Werewolf XVI - Star Trek

Ectoplasm · 05-09-2017 8:34pm

Ectoplasm wrote: »

I'm open to being convinced. My vote for Strawbs is based on my own gut feeling from yesterday and a total lack of other solid suspects. I thought Vale was Q due to a few of his Trek references but I'm starting to think that he'd play with that a bit more and he was doing the whole captains log before the game.

I am befuddled.

*tumbleweed*

This is part of the problem I reckon, nobody seems to have a very solid suspect with convincing enough reasons to push for them.

Necro · 05-09-2017 8:34pm

Kolido wrote: »

In this scenario, Sulli would be the real vig, shurely she would have shot Flushy first?

Of course stay hidden until all powers are used. Something is bugging me now, Flushy got 2 peeks from someone, guinan? But guinan has only one peek and one comms, where did the 2 peeks come from? I may be missing something obvious here.

Part 1: No. I don't think Sully was the vig but she may have spotted what she thought was the vig.

Part 2: In the current life, Guinan would have peeked Jayop/Trit and used comms with Flushy. If they use their double vote tonight that will confirm Flushy and Guinan.
If not....

quickbeam · 05-09-2017 8:34pm

Kolido wrote: »

Of course stay hidden until all powers are used. Something is bugging me now, Flushy got 2 peeks from someone, guinan? But guinan has only one peek and one comms, where did the 2 peeks come from? I may be missing something obvious here.

MrsF named Jay and Trit - one being Guinan the other being Guinan's peek. Didn't say (rightly) which was which. So, on peek.

tritium · 05-09-2017 8:34pm

Kolido wrote: »

In this scenario, Sulli would be the real vig, shurely she would have shot Flushy first?

Of course stay hidden until all powers are used. Something is bugging me now, Flushy got 2 peeks from someone, guinan? But guinan has only one peek and one comms, where did the 2 peeks come from? I may be missing something obvious here.

Flushy said she was naming guinan and the person theyd peeked. Shed gotten guinan from the comms.

Necro · 05-09-2017 8:35pm

Ectoplasm wrote: »

*tumbleweed*

This is part of the problem I reckon, nobody seems to have a very solid suspect with convincing enough reasons to push for them.

I'm voting for someone who is a half confirmed goodie tonight because I don't want my vote to influence the lynch. That's all I'll say.

patrickSTARR · 05-09-2017 8:36pm

Sorry giys ar the ireland match, who topped the ffa.

Kolido · 05-09-2017 8:36pm

Necrominus wrote: »

Part 1: No. I don't think Sully was the vig but she may have spotted what she thought was the vig.

Part 2: In the current life, Guinan would have peeked Jayop/Trit and used comms with Flushy. If they use their double vote tonight that will confirm Flushy and Guinan.
If not....

But where did the 2 peeks come from, Guinan only has 1. Did Flushy say both Trit and Jay were good?

Ectoplasm · 05-09-2017 8:37pm

Right well in the absence of any other wisdom I'm going to have go with my own gut

Kolido · 05-09-2017 8:37pm

I get it now, I was over analysing it, thanks guys

Necro · 05-09-2017 8:37pm

Kolido wrote: »

But where did the 2 peeks come from, Guinan only has 1. Did Flushy say both Trit and Jay were good?

One of them would be Guinan. The other would have been peeked and this would be communicated to Flushy via comms.

The one peeked is not necessarily good remember...

Jayop · 05-09-2017 8:38pm

Kolido wrote: »

But where did the 2 peeks come from, Guinan only has 1. Did Flushy say both Trit and Jay were good?

Ffs, guinan is one of the safelisted two. He wouldn't need to peak himself. He then told Flushy the his name and the name of the person he peaked. I presume she knows which one is which.

y0ssar1an22 · 05-09-2017 8:41pm

lads, can someone tell me why jay and trit are cleared?

and RIP sully, the gun was jumped i fear

WerewolfGM · 05-09-2017 8:43pm

13 minutes left to vote people!

Ectoplasm · 05-09-2017 8:43pm

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

lads, can someone tell me why jay and trit are cleared?

and RIP sully, the gun was jumped i fear

Afaik Flushy said she got a comms from Guinan who had a peek and got a good result. One is Jay one is Trit

quickbeam · 05-09-2017 8:43pm

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

lads, can someone tell me why jay and trit are cleared?

and RIP sully, the gun was jumped i fear

Same answer I gave Kolido:

quickbeam wrote: »

MrsF named Jay and Trit - one being Guinan the other being Guinan's peek. Didn't say (rightly) which was which. So, on peek.

So, cleared, if we believe MrsF.

y0ssar1an22 · 05-09-2017 8:44pm

quickbeam · 05-09-2017 8:44pm

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

Why are you posting that?

Kolido · 05-09-2017 8:45pm

quickbeam wrote: »

Same answer I gave Kolido:

So, cleared, if we believe MrsF.

Bear in mind, whoever was peaked, could be Q or Queen borg, so not 100% cleared.

y0ssar1an22 · 05-09-2017 8:45pm

quickbeam wrote: »

Why are you posting that?

no reason, just great jif

mahamageehad · 05-09-2017 8:46pm

quickbeam wrote: »

I'm a bit confused by the Strawberry train, so here's the "reasons" given by those who included her on their FFAs

I included Strawberry, based on my FFA reasons from yesterday. I haven't seen enough of her today to change that. I've already said I don't like the Berry or Grumpy trains, I think we're being led by the nose by wolves on at least one of em.

Necrominus wrote: »

Maybe. It's a stretch. But what if Robyn was the vig and not the berserker. They get a bullet and concoct this plan to clear Jayop who's under a bit of pressure.

I haven't fleshed it out fully and it's unlikely but I'm wary about the Strawberry wagon as a result.

No way anyone but Flush is the vig, I can't believe this hasn't been settled yet.

Necrominus wrote: »

And I should add, Jayop would be the recruiter or the queen in this scenario.

I implore the seer to check Flush tonight and if it's a bad hit you need to come out and tell us.

There's a chance Jayo is queen, but no chance he's recruiter. The numbers don't add up.

I'm still on P* for now, or possibly y0ss.

y0ssar1an22 · 05-09-2017 8:46pm

i believe mrs FD, and if she was lying re guinan there would be 1 counter claim from the 2. i had jay as my #1. confused now, with 14 mins left

sKeith · 05-09-2017 8:46pm

After waking up two mornings in a row with a massive romulan ale hangover I decide to put some time into tracking down the issues with the replicators. After over 12 hours of blood sweat and tears, I can now give you the celebratious notice that the replicators are now able to serve pints of beer once more. They can't do feck all else, but thats me happy again. Now to catch up on the thread.

Kolido · 05-09-2017 8:46pm

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

Everytime I see this I think of Vale for some reason!

Necro · 05-09-2017 8:47pm

mahamageehad wrote: »

I included Strawberry, based on my FFA reasons from yesterday. I haven't seen enough of her today to change that. I've already said I don't like the Berry or Grumpy trains, I think we're being led by the nose by wolves on at least one of em.

She said she wouldn't be around, to be fair.

y0ssar1an22 · 05-09-2017 8:48pm

quickbeam wrote: »

MrsF named Jay and Trit - one being Guinan the other being Guinan's peek. Didn't say (rightly) which was which. So, on peek.

does the timeline work for this? 1 action per day surely?

quickbeam · 05-09-2017 8:48pm

mahamageehad wrote: »

I included Strawberry, based on my FFA reasons from yesterday. I haven't seen enough of her today to change that. I've already said I don't like the Berry or Grumpy trains, I think we're being led by the nose by wolves on at least one of em.

You didn't do an FFA yesterday!

Necro · 05-09-2017 8:49pm

sKeith wrote: »

After waking up two mornings in a row with a massive romulan ale hangover I decide to put some time into tracking down the issues with the replicators. After over 12 hours of blood sweat and tears, I can now give you the celebratious notice that the replicators are now able to serve pints of beer once more. They can't do feck all else, but thats me happy again. Now to catch up on the thread.

Interesting that you would use a phrase Vale has tossed out a couple of times this evening when you say you haven't read back the thread yet...

The conspiracy theorist in me is twitching again

y0ssar1an22 · 05-09-2017 8:49pm

i'm gonnavote for a random i think. maybe erecto

mahamageehad · 05-09-2017 8:50pm

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

does the timeline work for this? 1 action per day surely?

That's the best guess.

Necrominus wrote: »

She said she wouldn't be around, to be fair.

I know. I'm not voting for her. She's still #3 on my suss list though.
You're defending her quite a lot though Necro, how come?

quickbeam · 05-09-2017 8:50pm

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

does the timeline work for this? 1 action per day surely?

Guinan's actions are for any time.

Werewolf XVI - Star Trek

Comments