2018/19 FPL Rate My Team Thread

Axwell

Mokuba wrote: »

West Ham forum disagrees with you. Thinks it's 50/50, leaning toward Adrian. I'd be inclined to listen to them.

Think ill take my chances

km79

Mokuba wrote: »

Axwell wrote: »

Fabianski was on extended holiday leave after the WC. Once he came back he played the last 2 games, they werent sharing all pre season he just wasnt there. They also just paid 7m for him, Adrian is on the last year of his contract. Fabianski is as good as nailed on bar lack of fitness or injury imo.

West Ham forum disagrees with you. Thinks it's 50/50, leaning toward Adrian. I'd be inclined to listen to them.

Wasn’t Adrian dropped for Joe Hart last year .......

Mokuba

km79 wrote: »

Wasn’t Adrian dropped for Joe Hart last year .......

And won his place back.

And it's a new manager.

I don't know why people come on here asking if players are nailed, go to the fans forums of the teams in question, most people on here are only pretending they know.

km79

Mokuba wrote: »

km79 wrote: »

Wasn’t Adrian dropped for Joe Hart last year .......

And won his place back.

And it's a new manager.

I don't know why people come on here asking if players are nailed, go to the fans forums of the teams in question, most people on here are only pretending they know.

You seen a seed of doubt in my mind now Will haveto have look when I get home
Was not fully convinced on him anyway with those stink fixtures

Mokuba

km79 wrote: »

You seen a seed of doubt in my mind now Will haveto have look when I get home
Was not fully convinced on him anyway with those stink fixtures

Maybe Fabianski will start. But seems very 50/50 on KUMB and in my opinion not worth the risk as a result.

http://www.kumb.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=172546&st=0&sk=t&sd=a&start=120

Literally any player I am thinking of including, I go straight to the fans forum of that team to see if they are expecting him to play.

Green&Red

Mokuba wrote: »

Maybe Fabianski will start. But seems very 50/50 on KUMB and in my opinion not worth the risk as a result.

http://www.kumb.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=172546&st=0&sk=t&sd=a&start=120

Literally any player I am thinking of including, I go straight to the fans forum of that team to see if they are expecting him to play.

If you have Foster you have three GWs to rectify Fab if he doesn't play

km79

Green&Red wrote: »

Mokuba wrote: »

Maybe Fabianski will start. But seems very 50/50 on KUMB and in my opinion not worth the risk as a result.

http://www.kumb.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=172546&st=0&sk=t&sd=a&start=120
Literally any player I am thinking of including, I go straight to the fans forum of that team to see if they are expecting him to play.

If you have Foster you have three GWs to rectify Fab if he doesn't play

What’s the point in risking it when 2 of those fab fixtures are stink anyway ?
This was an area of team I was to revisit anyway as I just want sold on that combo

Thanks mokumbu
It’s good to get a fresh perspective
I have tunnel vision at this stage

loadwire

GK: Patricio (Boruc)

DEF: Robertson, Stones, Wan-Bissaka (Bennett, Peltier)

MF: Salah, Ozil, Bilva, Richarlson, Jota

FW: Kun, Firmino (Ings)

*shuts laptop and throws out of window*

km79

West Ham press conference just over and annoyingly he wasn’t asked about keeper situation !

ThunbergsAreGo

I dont think I can justify Alexis
Which of these are best

A. Tomkins, Sanchez, Stephens

OR

B. Davies/Bailly, Bernardo Silva, Jota

claw

naughtb4 wrote: »

I dont think I can justify Alexis
Which of these are best

A. Tomkins, Sanchez, Stephens

OR

B. Davies, Bernardo Silva, Jota

In the same boat regarding Silva and Sanchez. Not sold on Silva but not sold on having a weaker defence for Sanchez.

Mokuba

km79 wrote: »

West Ham press conference just over and annoyingly he wasn’t asked about keeper situation !

It's not that big a deal if you have Foster too, as was said you'll have 3 weeks to get him out, should he not play.

And it's fine to have a gamble, I love to gamble on differentials, it makes the game for me.

Just a general tip to check the forums. E.g Most of the Southampton forum have no Cedric.

And the Chelsea forum reckons 4.5 Hudson Odoi and 6.0 Ross Barkley will be starting this weekend.

Just handy for things you mightn't expect.

Mike Ehrmantraut

After lots of tinkering, and finally deciding I'm definitely not starting the season without Salah, I'm currently stuck between the following

A
Patricio Foster
Mendy, Robertson, Cedric, Peltier, Wan Bissaka
Salah, BSilva, Richarlison, Cairney, Stephens
Aguero, Firmino, Lacazette

B
Patricio, Foster
Mendy, Robertson, Tompkins, Holebas, Wan Bissaka
Salah, Mane, Richalison, Pedro, Jota
Aguero, Mitrovic, King

Like the look of the forward line in A, but not sure if it leaves me a bit light in midfield, and with B, I'm not fully convinced in Mitrovic or King.

As for 4.5 defenders, I'm still deciding between Cedric, Tompkins and Holebas.

Would really welcome some advice or feedback

claw

Mike Ehrmantraut wrote: »

After lots of tinkering, and finally deciding I'm definitely not starting the season without Salah, I'm currently stuck between the following

A
Patricio Foster
Mendy, Robertson, Cedric, Peltier, Wan Bissaka
Salah, BSilva, Richarlison, Cairney, Stephens
Aguero, Firmino, Lacazette

B
Patricio, Foster
Mendy, Robertson, Tompkins, Holebas, Wan Bissaka
Salah, Mane, Richalison, Pedro, Jota
Aguero, Mitrovic, King

Like the look of the forward line in A, but not sure if it leaves me a bit light in midfield, and with B, I'm not fully convinced in Mitrovic or King.

As for 4.5 defenders, I'm still deciding between Cedric, Tompkins and Holebas.

Would really welcome some advice or feedback

I had Cedric and Mark Hughes is saying he is available to play but like it was mentioned earlier people on Southampton's forum aren't convinced he starts. I am torn between two different teams and Cedric was in one of them but not sure I am risking him now bearing in mind I have Wan Bissaka and Peltier. Tomkins and Holebas are fine I would have thought.

Green&Red

km79 wrote: »

What’s the point in risking it when 2 of those fab fixtures are stink anyway ?
This was an area of team I was to revisit anyway as I just want sold on that combo

Thanks mokumbu
It’s good to get a fresh perspective
I have tunnel vision at this stage

Who would you get? By sticking with Fab on a 50/50 you have a chance to look at the alternatives - for me Fulhams keeper (up in the air), cardiff to see how they are doing, likewise wolves as I already have a wolves defender. Brighton could be a good choice, their fixtures pick up after week 3 and dramatically pick up after week 6

TitianGerm

I went a bit random this season. Any thoughts?

ThunbergsAreGo

claw wrote: »

In the same boat regarding Silva and Sanchez. Not sold on Silva but not sold on having a weaker defence for Sanchez.

Yeah and Sanchez is a really short term punt, I dont want him once Lukaku is back (at that price)

KevIRL

Close to finished with my regular team

Foster/Ryan
Robertson/Mendy/Luiz/AWB/Peltier
Salah/Bilva/Jota/Ricky/Stephens
Kun/Firmino/Arnie

Nats9314

Opinions please....

Alison boric
Sakho Cedric wanbis Mandy kabasele
Salah richarlison moura neves bsilva
Agureo firming ings

km79

Green&Red wrote: »

Who would you get? By sticking with Fab on a 50/50 you have a chance to look at the alternatives - for me Fulhams keeper (up in the air), cardiff to see how they are doing, likewise wolves as I already have a wolves defender. Brighton could be a good choice, their fixtures pick up after week 3 and dramatically pick up after week 6

Might just go with one keeper yet
Half thinking about going with everton combo and changing Coleman to Bailly again.......or pva..........

thetimeisnow

Aguero.or Augbameyang

claw

naughtb4 wrote: »

Yeah and Sanchez is a really short term punt, I dont want him once Lukaku is back (at that price)

The reason I would have Sanchez is that I don't know what City midfielder to put in. I would say Sanchez has an easier match in week 1 than the City midfielders and you don't know which one of the City midfielders if any will be the one to do the business. It's 1 from Sanchez to any City midfielder bar Sterling for week 2. The downside is that I don't like my defensive options since I have a few big hitters in my team besides Sanchez.

ThunbergsAreGo

km79 wrote: »

Might just go with one keeper yet
Half thinking about going with everton combo and changing Coleman to Bailly again.......or pva..........

Yeah i had been on Ederson as a set and forget but going for Patricio now as a singel keeper. The variance in points between keepers isnt worth it

km79

km79 wrote: »

What’s the point in risking it when 2 of those fab fixtures are stink anyway ?
This was an area of team I was to revisit anyway as I just want sold on that combo

Thanks mokumbu
It’s good to get a fresh perspective
I have tunnel vision at this stage

Patricio and Foster ofer good options for 9-10 weeks from memory.

ThunbergsAreGo

claw wrote: »

The reason I would have Sanchez is that I don't know what City midfielder to put in. I would say Sanchez has an easier match in week 1 than the City midfielders and you don't know which one of the City midfielders if any will be the one to do the business. It's 1 from Sanchez to any City midfielder bar Sterling for week 2. The downside is that I don't like my defensive options since I have a few big hitters in my team besides Sanchez.

Yeah i was using the same logic

Get Sanchez in and then transfer to whomever you want in week 3

But that means having to run with some real fodder.....

The issue with Bilva is there isn't any natural replacement at that price point once he inevitably gets rotated

Cantona's Collars

...Foster...

Rudiger,Daniels,Mendy

Salah,Sane,Neves,Richardson

Firmino, Aguero,Zaha.

Fabianski,Pielter,Cairney,Wan Bissa.

0 itb.

Any changes I should make?

greedygoblin

Mike Ehrmantraut wrote: »

After lots of tinkering, and finally deciding I'm definitely not starting the season without Salah, I'm currently stuck between the following

A
Patricio Foster
Mendy, Robertson, Cedric, Peltier, Wan Bissaka
Salah, BSilva, Richarlison, Cairney, Stephens
Aguero, Firmino, Lacazette

B
Patricio, Foster
Mendy, Robertson, Tompkins, Holebas, Wan Bissaka
Salah, Mane, Richalison, Pedro, Jota
Aguero, Mitrovic, King

Like the look of the forward line in A, but not sure if it leaves me a bit light in midfield, and with B, I'm not fully convinced in Mitrovic or King.

As for 4.5 defenders, I'm still deciding between Cedric, Tompkins and Holebas.

Would really welcome some advice or feedback

These are effectively the 2 teams I'm torn between also (just some minor, same value variations aside).

I'm going with team B as is. If a premium midfielder you don't have looks like becoming essential then dumping Mane frees up the majority of the funds required. You don't have this flexibility with team A without a couple of hits. Just my €0.02.

sashafierce

This post has been deleted.

MayoSalmon

Ederson
Shaw Stones Roberson
Salah Sanchez Neves Richarlison
Aguero Firmino Kamara

Bench Foster Wan-Bissaka Wilshere

Thoughts?

ThunbergsAreGo

sashafierce wrote: »

This post has been deleted.

three fo your defenders are doubtful starters this weekend