Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Jurassic Werewolf - Isla Nublar
Options
Comments
-
Bounty Hunter wrote: »This discussion changed since the last time I checked in ha
Riona Mother f@cking Jackson saying that was a lot of fun mods, gg all. Great Game Brendan, might not be team village but we know the real winners Team Taco!
The split of the islands was a lot of fun even though I did not know what to expect being on the same island as seteives Necro & Joe
Ha, there was certainly a PW influence on Taco Island with me, you, beaker and Kolido that's for sure :pac:
Read your backroom and you're right, Detective Desmond would have poured over everyone's posts to help you make a decision for your power, but it worked out well regardless so kudos.
0 -
Ok so I have a bit of time now so here's my two/five cents on the game as promised:
Loved the split as I said already. As has already been said, doing it on COP would be all kinds of epic as no one would see anything the others said so would lead to much more mistrust between the islands. However, I also understand trialling it on boards for the first attempt as A) it's our home and
you can gauge things from a first run and only improve them for a next game.
The starter pack: Fcuk me... that was a lot of information. Can tell the amount of effort put into producing it and it was an interesting change.
One caveat is I will say I dunno if total mystery on village roles is a good thing. Thing is that wolves have a lot more information to start the game and have the benefit of communicating off thread to discuss their powers and what could possibly counter them. Think the island split alone being hidden would have been an amazing mystery item.
That being said, village probably should have won the game so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ - maybe it's a personal preference and not a big issue.
Kudos to Barney, first SK win (BH had first solo win though, but SK is much much tougher). Like Jack, I had you down as priest and hence why I didn't push you at all following the first night. Detective Desmond needs to trust his own judgement more I think.
The BG role was the thing that confused me a little. It wouldn't have made any difference to the game as it happened, but say fixxxer had placeholdered a player prior to lynch who was subsequently lynched - would they be allowed another choice? Obviously, mod rules etc and no complaints just trying to see inside your heads as to how the mechanics on the BG were supposed to work. I will say, not sure why he couldn't placeholder up to 9.59am was very confusing to me, but hey, it's your game, your rules of course.
Liked the arsonist role. Shame sKeith didn't get to play it longer, but it seems very interesting for future games. Played with a variant in an 80 player mash on MU and it was a... shock to the system when the wolf arsonist blew up along with 5 other goodies :pac:
Likewise, the wolf doppelganger - presumably a play on the Robber role? It was cool, think though if I was to include it I'd make the doppler steal from outside the pack, but again not a major thing, and again, tis your game so how it played out was grand.
Molly was upset regarding the wolves. From reading back I think you guys were just unlucky tbh. The EOD pile on Molly and Flushy blocking the conversion that night essentially broke the back of the wolf pack (and then Barney killed your fourth in sully on Taco Island).
Mick's double peek (a great call, with one conversion that day, he essentially had a confirmed villager in Mary free of being converted or a wolf, sadly it was the latter) also blasted probably the remaining hope the wolves had, Andy was already under heavy suspicion at that time.
Just a mention for poor Steve who was innocent and branded a wolf for the remainder of the game through a miscommunication :pac:
Quick mention for Rikand, I half figured it was you night 0 during our late night conversation, but wasn't sure. Could tell you were very experienced and you made good gut calls throughout the game, so don't beat yourself up about the ending at all. RL happens.
I think that's about all I've got on the game.
Thanks to the mods for the experience, it was certainly an interesting game.
Have set the bar high now... so we'll just have to try and match that for the August game.
0 -
A mistake was made and we made a decision on it. Jesus you sound bitter here for some reason skeith. I don't understand why since the whole thing didn't affect you at all in any way.
And actually I think you will find I didn't praise QB here and in the brs.
Who exactly are you jabbing here with your veiled insult?Aw, Keith, thanks for the sentiments. I like to think of myself as honest, and usually I am. But here I made a bad judgement call.
I shouldn't have shared the list with my teammates (I did). I shouldn't have quietly kept the list to myself and subtly steered my teammates to certain kills (I didn't). So maybe at least those two cancel each other out and I come out close to even on the honesty scale here.
I should have quietly told the mods I had the list, let them do a rejig and we all could have gotten on with things, and everyone would be happy. But, hindsight isn't much good after the fact. I hold no grudges to the mods for the decisions they made in regard to my poor judgement call.
See you on the 10th!
bitter, me. no way.
Yous never explained.
Up until qb's post above, everything i had read was that she showed the mods the list and to rectify the situation, you booted her from the game.
Its not my fault that that is all the evidence that was left behind for us on thread and in the backrooms.
qb has filled in the story, and now i understand, but before you judge me and call me bitter, read the thread and backrooms back over again from an outsider looking in and what you left behind and you will see that it looked like an injustice against a game break saviour was done, and i felt qb was wronged. it didn't matter in one bit that it didn't affect me.
veiled insult?0 -
-
-
Advertisement
-
-
-
-
-
-
Advertisement
-
-
-
-
-
-
Necrominus wrote:The starter pack: Fcuk me... that was a lot of information. Can tell the amount of effort put into producing it and it was an interesting change. One caveat is I will say I dunno if total mystery on village roles is a good thing. Thing is that wolves have a lot more information to start the game and have the benefit of communicating off thread to discuss their powers and what could possibly counter them. Think the island split alone being hidden would have been an amazing mystery item.
The pack was mostly stuff i grabbed off the internet. It looks more impressive that it is i think. That's what marketing is all about
Useful info from the pack was the hints at the start of it about the other islands, the HR page, which gave away an approximation of RV numbers and the genetics page which hinted that the Dino's were being controlled by handlers. I was saying this to someone, I kind of wanted the pack to be a little bit of extra background if people wanted to dive in, but if people didn't, it was still entirely possible to play the game just form info on thread.
I disagree on total mystery. Wolves had no idea what to be looking out for in terms of hints from RVs and in terms of tasks. It (the mystery) swung both ways imo and was something I really enjoyed from the previous game (easties).0 -
-
-
-
-
Advertisement
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Necrominus wrote: »Auto voting stuff would be AMAZING :eek: (If any admins are reading, I'd like this as my Christmas present please :pac: )
mine would be like google forms, but not.
for players.
you goto link,
who are you, select from list of remaining people.
passcode, type in code given to you by mods.
select who you want to vote for.
done.
will probably have time displayed, cause i can't guarante time in boards will be synced to that machine.
for mods, some initial setup will be necessary, but will be customizable and will be able to show all votes, and count and produce a copy pastable vote results.
thats the best i can offer. nothing boards integratable
COP integratable... hmmm.. once step at a time, build it first 0 -
-
-
Advertisement
-
![[Deleted User]](/applications/dashboard/design/images/defaulticon.png)
Advertisement