Werewolf: The Game Show

beakerjoe

MrsFlushdraw wrote: »

I just had to scroll back through 12 pages so I could remember what it was I had in mind for a game. I thought if I wrote it down here it would help. No need to be a nob! maybe if you knew the answer of the top of your head you could have said that instead? yes it is off topic. But had an idea for the game if it hasn't been done!

I dont care, how about some non neutral reads.

beakerjoe

No one looking at Stu or Fixxxer

Seriously

Barney also missed an FFA

Necro

beakerjoe wrote: »

Who didnt submit an FFA

Rikand, Fixxxer Uriel... who have I missed

Pter

I previously posted this:

Necro wrote: »

Still no FFAs from:


Fixxxer
Quickbeam
Rikand
Lord TSC
Uriel
Drumpot
Deconduo

And omitted Pter admittedly.

Since that QB, Deco, and Lord all FFAed.

So list would be
Fixxxer
Rikand
Uriel
Drumpot
Pter

who did not submit an FFA.

MrsFlushdraw

beakerjoe wrote: »

I dont care, how about some non neutral reads.

How about no and stop being a bully PITA.

You are all games and fun when it suits you. If I have a read on someone I will say. I don't need you to tell me what to do thanks.

Now run off to your cave

Necro

beakerjoe wrote: »

No one looking at Stu or Fixxxer

Seriously

Barney also missed an FFA

No Barney did FFA. Tis above.

Baggly

Necro wrote:

And omitted Pter admittedly.

Because Pter did an FFA. And honked it immediately after BJ honked.

Baggly

An FFA that puts you tied for 3rd spot necro.

Necro

Pter wrote: »

Because Pter did an FFA. And honked it immediately after BJ honked.

Did you? I must have missed it?

Baggly

Sully and you are my FFA.

Necro

Pter wrote: »

Nah he is capable and due.



Honk also. Sully and necro. That was mine.

Ah. no idea how I missed that.

deconduo

Day 0 was all fluff. First non-fluff post comes on the afternoon of Day 1:

sullivlo wrote: »

I would usually trust your gut, but in this case you’re wrong. Peek away on me, but it would be a waste of a peek.

.... more stuff in a similar vein .....

Quite defensive here, but nothing else of substance.

sullivlo wrote: »

#FFA1
Necro
Pter
Beaker

Necro and pter because their interactions seem too forced/planned.

Beaker because of the crazy role claim.

Throws out FFA list with minor justification. Hadn't really mentioned any of these people before. Next next few posts after this are just 'nope, not me' defensive posts. No reads, or anything to back up the FFA list.

sullivlo wrote: »

So who are top 3? Lough, Necro and qb?

sullivlo wrote: »

Okay. I have voted from those 3.

sullivlo wrote: »

RIP Lough! Enjoy Christmas.

This series of posts is what really got my hackles up. Sully was somewhat in the firing line already, had not contributed anything really - and then fires out this 'IDGAF' one-liners. This is awful stuff

sullivlo wrote: »

Am I a wolf? No. Any other suspicion? Pter, beaker and barney.

Adds barney to the list, but nothing to back it up with again.

sullivlo wrote: »

Finally something I can respond to.

The multi quote was due to time constraints. I multi quoted, copied it into a document and built responses in.
The “peek me” was in response to the ridiculous claim of bj - he was looking for candidates to peek. My name was in lots of FFAs so I wanted to clear my name.

As for not being helpful sorry.

FWIW:
Necro - something dodgey. Can’t figure if the talking clock was a task or not.
Pter - mad prize claim, looks to be covering himself in case he doesn’t die in a lynch.

Combination of necro and Pete and their lovers tiff would make me suspicious of both.

Quick was very... quick to engage with the countdown clock too.

Beaker - was only having fun with his role claim but I think there was more to it.

I’m suspicious of Rice cakes but I’m not sure if that’s just my bias because he was baiting me.

Drumpot also puzzles me - why make my post bold? Task?

Yay, first post of substance 56 hours into the game. At least I can say that Sully has contributed more than PJ :eek:

sullivlo wrote: »

#ffa2
Necro
Pter
Quickbeam

For reasons listed in previous post.

sullivlo wrote: »

I am suspicious of necro and the clock. But iirc quick was the first to mention the clock - before necro. So it made me think task.

sullivlo wrote: »

Nothing major on fixxxr. Seems fairly innocuous.

Flush seems to be a bit inconsistent in her posts - flip flopping a bit.

Stu - gut says good.

Good stuff good stuff. Finally getting some actual reads and not just pure defense. Would like stronger reads and more than just one-liners but hey.


Conclusion: Terrible start, no contributions really at all. Flippant and uncaring about the day 1 lynch - but some minor progress in the last 2 hours. Enough to drop her down from first to #2 behind PJ on my lynch list.

@Sully: Please give us more reads and more of your thoughts on other players. Try to give us more than just one liners as well.

beakerjoe

Pter and Necro in a new series reboot of Bottom

WerewolfGM

quickbeam wrote: »

Just voted for anyone who asks later.

@Mods, there's dead people and subbed-off people still on the form, in case you're not aware.

Thanks for the heads up. I think I have this fixed now :cool:

Jack Moore

beakerjoe wrote: »

Whatever about me, but can you nit see his play is altered this game.

I agree with the bus driver

Necro

Updated FFAs:

Player Name Choice 1 Choice 2 Choice 3
Stu Redman partyjungle quickbeam sully/Rikand
Necro Uriel sully Flushy
duffman13 quickbeam sully beakerjoe
partyjungle Necro fixxxer Uriel
Sully Necro Pter quickbeam
Flushy Uriel quickbeam sully
beakerjoe fixxxer quickbeam Stu Redman/Flushy
Jack Moore Pter sully Lord TSC
Barney92 fixxxer Uriel sully
Lord TSC Necro Flushy Stu Redman
deconduo partyjungle sully
quickbeam sully partyjungle Flushy
Pter sully Necro

Results:

sully 9
quickbeam 5
Uriel 4
Flushy 4
Necro 4
fixxxer 3
partyjungle 3
Pter 2
Stu Redman 2
Rikand 1
beakerjoe 1
Lord TSC 1

This is why we put hashtags on things folks.

So looks like a choice of 5. Same 4 as before
Sully, QB, Uriel, Flushy - and myself.

Yay for split choices.

Baggly

If tasks are in play QB did another one earlier.

quickbeam

Pter wrote: »

If tasks are in play QB did another one earlier.

No I didn't. Which post?

MrsFlushdraw

Pter wrote: »

If tasks are in play QB did another one earlier.

Oh?

quickbeam

As I've had so little so far this evening, I'm presuming it's mentioning This Is Your Life. Which isn't even a gameshow.

Necro

Pter wrote: »

If tasks are in play QB did another one earlier.

I'm starting to think you just want to loop out this sully/Necro axis of evil you're pushing for another day.

beakerjoe

quickbeam wrote: »

As I've had so little so far this evening, I'm presuming it's mentioning This Is Your Life. Which isn't even a gameshow.

Any read on stu and Fixxxer

quickbeam

beakerjoe wrote: »

Any read on stu and Fixxxer

Yeah, I think Stu is good. I'm not seeing what you're seeing, though I think you're good too.

I'm not sure about Fixxxer. Slight uneasy feel but haven't had time to do the search back to pull evidence of what it is about him.

Baggly

quickbeam wrote:

As I've had so little so far this evening, I'm presuming it's mentioning This Is Your Life. Which isn't even a gameshow.

Fair point. I did say IF

Baggly

Necro wrote:

I'm starting to think you just want to loop out this sully/Necro axis of evil you're pushing for another day.

Who asked you? I've voted sully like I said I would yesterday. If duffer shoots her I'll vote you. If you both die I move on.

Necro

Lord TSC wrote: »

Going off what I've posted over the day...

#FFA1
1. LoughC
2. Necro
3. MrsF


Order of preference too.
In all due fairness to MrsF, if the "hotspot" thing was a reference I didn't get, that's fair enough. As it is, she's third on my list because she engaged with Necro and Lough after the munch, participating in the downplaying of Virt. My preference is squarely on 1 and 2 right now.

Lough right at the top by a margin though. Downplaying Virt's role, and then saying he's a loss for the village, and then trying to tie the death to Beaker....he's all over the place right now, imo.

Lord TSC wrote: »

My #FFA2 right now

1. Necro (and where my vote is likely going in) the countdown clock that isn’t counting down.
2, MrsF, who made my list yesterday and has done nothing to allay those fears today. If anything, her read list was washy, and that she wouldn’t be honest about why I’m on it as a wolf lean only makes me more suspicious.
3. Stu. Much as yesterday, 1 and 2 are my main fears. As was pointed out,Stu isn’t acting like Stu. But he’s way below Necro and a good bit below Flushy.

Stuncould well change by the deadline though.

Lordy, I feel your reads are completely static and it's exactly what a wolf would do if they were FFAing.

Eliminate one, move onto the next.

Even the wording you use is so consistent. Margins, way below...

I'd like a full reads list from you tbh.

Baggly

Necro, you remind me of the German version of Andy Capp.

Jack Moore

Pter wrote: »

Necro, you remind me of the German version of Andy Capp.

Andy Crapp

Jack Moore

Can the captains isolate consecutively ?

fixXxer

Originally Posted by fixxxer View Post
Its a good time to come clean on this Rikand.

I don't think Sulli is a wolf, there hasn't been any hint of intervention from other players to deflect or make any sort of defence on her behalf. SK would be my guess. Or just a grump.
Wait, now you dont think Sully is a wolf? Why?

Like how can you be sure? Based on what?

I smell evil here. Based off this, Fixxxers not looking good.

---

BK, your lists make me think you are on our village side, but your unwillingness to read whats in front of you makes me wonder. I literally spell it out what my thought are in the post there and you make a comment saying "but he doesnt explain it" It says it right there, no one intervened to deflect or defend sulli so in my eyes that doesn't make me feel like Sulli has any back up. Sullis replys remind oe of LoughC, defensive but not enquiring. To me that feels team evil, but solo evil.

Jack Moore

fixxxer wrote: »

Originally Posted by fixxxer View Post
Its a good time to come clean on this Rikand.

I don't think Sulli is a wolf, there hasn't been any hint of intervention from other players to deflect or make any sort of defence on her behalf. SK would be my guess. Or just a grump.
Wait, now you dont think Sully is a wolf? Why?

Like how can you be sure? Based on what?

I smell evil here. Based off this, Fixxxers not looking good.

---

BK, your lists make me think you are on our village side, but your unwillingness to read whats in front of you makes me wonder. I literally spell it out what my thought are in the post there and you make a comment saying "but he doesnt explain it" It says it right there, no one intervened to deflect or defend sulli so in my eyes that doesn't make me feel like Sulli has any back up. Sullis replys remind oe of LoughC, defensive but not enquiring. To me that feels team evil, but solo evil.

I think she’s a sk as well
I’m worried that beaker and peter is a w/w interaction

It it is then lord is in on it