Werewolf Vanillarama II - Double the Vanilla

sKeith · 08-10-2018 12:39pm

tritium wrote: »

Yes,

what are your thoughts on it?

you retaliate to duffman saying you are a wolf by saying there was a lovely but subtle interplay between duffman and barney. I find it odd. smearing two due to omgus v duffman or you really see some kind of subtle interplay between the two but ca't show this interplay.

That one post you quote, interplay... I just dont see it!

sKeith · 08-10-2018 12:41pm

beakerjoe wrote: »

Well you can be coy about things and I can mark you for death, or you can speak up

Thats if you believe Im the Vig

Why would I believe you were the vig?

tritium · 08-10-2018 12:43pm

beakerjoe wrote: »

A wolf can have many incentives, one being to appear like they are not a wolf

Wolves dont have to look wolfy to be a wolf

Correct, but that’s the fun of this game isn’t it. You need to assess how likely a wolf is to have picked up on something and posted tactically on an unwolfy way. Like I said you take the evidence until you have more evidence

sKeith · 08-10-2018 12:44pm

Lord TSC wrote: »

In fairness, I wouldn't hold it against you at all. I've got a feeling that this is more of a "We've got little else to go on, so hand up someone for something minor" situation going on.

I'd be way more suspicious of people trying to paint you asking for clarification on a name as "wolfy" than actually asking for the clarification...

I sometime have issues figuring out english sentences. I am having lots of trouble figuring out the bolded. Can you explain it again, and imagine your audience is a 6 year old.

tritium · 08-10-2018 12:44pm

sKeith wrote: »

you retaliate to duffman saying you are a wolf by saying there was a lovely but subtle interplay between duffman and barney. I find it odd. smearing two due to omgus v duffman or you really see some kind of subtle interplay between the two but ca't show this interplay.

That one post you quote, interplay... I just dont see it!

The interplay is what I’ve stated. I’ve also stated why duffman isn’t actually top of my list. What flaw do you see in my reasoning?

beakerjoe · 08-10-2018 12:45pm

sKeith wrote: »

Why would I believe you were the vig?

Fair enough......

But yes or no, do you believe me?

beakerjoe · 08-10-2018 12:46pm

Am I a ballsey wolf, a balsey Vig or an NRV

Who knows right?

sKeith · 08-10-2018 12:47pm

tritium wrote: »

The interplay is what I’ve stated. I’ve also stated why duffman isn’t actually top of my list. What flaw do you see in my reasoning?

I would expect 'interplay' to include more than a singular post. You been asked to expand, but wont.

beakerjoe · 08-10-2018 12:49pm

A lot of lower posters thus far

Lord TSC · 08-10-2018 12:49pm

sKeith wrote: »

I sometime have issues figuring out english sentences. I am having lots of trouble figuring out the bolded. Can you explain it again, and imagine your audience is a 6 year old.

I'd be leaning towards Barney genuinely not knowing who "Tesco" was.

I wouldn't believe, in isolation, that such a request for clarification is enough to paint him as a wolf.

I would think a wolf might try and use it to start a snowball on him.

sKeith · 08-10-2018 12:51pm

beakerjoe wrote: »

Fair enough......

But yes or no, do you believe me?

No, but don't take that as a reason to have to prove something. I was vig killed as innocent in vanillarama. I was vig killed as a power role in stephen king. Both given 0 time for me to make a case for myself.

tritium · 08-10-2018 12:52pm

sKeith wrote: »

I would expect 'interplay' to include more than a singular post. You been asked to expand, but wont.

There is no won’t, I’ve fully explained my reasoning. Up to you if you want to accept or dismiss it.

Barney92 · 08-10-2018 12:56pm

tritium wrote: »

It’s not the why Barney bit per se. What incentive has a wolf to ask that question? If the breadcrumbs of evidence point to more villager than wolf behaviour then the player should be retained until other, different evidence emerges- would you agree?

Your post here is the incentive Trit. If Duffman is a wolf, you're now at the point you think I'm more likely to be a wolf than he is. I'd argue that's pretty incentivising for a wolf.

I would agree that you keep people that you believe to be villagers longer than those you think to be wolves.

tritium · 08-10-2018 12:58pm

Barney92 wrote: »

Your post here is the incentive Trit. If Duffman is a wolf, you're now at the point you think I'm more likely to be a wolf than he is. I'd argue that's pretty incentivising for a wolf.

I would agree that you keep people that you believe to be villagers longer than those you think to be wolves.

Do you think duffman is a wolf?

Barney92 · 08-10-2018 1:02pm

tritium wrote: »

Do you think duffman is a wolf?

Not at the minute no. So far I think they've been throwing names out without anything behind them. Seems to me to be a villager trying to get some reactions out of people.

beakerjoe · 08-10-2018 1:02pm

sKeith wrote: »

No, but don't take that as a reason to have to prove something. I was vig killed as innocent in vanillarama. I was vig killed as a power role in stephen king. Both given 0 time for me to make a case for myself.

Tick tock sKeith..... so make a case for yourself ASAP

Or dont since you dont believe me

sKeith · 08-10-2018 1:03pm

tritium wrote: »

There is no won’t, I’ve fully explained my reasoning. Up to you if you want to accept or dismiss it.

noun: interplay
the way in which two or more things have an effect on each other.

synonyms:interaction, interchange, teamwork, cooperation, reciprocation, reciprocity, give and take

Why refuse to requote the interplay, and just post one post and say, thats the interplay i was talking about?

sKeith · 08-10-2018 1:06pm

beakerjoe wrote: »

Tick tock sKeith..... so make a case for yourself ASAP

Or dont since you dont believe me

If you BJ are the vig, go ahead, shoot me. Then you won't come near my 100% record as vig

beakerjoe · 08-10-2018 1:07pm

sKeith wrote: »

If you BJ are the vig, go ahead, shoot me. Then you won't come near my 100% record as vig

You can keep your record.

sKeith · 08-10-2018 1:20pm

Lord TSC wrote: »

Quoting these for my own sake for latter. Two people posting the exact same thing (even down to the blah blah "quotation of suspect" blah blah structure) in rapid succession.

okay, i'll forgive the rapid sucession thing.

sullivlo wrote: »

Jaysus. Can’t win. Post too much get accused of being a wolf. Don’t post, get accused of being a wolf.

I only glanced through the thread so can’t quite point fingers yet but the new guy looks suspicious. Either a “me so innocent me no understand” when he clearly does, or his wolfy buddies are coaching him.

-

On a non-game related thing - I’ll be mainly posting from my phone and I can only use that ****e interactive interface so I can’t quote properly. I’ll try bring my iPad with me where I can use the normal site. But the interactive site is a nightmare with all of the buttons and mod buttons. So apologies in advance if I mess up quotes/miss posts.

fixxxer wrote: »

Well this all escalated very quickly.

Gannicus, getting a "little ol me don't know what I'm doing" vibe from you. Will be watching your posts.

MrsFlushdraw wrote: »

Anyway, good morning folks, great to wake up and not feel sick! was a rough day yesterday lol.

So, no Jack?? but the rest of us are here though. A noob that talks like a semi-noob. Welcome G (can't remember name) enjoy the game!

but you excluded mfd, who's post is closer in time to fixxxers than sullys.

sKeith · 08-10-2018 1:24pm

sKeith wrote: »

No, but don't take that as a reason to have to prove something. I was vig killed as innocent in vanillarama. I was vig killed as a power role in stephen king. Both given 0 time for me to make a case for myself.

You're wrong! it was sherlock, not stephen king game.

sullivlo · 08-10-2018 1:25pm

I posted early because of insomnia - no clue about that other chap. After the aforementioned insomnia, I am now very tired. I have no comeback beyond “I am not a wolf”. It’s not my first time playing this game - do you really think I’d be stupid enough to have repetitive posts with another poster?! Clutching at straws against me, methinks.

fixXxer · 08-10-2018 1:26pm

Lunch time catch up time.

fixXxer · 08-10-2018 1:29pm

Awks Sulli we posted together again.

tritium · 08-10-2018 1:32pm

sKeith wrote: »

noun: interplay
the way in which two or more things have an effect on each other.

synonyms:interaction, interchange, teamwork, cooperation, reciprocation, reciprocity, give and take

Why refuse to requote the interplay, and just post one post and say, thats the interplay i was talking about?

You’re only considering the post and not any other interaction or intent in back rooms for example

Jack Moore · 08-10-2018 1:33pm

beakerjoe wrote: »

You can keep your record.

I had to change mine

Youbsgooting flushy or what ?

sKeith · 08-10-2018 1:33pm

fixxxer wrote: »

Awks Sulli we posted together again.

lol, now thats what rapid succession is.
posting 2 hours later is not 'rapid sucession'.

I assume sullys post is to tesco, as it was him that made the rapid succession post.

Jack Moore · 08-10-2018 1:34pm

sKeith wrote: »

okay, i'll forgive the rapid sucession thing.

but you excluded mfd, who's post is closer in time to fixxxers than sullys.

Well since they are wolves it makes sense really
Avoid avoid

duffman13 · 08-10-2018 1:38pm

beakerjoe wrote: »

Can I shoot you to ptove myself?

All in favor say I

You can shoot me if you want.

I merely pointed out you couldn't kill Trit, you can't kill him cause you

A) Don't have a bullet

and

killing your wolfy comrade at this stage will drastically reduce your odds of winning

fixXxer · 08-10-2018 1:40pm

Jack Moore wrote: »

I had to change mine
Youbsgooting flushy or what ?

We don't know that BK is the vig but you want him to shoot blindly in to the crowd. Considering the numbers it's possible a villager would be hit if you're wrong.
Our vig would be out and need to take another almost blind shot before the wolves get him tomorrow.

It's not a great plan.

Werewolf Vanillarama II - Double the Vanilla

Comments