Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Silence of the Wolves - A Game of Werewolf GAME THREAD
Comments
-
-
-
-
-
I partially apologise for the long post with multiple quotes but think that it is kind of necessary. No one has come out and said it yet so I think I should. When you are doing an FFA please put #FFAX with X being the day number. It's #FFA1 for this round of FFAs and then will increase after this lynch to 2 and so on. The reason for this is to allow easy searching. As you can see from the quotes below there are a number of variations that people have been using which makes it hard to search. I have yet to do an FFA yet but will have one up later.
#FFA1
Also to note that I may have missed some in my search back, so this isn't a comprehensive list. I also think it excludes people who used the hashtag #FFA1 (I know Pter did). I'm not going to hang anyone for not using the standard hashtag but it might make me concerned about regular players if they don't use the standard format, especially if their FFAs are 'weak'.So I've done my reads - a bit later than planned but this is where I'm at right now.
For my current #FFA it's my top 3 wolfiest, G & R, Kolido and Tusk but still another day to lynch so this could and likely will change.
Barney92 Gif heavy, bit about 'if' Strawbs dies, did reads on Whiplash's posts - Slight village
Bounty Hunter Also gif heavy. Suggested and did FFA. Slight village.
Clarabel Not much here - neutral for now
crosstownk 2 Posts - nothing
Digital Solitude 1 Post - nothing
Dublinandy2 Unique posting style which I kind of like - need to be careful of that. Others very suspicious but I'm not seeing it. Closer look needed. Neutral for now.
Duffman13 Made an early read and no sign since munch. Neutral to wolf.
Ectoplasm Me. Village.
fixxxer Mostly gifs to start. Did a read back based on munch choice - smart wolf or active village? Lines up Trit as shady while suggesting Skunk more clear, team? Neutral to wolf for now
Green&Red Quick to go with SK being village. Why? Team? Focused on Dandy. Accuses others of throwing shade while throwing shade. Current top wolf suspect.
kitten_k Suggested munches not useful - strange. Watch interplay with Strawbs. Neutral to wolf at the moment.
Kolido Why would 1st munch be most telling of the game? Setting village up to read more into it than necessary? Slight wolf.
Loughc 2 Posts - nothing
Pter Mostly reacting to Skeith. Kind of disagree with him on Dandy but agree that there's likely a loud wolf. Slight village
quickbeam Not too much here to go on. Similar reaction to mine with Kitten's post. Neutral for now.
sKeith Aggressive play - taking on leader role yet not munched - double/triple bluff? Not convinced he's village but not convinced he's wolf. Neutral for now.
Strawberry Milkshake Originally top suspect - reread post that bothered me so moved off top suspect spot. Slight wolf with Kitten possibly
Succubus_ Claimed suspect already - were they, check. Other than that, 2 posts - nothing.
TheSkunk Post about wolves going for someone who hasn't posted much is worth noting; who's been looking at Skunk? Kinda defends Andy - always makes me wary. Neutral to village but definitely needs follow up look.
Triceratops Ballet Kind of with her on the whole 'lets call out low posters' bs. Neutral for now.
tritium Suspicious of Skunk. Mild shade at Barney. Notes GnR & DAndy's interaction. Agrees with me on G&R, yet I'm leaning slight wolf.
tusk Type of villager post rang a bell - slight wolf
Whiplashy Dead Munch Day 1
Current Order
Green & Red Wolfiest
Kolido
Tusk
Tritium
Kitten K
Strawbs
Duffman
fixxer
Dandy
Skeith Neutralish
TB
QB
Clarabel
Skunk
Barney
Bounty Hunter
Pter
Me Villageriest
succubus Not enough to go on really
CTK
Lough C
DigiMy current list, top is clear bottom is dodgy, just graded, not sorted within grades yet.
Lock clear villager
sKeith - Lock CLEAR
leaning village
Green&Red - decent read of me, advancing player or TMI? (for newbies 'too much information') ah feck, barney can keep an eye on him, consider me slightly pocketed here
tusk - I can see where his sKeith / skunk and kolido wolf leans are coming from. He's also villa leaning my villa lean. You earned a villa lean from me.
Strawberry Milkshake - Like answers given when i asked about why she like the fact there was no village aligned power roles.
tritium - nice acknowledgment of mountainous (for newbies, the nice picture of the mountains was a ref to the type of game we are currently playing, mountainous, no power roles, and only vanilla wolves) shade / not shade on me and pter, or just trying to game solve. Dont lynch here first. Reevaluate the here on day 2. There posts so far are pro village.
Barney92 - some shade but is honest about it, game solvey? depends how pter flips, not w/w with pter.
Dublinandy2 - not all wolves are furry, the eccentric, either he is pocketing me or whatever, i like him.
quickbeam - very slight village lean
nullish
Bounty Hunter - forty coats with his fifty pockets.
Pter - seems to try hard to read my posts but ignores mention of TB being guarded about what she posts. Asks for explanations to stuff already in thread. Seems to be trying to act villagery. Recieved some backup from sm, but i'm village leaning on sm, so gonna discard that for a while.
Ectoplasm - has a long list that SM is top of , but when asked can't produce any list. ecto has moved up today as she gave a reads list, i'll be keeping an eye on the list, but giving one is good..
Clarabel i like clarabels progression, she is making reads, she is scum reading some of my town lean, but thats okay, i need somebody to keep me straight on my blinkers.
Null
Succubus_ - picked up on pter & sKeith back and forth. picked up on kolido birthday, but not when. thats a very low thread awareness. still null.
Crosstownk - pretty null except G&R softly defended them. They mentioned that if necro was playing it be like reading war n peace. i couldn't relate, and i wonder if he had actually read war and peace, caz, why lie about that, and gnr comes swinging hard at me re war and peace.
Digital Solitude - null as null can be, has he forgotten about the game?
Triceratops Ballet - she says she has to watch what she says, nothing further, more came from tb, still on watch, but more null now than lean bad.
very slight inkling of wolf equity
Kolido - shader
Loughc - shader, lough c aint moved, 2 poster, get posting or modkill on the way.
Duffman13 - claims to have found two wolves in the OPs, one's a dead villa. moved duff down today.
leaning wolf
kitten_k - very defensive, skims thread.
fixxxer - having trouble giffing. fixxxer has moved down, backing skunk
TheSkunk - Liked there OP more than most, sk v duffman. troubled re my lock clear. provides excuses for absence that nobody cares about. Still, wants to know why lock clear. seems to misunderstand shade vs picking apart peoples posts. Yeah, making a new grade for this one. leaning wolf.
The Dead
Whiplashy (Villa) - jokes that kolido is a wolf.
okay, so i have 3 in my leaning wolf, take this as my ffa.
i have 7 in my village, this is great.
if i havent moved you in a while, you need to get talking with me, make me see you.....Bounty Hunter wrote: »#FFA 1
1.Green&Red
2. Strawberry
3.Duffman
Green & Red - Wanting to start a bandwagon and in doing so casting shade on anyone who would think alike as bandwagoning before later being open to moving off DubAndy
Strawberry - Claimed max 100 posts per cyce would be difficult but has only just about hit 30 so far. reacted more than most to Whiplash death but then immediately voted Kitten without much of an explanation. Not pushed on FFAs apparently and then went to do homework on our departed Whiplash and return but didn't mention whiplash again after that,
Duffman - That 3rd one is not super strong but I easily imagine one of the wolves staying very quiet given it's only officially day 1 and they have company to hide in from the lower posters, maybe LoughC, Duffman or someone similar and its hard to justify one in a group
few other notworthy people are:
Dublin Andy - Potentially on a team with G&D based on the above but looking at Andy in isolation his posts sometimes seem a bit prepared. Had an early excuse for missing Day 0 too and wolves often feel the need to excuse their absence more. If anyone was going to push a low lying wolf out of my top 3 atm it'd probably be him
sKeith - Not a fan of the whole Lock Clear thing but don't think a wolf would be playing like sK is atm and drawing such attention. That said posting so much more often than others while not imo really directing the village could be in terms of misdirection / distraction but no for me
Trit - Could mostly be gut that has me suspecting Trit a little, a few wishy washy posts stating that interactions could indicate someone is a wolf or not a wolf etc
Triceratops - no read at all, not a fan of using the term fluff but feel TB and her shower renovation has done enough without adding a whole lot to kinda skirt by and this has my gut worrying a bit
The rest I don't have much of a lean on Pter for example I was a little suspicious but his reads aren't too far off my own and that would make me not focus too much on him yet
Will probably put a placeholder in for 1 or 2 above soonFFA #1
1. SKeith - Despite the consensus that’s who I think is. I know people are saying a wolf wouldn’t post like that but why wouldn’t they? He’s involved in literally everything going on so far.
2. Green&Red - The whole Andy band wagon thing. He was the one who brought up SKs previous posting style and he had a little back and forth earlier in the game with SK.
3. Tusk - Didn’t respond when I offered up an explanation about Whip but agreed with another poster poster after that it had something to do with me. Also liked post #275 from G&R to SK, only saw it when going back but thought it odd and possibly a wolf liking their wolf buddies interaction.
Open to change over the next couple of days but that’s it for tonightDublinandy2 wrote: »My FFA:
G&R - seemed to focus on me immediately and wouldn’t let go for no other reason than I didn’t conform.
Pter - likes to point, sit back and then watch. Not a fan of his style.
Bounty Hunter - I didn’t have a third but he seems to be the one that no one is questioning and I believe everyone should be questioned somewhat until the game progresses more.Well as I said, doing my reads of Keithys list.
Keithy - why is a nrv trying to clear themselves so much in a game with no roled vils. How many times have you posted that list with you lock clear, thats the first thing I see. I can see through your big wolfy eyes
So if Keithy is a wolf, he will likely tarnish another member, step right up Lough.
Chances are a rather new player will be wolf number 3. What ya think Clarebel?
FFA#1
Keith
Lough
Clarebel
I would keep Keith around for his wolf input, voting Lough atm.
Village lean going on above analysis, pter, bh, lady Skunk.Note to self: keep up with the thread and don't wait until you have pages to read! Ok, so we're voting tonight before 9. Feck, I'm absolutely suspicious of everyone and I obviously need to post more so people can get a handle on me.
Ok, so an FFA is where we put up 3 people we suspect the most?
1. sKeith - sorry but I just think you're a bit too eager to hunt wolves, seems like a cover.
2. Loughc - this is going on others' suspicions as I haven't played before and it seems odd for a mod to be keeping such a low profile.
3. Pter - sorry Pter but I'm just getting a whiff of wolf off you, can't put my finger on it
This list could change and I haven't voted yet.I'm on page 33
I've voted duffman for obvious reasons....I forgot it was starting.
My FFA right now is
Strawbs
Trit
Barney
Will update after I've read ALL of the pages. Won't be posting under the sea. Missed my train to London, makes me sad.#FFA 1
Dandy - Raised my suspicions from the start. I was beginning to warm to him but yesterday he claimed he trusted Petr, now he doesn't. I know things move on but I want to have a proper read of his posts. My vote remains here
Fixxxer - gut feel, I've had it as hes posted in real time and reading back over his posts I still have it. Nothing I could put my finger on
Third is a toss up, I'll come back to it later - currently between about five or sixThis is a very good point!
FFA.
Strawbs - Always a wolf
Lady skunk
So many pages to go. I should probably get a pencil instead of using my posts ton track notes0 -
Advertisement
-
-
-
-
-
Awh man after catching up I’m sad I have two votes
No worries though Quickbeam, hope you’re feeling better soon.
SK, I haven’t got much of a read off of Kitten. Nothing that stood out and made me question her anyway. There’s a lot of people like that for me though. Innocent until proven suspicious :pac:
Tusk, I don’t even know how I can get you to change your vote on me as you’re in my FFA too. Interested to see what your response will be to why you’re in my FFA.
Thinking of voting G&R out of my 3. After reading your first big response I was kind of hesitant but your following replies to people still have me a little suss. Not definite on that though.
SK you’re number 1 on my FFA but I remember you saying you’d provide proof of your lock clear claim if you weren’t lynched tonight. I reckon if you can prove it then great but if not then you’d definitely be next vote for me. If you’re going to go back on your word though I’ll be putting my vote on you.
I’ll have a proper read over everything from today when I’m back from work and will post when I vote.0 -
Advertisement
-
-
-
-
-
Awh man after catching up I’m sad I have two votes
No worries though Quickbeam, hope you’re feeling better soon.
SK, I haven’t got much of a read off of Kitten. Nothing that stood out and made me question her anyway. There’s a lot of people like that for me though. Innocent until proven suspicious :pac:
Tusk, I don’t even know how I can get you to change your vote on me as you’re in my FFA too. Interested to see what your response will be to why you’re in my FFA.
Thinking of voting G&R out of my 3. After reading your first big response I was kind of hesitant but your following replies to people still have me a little suss. Not definite on that though.
SK you’re number 1 on my FFA but I remember you saying you’d provide proof of your lock clear claim if you weren’t lynched tonight. I reckon if you can prove it then great but if not then you’d definitely be next vote for me. If you’re going to go back on your word though I’ll be putting my vote on you.
I’ll have a proper read over everything from today when I’m back from work and will post when I vote.
Okay, they are your null reads. Its not innocent until suspicious.There’s a lot of people like that for me though. Innocent until proven suspicious
grade them null until you like, then move up to villageish.
or null until you dislike, then move those down to wolfish.
When you really trust someone, they can move towards you village core, and you trust and integrate their read with your own and try solve game.
With everyone is innocent, you are possibly trusting wolves, who have motives that are not village aligned.
Not what I said. I'll use it to prevent a mislynch on me and not before.SK you’re number 1 on my FFA but I remember you saying you’d provide proof of your lock clear claim if you weren’t lynched tonight.
Ehh, if I go back on my word, then i've been mislynched, and auto-priest has said that I'm village alligned, so thats some weird ass empty promise.If you’re going to go back on your word though I’ll be putting my vote on you.
I'm turning around on this slot.
This post has village feel to it.
Reaction to the two votes just feel villagery, especially when qb was one of them.
As I have said manys a time, the best way to get votes of you is find your votees a viable alternative.0 -
-
-
-
-
-
Advertisement
-
FFA #1
3. Tusk - Didn’t respond when I offered up an explanation about Whip but agreed with another poster poster after that it had something to do with me. Also liked post #275 from G&R to SK, only saw it when going back but thought it odd and possibly a wolf liking their wolf buddies interaction.
Open to change over the next couple of days but that’s it for tonight
I still need to catch up on the thread, but here's my thoughts...
Not sure what I didn't respond to, but happy to weigh in if you remember what it is? my liking of G&Rs comment was purely for my love of sarky comebacks. I was actually surprised nobody else liked it too. It nearly had me p*ssing myself.
All I'm doing is calling out things I see as dodgy, as I said, at the beginning, mostly it was a gut reaction, and from then, bits and bobs of interaction only heightened my suspicion. That, plus DublinAndy's adamant protection of you isn't helping your case for me.
On your side, I don't think your explanations of my wolfiness are enough to waste a vote on, unless you're trying to silence me because I'm on to you. However, I see now that somebody else has jumped on me too, so I would be imploring the village to look at you and that person (ecto iirc), and dublinandy as wolves, if the vote goes my way tonight.
As for the other person who has me in their ffa, my 'type of villager' comment actually took me a while to write. I was afraid if i simply said 'type of player' people would jump on that as a wolf play, but I guess that backfired
0 -
-
-
I still need to catch up on the thread, but here's my thoughts...
Not sure what I didn't respond to, but happy to weigh in if you remember what it is? my liking of G&Rs comment was purely for my love of sarky comebacks. I was actually surprised nobody else liked it too. It nearly had me p*ssing myself.
All I'm doing is calling out things I see as dodgy, as I said, at the beginning, mostly it was a gut reaction, and from then, bits and bobs of interaction only heightened my suspicion. That, plus DublinAndy's adamant protection of you isn't helping your case for me.
On your side, I don't think your explanations of my wolfiness are enough to waste a vote on, unless you're trying to silence me because I'm on to you. However, I see now that somebody else has jumped on me too, so I would be imploring the village to look at you and that person (ecto iirc), and dublinandy as wolves, if the vote goes my way tonight.
As for the other person who has me in their ffa, my 'type of villager' comment actually took me a while to write. I was afraid if i simply said 'type of player' people would jump on that as a wolf play, but I guess that backfired
If I die a village it will help her cause though?0 -
-
-
-
-
-
Advertisement
-
Advertisement