Werewolf XVI - Star Trek

O mama has slightly peeked my interest also. But gut feeling nothing concrete

patrickSTARR

Necrominus wrote: »

Everyone wants a piece of ol' Necro it seems

FFA incoming shortly just home and booting up laptop for the evening

Esp me. Lordy doesn't tho, hes your wolf pal

patrickSTARR

One thing Ive noticed, Mick is usually more off the wall in his posts, Ive noticed hes more reserved

Take that for what its worth

Baggly

*mod note*

Gang everyone is free to vote for themselves if they want to.

If there are 23 votes for 'no lynch' and 1 vote for a player, then the player doesn't get lynched. No Lynch option is active and no Lynch will happen.

Just FYI, we wanted to bring this to your attention as we are aware the voting rules are different in some respects to other games.

Necro

#FFA1:

1. Mick - Something not sitting right with me on 2 fronts. Number 1 was him cosying up to the now deceased Robyn earlier this morning, and Number 2 was jumping all over the no lynch strategy. It's not much, but it's whats I got for now.

2. PJ - Very very suss. No explanation of the 'I am Q. Don't lynch me.' post yesterday. Could be a wolf trying to masquerade as a villager.

3. This is a toughie. I'm gonna go with Quickbeam. I'm getting a very dodgy vibe out of them. It's a real gut feeling but just not sitting right.

Oh. And I think Vale is Q. Which explains a little bit of the 'Captain's Log' posts etc and general mayhem vibe he's portraying. Could be wrong but that's my call for now.

Necro

patrickSTARR wrote: »

Esp me. Lordy doesn't tho, hes your wolf pal

*SIGH* You're going to feel very very silly when it's confirmed I'm not a wolf. That's the only way your theory holds up and I'm not...so... when, not if this happens...

Barney92

Pter wrote: »

*mod note*

Gang everyone is free to vote for themselves if they want to.

If there are 23 votes for 'no lynch' and 1 vote for a player, then the player doesn't get lynched. No Lynch option is active and no Lynch will happen.

Just FYI, we wanted to bring this to your attention as we are aware the voting rules are different in some respects to other games.

Well this means that the flaw in my plan isn't actually a flaw. Not that I think we should definitely do it. Also, people have been against it from early on so not everyone is going to do it.

y0ssar1an22

as of right now i will not be voting, or voting for no one. there is a 75% chance of hitting a goodie. with nothing to go on, and the odds in favour of hitting a goodie, i will vote no one. no point us doing the wolves work

Jayop

Pter wrote: »

*mod note*

Gang everyone is free to vote for themselves if they want to.

If there are 23 votes for 'no lynch' and 1 vote for a player, then the player doesn't get lynched. No Lynch option is active and no Lynch will happen.

Just FYI, we wanted to bring this to your attention as we are aware the voting rules are different in some respects to other games.

OK so if half +1 vote no lynch then that's the majority.

Necro

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

as of right now i will not be voting, or voting for no one. there is a 75% chance of hitting a goodie. with nothing to go on, and the odds in favour of hitting a goodie, i will vote no one. no point us doing the wolves work

I MAY be amenable to this strategy. My theory on Mick is... weak to be honest and it's the strongest wolfy vibe I'm getting right now. No decisions right now though, let's see what the rest of the evening brings us

MrsFlushdraw

I am heading out. Going to make a vote for no lynch in case I am not back

ill be voting no lynch tonight

Necro

Jayop wrote: »

OK so if half +1 vote no lynch then that's the majority.

Given you've said it's pointless worrying about Q do you really feel this is a good strategy though? I'm skeptical. Not because I wish to see anyone strung up. But because we lose a chance to potentially bag a wolf...

Jayop

[Deleted User] wrote: »

ill be voting no lynch tonight

Given the new info we have it makes sense.

sKeith

I knew i was not remembering incorrectly, it was you that posted the captains log.

Necrominus wrote: »

#FFA1:

1. Mick - Something not sitting right with me on 2 fronts. Number 1 was him cosying up to the now deceased Robyn earlier this morning, and Number 2 was jumping all over the no lynch strategy. It's not much, but it's whats I got for now.

2. PJ - Very very suss. No explanation of the 'I am Q. Don't lynch me.' post yesterday. Could be a wolf trying to masquerade as a villager.

3. This is a toughie. I'm gonna go with Quickbeam. I'm getting a very dodgy vibe out of them. It's a real gut feeling but just not sitting right.

Oh. And I think Vale is Q. Which explains a little bit of the 'Captain's Log' posts etc and general mayhem vibe he's portraying. Could be wrong but that's my call for now.

Necrominus wrote: »

Jayop

Necrominus wrote: »

Given you've said it's pointless worrying about Q do you really feel this is a good strategy though? I'm skeptical. Not because I wish to see anyone strung up. But because we lose a chance to potentially bag a wolf...

I said that before the new rule clarification. I think the first night or two a no lynch might be better till we have more to go on.

Necro

sKeith wrote: »

I knew i was not remembering incorrectly, it was you that posted the captains log.

Not the literal Captain's Log, sKeith! Vale has been providing us Captain's Log updates since last night as the self appointed ship captain.
That's what I was alluding to

beakerjoe

Necrominus wrote: »

*SIGH* You're going to feel very very silly when it's confirmed I'm not a wolf. That's the only way your theory holds up and I'm not...so... when, not if this happens...

Perhaps, but I gotta play the game as I see it. My you and Lordy wolf theory fits nicely for me.

Necro

Jayop wrote: »

I said that before the new rule clarification. I think the first night or two a no lynch might be better till we have more to go on.

Meh... I'm still not convinced to be honest. I certainly wouldn't be voting no lynch right up until 8.50pm at the earliest given we have another 4 hours to see what might come to the fore.

I'm voting for myself

patrickSTARR

I don't like the no lynch option so early, it should only be used if we think someone is Q by the process of deduction. We need to take out wolves.

Necro

beakerjoe wrote: »

Perhaps, but I gotta play the game as I see it. My you and Lordy wolf theory fits nicely for me.

Huh?? I thought it was Pstarr's theory?? I'm confused

beakerjoe

Necrominus wrote: »

Huh?? I thought it was Pstarr's theory?? I'm confused

Im reading it as a good theory, its not mine

y0ssar1an22

patrickSTARR wrote: »

I don't like the no lynch option so early, it should only be used if we think someone is Q by the process of deduction. We need to take out wolves.

but only 25% chance of that. are you that sure you have a wolf?

beakerjoe

Necrominus wrote: »

Huh?? I thought it was Pstarr's theory?? I'm confused

Tell me why I shouldnt believe his theory so?

Barney92

patrickSTARR wrote: »

I don't like the no lynch option so early, it should only be used if we think someone is Q by the process of deduction. We need to take out wolves.

I don't think no lynch should be chosen if we think someone is Q. Just lynch someone else. Whoever your second choice is.

My idea was to remove Q from the game for the first two days and hope for the best. That way we wouldn't have to second guess people's motives, we'd just be looking for wolves and not people trying to look a bit dodgy. Slips from wolves would then look to us as slips, not intentional mistakes by Q.

Necro

beakerjoe wrote: »

Tell me why I shouldnt believe his theory so?

Well I don't particularly have a way to prove it apart from stating absolutely that I'm not a wolf. No clue about Lordy to be honest. But, if I'm not a wolf as per the theory. Then... it's a pretty silly theory.

patrickSTARR

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

but only 25% chance of that. are you that sure you have a wolf?

Im not, but if we never lynch anyone then I think the wolves chances of winning increase. id rather gamble.

Lads we are odds against to hit a wolf even if Q wasn't in play no lynch would be the best option to start as you dont take any villagers out.

Lynches kill a way higher % of villagers then wolfs

I think voting for "No Lynch" on the first day is almost always the right play. I can't believe we haven't done it before.