WW XIV - Marvel & DC

Holly WW · 26-06-2017 8:09pm

Steve WW wrote: »

Whats that not annon mick? Depends on the rules :P

ha ha **** gg you prick

Abigail WW · 26-06-2017 8:09pm

Phil WW wrote: »

I'm not switching off Steve. The push for Luke to come out on thread is enough to keep me suspicious.

It's ok but you are killing a team player and stuff

Mary WW · 26-06-2017 8:10pm

Eva WW wrote: »

Why's this now??

Nice avatar, btw!

I was wondering the same thing too. Why you abigail?

Wendy WW · 26-06-2017 8:10pm

Phil WW wrote: »

I'm not switching off Steve. The push for Luke to come out on thread is enough to keep me suspicious.

you know that are some serious stats to back up the fact that wolves very rarely switch their vote?

Gertrude WW · 26-06-2017 8:10pm

Phil WW wrote: »

I'm not switching off Steve. The push for Luke to come out on thread is enough to keep me suspicious.

Phil, look at my timeline.

Holly IS Kilgrave. Holly should be lynched.

Clodagh WW · 26-06-2017 8:10pm

Mary WW wrote: »

We are risking a decent amount by lynching Holly but I think she is Kilgrave. Also it's more likely she's a baddy or not an important villager than she is an important villager.

i believe she's Kilgrave too but not as much as i believe Steve is jessica, and getting rid of kilgrave should be the biggest priority due to the power of mind control. sacrificing jessica is a surer way to do that than guessing who kilgarve is. though if we give steve benefit of doubt for now and get rid of holly's erratic posts then it's true we wouldn't lose out so much as long as we still get of a baddie.

Abigail WW · 26-06-2017 8:10pm

Eva WW wrote: »

Why's this now??

Nice avatar, btw!

It's in honour if the greatest player never to lynch a wolf in mu

Mary WW · 26-06-2017 8:11pm

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Here's how I see this went down:

1. Steve comes out as Jessica. Backs this up with a post from this morning. No counter-claim as of yet.

2. Holly appears and claims Luke in a strangely word post.

3. Suspicions of Jake as a wolf. I even name him as Kilgrave.

4. Jake claims seer randomly as well as a host of nonsense.

5. Holly is back and posting rapidly.

6. Jake comes back with the 'xoxo' post to Mary that Holly did to both Mary and Steve.

Holly IS Kilgrave. Save the goodie. Kill the baddie.

Good work Gertie, that's how I see it too.

Gertrude WW · 26-06-2017 8:11pm

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Here's how I see this went down:

1. Steve comes out as Jessica. Backs this up with a post from this morning. No counter-claim as of yet.

2. Holly appears and claims Luke in a strangely word post.

3. Suspicions of Jake as a wolf. I even name him as Kilgrave.

4. Jake claims seer randomly as well as a host of nonsense.

5. Holly is back and posting rapidly.

6. Jake comes back with the 'xoxo' post to Mary that Holly did to both Mary and Steve.

Holly IS Kilgrave. Save the goodie. Kill the baddie.

Quoting this again as the thread is moving rapidly.

Steve WW · 26-06-2017 8:11pm

Holly WW wrote: »

ha ha **** gg you prick

Sorry mick... but if its pulled off Gertrude deserves the credit. I dont think we'll get enough to swap though.

Abigail WW · 26-06-2017 8:11pm

Mary WW wrote: »

I was wondering the same thing too. Why you abigail?

Who

Abigail WW · 26-06-2017 8:12pm

Steve WW wrote: »

Sorry mick... but if its pulled off Gertrude deserves the credit. I dont think we'll get enough to swap though.

It was my ideas you doper

Gabriel WW · 26-06-2017 8:12pm

I first raised the idea of not going with Steve. Happy to change if the village is confident in killing Holly now.

WerewolfGM · 26-06-2017 8:12pm

Steve WW wrote: »

@MODS

just a quick question. If luke has peeked me, is there any situation where you would not allow me into a backroom with him?

Maybe technical issues?

Abigail WW wrote: »

It's ok but you are killing a team player and stuff

Change your avatar please Abigail. You know Tigger isn't playing so don't start any rubbish.

Neutral avatars only please.

Phil WW · 26-06-2017 8:12pm

Abigail WW wrote: »

It's ok but you are killing a team player and stuff

Possibly and it might come back to haunt me but I'm not comfortable switching at the moment.

Mary WW · 26-06-2017 8:13pm

Clodagh WW wrote: »

i believe she's Kilgrave too but not as much as i believe Steve is jessica, and getting rid of kilgrave should be the biggest priority due to the power of mind control. sacrificing jessica is a surer way to do that than guessing who kilgarve is. though if we give steve benefit of doubt for now and get rid of holly's erratic posts then it's true we wouldn't lose out so much as long as we still get of a baddie.

That's a fair view point Clodagh and I'm not saying it's wrong. I was just trying to convince you to vote for Holly. I won't fault anyone who votes for Steve as I was amongst the till recently and I'd see why you would.

Steve WW · 26-06-2017 8:13pm

WerewolfGM wrote: »

Maybe technical issues?

Change your avatar please Abigail. You know Tigger isn't playing so don't start any rubbish.

Neutral avatars only please.

U forgot to answer the first question

Gertrude WW · 26-06-2017 8:13pm

Gabriel WW wrote: »

I first raised the idea of not going with Steve. Happy to change if the village is confident in killing Holly now.

Yep, I'm convinced because of the timeline I posted. I'll be seriously pissed if we lynch Steve now as I am convinced Holly is Kilgrave

Mary WW · 26-06-2017 8:14pm

Abigail WW wrote: »

Who

Why should you be protected? Or at least why did you say you should be?

Gertrude WW · 26-06-2017 8:14pm

Phil WW wrote: »

Possibly and it might come back to haunt me but I'm not comfortable switching at the moment.

Again, forget the Luke thing. Look at my timeline. Holly is Kilgrave and should be lynched

Isla WW · 26-06-2017 8:14pm

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Here's how I see this went down:

1. Steve comes out as Jessica. Backs this up with a post from this morning. No counter-claim as of yet.

2. Holly appears and claims Luke in a strangely word post.

3. Suspicions of Jake as a wolf. I even name him as Kilgrave.

4. Jake claims seer randomly as well as a host of nonsense.

5. Holly is back and posting rapidly.

6. Jake comes back with the 'xoxo' post to Mary that Holly did to both Mary and Steve.

Holly IS Kilgrave. Save the goodie. Kill the baddie.

I REALLY like this post. It's very clearly putting out the case. I'm still not 100% sure but I'm starting to lean towards Holly.

I just have a niggly doubt that we're being led up the garden path by some very sneaky wolves. But there is a huge amount of evidence against Holly. And I didn't really want to lynch steve in the first place anyway.

******** I dunno.

Steve WW · 26-06-2017 8:14pm

Phil
clodagh
ist...
Angus

4 are very suss amd requir more investigation tomorrow imo

Liam WW · 26-06-2017 8:15pm

I've yet to vote, any way we can all come to an agreement?

Gertrude WW · 26-06-2017 8:16pm

Isla WW wrote: »

I REALLY like this post. It's very clearly putting out the case. I'm still not 100% sure but I'm starting to lean towards Holly.

I just have a niggly doubt that we're being led up the garden path by some very sneaky wolves. But there is a huge amount of evidence against Holly. And I didn't really want to lynch steve in the first place anyway.

******** I dunno.

If I'm wrong I'll happily bear the brunt of any punishment coming my way. I'm convinced Holly is Kilgrave. We should not kill Steve as Luke can confirm their identity. No need for seer checks. If Steve is lying Batman or Iron Man can finish them off

Eva WW · 26-06-2017 8:16pm

Clodagh WW wrote: »

i believe she's Kilgrave too but not as much as i believe Steve is jessica, and getting rid of kilgrave should be the biggest priority due to the power of mind control. sacrificing jessica is a surer way to do that than guessing who kilgarve is. though if we give steve benefit of doubt for now and get rid of holly's erratic posts then it's true we wouldn't lose out so much as long as we still get of a baddie.

But if Kilgrave can only mind control once (which has been confirmed) and we're pretty sure he's mind controlling Jake, then there's no power in the mind control. We just ignore what Jake says. Simple.

Kill Steve - get Kilgrave & lose villager
Kill Holly - probably get Kilgrave, almost certainly get baddie of some description, keep villager. Worst comes to worse, if Holly is good - lose villager, need bullet to take out Kilgrave.

Phil WW · 26-06-2017 8:16pm

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Phil, look at my timeline.

Holly IS Kilgrave. Holly should be lynched.

You may well be right. I know you are convinced but I'm not. Quite a few others are convinced so I think the vote will be tight.

Wendy WW · 26-06-2017 8:17pm

Liam WW wrote: »

I've yet to vote, any way we can all come to an agreement?

vote for who you think is bad

Katie WW · 26-06-2017 8:17pm

Isla WW wrote: »

I REALLY like this post. It's very clearly putting out the case. I'm still not 100% sure but I'm starting to lean towards Holly.

I just have a niggly doubt that we're being led up the garden path by some very sneaky wolves. But there is a huge amount of evidence against Holly. And I didn't really want to lynch steve in the first place anyway.

******** I dunno.

If Jake is alive after munch we know he is a baddie as no wolf team would see a seer claim and let it live.

Mary WW · 26-06-2017 8:17pm

Liam WW wrote: »

I've yet to vote, any way we can all come to an agreement?

I doubt it Liam. Some are saying people won't be convinced to move off Steve but others including myself no longer want to vote for Steve and think Holly is Kilgrave.

Gertrude WW · 26-06-2017 8:17pm

Liam WW wrote: »

I've yet to vote, any way we can all come to an agreement?

Lynch Holly. She is Kilgrave.

WW XIV - Marvel & DC

Comments