Werewolf XVI - Star Trek

grumpylumpy

Oh yeah, all this could be for nothing and Q won already, right?

Necro

Seriously. Everything that I say from now on?? Do the opposite. Thanking you in advance.

Necro

I feel like a broken record.

I'm sorry Kolido.

I tried to find something fitting for your tribute. It was either Kool and The Gang or Kaleidoscope.

I don't feel like Celebrations right now. So...

The_Valeyard

Necro, if it turns out you are a wolf (and well played if you are)

Im going to somehow find a way to kick you in the balls.

y0ssar1an22

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

No Lynch – 3 Votes (MrsFlushdraw, Drumpot, Jayop)
Mick – 6 Votes (sKeith, Quickbeam, Beakerjoe, Sully, Kolido, Partjungle)
PartyJungle – 4 Votes (LordTSC, Guffy, Barney, Necro)
Mahamageehad – 2 Votes (Valeyard, Tritium)
Yossarian – 3 Votes (Ecto, Strawberry, Digi)
LordTSC – 1 Vote (PatrickStarr)
Strawberry – 1 Vote (Mahama)
Sullivo – 1 Vote (Yossar)
PatrickStarr – 1 Vote (Crosstown)
Did not vote - 2 - Grumpy, Mick


Quote:
Originally Posted by WerewolfGM
LYNCH VOTE TALLY NIGHT 2


PatrickSTARR - 4 Votes (Mahamageehad, Crosstown, Lord TSC, Kolido)
Strawberry Milkshake – 3 Votes (Jayop, Ectoplasm, MrsFlushdraw)
Kolido - 2 Votes (sKeith, Strawberry Milkshake)
BeakerJoe – 2 Votes (Valeyard, GrumpyLumpy)
GrumpyLumpy – 2 Votes (PatrickSTARR, BeakerJoe)
Quickbeam – 1 Vote (Drumpot)
Yossarian – 1 Vote (Barney)
Digital Solitude - 1 Vote (Tritium)
Drumpot - 1 Vote (Quickbeam)
Valeyard – 1 Vote (Guffy)
SKeith – 1 Vote (Necro)
Crosstown – 1 Vote (Digi)
Jayop - 1 Vote (Yossarian)

night 1: mick and PJ were up for the chop, 2 villagers. my thinking: the wolves spread their votes cos there was no need for them to band together.
therefore: guffy, barney, necro cleared for me.

night 2: lordy voted for p*. he was good. the question here: did 2 (or more?) wolves go for p* to save SM? or are the votes so spread that it didnt matter so they voted seperatley, or SM could also be a villager?
in which case: mahama, cross and kolido are also good.

maybe we should look to the milkshake more closely

based on the above i think we should cut guffy, barney, necro some slack today

the evidence mounting against SM is getting stronger. i said if she is bad we can clear mahama, cross and kolido . 2 of those have since been proven good, but are dead.

SM for next lynch

RIP kolido

Necro

The_Valeyard wrote:

Necro, if it turns out you are a wolf (and well played if you are)

Im going to somehow find a way to kick you in the balls.

I wish. I really really wish right now I was a wolf.

More than anything I wish I was a wolf right now.

MrsFlushdraw

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

the evidence mounting against SM is getting stronger. i said if she is bad we can clear mahama, cross and kolido . 2 of those have since been proven good, but are dead.

SM for next lynch

RIP kolido

QB for next lynch! wew can get SM tomorrow night.

y0ssar1an22

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

the evidence mounting against SM is getting stronger. i said if she is bad we can clear mahama, cross and kolido . 2 of those have since been proven good, but are dead.

SM for next lynch

RIP kolido

would imply mahama is bad. whats her story again?

WerewolfGM

SLEEPY MODULATORS ARE SLEEPY. CAN ALL PLAYERS PLEASE TRY NOT TO SELF DESTRUCT OVERNIGHT? THANK YOU FOR YOUR CO-OPERATION.

MODS OUT.

The_Valeyard

MrsFlushdraw wrote: »

QB for next lynch! wew can get SM tomorrow night.

You sure Digi not turned? Forced to say those things for the Queen he could now serve?

The_Valeyard

WerewolfGM wrote: »

SLEEPY MODULATORS ARE SLEEPY. CAN ALL PLAYERS PLEASE TRY NOT TO SELF DESTRUCT OVERNIGHT? THANK YOU FOR YOUR CO-OPERATION.

MODS OUT.

Necro

WerewolfGM wrote:

SLEEPY MODULATORS ARE SLEEPY. CAN ALL PLAYERS PLEASE TRY NOT TO SELF DESTRUCT OVERNIGHT? THANK YOU FOR YOUR CO-OPERATION.

I can't make that promise. But I promise that Vale will clean up the mess if I do.

The_Valeyard

Necrominus wrote: »

I can't make that promise. But I promise that Vale will clean up the mess if I do.

The only thing I'm bad at is this game. Please munch me borgs, I'm losing the will to live.

The_Valeyard

Necrominus wrote: »

I can't make that promise. But I promise that Vale will clean up the mess if I do.

The_Valeyard

why do some memes work and not others?

Necro

Is it now time for Flushy to tell us who the real Guinan is? And they can (hopefully) be protected tonight

tritium

Necrominus wrote: »

Is it now time for Flushy to tell us who the real Guinan is? And they can (hopefully) be protected tonight

Nope, especially not after the switch

Guffy

Tomorrows munch will be very interesting as the results will mean a few things depending on who's munched.

The_Valeyard

Unless flushy swtiched


Or Trit the wolf?


Yoss the queen?


who knows

Necro

The_Valeyard wrote: »

Necro, if it turns out you are a wolf (and well played if you are)

Im going to somehow find a way to kick you in the balls.

Vale, fancy setting up a tag team? We can meme and gif the wolves into submission.

Or at least have fun while they murder us all one by one.

The_Valeyard

F*ck this, im off to my quarters to sleep.


First person on the bridge can be first officer.

The_Valeyard

Necrominus wrote: »

Vale, fancy setting up a tag team? We can meme and gif the wolves into submission.

Or at least have fun while they murder us all one by one.

God damn it, you are a wolf arnt you?


Night.

MrsFlushdraw

The_Valeyard wrote: »

You sure Digi not turned? Forced to say those things for the Queen he could now serve?

Only way to find out. Lynch QB if she is good we kill Digi. If she is evil and he still alive then we take it from there, peek at a time. He could give us QB to show he not converted, but if he dies we know he is safe. If I was going to recruit I wouldnt chose the seer as it is too obvious.

The_Valeyard

MrsFlushdraw wrote: »

Only way to find out. Lynch QB if she is good we kill Digi. If she is evil and he still alive then we take it from there, peek at a time. He could give us QB to show he not converted, but if he dies we know he is safe. If I was going to recruit I wouldnt chose the seer as it is too obvious.

Well, at least we get one answer i suppose....


Unless its part of the plan,

Sacrifice one, to make Digi above board, false sense of security, bla bla bla,


this game is making paranoid


going to sleep. Night all.

Necro

The_Valeyard wrote: »

God damn it, you are a wolf arnt you?


Night.

Barney92

The_Valeyard wrote: »

Well, at least we get one answer i suppose....


Unless its part of the plan,

Sacrifice one, to make Digi above board, false sense of security, bla bla bla,


this game is making paranoid


going to sleep. Night all.

Nah, we'd sense something was up if digi was converted but wasn't munched I reckon. We'd hardly trust a seer who the wolves are happy to keep alive, especially when the bodyguard can't protect two nights in a row. Think of how quickly we thought he was lying before the lynch.

Necro

Should BG protect Digi tonight? I think not.

y0ssar1an22

PatrickSTARR - 4 Votes (Mahamageehad, Crosstown, Lord TSC, Kolido)
Strawberry Milkshake – 3 Votes (Jayop, Ectoplasm, MrsFlushdraw)
Kolido - 2 Votes (sKeith, Strawberry Milkshake)
BeakerJoe – 2 Votes (Valeyard, GrumpyLumpy)
GrumpyLumpy – 2 Votes (PatrickSTARR, BeakerJoe)
Quickbeam – 1 Vote (Drumpot)
Yossarian – 1 Vote (Barney)
Digital Solitude - 1 Vote (Tritium)
Drumpot - 1 Vote (Quickbeam)
Valeyard – 1 Vote (Guffy)
SKeith – 1 Vote (Necro)
Crosstown – 1 Vote (Digi)
Jayop - 1 Vote (Yossarian)


revisit night 2 votes:

1 wolf and 3 good voted for p*

i still believe SM is bad, so wolves wouldt have voted her. therefore i will not be voting: Jayop, Ectoplasm, MrsFlushdraw

looking to the kolido votes: SM and skeith. 2 wolves?

tritium

Ok folks. To make the best of a bad situation. We're not dead yet. First some possibilities- here are the scenarios I see

1) Digi is the real seer
in this case they either converted him or they didn't. Giving us either

Digi is seer and QB is bad
Digi is converted seer and QB is not bad
Digi is converted seer and QB is bad and being used to buy Digi deep cover


1) Digi is not the real seer. Then one of
QB is not bad
QB is bad and being used to buy Digi deep cover


In all of the above QB being good is not the best wolf outcome - it takes them close but not close enough. Therefor lynching QB should be our play tomorrow.

After that assuming she flips bad (and I think she will and has teed up for this) we're left with either
Digi is legit
Digi is turned
Digi was a wolf all along

I think best strategy here is to take Digi's seer read on QB at face value. Excluding the queen flip he the following possibilities for the following read
(I) he lies villager is a wolf and we mislynch then lynch him - last chance saloon for us but still winnable
(ii) he tells truth villager is villager and we have a safelist
(iii) he lies wolf is a villager - our biggest fear
(IV) He tells truth on wolf is wolf. So basically any wolf flip on his next peek is useful to us, any village flip not so much.

Basically we need to play a little logic game on the next seer peek.

Thoughts on this strategy?