown by the Jake reveal as it throws a spanner in who I thought was Kilgrave, so maybe my suspecions arent quite on the money yet.

Gertrude WW

Conor WW wrote: »

And also to explain my finger-pointing at you; its early days, I had a fishy feeling based on your posting style, nothing more. You are the least suss of the three I mentioned. Derry is very suss tbh. Wendy still up there

This explains it a bit more now that I get the chance to read it properly. I think I know the post you're referring to by the way. I was just jesting with...Holly I think it was at the time regarding having no avatar. A bit fluffy I do agree.

Nigel WW

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Naughty Steve :P Give us an FFA there for ****s and giggles (even though we will hang you from the neck until death regardless later)

If Steve is confirmed as Jess after the lynch, then his theories are a good baseline

Mary WW

Okay, this lends credence to Holly being Kilgrave if you ask me. Controlling Jake the Snake to come out as seer. Seems bizarre and strangely obvious but here we are.

Steve WW

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Naughty Steve :P Give us an FFA there for ****s and giggles (even though we will hang you from the neck until death regardless later)

Wendy
wnedy
Wendy

tbh im working to pay for my drink so havent been to focused since reveal

Gertrude WW

Nigel WW wrote: »

If Steve is confirmed as Jess after the lynch, then his theories are a good baseline

Absolutely. Even if Steve is lying it could be interesting to who he gives. I'd love to ask Holly and Jake for FFAs too but that probably wont happen

Henry WW

Mary WW wrote: »

Seems bizarre and strangely obvious but here we are.

It does. Especially this early.

And it concerns me to some extent.

Conor WW

Gertrude WW wrote: »

#FFA1

Ok, here's my choices if we were running an FFA today. I'll name them first and present my evidence as well.

1. Jake - I think Jake is a wolf. I know he came under suspicion earlier but this post is just... off. And not villagery at all. Judge for yourselves I guess.



2. My second vote would be for Katie. This is based off their very first post in the game. Again, I don't think it's a smart village thing to do before the munch (now no one died, but we weren't to know that). Setting off alarm bells.



3. My third vote would go to Conor. I know he has responded to this post I'm quoting below but I'm not satisifed with the answer. What exact posts about the 3 named are suss?




So, for easy viewing:
1. Jake
2. Katie
3. Conor.
Evidence above.

It's early doors. You're basically pointing the finger at me because I did it first to you. Meh.

I can answer why I'm suss, I just want a little bit more time. I'll give you full low down before tomorrow's lynch.

Derry WW

Conor WW wrote: »

You should have a thread in the back room to put in your kill orders

You would know all about that alright.

Mary WW

Henry WW wrote: »

It does. Especially this early.

And it concerns me to some extent.

That's why I think Holly is Kilgrave.

Gertrude WW

Conor WW wrote: »

It's early doors. You're basically pointing the finger at me because I did it first to you. Meh.

I can answer why I'm suss, I just want a little bit more time. I'll give you full low down before tomorrow's lynch.

I responded to you after this. I'm still not certain as to why you'd just throw out three names and disappear. I'm not concerned with being accused at all but just the lack of reasoning had me more worried. Once you explain it better my concerns may or may not be assuaded. I certainly wouldn't be voting to lynch you at this point based off this.

Nigel WW

Abigail WW wrote: »

You stick to whatever makes you happy.

Im keeping my options open. Nothing is confirmed other than everyone here are fantastic liars.

Again, not saying your a wolf but from my logic its possible you may be a wolf, right?

Like if your in my shoes, you can see how I may think your a wolf.

Steve WW

Mary WW wrote: »

That's why I think Holly is Kilgrave.

As much as id love to play on i dont think its a risk ye can take is it? If holly is killgrave she dies anyway. If not she is under mind control, she could be a wolf or an nrv or she could be a rolled good player and ye are putting that at risk.

When jake or holly survive, remember it doesnt clear them. It could just as easily be a wolf claiming to have been controlled to get some villy points that they would naturally, and wrongly get, because they were controlled.

Gabriel WW

Mary WW wrote: »

That's why I think Holly is Kilgrave.

The Jake reveal opens up the possibility that one of Holly or Jake is Kilgrave, with Holly being the mind controlled if Jake is Kilgrave.

Im not as certain about Holly because of this, but its all academic with the Steve kill plan.

Doris WW

Abigail WW wrote: »

FFA1
Doris, Jake and Isla

Although a lot depends on what happens when Steve is lynched. Thanks Steve unless you are a character that wins or gets more powerful if lynched. I have one concern you are the Hulk and will destroy us all if you are the first lynched and that you planned this by sowing seeds that you are Jessica and then that we should lynch Jessica. I think I'm just being paranoid tho.

Henry WW wrote: »

Right, I'll give my very loose FFA

1. Doris. 3 posts and all fluff.
2. Jake. See above.
3. I don't have 3rd yet.

What's wrong with Fluff ?

Only thing I would say is if you did vote me out, it would save me 2 hours of backpage reading . .

That said, I thought it handy to record the people who started this Doris fan club . .

I bet villians and heros have fapped off at least once thinking of me at some stage . .

Gertrude WW

Mary WW wrote: »

That's why I think Holly is Kilgrave.

One or the other, or both are definitely Kilgrave. I'd be inclined to agree with you on Holly but Jake's earlier post (see my FFA) makes me think it might be him. Both are probably baddies regardless