Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Cold feet or normal worries?

  • 17-05-2018 2:36pm
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭


    Hi All,

    I'll try and get to the point quickly! So I'm getting married in a few months and I am over the moon about it. My fiancé is a wonderful guy; he's kind, caring, and just in general a really good guy. My family all think he's great and I've made a really good decision. We’re together 6 years and have lived together for most of that.

    I don't know if I am genuinely getting cold feet or if these feeling are normal as the wedding approaches. I had to move 3 hours away from my home town for him, as he is a farmer. It’s a very small place and I haven’t made any friends a few acquaintances. So I am worried I will feel isolated in this tiny farming community for the rest of my life.

    I am also worried that my fiancé has invested so much time and he is mad to have a baby that he is willing to just go ahead with the wedding. He wants me to time it so that I am off the pill for the honeymoon; he said he doesn’t want to be in his 40s starting out family. I have actually asked him this and he said no he’s marrying me because he loves me.

    Last year I made up a list of things to do on Sundays that I would like to do. We haven’t done a single one. When we meet I was huge into backpacking I love to travel it’s my biggest passion in life. I nearly think I’ve travelled too much and that’s why I can’t settle into domestic life? I love to go and do things and see things but he never wants to go with me. I know I can go alone but I don’t want to spend all my life doing everything alone!

    I just feel that he doesn’t really want to put in an extra effort sometimes. A few weeks ago I had to go home for a family emergency during the week I asked him to come down the Saturday evening for the night as I needed his support. He said he was too tired. I know he works really hard but I feel I will always come 2nd. He hardly ever comes to my family occasions at one point last year a family member joked had we broken up.

    I don’t really know what to do. I love him to pieces and I know he loves me. I know he’s a farmer so I cannot honestly expect him to move even though I would love to go off to Canada or UAE for a year or two. Are these just normal feelings for when you come into your 30s and life starts to change?

    Thanks for reading.


«1

Comments

  • Registered Users Posts: 1,303 ✭✭✭daithi7


    Sounds more than just cold feet to me OP. But then reading your post, I think in you know this too....

    I'll leave the women advise you here, but not engaging in your passions (back packing, travel), not doing any of the things you listed last year, not attending family events/emergencies when asked , etc are all red lines imho.

    Good luck with whatever you decide.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 710 ✭✭✭ginandtonicsky


    I'm afraid you're going to have to have an honest full-disclosure conversation with your fiancé and work through these concerns together as a couple.

    I don't think they're necessarily tied into any real lack of desire you have to marry him or any lack of love on your part; planning a wedding and the rest of your life just forces you to think about these things naturally enough.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,528 ✭✭✭ShaShaBear


    I don't doubt for a second that he loves you, but it does sound like he is getting everything he wants and you're giving up everything to make the marriage work. Especially the rushing of a pregnancy. I know a few girls in long-term relationships with farmers and most of them have had to fully accept that they're "widows" for the better part of the year. However, in saying that, all of them have a very good support network of friends and family a stone's throw away to keep them sane, help with kids and keep the social life alive. Moving so far away with no friends made and potentially already pregnant could leave you very isolated and miserable, since you might likely not see your husband dawn till dusk on a busy day :(
    You both need to sit down and have a very serious discussion about this. Make sure you are heard and your concerns alleviated to your complete satisfaction before you go through with this wedding. If you have to cancel, so be it. If you both need more time to find a balance, it's okay to postpone it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,812 ✭✭✭Addle


    Are you from a farming background yourself OP?
    Cos you'll never 'get it' if you aren't.
    It's a whole different way of life, with more commitments than any self employment.
    Life will revolve around the farm.
    Are you willing to put up with that?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 421 ✭✭banoffe2


    I admire your awareness and honesty OP, you have plenty experience of living with this man. People don't change unless they want to, and we shouldn't feel the need to want to change anyone, however your expectations are reasonable, if he is making no effort during the courtship I'd hate to imagine how things will be down the road, when you are home alone with a small baby, it could be a very lonely existence.
    Personally I wouldn't waste time sitting down and having the chat about the expectations, you have done this before and you know the results.

    Remember you have choices, look after yourself, it takes courage to be true to yourself. Best of luck


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,584 ✭✭✭Rekop dog


    There's a strong juxtaposition between your opening paragraph and the actual realisites of the relationship in the rest of post. He's doesn't sound caring whatsoever, selfish and controlling from what I can see.

    To blatantly ignore the list you went to the effort of making of things you'd like to do on a Sunday would suggest he doesn't respect you very much. Most healthy relationships involve people being attentive of their partners wants and needs and trying to keep them happy. He's doesn't even begin to bother on this front from what you say. And I wouldn't be all that sure your family are overly fond of him either, if they're making jokes to you about him never being around you can be sure they're saying worse behind your back.

    You can continue to bury your head in the sand that this will work and excuse all his actions because thats the way farming life is, but sounds like you're committing to a miserable life where you can't possibly be happy and you'll have to park the more adventurous side of your personality for good. You sound a bit trapped and suffocated to me, and that's only going to get much worse once the wedding high subsides and the real realities of having this extremely plain life forever set in.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    Thanks for the responses.

    No I am not from a farming background, I'm for a mid sized town. I do get that farming is life. But it's dry stock so whilst calving and silage are very busy it's not as full on as milking lets say. We could easily go do something for the day. The problem is that he doesn't earn a wage from the farm so he works full time too. It was grand until he went out on his own, so now between the farm and his business I hardly ever see him. Which kinda sucks because I work for the most part in an office by myself and come home then to an empty house.

    It makes me sound selfish. Giving out that he works too hard!

    I love when we do go somewhere for the weekend though or on holidays we always have such a laugh together.

    I think this would be a whole lot easier if it was closer to home. I am from a very big extended family and we are all very close. I hate missing out on what feels like everything (bit dramatic!) I go down for the bigger things, but my nephews 5th birthday on a Sunday for a few hours no, I'm not going to do a 6 hour round trip.

    I guess my choices are leave, and be miserable because I miss him and know that he is the right man for me. Or stay and get used to being lonely but get to be really happy some of the time.


  • Registered Users Posts: 684 ✭✭✭zapper55


    Actually you've two more. Have an honest chat and see if things do actually change or leave and maybe meet someone you are more compatible with. I don't say this lightly. But it sounds like you'd have to.do a huge amount of compromise if you stay with this man and things stay as is.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,690 ✭✭✭Mokuba


    Rekop dog wrote: »
    There's a strong juxtaposition between your opening paragraph and the actual realisites of the relationship in the rest of post. He's doesn't sound caring whatsoever, selfish and controlling from what I can see.

    To blatantly ignore the list you went to the effort of making of things you'd like to do on a Sunday would suggest he doesn't respect you very much. Most healthy relationships involve people being attentive of their partners wants and needs and trying to keep them happy. He's doesn't even begin to bother on this front from what you say. And I wouldn't be all that sure your family are overly fond of him either, if they're making jokes to you about him never being around you can be sure they're saying worse behind your back.

    You can continue to bury your head in the sand that this will work and excuse all his actions because thats the way farming life is, but sounds like you're committing to a miserable life where you can't possibly be happy and you'll have to park the more adventurous side of your personality for good. You sound a bit trapped and suffocated to me, and that's only going to get much worse once the wedding high subsides and the real realities of having this extremely plain life forever set in.

    This is such rubbish. Selfish and Controlling? What utter, utter nonsense.

    Have you any idea about the insane hours and work involved in running a farm and holding a full time job also?

    This guy is running himself into the ground trying to support this woman and a potential future family.

    People often make lists and not follow through on them. That's life. Things get in the way. Go and look at New Years resolution threads and see how many people have followed through on them.

    OP - Why are you surprised that a farmer can't travel the world with you. The farm won't run itself. It's not like another job where you can just expect the work to be covered in your absence - if the work isn't done by him it won't be done. You have said you have went on holidays - so plan it out far enough in advance, with reasonable time frames and I bet there won't be an issue.

    If you want to travel then travel. But don't act like he is holding you back. You surely knew what you were signing up for. It is a very specific way of life.

    You seem to not have too many hobbies of your own. You seem overly reliant on him to do things with.

    I've seen this before and I know where this is going. It's only going to get worse for you and he doesn't deserve your resentment.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,584 ✭✭✭Rekop dog


    Mokuba wrote: »
    This is such rubbish. Selfish and Controlling? What utter, utter nonsense.

    Have you any idea about the insane hours and work involved in running a farm and holding a full time job also?

    This guy is running himself into the ground trying to support this woman and a potential future family.

    People often make lists and not follow through on them. That's life. Things get in the way. Go and look at New Years resolution threads and see how many people have followed through on them.

    .

    The part about him wanting her off the pill by the honeymoon sounds controlling, it's seems like a one way decision from how she's worded it.

    And the second job was only mentioned after my post but I can't see the point in having the farm at all if it's not financially viable to be honest. His time would be far better spent getting an education and a better job to sustain his potential family and he'd also have more time for them then. It seems a miserable existence working all the hours under the sun to scrape by and not having the energy/enthusiasm to do anything else.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 889 ✭✭✭messy tessy


    Rekop dog wrote: »
    I can't see the point in having the farm at all if it's not financially viable to be honest. His time would be far better spent getting an education and a better job to sustain his potential family and he'd also have more time for them then. It seems a miserable existence working all the hours under the sun to scrape by and not having the energy/enthusiasm to do anything else.

    I think unless you are brought up on a farm or have a genuine interest in it, it is very difficult to understand the attachment to the land. You don't know that the OP's partner has a miserable existence, he might genuinely adore farming.

    I agree you need to have a chat with him about what you are feeling. I don't get the feeling he is controlling but you do sound lonely. Did I read your post right - you have lived in that area for 6 years without making any friends?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    I 100% know that he can not just pack up and leave and I wouldn't expect him too I was just saying that's what I'd be at if there were no restraints. He didn't live/ work on the farm the 1st year and a half we meet travelling. I'm not looking to move to Aruba and run a cafe. I want to go do something no more than an hour away on a Sunday or the cinema on a Saturday.

    He is not controlling at all I think he's just mad to be a dad and I think he'll be amazing at it.

    Yes I do rely on him a lot, I've tried making friends up here when. It's hard though it's a small place and I've joined one or two classes I've been trying to look up local hobby groups but unless you can play gaelic football there really doesn't seem to be much. Just the boss at work. I'm an outgoing, friendly person so I'll keep trying. I guess that's why I was asking is it a '30s thing' making new friends is harder.

    We had a big conversation tonight. He said he's feeling very stretched and that something would have to give. It definitely wouldn't be me, it couldn't be the farm so it will have to be the business. He's running himself into the ground he's doing mad hours the main lad he does work for expects him to be available at the drop of a hat.

    I know his dream would be to be a full time farmer and I fully back that. It's a fairly sizable herd at the moment it wouldn't need to go much bigger for there to be a livable wage once he does inherit it.

    Thanks everyone for the advice I think we have gotten to the core of what is going on here and hopefully he can find a more regular job because even though he doesn't get a wage off the farm he does a decent amount of work and he cannot keep going at the rate he's going.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,951 ✭✭✭dixiefly


    I don't think that any individual issue in itself is a red flag. However its the combination of all of the issues that you highlight that would be a real concern.

    Myself and my wife are over 25 years married and we are different people with different interests in many ways. However, and I have thought of this several times, the key in our marriage has been an ability of both of us to compromise with a sense of the others needs being kept in our minds.

    I am not from a farming background but the family had a business until recent years and I understand the ongoing committment to it with no financial reward. That ingrained bond to the farm is there in all farmers and is laudable and must be accepted by anyone marrying in. However, there needs to be some facility investigated to arrange relief so that he can go with you to places and family events. He needs to compromise and arrange (and pay for) this.

    From your own point of view, you need to think through whether you will be able to build up a support network in the area around where you are living. Are other farmer's partners friendly and open? What about your fiance's friends and their partners? When the children come along and gong to school then the opportunity to make new friends will follow but that doesnt always happen.

    In our own case we have lived relatively close to family and this is a big big thing for people that are close to family. In many cases, even if a couple marry and live initially away from the family and friends of either partner there is always the possibility of moving closer to either or both home area. However in cases of farms or a fixed business this cannot happen.

    I think you will need to be of a certain personality to get through the next few years. You need to be more independent in doing your own thing. You need to be able to make friends easily. You need to be able to accept that you will miss family events but at the same time be able to get your husband to go to these events when its important to you.

    I know people who have moved many miles from original homes and families accept this. i also know cases where some cant get to most events. It really depends on how ok you are with that.

    In the end you need to think through how important these things are for you. The only thing I would say is that you should think through what supports you have before starting your family. We had family around and it is a huge positive. I can understand your fiance wanting to start quickly as he wants to be young for his kids. But you need to talk to people that are experienced in bringing up a baby on a farm and identify supports. For instance will your fiance be open to your own mum / friends / sisters to come and stay for several days at a time?

    Does your finance accept that you are now a 50% player in the enterprise? I have seen before where the farm and farmhouse etc is seen as part of the original family and the girl the farmer marries is a blow in until she really establishes herself.

    It is possible to work through all of this in my opinion and many have but you both need to be totally committed to this with good relationships and also good relationships and acceptance of you and your needs by him and his family. He needs to probably identify cover even for a few hours on a sunday to allow some couple time for you guys.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 15,387 ✭✭✭✭rainbowtrout


    So if you've lived together for most of the relationship, I assume it's fair to presume that's 4-5 years?

    It would concern me that if I lived in such a small place for that long that I would have no friends, how do you envisage that panning out after the marriage? Also how well integrated have you become into his circle of friends, given that he is living in his home area. I'm guessing you don't know any of his friends well enough to call them your friends.

    While you have your partner, a social network is important, particularly if he is working full time and farming in the evenings/weekends. You could be very isolated if you go ahead with the marriage and are at home (even just on maternity leave) with a baby. How has it been living with him for the last number of years in this regard?

    Your fiance wants you to go off the pill straight away, from the way you have written it, it sounds like this is one sided. Do you want to have a baby straight away? Do you want a baby at all? Do you have any say in this?

    Farming is busy but there is no reason that he can't take a Sunday afternoon off now and again to do something with you. Assuming again there is a varied list of activities that you created, surely some of them require little time, effort or money. Relationships are a two way street. There should be some give on his side.

    I think you will have to forget about backpacking holidays with him realistically unless you want to go with a friend or on your own. I've never met anyone who has had a farmer boyfriend/husband who does the whole backpacking thing. It's just not part of the farming lifestyle. I honestly think you'll be lucky to get a week in a holiday cottage in a seaside town in Ireland as a family in the next twenty years, looking at my friends who have married farmers.

    I would be concerned at him not supporting you for your family emergency. If you ignore all the issues with not going backpacking and not doing anything on Sundays, you need to be able to rely on your partner for situations such as this one and he didn't come through for you. He was tired. Not even 'who's going to feed the cattle'. That would be a red flag for me.

    You are not only marrying into his family, but he is also marrying into yours. They may live 3 hours away, but they are not 'out of sight, out of mind'.

    Your observation is probably right, you will always come second, the farm will always come first. But are you always coming second to other stuff too?

    Canada/UAE is not going to happen with him, if you are going, you are going on your own. Your lifestyles are not compatible for that change of location.

    With regard to the wage thing, is it because his farm is only breaking even/making a financial loss or is it his parents farm that he works on but doesn't own?

    People don't change. If he's not willing to do these things now before you are married he is not going to do them after you are married. So are you content to marry this man, and live in this place far from your family network and attend family events on your own and not do anything on sundays, and have children straight away, because as another poster pointed out, there is another choice, you can look for someone more compatible with your lifestyle.

    You do need a frank conversation with him about where this relationship stands, because farm aside it does sound like there are some compatibility issues.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,487 ✭✭✭Fighting Tao


    If the farm is not profit making and he has to work full time elsewhere, then it’s a hobby. Farmers will say it’s more than that but the reality of being an adult is that you work full time to provide for your family and so he has a full time job. Don’t be conned by people saying you don’t understand because you are not from a farming background. He needs to grow up and decide if he wants to play being farmer or have a life with you.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    I would love if he had a group of friends I could have fallen into But he actually has no friends. Even for the up coming wedding I'm inviting 30 friends he is only inviting family. He's happy to do his own thing. It's me that needs a social circle.

    The Sunday things I mentioned I think the most expensive thing on the list was kilmanham jail majority were free.

    I do want kids with him but not until I'm happy with where our relationship is and where we are. Kids are not a plaster to me anyway. I don't want to bring them in trying to fix my unhappiness.

    It's just frustrating I love this man, he for me is perfect. Why do i have to need a social circle!! There isn't even bridge or bingo close by. I'm not allowed play poker in the local anymore, they called me a shark. Not my fault they underestimated my sweet innocent smile


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    I would love if he had a group of friends I could have fallen into But he actually has no friends. Even for the up coming wedding I'm inviting 30 friends he is only inviting family. He's happy to do his own thing. It's me that needs a social circle.

    The Sunday things I mentioned I think the most expensive thing on the list was kilmanham jail majority were free.

    I do want kids with him but not until I'm happy with where our relationship is and where we are. Kids are not a plaster to me anyway. I don't want to bring them in trying to fix my unhappiness.

    It's just frustrating I love this man, he for me is perfect. Why do i have to need a social circle!! There isn't even bridge or bingo close by. I'm not allowed play poker in the local anymore, they called me a shark. Not my fault they underestimated my sweet innocent smile


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,247 ✭✭✭milli milli


    OP you seem to be giving up an awful lot for this man. I agree with the poster who said he wasn’t there for you when you had your family crisis. Yes working two jobs is exhausting but what happens when you have children and there’s something similar?

    I have no doubt you love him but you are giving up your whole life and passions for him. I would think long and hard about that. And as others have said, unless he gives up the farm your foreign travels WON’T be with him.

    Have you heard about people on their deathbeds wishing they hadn’t worked so hard? I’m self-employed and know the hours you need to put in but I took a step back and realized I needed to create more of a balance. Last year I took my first foreign holiday in 7 years (and I love traveling). Apart from the money thing, I’m not going to let that happen again.

    I’m glad he’s giving something up because there’s no point in working yourself into the ground if you can’t enjoy it and spend time with your loved ones.
    He needs to prioritize you.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 15,387 ✭✭✭✭rainbowtrout


    Cold Feet wrote: »
    I would love if he had a group of friends I could have fallen into But he actually has no friends. Even for the up coming wedding I'm inviting 30 friends he is only inviting family. He's happy to do his own thing. It's me that needs a social circle.

    The Sunday things I mentioned I think the most expensive thing on the list was kilmanham jail majority were free.

    I do want kids with him but not until I'm happy with where our relationship is and where we are. Kids are not a plaster to me anyway. I don't want to bring them in trying to fix my unhappiness.

    It's just frustrating I love this man, he for me is perfect. Why do i have to need a social circle!! There isn't even bridge or bingo close by. I'm not allowed play poker in the local anymore, they called me a shark. Not my fault they underestimated my sweet innocent smile

    Why doesn't he have friends? It's not to say there's something wrong with it, but for someone who has lived all his life (presumably) in one small community and grown up there, is it not unusual to not have any friends in the locality?

    Why are you questioning why you need a social circle, like you are trying to justify accepting a life of isolation? It's normal to want friends and to spend time with other people.

    I'd forget about the kids for now and whether they'd be a sticking plaster or not, I'd be considering whether I want to get married in this situation, and whether the wedding/marriage is a sticking plaster for the current state of the relationship.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,812 ✭✭✭Addle


    Maybe his friends moved away.
    None of my friends live near where we grew up.
    It's not his responsibility to find friends for her.
    I don't have good friends where I live.
    I don't feel like I need to socialise every evening. When we do catch up, we have a great time. But the most I'd see most of them is once a month.

    Are you too dependent on him OP?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,951 ✭✭✭dixiefly


    Addle wrote: »
    Maybe his friends moved away.
    None of my friends live near where we grew up.
    It's not his responsibility to find friends for her.
    I don't have good friends where I live.
    I don't feel like I need to socialise every evening. When we do catch up, we have a great time. But the most I'd see most of them is once a month.

    Are you too dependent on him OP?

    She said he didnt have friends fullstop, not that he didnt have friends in the locality. If he had friends he would be inviting them or some of them to the wedding irrespective as to whether they lived in the same locality or not.

    Regarding the comment about the OP being dependent on him. It is wholly natural that a person that moves into a new area that is the home place and family of their new partner would depend on that person to blend in or settle down. You seem to to using it as a negative against the OP. I don't think it is and I think the OP (based on her story) has given up a lot in the relationship.

    I do think that the OP should look at other ways to get to know new people be it local sports clubs, drama, charity work. If there are other options work wise it may be a good thing as she said she has no contact with others in the current job.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,812 ✭✭✭Addle


    Ya, but OP can visit Kilmainham with someone other than her OH.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 421 ✭✭banoffe2


    Hi OP there are far too many red flags here for me, the no friends only family on his side to the wedding would be a deal breaker for me, not to mention all the other sacrifices you have made, at least you know in advance what you heading into, a lonely existence, you will be on your own, you deserve better. Sometimes we confuse love with dependency. I think time out and space would be well worth considering, when we remove ourselves from situations we can think and see more clearly, as I said in previous post, I admire your awareness, honesty and courage. x


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 15,387 ✭✭✭✭rainbowtrout


    Addle wrote: »
    Ya, but OP can visit Kilmainham with someone other than her OH.

    But the OP made a whole list of things that could be done in one day, many of them free and they as a couple haven't done any of them. It's not unreasonable to expect to spend some free time on a sunday doing something nice/fun with your partner. She did say some of the things she listed are no more than an hour away from where they live, or go to the cinema. The cinema is hardly an outlandish request.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,818 ✭✭✭jlm29


    OP, if you do have kids, will you have any support with them? Does he have family close by?
    My OH is a farmer, and we have three kids, and it’s HARD. I have support from my side, (and lots of it- and my family and friends are less than half an hour away). As they get bigger they can head off with their dad on the tractor, but when they’re small, I parent them pretty solo.
    These summer evenings are a killer. We all come home from work/childminder, and I can’t even get out for a walk, because he’s working. If I put the small ones in the buggy, they’ll sleep the whole way, coz they’re tired, and then they’re up all night.


  • Registered Users Posts: 289 ✭✭LolaJJ


    Hey OP,

    I don't think anyone is in a perfect relationship. Both people always have to make some kind of compromise. I think the "right person" is someone who helps you to achieve all the things you want to do with your life and the "wrong person" stands in the way of that.

    Reading your posts, it sounds like you are the right person for him, but he may not be the best person for you...


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,055 ✭✭✭Emme


    OP farming life is hard. It helps if the neighbours are friendly but some parts of the country are more accepting to newcomers than others. My mother came from a farm in a very friendly area and married into my father's farm which is in a very unfriendly area. She never got used to that. Like your fiance, my father was an extremely hard worker and his life was the farm. I think my mother would have liked to get away more but in those days you made your bed and lay in it and accepted your lot. The life my mother endured put me off marrying a farmer for life.

    I can understand your boyfriend not having time for going out but not wanting to meet your family is not a good sign. Not supporting you in a family crisis is a big red flag. If something happened in his family would he expect you to help out? Do you live near his parents?

    Also demanding that you go off the pill for the honeymoon is a red flag if you are not in agreement. It's as if he wants to tie you down straight away with a baby the way you can't go off travelling or have freedom. Now you may want a baby straight away which is fair enough. But was it him who suggested you going off the pill for the honeymoon?

    You seem to be making most of the compromises and if you feel that you come second in everything now it will be worse after you get married.

    Some farming families can be very patriarchal and controlling. Despite it being 2018, in those families women have a certain role and they have to stick to it. Like having a full-time job to bring in money, having children straight away (preferably boys), not expecting anything in the way of treats, days out, holidays or luxuries and always be ready and willing to help out on the farm when not at work. Do his family accept you and could you count on their support if you had children? Would you be able to get one of them to mind the child if you had to go away somewhere? If you don't get support in an isolated rural area life will be impossible and dare I say it, hell.

    I would be concerned that he has no friends but maybe most of his class from school has emigrated or are working away. However many farmers join a GAA club and make friends that way. I come from a farming background, live in a relatively unfriendly rural area but most farmers around have friends and the ones that don't are frankly weird.

    I am concerned that you have been living with him and haven't made many friends in the area or really integrated much. Are they old fashioned down there and don't approve of people living together before marriage? I also don't like that people in the pub are calling you a card shark and won't play cards with you. I get the feeling that the area is unfriendly and it's hard to get to know people - could you handle that for yourself and your children?

    If your fiance had been supportive in your recent family crisis I would be saying go ahead, life isn't perfect and you don't always get what you want. But if he isn't supportive and hasn't a history of being supportive you need to think long and hard about what you are getting into. I know of several farmers in my area who got married and the marriage broke down after 6 months. The women concerned were not viewed kindly but from my point of view there would have been mitigating factors from the husband's side. One man came from a very inward looking family where they worked very hard and didn't mix much outside family. Another man is reputed to have got very controlling after the marriage and she walked.

    Also is his farm viable? I can understand loyalty to the land but if he has to work that hard to break even would he not be better off leasing the land and using his time to work in a job that pays? He needs to be open to change because farming is changing very fast and will change even faster in the future. If the land is not in his name he will not be able to do anything except continue working for very little. I don't know how you get on with his family but if the land is not in his name it is unlikely he will inherit for some years so if he gives up his part-time job your wage will be supporting you both and whatever children you have. Farmers were always reluctant to pass land on to the next generation and some incentives were made in the 80s which made it attractive to pass land to a child under 35. However divorce changed that and farmers now are very unwilling to pass land to the new generation for fear the spouse will divorce and walk away with half the farm. Farmers can be especially suspicious of somebody not from a farming background marrying into the family.

    Have you both gone to pre-marriage counselling?

    If you are having serious doubts you would be better off to postpone the wedding rather than to get married in 3 months and separate 6 months after due to incompatibilities. You need to write down all your concerns, sit down with him and seriously discuss everything. He needs to take your concerns seriously. If he doesn't then you have a problem.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    A lot to catch up on there!! I was very annoyed that he didn't come down home with me when I needed him too but he has come of other things in the past.

    I love his parents, they are both really lovely and very accepting of me. His siblings live away from home but are very nice too. The friends thing, I don't get it but that's just me I need a big circle of friends. He did have friends in school/ early 20s then left for 5 years and never really picked back up with people. He is happy to chat away to people when we are out but he wouldn't be texting anyone or that. I don't think it's particularly weird, he's just a quiet person that's happy in his own company.

    It's not that it is an unfriendly area it's just that I think people already have their own friends/ families social circles already and don't really need a new friend. With regards to clubs etc it really is a very small area with limited options. There is an Irish Country women's Association in the village, I might join that.... There is another woman that does a few days here and there in the office, she's not local either (only about 30mins away) she said after having kids she did really get to know the people in the local area.

    It's not a part time job he has its a full on self employed job. He was gone at 5am this morning and probably won't be home until 7pm tonight and may have to do something on the farm before coming home so he is exhausted. He's on about looking for a more normal job he used to work 8am - 4pm which was perfect. The farm is profitable, he's just not getting the profit and I really do not see the farm being handed to him 'before time'.

    I would never expect him to give up the farm for me. That would 100% not work out!! He loves me and he loves the farm I could never ask him to choose because if he chose me he'd resent me. I only off handed said if it wasn't for the land I would most likely not live in Ireland but the land is there. I am not asking to go backpacking for 6 months in south America. I am asking to go away on a Sunday for a few hours. Yes I can go to Kilmanham Jail by myself and I do plenty of things alone but I would also like to do things with him.

    I suppose it's with the upcoming wedding that these things have come closer to the surface in my mind, the reality of it all. The reason I have been happy coasting along the last 3 years is because nearly every 2nd weekend I had college and was very focused on studying so I didn't really have time to be worried about making friends.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,055 ✭✭✭Emme


    If he's leaving the house at 5am and not getting home till after 7pm on a reguar basis no wonder he's tired. I can also see how he might not feel up to taking a trip on Sundays. If you offered to drive would he be more open to it?

    You will have to write down all your concerns and sit down and talk to him about it. He may want children straight away but he is working mad hours and is tired as it is. A new baby is lovely but brings broken sleep, feeds and nappy changes round the clock. That would not work well with his current schedule. Realistically he should address his hours and get into a more manageable routine before you start trying for a baby.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,951 ✭✭✭dixiefly


    Emme wrote: »
    OP farming life is hard. It helps if the neighbours are friendly but some parts of the country are more accepting to newcomers than others. My mother came from a farm in a very friendly area and married into my father's farm which is in a very unfriendly area. She never got used to that. Like your fiance, my father was an extremely hard worker and his life was the farm. I think my mother would have liked to get away more but in those days you made your bed and lay in it and accepted your lot. The life my mother endured put me off marrying a farmer for life.

    I can understand your boyfriend not having time for going out but not wanting to meet your family is not a good sign. Not supporting you in a family crisis is a big red flag. If something happened in his family would he expect you to help out? Do you live near his parents?

    Also demanding that you go off the pill for the honeymoon is a red flag if you are not in agreement. It's as if he wants to tie you down straight away with a baby the way you can't go off travelling or have freedom. Now you may want a baby straight away which is fair enough. But was it him who suggested you going off the pill for the honeymoon?

    You seem to be making most of the compromises and if you feel that you come second in everything now it will be worse after you get married.

    Some farming families can be very patriarchal and controlling. Despite it being 2018, in those families women have a certain role and they have to stick to it. Like having a full-time job to bring in money, having children straight away (preferably boys), not expecting anything in the way of treats, days out, holidays or luxuries and always be ready and willing to help out on the farm when not at work. Do his family accept you and could you count on their support if you had children? Would you be able to get one of them to mind the child if you had to go away somewhere? If you don't get support in an isolated rural area life will be impossible and dare I say it, hell.

    I would be concerned that he has no friends but maybe most of his class from school has emigrated or are working away. However many farmers join a GAA club and make friends that way. I come from a farming background, live in a relatively unfriendly rural area but most farmers around have friends and the ones that don't are frankly weird.

    I am concerned that you have been living with him and haven't made many friends in the area or really integrated much. Are they old fashioned down there and don't approve of people living together before marriage? I also don't like that people in the pub are calling you a card shark and won't play cards with you. I get the feeling that the area is unfriendly and it's hard to get to know people - could you handle that for yourself and your children?

    If your fiance had been supportive in your recent family crisis I would be saying go ahead, life isn't perfect and you don't always get what you want. But if he isn't supportive and hasn't a history of being supportive you need to think long and hard about what you are getting into. I know of several farmers in my area who got married and the marriage broke down after 6 months. The women concerned were not viewed kindly but from my point of view there would have been mitigating factors from the husband's side. One man came from a very inward looking family where they worked very hard and didn't mix much outside family. Another man is reputed to have got very controlling after the marriage and she walked.

    Also is his farm viable? I can understand loyalty to the land but if he has to work that hard to break even would he not be better off leasing the land and using his time to work in a job that pays? He needs to be open to change because farming is changing very fast and will change even faster in the future. If the land is not in his name he will not be able to do anything except continue working for very little. I don't know how you get on with his family but if the land is not in his name it is unlikely he will inherit for some years so if he gives up his part-time job your wage will be supporting you both and whatever children you have. Farmers were always reluctant to pass land on to the next generation and some incentives were made in the 80s which made it attractive to pass land to a child under 35. However divorce changed that and farmers now are very unwilling to pass land to the new generation for fear the spouse will divorce and walk away with half the farm. Farmers can be especially suspicious of somebody not from a farming background marrying into the family.

    Have you both gone to pre-marriage counselling?

    If you are having serious doubts you would be better off to postpone the wedding rather than to get married in 3 months and separate 6 months after due to incompatibilities. You need to write down all your concerns, sit down with him and seriously discuss everything. He needs to take your concerns seriously. If he doesn't then you have a problem.

    Excellent post. It is clear that a lot of thought went into this post.


  • Registered Users Posts: 1,018 ✭✭✭L1985


    Excellent post above as well. Just my two cents from a diff perspective. I'm female and farm while working full time. The farm can suck all of your energy and focus if you let it. The work is literally never finished and you are a lot more consumed with it then with the job that actually pays the bills. This isn't healthy. I had to take a step back and say to myself that the farm will always need something to be done but no point in living if you have no life. I take every Sunday off as best as I can and if I find I'm working every Sunday I get help in to stop that. In regards to your post-i think you need to have a serious talk with him. If all of his energy is directed at the farm how can he be talking about having kids when he won't be the one around them or actively involved. One afternoon a week to go off and do something along with a night out every two or three weeks is hardly being unreasonable before kids come along!. The issue is he needs to see this and the push needs to come from him. If he doesn't see this then he will work himself into the ground and wonder where it all went wrong....also emotional support is crucial in a relationship as well as in farming and I would be worried as it doesn't seem like he's valuing that or giving that from any direction and that's not healthy either. Best of luck OP you have a lot to consider and I hope it works out the best for you!


  • Registered Users Posts: 889 ✭✭✭messy tessy


    Cold Feet wrote: »
    It's not a part time job he has its a full on self employed job. He was gone at 5am this morning and probably won't be home until 7pm tonight and may have to do something on the farm before coming home so he is exhausted

    Surely the self employed job is causing the majority of the tiredness?! Seems crazy hours...


  • Registered Users Posts: 889 ✭✭✭messy tessy


    Cold Feet wrote: »
    It's not a part time job he has its a full on self employed job. He was gone at 5am this morning and probably won't be home until 7pm tonight and may have to do something on the farm before coming home so he is exhausted

    Surely the self employed job is causing the majority of the tiredness?! Seems crazy hours...


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    So sitting here crying..... again :-/

    We did have a talk but honestly not a whole lot has changed. The last two/ three weeks have been shocking difficult with the weather etc so I wouldn't expect him to be anything other than dedicate to the farm right now. But the weeks before hand nothing changed.

    If we lived in my home town I thing I could cope with this but I don't think I can. He is never around. I asked each day last week could we go to the lake, one I've never been to "no it'll be too busy I cant be arsed" I asked would there be another smaller lake or even a drive we could go on? " Maybe another time"

    I don't think I can do this. I want him, but he already seems to take me for granted. I know he works super hard, although one poster did say he works hard to support me, I support myself, I earn more than him.

    I just want to explode I don't know what to do. I love him but I hate my life I don't know what to do. I don't want to find someone 'more compatible' but am I giving up on a happy life?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,055 ✭✭✭Emme


    So sitting here crying..... again :-/

    We did have a talk but honestly not a whole lot has changed. The last two/ three weeks have been shocking difficult with the weather etc so I wouldn't expect him to be anything other than dedicate to the farm right now. But the weeks before hand nothing changed.

    If we lived in my home town I thing I could cope with this but I don't think I can. He is never around. I asked each day last week could we go to the lake, one I've never been to "no it'll be too busy I cant be arsed" I asked would there be another smaller lake or even a drive we could go on? " Maybe another time"

    I don't think I can do this. I want him, but he already seems to take me for granted. I know he works super hard, although one poster did say he works hard to support me, I support myself, I earn more than him.

    I just want to explode I don't know what to do. I love him but I hate my life I don't know what to do. I don't want to find someone 'more compatible' but am I giving up on a happy life?

    This does not sound good. I know a full-time farmer/agricultural contractor. He works very hard but makes time to go away for weekends and holidays a few times a year.

    If he's not willing to compromise for you now it would be 10 times worse if you got married. If you are going to stay with him I would advise you to postpone the wedding for a year to see how things go.

    He's not taking you into account or considering what you want. You said earlier that he wants you to go off the pill immediately when you get married. All things considered this is controlling. You say you earn more than him. Would he want to take control of your money if you got married? Also if you have a child straight after your marry and he is never around you would effectively be a single mother. I suppose that would be good preparation for you if things did not work out.

    You ask if you are giving up a happy life. I would say yes, definitely. If you marry this man it will be a long relentless grind which in the short, medium and long run will do nobody any good. I saw this kind of lifestyle first hand with my parents and it took its toll on their health. It put me off farming for life and made me very shy of marriage. Have a look at my earlier post in this thread for further clarification.

    If your gut instinct is to walk away then walk away.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 6,168 ✭✭✭Ursus Horribilis


    I don't want to find someone 'more compatible' but am I giving up on a happy life?

    Maybe you're giving up on a happy life by staying with him? You've now got plenty of experience of living with him full-time now that the honeymoon/college years are over. We can see how well that's going. How compatible are you really when he's unable or unwilling to compromise in any way?

    I hate to say it but I think it's ultimatum time here. Talk of postponing the wedding might just give him the kick up the arse he badly needs here and get the ball rolling. As things stand, you'd be mad to go through with the wedding or start a family without resolving this.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 15,387 ✭✭✭✭rainbowtrout



    I asked each day last week could we go to the lake, one I've never been to "no it'll be too busy I cant be arsed" I asked would there be another smaller lake or even a drive we could go on? " Maybe another time"


    So he's not even giving the excuse of being too busy with the farm or too tired. He just can't be arsed. How exactly is this situation going to improve when he has zero inclination to make any changes. What you are asking for is miniscule in the greater scheme of things.

    Is the wedding still going ahead?

    I don't think I can do this. I want him, but he already seems to take me for granted. I know he works super hard, although one poster did say he works hard to support me, I support myself, I earn more than him.

    I just want to explode I don't know what to do. I love him but I hate my life I don't know what to do. I don't want to find someone 'more compatible' but am I giving up on a happy life?


    If he's taking you for granted now it's not going to get any better. I'm not sure how compatible you both are if you are not happy. Can you see yourself living this life for the next 30-40 years? Maybe with a few kids that you are largely raising by yourself?


  • Administrators Posts: 14,461 Admin ✭✭✭✭✭Big Bag of Chips


    How does he see it working out if you have a honeymoon baby? Will he be around more often, or will you be expected to be a single parent? Will he be available for days out then? All well and good for him to be planning the picture perfect family, but not much good if he's not willing, or able to back it up in reality. Having an absent husband can quickly lead to resentment.

    However, I moved to an area where I knew nobody, and I will admit that it was only when my children started in school/playschool that I met other mothers and actually made some really good, loyal friends. So that is something to bear in mind. But... School or playschool is a long way off for you at this stage. You need to talk to him.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 262 ✭✭ahnow


    Maybe an ultimatum or even a brief separation to see if there’s any changes going forward. I don’t know anything about the work involved with farming life, it seems really consuming and probably like there’s not much give in the time you have to put toward it, but your needs are not being met here.
    It all sounds very isolating, especially the thoughts of having a child shortly after being married, it just sounds like you’d be at home alone with the baby most of the time. Yous should have one date night a week even, where yous head out and do something nice together-where is the joy in your relationship and the time given to celebrating each other and celebrating life? Do you have moments of joy? Are they enough?

    The wanting to have a baby so soon doesn’t sit right with me, it does seem like there might be an element of wanting to tie you down, or checking off boxes, unless that has been the want and plan all along-I could be way off mark. It just seems a bit old fashioned and maybe something to be aware of, is his family and him a bit old school? How are women perceived and treated in the family?

    Holding off on the wedding might be an idea and see if there’s any changes down the road. I’d be concerned if I were in your shoes too. I read an article recently about one of the major factors in why long term couples split and divorce happens. It said that a big reasons was that needs or requests that have been clearly stated but are repeatedly ignored were the main one, it’s asked for the first while, then the person eventually stops asking, resentment grows, then it becomes a straw that broke the camel’s back scenario as time goes on.
    After re-reading the posts there honestly taking a step back and appraising the situation it might be an idea to look at everything you offer him....and then look at everything he is offering you now.
    You can love someone very deeply, have a very deep connection with them, but that may or may not necessarily mean they’ll be someone that brings you the greatest happiness, or that what they are offering you is enough.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    Thanks for the replies. I think I just had a very stressful day at work yesterday and he had been away with work the whole weekend. I had, had a very bad day on Monday and because he was away with work, and I'm alone in the office right now I felt very very alone and isolated. There is one girl I am friends with who I probably should have called to on Monday night.

    He is under enormous pressure with the weather the farm is having serious issues, no water, already feeding silage because grass isn't growing. So I don't want to be adding too his worries now. He said the other night something along the lines of why does he keep getting dealt crap cards, one after the other.

    With regards the baby, I think he has just been ready to have kids for about 10 years and is mad to be a dad. I told him I wanted to wait until at least next summer before we start trying and he has no issue with that. I'm stressed planning this wedding too, I think I've everything sorted but people keep sticking their noses in so that's probably not helping the situation.

    His parents would be very traditional old school farmers, his dad worked, mam stayed at home. But his sisters are not like that, both work in big cities and are very independent.

    He knows how unhappy I am, and I think he'd move somewhere else with me if it wasn't for the farm. I can't give him an ultimatum on that anyway because even though I know it would break his heart he would have to pick the farm. I think I will ask him to stop working for himself and get a 'normal' job again until he inherits the farm.

    My aunt moved, away when she got married, she said it took her nearly 10 years to actually settle into the town but she loves it there now. I have been in college part time also the last few years which really got in the way of making a social life. But that just finished up so hopefully I should have more spare time now. Maybe I'll start a local book club!


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 15,387 ✭✭✭✭rainbowtrout


    But you're not asking him to give up the farm, you're asking him for a couple of hours of his time on a Sunday and he's not willing to spend time with you. Why isn't he willing?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,055 ✭✭✭Emme


    OP Again1 wrote: »
    Thanks for the replies. I think I just had a very stressful day at work yesterday and he had been away with work the whole weekend. I had, had a very bad day on Monday and because he was away with work, and I'm alone in the office right now I felt very very alone and isolated. There is one girl I am friends with who I probably should have called to on Monday night.

    You have a right to express how you feel. You will have stressful days at work again. If your fiance cannot support you when you have hard days you need to think seriously about your future with him. Right now you are the one making all the compromises for him and getting nothing in return. You feel alone and isolated but you can't turn to him for help because you don't want to trouble him. That's not a relationship - that's living in fear.
    OP Again1 wrote: »
    He is under enormous pressure with the weather the farm is having serious issues, no water, already feeding silage because grass isn't growing. So I don't want to be adding too his worries now. He said the other night something along the lines of why does he keep getting dealt crap cards, one after the other.

    He is under pressure with the weather and you have stressful days at work. You say you don't want to be adding to his worries. Stop apologising for your existence! You are already tiptoeing around him walking on eggshells. What would it be like if you were married to him? There will always be enormous pressure with farming because that is the nature of the job. If it isn't lack of rain it's too much of it. If he can't cope with the pressures of farming he shouldn't be doing it. He won't realise that though and he will continue to farm no matter what because that is expected of him by his family.

    The reality is that he will aways be "under enormous pressure" no matter what and this will be an excuse for him to ignore what you want and to make extra demands on you.
    OP Again1 wrote: »
    With regards the baby, I think he has just been ready to have kids for about 10 years and is mad to be a dad. I told him I wanted to wait until at least next summer before we start trying and he has no issue with that. I'm stressed planning this wedding too, I think I've everything sorted but people keep sticking their noses in so that's probably not helping the situation.

    You say he has agreed to put off having a child for a year. I think you should put off the wedding for a year. See if things change or improve. If they don't then I would advise you not to marry this man. I would not advise you to marry this man full stop. It is better to postpone the wedding for a year now than to divorce 6 months or a year after the wedding. I know of several marriages to farmers where the wife ran away screaming after less than 2 years and a divorce followed. These marriages were to farmers from very traditional backgrounds who did not take the needs or opinions of their wives into account. I am not being nosy but are there any broken engagements/long relationships in this man's history? He says he has been ready for children for 10 years but it sounds like his idea of fatherhood is for you to do all the work with the children and for him to take pride in his children (ideally sons).
    OP Again1 wrote: »
    His parents would be very traditional old school farmers, his dad worked, mam stayed at home. But his sisters are not like that, both work in big cities and are very independent.

    This is very telling. He is from a very traditional farming background which is obvious from his attitudes. It is also clear that his sisters got the hell out of Dodge so that they could live independent lives. They saw how women were treated on the farm first hand and they were having none of it. Could you talk to either of them about how you feel and how he never takes your needs and feelings into account?
    OP Again1 wrote: »
    He knows how unhappy I am, and I think he'd move somewhere else with me if it wasn't for the farm. I can't give him an ultimatum on that anyway because even though I know it would break his heart he would have to pick the farm. I think I will ask him to stop working for himself and get a 'normal' job again until he inherits the farm.

    He might know how unhappy you are but it doesn't seem to bother him much. On several occasions you have begged him to go away for a few hours together. At first the farm was the reason he couldn't go but the last time you asked he said that he "couldn't be arsed". These are not the words and actions of a man who cares about how you feel. He won't do anything you ask so if you ask him to stop working for himself and get a "normal" job you will be wasting your breath. He knows you won't give him an ultimatum of any kind and this is probably one reason he chose you. He also knows he can get away with treating you whatever way he likes.
    OP Again1 wrote: »
    My aunt moved, away when she got married, she said it took her nearly 10 years to actually settle into the town but she loves it there now. I have been in college part time also the last few years which really got in the way of making a social life. But that just finished up so hopefully I should have more spare time now. Maybe I'll start a local book club!

    You are not your aunt. There is no guarantee that in 10 years time you will love a town where the people won't play cards with you and call you a card shark because you won a few times. My mother moved from a neighbouring county to be with my father and never settled into the area because people don't accept outsiders. Every situation is different.

    Any way I think that you won't have time for a book club or for any hobbies if you marry this man. Your life with be your job (bringing in money for him), the children and the farm. I guarantee that you will be landed with the lion's share of the household bills, buying clothes for the children etc. All his money will go into the farm and not one cent of it will go into the household.

    You were probably caught up too much in your study before to see what is going on in the relationship. Now you are not studying you see what is happening.

    I am not being dramatic but perhaps you should look up emotional abuse on the Women's Aid website. Some emotional abusers think it is normal because that is what they grew up with and they see one partner lying down and letting the other walk over them. I know I am repeating myself but no matter what this man says he has absolutely no consideration for your feelings or for what you want. Marrying you would be a means to an end for him - having somebody to bring in an extra income, to manage the household and to have children (preferably sons) to carry on the farm.

    Think very carefully before you marry him and remember, putting off the wedding for a year to see if he improves is better than a divorce later on. You had doubts about this marriage 2 months ago and you still have doubts. Go with your gut and don't do what you feel you should do because you don't want to inconvenience people.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 15,387 ✭✭✭✭rainbowtrout


    OP Again1 wrote: »
    He knows how unhappy I am, and I think he'd move somewhere else with me if it wasn't for the farm.

    I'd agree with everything Emme said above, but also, it would be very easy for him to promise you everything you want in theory 'but for the farm'.

    Of course I'd go backpacking...but for the farm.
    Of course we'll take a holiday... but for the farm
    Of course we'd move closer to your family and friends... but for the farm.

    Easy to say all of those things when he knows he will never have to follow through on them.

    But the things he can provide you with - a bit of company in the evening, or a day out on a Sunday, he doesn't give you. Actions speak louder than words.

    Pointless thinking about what he might agree to if it wasn't for the farm. Those things will never happen. Look at what you're asking for and what he can do, and what he is refusing to do.


  • Registered Users Posts: 18 determinedlass


    If you marry him you won't have time for a book club or for any hobbies. Your life with be your job (bringing in money for him), the children and the farm. I guarantee that you will be landed with the lion's share of the household bills, buying clothes for the children etc. All his money will go into the farm and not one cent of it will go into the household.

    THIS POST TIMES A THOUSAND. You will be the laying hen for this man - bringing in the money and doing everything as well. There will always be an excuse. I come from a farming background. My father and mother helped and supported each other and he had an active role in my upbringing BUT I realise now he is definitely the exception.

    If he is in his late thirties and has still not been given the farm, then that is another red flag. How long does he have to wait - many wait until their fifties.

    You are not getting any support at the moment - it is a one-way street only. Things will only get worse once you both are married. He is working himself into the ground but this won't change as he prefers work( I don't think he even realises it though) to spending quality time with you. Work is his get out clause and the joke of it is that despite two jobs, he is still not very well paid. So you will be with a person who cannot financially or emotionally support you, but you are expected to do both for him and look after the house and parent(alone) and subsidise the farm on top of that ( which in time you will - make no doubt about that). From what I observe there are a few exceptions to this (friends, family etc.), but only the farming couples who made time for each other from the beginning.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 15,411 ✭✭✭✭woodchuck


    OP you don't sound happy at all. And there is no indication that anything is going to change, despite having voiced your concerns.

    I think you'd be mad to go through with the wedding...


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,151 ✭✭✭stargazer 68


    Op I have to agree that you should think long and hard about this. He 'couldn't be arsed' to take you out for a couple of hours????? Ah here now - there will always be the farm as an excuse for everything - and it is hard work - but there has to be time out. What happens when you have kids and want to go on holidays or days out with them - are you going to do it all on your own?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,055 ✭✭✭Emme


    OP I forgot to say that looking after the elderly parents when the times comes will be your job. He will be too busy with the farm to do it and the sisters might throw in suggestions but they will be too busy with their lives to get stuck in with the heavy lifting. So children, job, farm and caring for elderly parents. How does that strike you?

    I'm not being horrible but I'm simply pointing out the stark reality of being a woman who has married in to a traditional Irish farm. I've seen how these women have been treated all my life. The odd one gets lucky and has a husband who is considerate and willing to take her needs into account. Others marry men like your fiance and end up worn out, bitter and old before their time from doing everything. If you get sick you'll just have to drag yourself along and manage the best you can because nobody will give you any sympathy.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    OP, I feel so sorry for you. What a horrible relationship you're in. I have to say the way you try to minimise and explain away and apologise for your feelings and also his behaviour is a bad sign. You sound like a woman whose relationship has completely beaten her down.

    My advice to you would be as follows:
    Get a pen and paper and on one side write out what your life will be like with him - be brutually honest with yourself. On the other side put down what life would be like without him, again be brutually honest. Sometimes looking at something in black and white can help clarify thoughts.

    I'm wondering why he wants kids so badly, he won't be present to raise them?? He'll be consumed with working the farm.

    're doing things on weekends etc, you won't have time anyway as you'll be working full time, raising kids, looking after the house, and helping him on the farm. That's going to be your life. He's pretty much told you that it will be that way as he refuses to do things with you/spend time together/basically be a normal couple.

    Happy relationships usually have both parties putting roughly equal effort into it. He doesnt sound like he's putting even 5% effort into it! One person cannot carry a relationship and do all the compromising, not if they want to be happy.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 166,026 ✭✭✭✭LegacyUser


    I think I'll print off this post and let him read it tonight!

    He is going to need a 2nd job for the foreseeable future, because there is no way his parents would hand down the farm, to be fair his dad still does a lot of the work on the farm and it's their source of income even though they are both officially retired. I don't think he sees me as a good source of income. When he does inherit the farm should be able to support a family. I'd be the sort of person who likes to work and will most likely keep on something part time, but I don't think he'd be forcing me to work in order to support the farm.

    I think if he switched back to a normal job things would get better. I'm so bored and lonely I ended up having a few drinks most night, which is not good I know. We don't really fight about it but I know he def doesn't like it, and he is right there is no need to be drinking every night. I've signed up for some classes for next week so hopefully that helps.

    He really is a very sweet guy and I hope that does come across too. He is just a bit of a work-a-holic. As some one said I don't even think he realises he prioritises work over me, it's just what he's like. He would be quite sensitive too, I can see that my unhappiness is having an effect on him. He's love to 'fix it'.

    Someone asked does he have a string of broken relationship, no I'm his 1st girlfriend. He has some short romances when he was younger but never anything serious. I know this sound awful but until his mid 20s he wouldn't have really been considered very good looking.

    I think I'll talk to him tonight and try to figure out, is he actually serious about getting a normal job again and stopping the crazy hours. I know he will have some mad weeks on the farm and I can live with that, but I don't think I can live with his crazy schedule at the moment.

    If we can't seem to come to an agreement ourselves, I know when we done our marriage course they said accord offer relationship counselling, it might be worth a shot? If none of that works, maybe ye are right and I should postpone the wedding.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 318 ✭✭Mikenesson


    Hold off on marriage and baby or rethink it altogether op

    There's no point locking yourself into a situation you're currently unhappy with

    I can see what he's hoping to get from the marriage but not from your perspective


  • Advertisement
Advertisement