Werewolf XVI - Star Trek

Digital Solitude

Necro you must be on your own list at this stage?

sKeith

necro should be in that race he has been raving about!

Ectoplasm

Well fcuk that. Bedtime for me. Really hoping one of the dead is Q. Busy day tomorrow, we need to get our act together big time.

Necro

Jayop

I did say I thought mahama was good and lordy was pulling a schneaky double bluff.

We need a head count.

Jayop

At this stage do we just forget about Q because barring the Wolves taking him out it's going g to kill us as the game goes in.

Necro

I'd say yes but I should probably just stay quiet for a little while.

Digital Solitude

12-4 right now, to be 11-4 in the morning

Worst case scenario is 9-5 after the lynch tomorrow.

So we have a minimum of 3 more lynches

Necro

Probably need a priest to come out sooner rather than later... if they weren't killed yet that is

Ectoplasm

1.QB
2.Trit PROB GOOD
3.Yoss
4.Digi
5.robyntmorton DEAD/GOOD
6.Ectoplasm
7.Sully DEAD/GOOD
8.BJ
9.Guffy
10.sKeith
11.patrickStarr DEAD/GOOD
12. LordTSC DEAD/EVIL
13.Necrominus
14.Jayop PROB GOOD
15. Micksjaguar DEAD/GOOD
16. Mahamageehad DEAD/GOOD
17. Strawbs
18. Valeyard
19. Crosstown
20. Grumpylumpy
21. Drumpot DEAD/GOOD/WORF
22. Mrs Flushdraw PROB VIG
23. Barney
24. Kolido
25. PJ DEAD/GOOD

14 left and worst case scenario 5 evil (4 borgwolf and a Q

Guffy

Just finished work. Missed all the fun. Scanned through every now and again but will give a proper read when I'm home. Sorry to see maha go, she was (obviously now) one of the gooduns.

Ectoplasm

Digital Solitude wrote: »

12-4 right now, to be 11-4 in the morning

Worst case scenario is 9-5 after the lynch tomorrow.

So we have a minimum of 3 more lynches

Are my maths wrong?

Necro

Right. I'm off to bed now. Probably gonna ease back a bit tomorrow. I'm having a mare. (Sorry mahama..again)

Ectoplasm

I meant 14 unknown left and worst case scenario 5 of those are evil (4 borgwolf and a Q) but I may have gotten my list wrong

Guffy

Ectoplasm wrote: »

14 left and worst case scenario 5 evil (4 borgwolf and a Q

Q doesn't affect the kill rate so no need to worry about him from that point also we dont need to kill him to win iirc

tritium

Kolido is a wolf

wagoned twice

post #287, unnatural focus on Q even by the standards of this crew

post #615, tries to safelist Lord

post #1408, quick to smooth suspicion when Lord gets controversial

should have asked Drumpot to wait......

sKeith

might explain necros hard on for me!

Necro

sKeith wrote:

might explain necros hard on for me!

Meh. I already said I was wrong re your votes. Why did you vote for Mick again?

Barney92

Fair play Drumpot in one sense, but I think they may have gotten ahead of themselves shooting again tonight. There was no hurry. But they have killed a wolf so there is that. I don't know what people saw in Mahama being evil to be honest.

sKeith

Necrominus wrote: »

Meh. I already said I was wrong re your votes. Why did you vote for Mick again?

Are you even reading my responses?


#ffa1

mick - mick is usually good with numbers and his no lynch agenda does not make sense. if we have 10 shots at killing a wolf 6 lynches and 4 bullets, why waste a shot.

Barney92

sKeith wrote: »

Are you even reading my responses?


#ffa1

mick - mick is usually good with numbers and his no lynch agenda does not make sense. if we have 10 shots at killing a wolf 6 lynches and 4 bullets, why waste a shot.

Wasting a shot - like we have done already you mean? There was some logic in the plan, it would mean we couldn't lose the game on the first night. The no lynch did make some sense, people might disagree with it and ultimately enough did that we didn't go for it but to say it made no sense I believe is incorrect.

Necro

sKeith wrote:

mick - mick is usually good with numbers and his no lynch agenda does not make sense. if we have 10 shots at killing a wolf 6 lynches and 4 bullets, why waste a shot.

Apologies, I did miss that. I see the logic in trits argument for Kolido though.
At this point I'm just wiping the slate clean and re-evaluating everything. Let's not tear each other to pieces just yet.

sKeith

I tried and tried to reason to him with maths and odds, which, imo he is good at, but he couldn't see why multiple shots at a bad odds is better than less shots.

Digital Solitude

Ectoplasm wrote: »

I meant 14 unknown left and worst case scenario 5 of those are evil (4 borgwolf and a Q) but I may have gotten my list wrong

I'm completely discounting Q.

25 players 9 dead. 2 lynches, 2 munches, 2 Vig bullets, 3 by Worf

Leaves 16, 12-4

Necro

Barney92 wrote:

Fair play Drumpot in one sense, but I think they may have gotten ahead of themselves shooting again tonight. There was no hurry. But they have killed a wolf so there is that. I don't know what people saw in Mahama being evil to be honest.

Yep. I hold my hands up to that one. My bad. Seeing things where there are none.

tritium

All great and useful but can we please lynch Kolido tomorrow

Ta muchly

Digital Solitude

Barney92 wrote: »

Fair play Drumpot in one sense, but I think they may have gotten ahead of themselves shooting again tonight. There was no hurry. But they have killed a wolf so there is that. I don't know what people saw in Mahama being evil to be honest.

It was Lordys post that threw me.

Barney92

sKeith wrote: »

I tried and tried to reason to him with maths and odds, which, imo he is good at, but he couldn't see why multiple shots at a bad odds is better than less shots.

I would completely agree with you in the absence of Q, but I think that alters things. It certainly did in my mind and must have in Mick's.

Necro

tritium wrote:

All great and useful but can we please lynch Kolido tomorrow

I'm on board with this anyways. Happy to take a back seat. Who did Kolido vote for again? P* and?

Barney92

Digital Solitude wrote: »

It was Lordys post that threw me.

Lordy came to the defence of a few different people over the two days I believe. This one was unfortunately timed for Mahama, but they can't have known they were definitely getting shot.