Werewolf XXII - Disney Classics Showdown

duffman13

Guffy wrote: »

But again... why kill a possible seer?


Ok think about it. If virt is a wolf why did they make the play now? I mean if barry comes back after the lynch and says i was silenced and virt is a wolf its game up for virt. So why did he do it and why now?

Who is he saving from the lynch by doing it now?

Answer flushy.... ****ed if i know why though.

I just meant I'd give it to 7.55 to verify one or the other. I'd be defaulting to Flushy for the lack of other options. I personally will wait as late as possible if we can nail Jafar though

quickbeam

Guffy wrote: »

Again i pose the question.. is barry on a different timeline??


At what point do you give barry to come back before you decide who to vote? Do you give him until 7.59?

I honestly dont understand how flush is still alive.

Qb why are you advocating killing a possible seer when if we wait a little longer then we will have more info?

Yes, he's on a different timeline. Sorry to the mods if this is meta and against the rules*, but I checked his posts from yesterday and he wasn't on between about 2 until nearly 9. Today, he posted his cheese image at about 1, so maybe his absence isn't for such nefarious reasons after all. I hadn't checked this when I posted above, but had, I admit, taken the word of those who were talking about him being silenced, and unable to contradict Virtanen.

So I guess, we could have Virtanen telling the truth, even without a Barry confirmation prior to lynch. I admitted there could have been holes in getting my head around the whole thing, as it's a mindfúck as I think we'll all agree.

So, no decisions yet, until closer to the lynch and make the decision then?? But it'd have to be one of Virtanen, Banjo and MrsFlush, right?

*I'll take the slap on the wrist now mods, if I was out of line here.

Necro

quickbeam wrote: »

Yes, he's on a different timeline. Sorry to the mods if this is meta and against the rules*, but I checked his posts from yesterday and he wasn't on between about 2 until nearly 9. Today, he posted his cheese image at about 1, so maybe his absence isn't for such nefarious reasons after all. I hadn't checked this when I posted above, but had, I admit, taken the word of those who were talking about him being silenced, and unable to contradict Virtanen.

So I guess, we could have Virtanen telling the truth, even without a Barry confirmation prior to lynch. I admitted there could have been holes in getting my head around the whole thing, as it's a mindfúck as I think we'll all agree.

So, no decisions yet, until closer to the lynch and make the decision then?? But it'd have to be one of Virtanen, Banjo and MrsFlush, right?

*I'll take the slap on the wrist now mods, if I was out of line here.

quickbeam

WRIST I said, Necro! FFS, not the face. Anything but the face!!!!!!

Arabtinian

Whoah eventful afternoon while i was workin!
Where did the arrows come outa or were they jus gifted lately?

At least thats one baddie got. Now to push on and get another

beakerjoe

quickbeam wrote: »

Okay, let me get my head around this...

PJ shot Lordy because Bounty Hunter, Belle's apprentice said Lordy was Jafar. Lordy is evil for sure, but may or may not be Jafar. Only Barry can confirm this.

Meanwhile, across town ... Virtanen comes out as Belle and says that Lordy wasn't Jafar but Banjo is. *If* Virtanen is telling the truth this means that Banjo is Jafar and Bounty Hunter is, at best, mistaken about Lordy being Jafar, and at worst, lying about Lordy being Jafar.

The theory now being that only Barry can confirm or deny whether Virtanen is right about Lordy being Jafar. But Barry has been MIA so (still the theory) silenced by Virtanen's team so he can't counter the Lordy /= Jafar claim. Only the Alpha Males have the power to silence a player, so Virtanen, in this scenario would be on that team?

So am I right in saying that if Barry doesn't make an appearance before lynch, then it proves Virtanen as a wolf, and we should lynch him?

But if Barry does does turn up, well then there's two other scenarios ...
(1) he confirms that Lordy /= Jafar therefore Banjo would have to be Jafar and we lynch him, or;
(2) he confirms that Lordy = Jafar therefore Virtanen is lying, so we lynch Virtanen - this seems improbable to me though. Virtanen, to make his claim must either know that Barry will confirm his claim, or know that Barry won't turn up to deny his claim.

Meanwhile we have MrsFlush dying to be killed! I am still very much leaning towards her being a wolf, but there is a small possibility that she really is Hercules. Her question of: "why hasn't the real Hercules counter claimed then?" is moot though since Hercules is still best to stay hidden regardless of MrsFlush's posts.

My theory is, as there's the off chance MrsFlush is a goodie, we go with the option of lynching Virtanen or Banjo depending on whether Barry turns up and/or confirms the stories.

Have I gathered the scenario right? It was a bit of a nightmare getting the head around it on catch up!

If barry doesnt appear it could be just because he hasnt managed to get online. Lete not assume anything yet. I think hes on a different timezone.

Necro

quickbeam wrote: »

WRIST I said, Necro! FFS, not the face. Anything but the face!!!!!!

Ok, I'm done

beakerjoe

Arabtinian wrote: »

Whoah eventful afternoon while i was workin!
Where did the arrows come outa or were they jus gifted lately?

At least thats one baddie got. Now to push on and get another

Push on..... you havent done much yet pal. Youve barely been posting

MrKingsley

Right I think Im going with old Flushy meadows.

Ill be offline from 7 onwards.

whilst I do want to believe Virt (and banjo for that matter but its impossible) there is one thing that I really cant get over. I wont bring it up until after the lynch though

Barry_Lyndon

beakerjoe wrote: »

If barry doesnt appear it could be just because he hasnt managed to get online. Lete not assume anything yet. I think hes on a different timezone.

Hello. Whats up?

Guffy

Barry_Lyndon wrote: »

Hello. Whats up?

Lol

Was lord jafar?

Barry_Lyndon

I’m skimming
Lord is Malificient

Arabtinian

Arabtinian wrote: »

Whoah eventful afternoon while i was workin!
Where did the arrows come outa or were they jus gifted lately?

At least thats one baddie got. Now to push on and get another

Honestly, no idea how I was activated. It could have been a balancing measure by the mods

MrKingsley

duffman13

Barry_Lyndon wrote: »

I’m skimming
Lord is Malificient

Serious, fook so BH was lying! Thank **** you came back

Guffy

Virt is seer
Kill banjo then so as not to allow jafar live?

duffman13

Guffy wrote: »

Virt is seer
Kill banjo then so as not to allow jafar live?

That's my read of it

Arabtinian

beakerjoe wrote: »

Push on..... you havent done much yet pal. Youve barely been posting

Just lurking in the background with my evil comrades!

Barry_Lyndon

Bounty Hunter wrote: »

I think the story with Mick is that he died as a Lion but was peeked as a NRV princess before he became that character, I was not an apprentice at that stage though.

I was told LTSC, I relayed that, he died, he was evil, he should be revealed as Jafar but without the reveal I guess this Virt stuff is super suss even if I don't like MsFMulan slip by as others let her slip into the background.

This is strange I need more info on this.

beakerjoe

Barry_Lyndon wrote: »

I’m skimming
Lord is Malificient

Now business is picking up....

Arabtinian

[Deleted User] wrote: »

Honestly, no idea how I was activated. It could have been a balancing measure by the mods

Ah ok. Wel good decision on the shot. And now barry is back. Should make for a clearer decision lynch wise

Barry_Lyndon

Bounty hunter is evil? Ermaghad

So we have BH, MrsFD and Banjo all for the gallows?

Barry_Lyndon

Id say Banjo is Jafar me and Aladdin suspected this for a while.

beakerjoe

Barry_Lyndon wrote: »

Bounty hunter is evil? Ermaghad

I think i owe you a coke

Changing my vote to Banjo to confirm vet's story

Something is still not adding up.

beakerjoe

Vote changer from Flush to Banjo.

Flush gets the apple tonight and BH is next for the chop. Am i right.....

MrKingsley

Strawberry Milkshake wrote: »

Something is still not adding up.

Whats that?

beakerjoe

Strawberry Milkshake wrote: »

Something is still not adding up.

My ears are open....