WW XXI: Christmas Chaos!

Jake WW

Orla WW wrote: »

It doesn't clearly say there is a task anywhere, it says moggi has to entertain the mods, that can happen behind the scenes too. What I'm saying is there's a possibility that there is no tasks, but it suits the baddies for us to lose ourselves looking for tasks rather than looking for them so they may be intent on keeping task talk alive. Also if Mogwai is team village why are we looking to out him in the first place?

We have to find him eventually and its easier to track tasks day by day, rather than us getting all the wolves and then having to go back through days worth of posts.

Having said that, i do agree with your point. Important not to get lost in task tracking, as we have no confirmation there are tasks to be found, and wolf hunting is equally, if not more, important, so that we do not arrive at a lynch without good prospective lynchees.

Gabriel WW

Jake WW wrote: »

Sorry to be cryptic, but for anyone actually looking at posts and not just paranoidly poking posts, we may have had a significant role claim, on day 1.

This could also be an attempt to draw a bg protect.

Regardless, it warrants highlighting and discussion, either way.

I never get the point in half saying something either say it or dont as your just giving info to people who are incentivesed to look for it. Also why try draw by cover on day 1 odds as they will miss

Tegan WW

Ah here Frank. It’s clear you are intentionally missing my reason for suspecting you.

If, as you say, I am accusing those who have questioned me, why am I not casting my suspicions on angus?

Liam WW

Steve WW wrote: »

There was 354 letters in your post.

Hi Steve

Jake WW

Gabriel WW wrote: »

I never get the point in half saying something either say it or dont as your just giving info to people who are incentivesed to look for it.

Well there is a clear reason for doing so, but since you are under a bit of heat at the moment, ill refrain from spelling everything out to you until i have a reason to think you are good.

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Also why try draw by cover on day 1 odds as they will miss

Im certain there is a point in here, but im not 100% on what you mean.

I mean, if you do read my post, i said ah ffs. Like either of the theories i put forward are silly plays on day 1.

Steve WW

Liam WW wrote: »

Hi Steve

Hi Liam.

Gabriel WW

Tegan WW wrote: »

Ah here Frank. It’s clear you are intentionally missing my reason for suspecting you.

If, as you say, I am accusing those who have questioned me, why am I not casting my suspicions on angus?

I'm saying your plan was silly as you were so obvious in what you were doing someone was always going to point it out and someone agree with it. I left it As I wanted to see where you were going with it but once it was brought up I thanked the post that did to agree. Anyways as I said lynch away I know u want to

Gabriel WW

Gabriel WW wrote: »

I'm saying your plan was silly as you were so obvious in what you were doing someone was always going to point it out and someone agree with it. I left it As I wanted to see where you were going with it but once it was brought up I thanked the post that did to agree. Anyways as I said lynch away I know u want to

Wait I'm not frank carry on

Winifred WW

FFS that was an effort! After some trial and error folks Wini has arrived to join the festive celebrations. Sorry I'm late. I have been watching the thread so I'm not behind (well I am a little bit) I just couldn't get logged in.

Tegan WW

tritium wrote: »

Your roster


Isla WW
Barbara WW
Winnifred WW
Nigel WW
Gertrude WW
Holly WW
Gabriel WW
Steve WW
Abigail WW
Doris WW
Riona WW
Desmond WW
Frank WW
Derry WW
Mary WW
Phil WW
Orla WW
Liam WW
Angus WW
Wendy WW
Tegan WW
Jake WW
Ewan WW
Conor WW
Eva WW

Post count

Wendy WW 48
Tegan WW 44
Gabriel WW 29
Nigel WW 21
Isla WW 16
Steve WW 14
Frank WW 14
Angus WW 13
Barbara WW 13
Doris WW 13
Derry WW 8
Jake WW 7
Gertrude WW 5
Orla WW 5
Liam WW 4
Desmond WW 4
Riona WW 3
Conor WW 3
Holly WW 2
Phil WW 2
Mary WW 2
Ewan WW 1

Doris WW

What was the claim Jake? Or do I want to draw attention to it?

Steve WW

Doris WW wrote: »

What was the claim Jake? Or do I want to draw attention to it?

I'm not 100% sure what they are talking about.

Tegan WW

Waiting on Winnie, Abigail and Eva?

Isla WW

Well that was an interesting last page but im still mostly of the same opinion. I'm not sure they are but at least some people think they are less in the dark than I am.

Mogwai for example is a role I would not be hunting openly now as the OP does state that that person is a villager and if they get nice powers as the OP suggests it could be good to have them around. Whoever you are, if the Village does turn on you please use those powers for good before we act.

I think I read about a page back someone saying we had a potential role reveal, who was that? is that something I missed or just not being highlighted intentionally?

Other than that though I feel we just have Villagers getting spooked and wanting to lynch those after them assuming they must be wolves. I don't see too much concrete to go on. Must rewatch the movies this is based on actually

Liam WW

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Wait I'm not frank carry on

True, your posts are very long winded

Isla WW

Tegan WW wrote: »

Waiting on Winnie, Abigail and Eva?

Thats not a bad turn out really this early although I'd hope for the lads running the game that they dont have big roles if they remain inactive.


Just for clarification, your thing was just that you claimed to be a noob so that you could see how people react to basic questions or what?

btw did we have many new WW players sign up this time.

Isla WW

Also I'm guessing our seer knows what Wendy was. Keep that to yourself I suppose unless it is info we need to have, but you would assume she was a Villager anyway given her death.

Mary WW

ah day 1 where everybody and nobody is a wolf

Steve WW

Tegan WW wrote: »

Waiting on Winnie, Abigail and Eva?

Winnie posted, you must have missed it.

Winifred WW

Winnie is here!!!!

Also just for my 2c on the issue, Mogwai reads as team village, he'll win the game if he stays alive till the end game. There's a very slim chance of that happening IMO. So therefore I see him as team village and am happy to leave him be for now on.

Isla WW

The Lynch tonight will be very interesting as right now everyone is classed into 2 groups for me. People who have not posted enough to have a handel on and people who seem to be suspicious of everyone and nobody at the same time.

Steve WW

Isla WW wrote: »

The Lynch tonight will be very interesting as right now everyone is classed into 2 groups for me. People who have not posted enough to have a handel on and people who seem to be suspicious of everyone and nobody at the same time.

That is such fluff!

Just say, I have people grouped into posted and not posted.

Its easier to read that way.

Desmond WW

Liam WW wrote: »

True, your posts are very long winded

Liam can you clear up your post regarding tegan earlier please?

Isla WW

Steve WW wrote: »

That is such fluff!

Just say, I have people grouped into posted and not posted.

Its easier to read that way.

Well usually when I don't have much to go on I'd look for direction in what others are saying but the talkative ones seem to have people they suspect but there is nothing concrete to make me follow their lead at the moment.

I haven't seen much Wolfy but if there has been much please villagers highlight it as we will have to lynch someone

Winifred WW

Not really seeing the reason for the suspicion on Nigel btw.

Nigel WW

Isla WW wrote: »

Well that was an interesting last page but im still mostly of the same opinion. I'm not sure they are but at least some people think they are less in the dark than I am.

Mogwai for example is a role I would not be hunting openly now as the OP does state that that person is a villager and if they get nice powers as the OP suggests it could be good to have them around. Whoever you are, if the Village does turn on you please use those powers for good before we act.

I think I read about a page back someone saying we had a potential role reveal, who was that? is that something I missed or just not being highlighted intentionally?

Other than that though I feel we just have Villagers getting spooked and wanting to lynch those after them assuming they must be wolves. I don't see too much concrete to go on. Must rewatch the movies this is based on actually

Its not a role we should be openly be hunting but hoping the powers are good for team village is a little naive. If we lynch the Mogi we get a benefit, if its killed by someone else we suffer. Not a day 1 priority but neither is it something we should be not paying attention to till day 4 or 5. The role becomes more and more critical towards the end game for both sides.

On the role claim, ive reread last nights and struggling to see anything. Obviously dont point it out if team village but very early doors to be looking for bg protection for no apparent reason.

Conor WW

Steve WW wrote: »

That is such fluff!

Just say, I have people grouped into posted and not posted.

Its easier to read that way.

Agreed, Isla has been queen of the fluff bunnies since her first post.

That latest pile of hogwash has her on my list of suspicious characters.

Not buying the Nigel thing personally, although I see how it could be misconstrued.

I want to hear more from the 'soul reader', Riona.

Come on down and have a seat. You were certain of two players being wolves, one is now dead and you haven't appeared since. So what's your next latest gem of 'wisdom'

Liam WW

Tegan WW wrote: »

If I’m a baddie I’m really making a balls of my role.

Twas aimed at this Dessie

Basically Tegan has to be a villager because no wolf would be so **** is what she's trying to push. It's always a weird attitude to have imo.

Conor WW

Also, FFAs on day 1? Pfft. I barely suspect anyone, let alone 3 people. Pile of hogwash.

One thing it MIGHT do is get better discussion, but.... I'm always conscious a roled good player can get misconstrued as bad in their efforts to hide their abilities. As a result they may find themselves at the top of the FFA list where they have to reveal or die. Bad idea as I said.

Also, role claims day 1? FFS. Next someone will be outing themselves on day 0 with their first post.

Gabriel WW

Liam WW wrote: »

Twas aimed at this Dessie

Basically Tegan has to be a villager because no wolf would be so **** is what she's trying to push. It's always a weird attitude to have imo.

So by pretending to be a new player really badly they confirm themselves as a villager as a wolf would never do it, i mean if the person used that logic to formulate a plan its not a massive leap to do it As a double bluff. I dont think it's the case but if you have it in you to do scenario A it's not beyond the realms of possibility to do b.


Ah was this short enough for you Liam O