Sopranos Mafia - Family Redefined - GAME THREAD

Necro · 30-10-2018 10:03pm

Lynch Day 2 Voting Results:

Lynch Candidate No. of Votes Votes
Fiona WW 5 Winifred WW, Holly WW, Gertrude WW, Vernon WW, Barbara WW,
Winifred WW 3 Henry WW, Liam WW, Brendan WW
Orla WW 2 Gabriel WW, Derry WW
Ewan WW 2 Katie WW, Nigel WW
Clodagh WW 2 Jake WW, Clodagh WW*
Oisin WW 2 Orla WW, Oisin WW*
No Lynch 1 Fiona WW
Gertrude WW 1 Mary WW
Liam WW 1 Desmond WW
Henry WW 1 Ewan WW

*self votes

Holly WW · 30-10-2018 10:04pm

Both Oisin and Clodagh voted for themselves? Da Fuq?

Barbara WW · 30-10-2018 10:04pm

Clodagh and Oisin self voting?

I feel as if Clodagh hasn't been on but Oisin?

Barbara WW · 30-10-2018 10:04pm

"Self voting" meaning "didn't vote" I presume?

Katie WW · 30-10-2018 10:05pm

Could see that happening a mile away... Grrrr

Holly WW · 30-10-2018 10:05pm

Barbara WW wrote: »

Clodagh and Oisin self voting?

I feel as if Clodagh hasn't been on but Oisin?

That’s what I was thinking. Oisin was VERY active this evening.

Holly WW · 30-10-2018 10:07pm

Derry WW wrote: »

Crap. I was afraid of that. NRV dicking around as I suspected.

Yeah if people could stop dicking around that would be great.

It boils my p!ss when a NRV dicks about like that it only distracts the village from the actual wolves.

We need to try and pull it back together village. The lead is slipping.

Gabriel WW · 30-10-2018 10:08pm

Yeah, Clodagh and Oisin didn't vote so are penalised a vote against themselves. But somebody else voted for them each too, so it's actually two votes in total against them.

Holly WW · 30-10-2018 10:11pm

Winnie, Gerty and Vernon. Gerty and Vernon are following the crowd when it comes to voting.

Winnie as well jumped on the bandwagon.

Jake WW · 30-10-2018 10:11pm

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Yeah, Clodagh and Oisin didn't vote so are penalised a vote against themselves. But somebody else voted for them each too, so it's actually two votes in total against them.

Yeh that’s how it works I presume even though they sort of only show one...

I was hoping voting for Clodagh would get her talking but maybe she’s not around at all? Not much but fluff from her thus far....

Katie WW · 30-10-2018 10:11pm

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Yeah, Clodagh and Oisin didn't vote so are penalised a vote against themselves. But somebody else voted for them each too, so it's actually two votes in total against them.

That's not how I read it. I think they've only one vote against them and its their own

Gabriel WW · 30-10-2018 10:11pm

Necrominus wrote: »

Lynch Day 2 Voting Results:

So, if I may, it should actually be:

Lynch Candidate No. of Votes Voters
Fiona WW 5 Winifred WW, Holly WW, Gertrude WW, Vernon WW, Barbara WW
Winifred WW 3 Henry WW, Liam WW, Brendan WW
Orla WW 2 Gabriel WW, Derry WW
Ewan WW 2 Katie WW, Nigel WW
Clodagh WW 2 Jake WW, Clodagh WW*
Oisin WW 2 Orla WW, Oisin WW*
No Lynch 1 Fiona WW
Gertrude WW 1 Mary WW
Liam WW 1 Desmond WW
Oisin WW 1 Orla WW
Henry WW 1 Ewan WW

*self votes

Gabriel WW · 30-10-2018 10:12pm

Katie WW wrote: »

That's not how I read it. I think they've only one vote against them and its their own

But Jake also voted for Clodagh and Orla also voted for Oisin, so two votes against them. One each from Jake and Orla, and one each from themselves.

Katie WW · 30-10-2018 10:13pm

Gabriel WW wrote: »

So, if I may, it should actually be:

Lynch Candidate No. of Votes Voters
Fiona WW 5 Winifred WW, Holly WW, Gertrude WW, Vernon WW, Barbara WW
Winifred WW 3 Henry WW, Liam WW, Brendan WW
Orla WW 2 Gabriel WW, Derry WW
Ewan WW 2 Katie WW, Nigel WW
Clodagh WW 2 Jake WW, Clodagh WW*
Oisin WW 2 Orla WW, Oisin WW*
No Lynch 1 Fiona WW
Gertrude WW 1 Mary WW
Liam WW 1 Desmond WW
Oisin WW 1 Orla WW
Henry WW 1 Ewan WW

*self votes

Why would there own votes not count in the vote count. It wouldnt be much punishment if they didn't.

Necro · 30-10-2018 10:13pm

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Yeah, Clodagh and Oisin didn't vote so are penalised a vote against themselves. But somebody else voted for them each too, so it's actually two votes in total against them.

Whoops. Updated.

Gabriel WW · 30-10-2018 10:14pm

Katie WW wrote: »

Why would there own votes not count in the vote count. It wouldnt be much punishment if they didn't.

They're own vote does count. It was listed separately. Oisin got one because he didn't vote, and one because Orla voted for him. Total 2. He was listed twice with 1 vote, when he actually got 2 votes in total.

Katie WW · 30-10-2018 10:14pm

Katie WW wrote: »

Why would there own votes not count in the vote count. It wouldnt be much punishment if they didn't.

It's alright I see the mod announcement has been updated.

Holly WW · 30-10-2018 10:15pm

Ewan why did you vote for Henry??

Gabriel WW · 30-10-2018 10:15pm

Gabriel WW wrote: »

They're Their own vote does count. It was listed separately. Oisin got one because he didn't vote, and one because Orla voted for him. Total 2. He was listed twice with 1 vote, when he actually got 2 votes in total.

Gabriel WW · 30-10-2018 10:16pm

So, now that that's cleared up, I get Clodagh not voting, she has been inactive all day and seems disinterested from the beginning.

But Oisin! C'mon, Oisin lad, an explanation if you will!

Jake WW · 30-10-2018 10:17pm

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Holly WW · 30-10-2018 10:17pm

Gabriel WW wrote: »

They're own vote does count. It was listed separately. Oisin got one because he didn't vote, and one because Orla voted for him. Total 2. He was listed twice with 1 vote, when he actually got 2 votes in total.

Can the BG protect this man please. Gabs is currently leading the village. We need a strong leader now. As it’s getting tighter.

Derry WW · 30-10-2018 10:19pm

Derry WW wrote: »

Yeah the win conditions make for a very interesting wolf team. I think we can assume that with Melfi dead Tony is pure Soprano now so they'll be trying to figure out Chris and Pussy. Actually the more I think about it are they deliberately not killing?

Can I bring this up again? Jake made a good point which I'd not given a huge amount of thought to so far. The win conditions and the potential for double crossing combined with the fact that there has been no kill so far makes me wonder if this isn't a deliberate strategy by the wolves. Is there an upside for them in not killing early on and hoping we take each other out to narrow the numbers?

Gabriel WW · 30-10-2018 10:20pm

Holly WW wrote: »

Can the BG protect this man please. Gabs is currently leading the village. We need a strong leader now. As it’s getting tighter.

Aww, shucks

Holly WW · 30-10-2018 10:22pm

Derry WW wrote: »

Can I bring this up again? Jake made a good point which I'd not given a huge amount of thought to so far. The win conditions and the potential for double crossing combined with the fact that there has been no kill so far makes me wonder if this isn't a deliberate strategy by the wolves. Is there an upside for them in not killing early on and hoping we take each other out to narrow the numbers?

That’s too risky of strategy for the wolves especially with the ITAs.

Derry WW · 30-10-2018 10:25pm

Holly WW wrote: »

That’s too risky of strategy for the wolves especially with the ITAs.

But how could they be sure that they'd hit an NRV/FBI/RV if they kill? I mean in their backroom they'd be listed by their Soprano names and could Christopher or Pussy afford to share their anon account names? I'm just wondering if, given that no lynch is a possibility for the village, could no kill be a valid option for the Sopranos?

Gabriel WW · 30-10-2018 10:25pm

So, wolves don't seem to be bandwagoning. The only one to vote for both lynchees both nights is Holly, who, we're pretty certain, isn't a wolf.

So, a very different set of people voting for victim each time.

Lynch 2 (Frank): Brendan WW, Clodagh WW, Derry WW, Ewan WW, Fiona WW, Holly WW
Lynch 3 (Fiona): Barbara WW, Gertrude WW, Holly WW, Vernon WW, Winifred WW

I'm not sure what that exactly tells us though.

Gabriel WW · 30-10-2018 10:27pm

Derry WW wrote: »

But how could they be sure that they'd hit an NRV/FBI/RV if they kill? I mean in their backroom they'd be listed by their Soprano names and could Christopher or Pussy afford to share their anon account names? I'm just wondering if, given that no lynch is a possibility for the village, could no kill be a valid option for the Sopranos?

Junior: "Hey, I think Fred WW has a role, let's munch him".
Tony / Fred WW: "Nah, I think he's just a NRV, we should go for Zach WW instead."

Katie WW · 30-10-2018 10:29pm

Gabriel WW wrote: »

So, wolves don't seem to be bandwagoning. The only one to vote for both lynchees both nights is Holly, who, we're pretty certain, isn't a wolf.

So, a very different set of people voting for victim each time.

Lynch 2 (Frank): Brendan WW, Clodagh WW, Derry WW, Ewan WW, Fiona WW, Holly WW
Lynch 3 (Fiona): Barbara WW, Gertrude WW, Holly WW, Vernon WW, Winifred WW

I'm not sure what that exactly tells us though.

It tells us sweet fa

It's a very quiet village. There's a cohort of low posters and few if any are doing FFAs we're literally allowing a coasting. Not sure if the initial day one success has led us to be complacent or the overall game mechanics are having a particular influence.

Derry WW · 30-10-2018 10:30pm

Katie WW wrote: »

Not sure if the initial day one success has led us to be complacent or the overall game mechanics are having a particular influence.

I think it's a combo of both.

Sopranos Mafia - Family Redefined - GAME THREAD

Comments