Werewolf XXII - Disney Classics Showdown

Banjo · 10-01-2018 2:43pm

Deleted User wrote: »

Can someone explain to me why on earth is Bounty Hunter still alive if he's a genuine seer? That's a high priority target for the baddies

At the moment, he's not trusted and he's not the seer, he's only the apprentice (if he's to be believed). Keep him around, you can draw out the seer by inviting a backup/counterclaim. If not, the seer is staying down till they find something useful.
Also, there's the risk that he's BG protected, so they risk losing a member.
On that score - Alpha are already at a disadvantage since Magnificent know who one if them is for sure. While they were Mufasa hunting, it wasn't worth the risk of losing Scar. Now... well now Gaston can make the kills and take the risks.

There's the possibility that Jafar has the power to change a peek, which makes him INCREDIBLY valuable to the wolves since he's the mouthpiece for the seer and him being alive ensures the misinformation gets out there fast.
(none of my predictions have come true so far, so don't give this point any weight)

And that's before you take into account how good a job we're doing of murdering ourselves, they don't need to take him out. Ping around him, try to hit the real power and then he's an easy target for the following munch.

Guffy · 10-01-2018 2:43pm

MrKingsley wrote: »

Again from all the apple rules posted yesterday. If a goodie gives a baddie the apple then nothing happens except that the baddie has control over it. After that I don’t know what the permutations are

Again your ignoring the baddie getting it a second time arent you?

10-01-2018 2:44pm

quickbeam wrote: »

Because he's not the seer. Not even claiming to be the seer.

He's claiming apprentice seer.

Belle is still (presumably) out there.

Apprentice seer is still higher priority than NRV

Also I thought the seer was redman stu hence belle being activated. I should have taking notes

10-01-2018 2:44pm

Barry_Lyndon wrote: »

What do you think we should do?

beakerjoe · 10-01-2018 2:45pm

Deleted User wrote: »

Apprentice seer is still higher priority than NRV

Also I thought the seer was redman stu hence belle being activated. I should have taking notes

Thats why you shouldnt just skim as i suggested yesterfay to you, its doesnt help the village

MrKingsley · 10-01-2018 2:46pm

Guffy wrote: »

Again your ignoring the baddie getting it a second time arent you?

From what I can recall drumpot never mentioned anything good, bad or indifferent about a baddie receiving the apple a second time

quickbeam · 10-01-2018 2:47pm

Deleted User wrote: »

Apprentice seer is still higher priority than NRV

Also I thought the seer was redman stu hence belle being activated. I should have taking notes

Stu was The Beast - the original seer. Presumably Belle was *his* apprentice.

When Stu pulled out, Belle was promoted to original seer, and got to choose an apprentice of her own.

Now whether BH is that person or not is debatable (I'm leaning towards it being true, but Belle could also have picked a baddie for her apprentice, so says nothing about BH's team).

Yeah, notes (on spreadsheet!! :P) are helpful in this game!

10-01-2018 2:49pm

Alright folks so the mods must reckon we're up **** creek without a paddle.

I was a princess NRV but I've somehow been activated as Merida (had to look her up) and I've been given a single arrow to slay someone with. I'm going to pick MrsFD so we can move on and so I can prove myself as confirmed good.

Unless you think I should get someone else? I'm slightly scared I'll get randomly killed before I use my power

grumpylumpy · 10-01-2018 2:49pm

Guffy wrote: »

Again your ignoring the baddie getting it a second time arent you?

From this I can't see any drawbacks to an NRV giving the apple to Flushy

Guffy · 10-01-2018 2:50pm

MrKingsley wrote: »

From what I can recall drumpot never mentioned anything good, bad or indifferent about a baddie receiving the apple a second time

But you accept the goodie getting it a second time results in a death, no?

beakerjoe · 10-01-2018 2:50pm

Deleted User wrote: »

Alright folks so the mods must reckon we're up **** creek without a paddle.

I was a princess NRV but I've somehow been activated as Merida (had to look her up) and I've been given a single arrow to slay someone with. I'm going to pick MrsFD so we can move on and so I can prove myself as confirmed good.

Unless you think I should get someone else? I'm slightly scared I'll get randomly killed before I use my power

Who? .... goes to the google machine....

10-01-2018 2:52pm

[Deleted User] wrote: »

Alright folks so the mods must reckon we're up **** creek without a paddle.

I was a princess NRV but I've somehow been activated as Merida (had to look her up) and I've been given a single arrow to slay someone with. I'm going to pick MrsFD so we can move on and so I can prove myself as confirmed good.

Unless you think I should get someone else? I'm slightly scared I'll get randomly killed before I use my power

Kill lord. Barry will then let us know if bounty is telling the truth.

beakerjoe · 10-01-2018 2:52pm

Ah yer one from Brave. Right.

Now How do we not know your Jaffers with a new power?

MrKingsley · 10-01-2018 2:52pm

Guffy wrote: »

But you accept the goodie getting it a second time results in a death, no?

Only from another goodie yes

10-01-2018 2:53pm

Strawberry Milkshake wrote: »

Kill lord. Barry will then let us know if bounty is telling the truth.

This is a better idea. Did lord claim anything other than NRV?

Banjo · 10-01-2018 2:53pm

Deleted User wrote: »

Alright folks so the mods must reckon we're up **** creek without a paddle.

I was a princess NRV but I've somehow been activated as Merida (had to look her up) and I've been given a single arrow to slay someone with. I'm going to pick MrsFD so we can move on and so I can prove myself as confirmed good.

Unless you think I should get someone else? I'm slightly scared I'll get randomly killed before I use my power

Taday yall be shootin fer yer own hand!

(I mean kill flushy.)

Guffy · 10-01-2018 2:54pm

MrKingsley wrote: »

Only from another goodie yes

Why are you differenciating? I mean did drumpot say that only if a goodie receives it twice or if a player receives it twice?

10-01-2018 2:54pm

beakerjoe wrote: »

Ah yer one from Brave. Right.

Now How do we not know your Jaffers with a new power?

You don't. Hopefully the flavour will suggest otherwise

grumpylumpy · 10-01-2018 2:54pm

Strawberry Milkshake wrote: »

Kill lord. Barry will then let us know if bounty is telling the truth.

Agreed, kill lord, give flushy apple. Removes a lot of ambiguity and should bag us 2 baddies. One possible NRV death included as I said I'm willing to sacrifice mysefl if needed

Banjo · 10-01-2018 2:54pm

beakerjoe wrote: »

Ah yer one from Brave. Right.

Now How do we not know your Jaffers with a new power?

I would ****ing hope that with the village in the state they're in they wouldn't give Alpha a 3rd additional kill! Although it is Necro...

10-01-2018 2:55pm

[Deleted User] wrote: »

This is a better idea. Did lord claim anything other than NRV?

Dunno if they even claimed nrv.

10-01-2018 2:55pm

Arrows away. Sorry not sorry Lordy

beakerjoe · 10-01-2018 2:55pm

Deleted User wrote: »

You don't. Hopefully the flavour will suggest otherwise

Kill Lord, Lynch Flush

Virtanen · 10-01-2018 2:55pm

If you do have an arrow to fire, aim it at BH or Flush IMO

grumpylumpy · 10-01-2018 2:55pm

beakerjoe wrote: »

Ah yer one from Brave. Right.

Now How do we not know your Jaffers with a new power?

So kill lordy and then we know

Lord TSC · 10-01-2018 2:56pm

quickbeam wrote: »

Now whether BH is that person or not is debatable (I'm leaning towards it being true, but Belle could also have picked a baddie for her apprentice, so says nothing about BH's team).0

I'll float one theory, and BH, I need you to really consider this option IF you're telling the truth.

We know Jafar had a power yesterday. Isn't there a slight, slight chance that Jafar (the master of disguise and manipulation) had the power yesterday to alter a peek and make "Jafar" return as the result, incorrectly?

IF you're good, if you're just wrong instead of lying, you need to realize that Jafar has possibly thus used his powers to take both of us down. Because when I die (and thats an inevitability now), you're screwed. IF you are good, and IF you are wrong and not just lying, then you're next on the chopping block. And worse, if people side with me and believe me and believe I am the NRV I say I am, you're gone instead. Worse, if you are good, that kills me tomorrow anyway. Eitherway, this info leaves the two of us swinging tbh.

Banjo · 10-01-2018 2:56pm

Does one of us get to be Wee Dingle? He was a pretty good shot too...

MrKingsley · 10-01-2018 2:57pm

Guffy wrote: »

Why are you differenciating? I mean did drumpot say that only if a goodie receives it twice or if a player receives it twice?

Because I remember Drumpot saying that is had to be a goodie. I’m on mobile so quoting is a pain in the ass but that’s how I recall it. Anyway I’ve said the same thing 4/5 times now I think.

Lord TSC · 10-01-2018 2:57pm

Please, please dont shoot me ffs. I'M NOT JAFAR!

10-01-2018 2:58pm

Virtanen wrote: »

If you do have an arrow to fire, aim it at BH or Flush IMO

Well we get two birds with one stone by going for Lord

Werewolf XXII - Disney Classics Showdown

Comments