WW XXI: Christmas Chaos!

Nigel WW

Angus WW wrote: »

Clarify what? They said it's ordered earliest to latest. As such, you voted earlier than Mary. So again, there's no grey area needing clarification, is there? Either Mary lied and voted well after when she says, or you are lying and voted way earlier. One of ye HAVE to be lying.

tritium wrote: »

Will double check later but should be eatliest to latest for each person

Will double check later, so im waiting for clarification as i know what time i posted.

Liam WW

Riona WW wrote: »

How do we no that? Is it not possible wini was mogwai and when lynched, a new gremlin was born? Instead of going back to the last person, which I see no mention of anywhere!

In the OP it states that if we lynch Mogwai then the gremlins miss their next munch, if the Gremlins munch Mogwai, they get an extra member.

There are hidden roles at play I think, but without knowing anything about them, Gabriel being Mogwai is the most logical conclusion

Riona WW

Angus WW wrote: »

If Wini was Moggy, then there wouldn't be a Gremlin conversion. The only way Gremlins get a conversion is if they munched Moggy. A lynch would have given us the prize, not them.

Ah - gotcha!

Still not sure why it didnt happen last night but whatever!

Liam WW

Abigail WW wrote: »

Your not very good at the game when you expose your self and Mary. All the votes count.

Abi why do you have such a hard on for Nigel?

Do you have thoughts on anyone else?

Nigel WW

Abigail WW wrote: »

Your not very good at the game when you expose your self and Mary. All the votes count.

Cool story, we will see when the mods come back. I know when i voted, also im not very good at the game, ive never said i am, cant comment on you as you've done feck all

Nigel WW

Riona WW wrote: »

Ah - gotcha!

Still not sure why it didnt happen last night but whatever!

Cause he only got munched this morning

tritium

Votes for tonight

DORIS WW 1 Nigel
HOLLY WW 1 Winifred
ISLA WW 2 Doris Orla
JAKE WW 2 riona Holly
MARY WW 2 Angus Steve
NIGEL WW 2 Gertrude Abigail
RIONA WW 1 Desmond
STEVE WW 1 Barbara1
WINNIFRED WW 7 Ewan Isla Derry Mary Jake Liam Frank

Abigail WW

Liam WW wrote: »

Abi why do you have such a hard on for Nigel?

Do you have thoughts on anyone else?

Just going for the obvious for now.

Angus WW

Mary WW wrote: »

I will gladly take a peak. I did not lie

This, btw, also may hint that Mary is the Gremlin that peeks as good

Angus WW

No Phil vote?

Riona WW

Ok

So I might as well ramble on with what i have noticed since I started.

Gabby was Moggy - So thats done

So we are left with

Stripe
Gremlin grunt
Marv
Harry
New Gremlin

Im not sure if the new gremlin was transferred from NRV'S or how that works but I presume so.

So We have 5 to get through - Id go with this.

Jake
Mary
Doris
Angus
Liam

Mary particularly seems dodgy (soz) Before you even caught yourself out over the voting times I just felt you were too prim and proper for your own good.

Jake - Seems like a fool of a chap - want to see him gone!

Doris - No-one knows a doris who isnt up to somthing - amirite??

Liam - Experienced player, Definitely has a lead role

Angus - News reader with RTE - - WHAT?

Riona WW

Add desmond to that - Desmond gets my 1st vote at every point from now on! Total dickhead!

Derry WW

tritium wrote: »

Votes for tonight

WINNIFRED WW 7 Ewan Isla Derry Mary Jake Liam Frank

For temporalicity, I think I voted around 8.15ish. no FFA as I had a crisis at home.

Liam WW

Wendy Munched

FFA 1

Player Choice 1 Choice 2 Choice 3
Barbara Tegan Doris Riona
Angus Conor Liam Barbara
Conor Holly Isla Winifred
Steve Tegan Conor
Isla Tegan Gabriel Frank
Tegan Frank Gabriel Barbara
Nigel Conor Gabriel Doris
Liam Frank Ewan
Winifred Conor Tegan Gabriel
Gabriel Tegan Frank
Ewan Frank Conor Tegan
Jake Desmond Nigel Isla
Frank Liam Tegan Gabriel
Riona Isla Conor Angus



Collated results

Tegan 7
Conor 6
Frank 4
Gabriel 4
Isla 3
Doris 2
Barbara 2
Liam 2
Desmond 1
Nigel 1
Holly 1
Winifred 1
Ewan 1
Riona 1
Angus 1

No FFA 1 from
Doris
Riona
Orla
Desmond
Gertrude
Mary
Holly
Phil
Eva
Abigail


Lynch Results


Vote history:

Tegan - 5 votes : Isla Steve frank Phil Gabriel
Conor - 4 votes: Nigel gertrude winifred mary
Doris-2 votes: Barbara Orla
Isla 2 votes- Jake Doris
Liam - 2 votes: Desmond Angus
Winnifred 1 vote-Conor
Phil - 1 vote: Derry
Frank - 1 vote: Liam
Eva - 1 vote: Ewan
Barbara -1 vote : Tegan
Angus -1vote: Riona
No Vote - Eva, Abigail, Holly

Lynch 1 - Tegan

Gremlin Munch 2 - Gabriel
SK Munch 1 - Conor

Modkill - Eva

FFA 2
Player Choice 1 Choice 2 Choice 3
Ewan Winifred Gertrude
Holly Jake Nigel Phil
Barbara Doris Riona Steve
Angus Steve Gertrude Winifred
Jake Isla Phil Winifred
Nigel Doris Phil Gertrude
Doris Isla Phil Ewan
Riona Barbara Jake Orla
Isla Winifred Phil Doris
Orla Isla Phil
Steve Riona Mary
Liam Frank Ewan
Winifred Holly Jake Mary
Desmond Riona Jake Winifred

Collated
Phil 6
Winifred 6
Jake 4
Gertrude 3
Doris 3
Isla 3
Riona 3
Steve 2
Ewan 2
Mary 2
Barbara 1
Orla 1
Frank 1
Holly 1
Nigel 1


No FFA2
Frank
Mary
Gertrude
Derry
Phil
Abigail[/QUOTE]

Lynch 2 - Winifred
Winifred - 7 Votes - Ewan, Isla, Derry, Mary, Jake, Liam, Frank
Nigel - 2 Votes - Gertrude, Abigail
Mary - 2 Votes - Angus, Steve
Jake - 2 Votes - Riona, Holly
Isla - 2 Votes - Doris, Orla
Doris - 1 Vote - Nigel
Holly - 1 Vote - Winifred
Riona - 1 Vote - Desmond
Steve - 1 Vote - Barbara
No Vote: Phil

Liam WW

Abigail WW wrote: »

Just going for the obvious for now.

That much is clear, you're currently ahead of yourself, but anyways, thoughts on any other player?

tritium

Folks

As requested, last nights results again and timestamp rechecked against whats on the voting form. Please note that the timestamp is with respect to votes case for a single player, i.e. if someone has two votes you can tell who voted first but if bill voted for suzy and bob voted for sarah you can't infer who is first here -let me know if you understood differently or need a different cut!

ANGUS WW 1 riona1
BARBARA WW 1 Tegan WW
CONOR WW 4 Mary Winifred Gertrude Nigel
DORIS WW 2 Barbara Orla
EVA WW 1 Ewan
FRANK WW 1 Liam
ISLA WW 2 Jake Doris
LIAM WW 2 Desmond Angus
PHIL WW 1 Derry
TEGAN WW 5 Isla Steve Frank Phil Gabriel
WINNIFRED WW 1 Conor WW

Orla WW

with that Orla's off to bed, talk to you in the morning folks

Steve WW

tritium wrote: »

Folks

As requested, last nights results again and timestamp rechecked against whats on the voting form. Please note that the timestamp is with respect to votes case for a single player, i.e. if someone has two votes you can tell who voted first but if bill voted for suzy and bob voted for sarah you can't infer who is first here -let me know if you understood differently or need a different cut!

ANGUS WW 1 riona1
BARBARA WW 1 Tegan WW
CONOR WW 4 Mary Winifred Gertrude Nigel
DORIS WW 2 Barbara Orla
EVA WW 1 Ewan
FRANK WW 1 Liam
ISLA WW 2 Jake Doris
LIAM WW 2 Desmond Angus
PHIL WW 1 Derry
TEGAN WW 5 Isla Steve Frank Phil Gabriel
WINNIFRED WW 1 Conor WW

That tells a different story!
Mary and Nigels stories check out.
mods: did you notice this is not what was posted before.

Nigel WW

tritium wrote: »

Folks

As requested, last nights results again and timestamp rechecked against whats on the voting form. Please note that the timestamp is with respect to votes case for a single player, i.e. if someone has two votes you can tell who voted first but if bill voted for suzy and bob voted for sarah you can't infer who is first here -let me know if you understood differently or need a different cut!

ANGUS WW 1 riona1
BARBARA WW 1 Tegan WW
CONOR WW 4 Mary Winifred Gertrude Nigel
DORIS WW 2 Barbara Orla
EVA WW 1 Ewan
FRANK WW 1 Liam
ISLA WW 2 Jake Doris
LIAM WW 2 Desmond Angus
PHIL WW 1 Derry
TEGAN WW 5 Isla Steve Frank Phil Gabriel
WINNIFRED WW 1 Conor WW

So I wasnt lying then!

Liam WW

tritium wrote: »

Folks

As requested, last nights results again and timestamp rechecked against whats on the voting form. Please note that the timestamp is with respect to votes case for a single player, i.e. if someone has two votes you can tell who voted first but if bill voted for suzy and bob voted for sarah you can't infer who is first here -let me know if you understood differently or need a different cut!

ANGUS WW 1 riona1
BARBARA WW 1 Tegan WW
CONOR WW 4 Mary Winifred Gertrude Nigel
DORIS WW 2 Barbara Orla
EVA WW 1 Ewan
FRANK WW 1 Liam
ISLA WW 2 Jake Doris
LIAM WW 2 Desmond Angus
PHIL WW 1 Derry
TEGAN WW 5 Isla Steve Frank Phil Gabriel
WINNIFRED WW 1 Conor WW

Thanks Trit, clears it up. All 4 stories check out now.

Liam WW

Frank, why the Wini vote? You've had nothing but fluff all day and never mentioned Wini before this

Mary WW

I told ye

Angus WW

God damn it.

So the votes posted last night were wrong then, and Mary and Nigel weren't lying then.

*shrugs*

Sorry lads. I'm off to bed. Think there's still possibly some good to come from the rabbit hole.

Mary WW

Angus WW wrote: »

This, btw, also may hint that Mary is the Gremlin that peeks as good

It says immune not peeks as good

Steve WW

Mary WW wrote: »

I told ye

You did, and the new evidence backs you up. Sorry, but until the new evidence was presented to us, all we have was the faulty evidence that said different.

Liam WW

Mary WW wrote: »

It says immune not peeks as good

If immune then the Seer will know they've peeked Stripe, as they can't peek Stripe, thus meaning that Stripe isn't immune to being peeked, and the paradox rages on.

Immune = Peeks good, only thing that makes sense given the info in the OP

Nigel WW

Liam WW wrote: »

Frank, why the Wini vote? You've had nothing but fluff all day and never mentioned Wini before this

Does your FFA table read correct, youve only 2 on it and Winny wasnt one for yourself? A couple of people only appear to have 2 in the FFA

tritium

Steve WW wrote: »

That tells a different story!
Mary and Nigels stories check out.
mods: did you notice this is not what was posted before.

Hadn't cross checked just redid it - will check tomorrow

Edit: yes look like I may have sorted part of list in wrong order - apologies

Angus WW

Final thoughts before I log off for the evening.

I'll be sticking to my list tomorrow anyway, of he Night one bandwagon possibilities.

Mary and Frank are the two names who seemed to did it on night one and then on night two voted with the crowd again.

Phil hopefully can be ignored. Didn't vote, and we didn't waste a kill on him.

I'll go back to what I proposed earlier; Isla or Dorris should be peeked tonight.

No point worrying, for now, bout the conversion. We'll need more info before we can spot a change in behaviour. So my instinct is to focus on the middle ground voters tomorrow.

Don't trust Steve at the moment either

I half expect to get munched tomorrow....nothing of value will be lost though :P

Mary WW

Angus WW wrote: »

Final thoughts before I log off for the evening.

I'll be sticking to my list tomorrow anyway, of he Night one bandwagon possibilities.

Mary and Frank are the two names who seemed to did it on night one and then on night two voted with the crowd again.

Phil hopefully can be ignored. Didn't vote, and we didn't waste a kill on him.

I'll go back to what I proposed earlier; Isla or Dorris should be peeked tonight.

No point worrying, for now, bout the conversion. We'll need more info before we can spot a change in behaviour. So my instinct is to focus on the middle ground voters tomorrow.

Don't trust Steve at the moment either

I half expect to get munched tomorrow....nothing of value will be lost though :P

Voted with the crowd? I had voted before anyone how is that with the crowd