Silence of the Wolves - A Game of Werewolf GAME THREAD

Baggly

Who decided it's strawbs vs kolido?

Who agrees that's a good choice?

Are we not voting the non modkill low posters?

Dublinandy2

If we're going for a speaker then it's fixxxer in my eyes
if it's strawberry vs kolido then it's kolido

I have had half an eye on the message board these last two days posting when I can and for some reason lots of people have mentioned fixxxer but he keeps getting brushed over. Maybe it's because he's a village or maybe because his hairy friends are doing a good job at hiding him. I have no idea and I dot' have the time at work to start reading 90 pages of posts.

But I'd look at him, kolido, g and r, pter and others before strawberry, she seems to be just involved and working towards the greater good.

quickbeam

Pter wrote: »

Who decided it's strawbs vs kolido?

Who agrees that's a good choice?

Are we not voting the non modkill low posters?

Keith asked Strawbs who she’d run against and she said Kolido.

I think it was only theoretical though. As was my answer as to who I’d vote for in such a race.

I don’t think it’s agreed we actually do it. I’m not arguing for it in any case and my vote is still currently elsewhere.

sKeith

Pter wrote: »

Who decided it's strawbs vs kolido?

Who agrees that's a good choice?

Are we not voting the non modkill low posters?

Don't extinguish the conversation.
This is a productive conversation we are all having here, and we are well away from 9pm and there is no majority voting enabled, whats your major malfunction.

Baggly

I'm voting for digi, as a non modkill low poster. I'm choosing him over crosstown as digi genied earlier.

Baggly

sKeith wrote:

Don't extinguish the conversation. This is a productive conversation we are all having here, and we are well away from 9pm and there is no majority voting enabled, whats your major malfunction.

I'm not. I'm asking questions.

tusk

Genied?

sKeith

Pter wrote: »

I'm not. I'm asking questions.

You threw a damp towel on the conversation.

sKeith

tusk wrote: »

Genied?

you rub the lamp and the genie appears, it's in reference to a player appearing right after their name is mentioned on thread.

Baggly

sKeith wrote:

You threw a damp towel on the conversation.

I asked some questions sk. Nothing stopping anyone to continue going along with the Kolido vs strawbs thing.

In fact my middle question encouraged people to confirm if they are for or against it.

Go away and don't be annoying me with your damp towel.

Barney92

tusk wrote: »

Genied?

Turned up on the thread shortly after being mentioned.

Baggly

Pter: 'digi'

*poof*

/digi posts

tusk

Pter wrote: »

Who decided it's strawbs vs kolido?

Who agrees that's a good choice?

Are we not voting the non modkill low posters?

I didn't see this as trying to stop the convo FWIW

sKeith

tusk wrote: »

I didn't see this as trying to stop the convo FWIW

I though we left the discussion about low posters hours ago, we move on and then pter reverts the conversation to low posters again.

Bounty Hunter

G&R did a detailed post about Strawbs, do the people who are on Kolido have something (not expecting the same) to explain why he is so wolfy he should be voted for?

sKeith

Bounty Hunter wrote: »

G&R did a detailed post about Strawbs, do the people who are on Kolido have something (not expecting the same) to explain why he is so wolfy he should be voted for?

did anybody declare voting on kolido?

Baggly

sKeith wrote:

I though we left the discussion about low posters hours ago, we move on and then pter reverts the conversation to low posters again.

Alongside the current discussion about voting strategy.

It needs to be said anyway if we are going to get the low posters posting.

Necro

tusk wrote: »

Genied?

You rang? :P

Ectoplasm

Tusk ISO notes

Initially suspicious of SKeith, Skunk and Kolido.

Posts about type of villager

Asks a lot of questions - normal for a new player.

Declared Kolido and switch to Skunk

Changes suspicions to Skunk, Kolido and DAndy here

Back to DAndy as clear

Challenges fixxer here

Play up to here seems quite new villager.

FFA now Skunk, Kolido and Ecto

This is a post that raised my suspicions. There are a few things standing out. Seemed to just drop fixxer as a suspect. Still getting wolf vibes from DAndy despiter earlier listing him as clear. A lot of 'need to read back' as explanation. Suspects Kolido for reasons they admittedly can't recall but isn't switching from wolf lean. Trit's munch makes them stick to Skunk as (apparently) top suspect for reasons that are unclear.

Verdict for now is possible tunneling. Neutral.

sKeith

Pter wrote: »

Alongside the current discussion about voting strategy.

It needs to be said anyway if we are going to get the low posters posting.

Your votes on a low poster. my votes on a low poster. If you find all the declared votes and show us the current standing on votes, i believe most are on low posters currently.


Its a mature thing to evolve the conversation away from low posters as speaking about low posters all day is stupid and unproductive.

quickbeam

Bounty Hunter wrote: »

G&R did a detailed post about Strawbs, do the people who are on Kolido have something (not expecting the same) to explain why he is so wolfy he should be voted for?

Depends what you mean by ‘on’ Kolido. I just read back what I wrote about him on my reads. I’m relatively happy to keep him on my sus list but I’d probably want to ISO him again before voting for him. I’m ‘on’ him only in the sense that my gut tells me Strawbs is more Villager than Kolido.

Ectoplasm

Bounty Hunter wrote: »

G&R did a detailed post about Strawbs, do the people who are on Kolido have something (not expecting the same) to explain why he is so wolfy he should be voted for?

My read on Kolido actually changed from quite wolfy to more neutral today.

Baggly

sKeith wrote:

Its a mature thing to evolve the conversation away from low posters as speaking about low posters all day is stupid and unproductive.

Which is why I asked what's the thinking about it ALONGSIDE asking questions about the current topic of discussion.

Bounty Hunter

sKeith wrote: »

did anybody declare voting on kolido?

Why would people be starting Strawbs vs Kolido if nobody was planning on voting Kolido? bit sus.

Baggly

Ectoplasm wrote:

My read on Kolido actually changed from quite wolfy to more neutral today.

Might that be because sKeith called him out on his posting style, so he changed it?

Ectoplasm

sKeith wrote: »

Your votes on a low poster. my votes on a low poster. If you find all the declared votes and show us the current standing on votes, i believe most are on low posters currently.


Its a mature thing to evolve the conversation away from low posters as speaking about low posters all day is stupid and unproductive.

Pter wrote: »

Which is why I asked what's the thinking about it ALONGSIDE asking questions about the current topic of discussion.

Jesus lads, I'd say get a room if I wasn't scared ye already had one :D

Pter wrote: »

Might that be because sKeith called him out on his posting style, so he changed it?

Could be. Back I go for another look...

tusk

tusk wrote: »

Without the context of the original ask, this would be a fair suspicion.

I'd like to hear from the rest of the village as to whether they expected a quick WvV or an in depth analysis... And if they agree with you that my suspicion is unwarranted.

I'm suspicious of everyone, not just you. Your actions simply jumped out at me, so I called it out.

Conversation with Fixxxer basically just died after this. But thanks for bringing it back up. Definitely something I need to review.

Ectoplasm

Tusk, you've been on Kolido since day 1. Can you go back and figure out why?

sKeith

tusk wrote: »

Conversation with Fixxxer basically just died after this. But thanks for bringing it back up. Definitely something I need to review.

Just voted fixxxer, if after review you think its a worthy cause, join me.

Green&Red

I’m probably partly to blame for the Strawbs v Kolido. When it was suggested I said I’d be delighted if it was a two horse race.
I actually don’t think it should be

Having said that - catch a wolf, kill a wolf, I believe I’ve caught a wolf

tusk

Ectoplasm wrote: »

Tusk, you've been on Kolido since day 1. Can you go back and figure out why?

Literally just did that. And to be perfectly honest, I can't see why from his post list. Maybe it was from a specific interaction with someone.

Based on going back through the posts, I'm taking Kolido off my list.

Thanks to whoever told me about that iso trick. I'll be doing that for all players tonight and updating my list.

sKeith

Whomever collects all the votes together in one post gains lynch immunity from me for tonight.

sKeith

Green&Red wrote: »

I’m probably partly to blame for the Strawbs v Kolido. When it was suggested I said I’d be delighted if it was a two horse race.
I actually don’t think it should be

Having said that - catch a wolf, kill a wolf, I believe I’ve caught a wolf

If strawberry is a wolf, thats kolido spewed good


If by blame you mean, all the hard work you done, then heck yeah you're to blame.

quickbeam

I’m now officially on the beer.

Ectoplasm

quickbeam wrote: »

I’m now officially on the beer.

Enjoy...I'm officially off it today. Still feeling the effects of yesterday

Which votes you talking sKeith? Declared since yesterday?

Green&Red

sKeith wrote: »

If strawberry is a wolf, thats kolido spewed good


If by blame you mean, all the hard work you done, then heck yeah you're to blame.

I’m not at all interested in Kolido, there’s some players I haven’t gotten round to considering, he is one of them

sKeith

Ectoplasm wrote: »

Enjoy...I'm officially off it today. Still feeling the effects of yesterday

Which votes you talking sKeith? Declared since yesterday?

all vots since voting opened, or if anybody has been tracking all along and can produce where the decalred votes are at right now.

fixXxer

quickbeam wrote: »

I’m now officially on the beer.

Ectoplasm

sKeith wrote: »

all vots since voting opened, or if anybody has been tracking all along and can produce where the decalred votes are at right now.

I haven't but seeing as I was planning to do this anyway for myself, I'll post my results when I've got them. If anyone else has, that'd be great.

tusk

tusk wrote: »

Thanks to whoever told me about that iso trick. I'll be doing that for all players tonight and updating my list.

Scratch this. May be tomorrow before I get to it.

Baggly

sKeith wrote:

If by blame you mean, all the hard work you done, then heck yeah you're to blame.

I wasn't online for a good while this afternoon so I didn't see your ISO but it's excellent, if not a little confirmation biasy on some points.

However it's pretty damning of strawbs on a few points. The kitten switch after humming and hawwing with herself. The helpful unhelpful villagery whippy analysis.

Its a good piece of analysis, but if it does come down to a race I'd like to see you so the same for someone else.

Actually do it on me if you would. I know I'm good and if you finger me as bad it will tell me how much salt to take strawbs analysis with.

fixXxer

Pter wrote: »

I wasn't online for a good while this afternoon so I didn't see your ISO but it's excellent, if not a little confirmation biasy on some points.

However it's pretty damning of strawbs on a few points. The kitten switch after humming and hawwing with herself. The helpful unhelpful villagery whippy analysis.

Its a good piece of analysis, but if it does come down to a race I'd like to see you so the same for someone else.

Actually do it on me if you would. I know I'm good and if you finger me as bad it will tell me how much salt to take strawbs analysis with.

Baggly

Hey whomever wants to finger me is welcome to try.

Baggly

It's getting to the stage where me dying will prob unearth more info than me living. And I haven't been able to keep up and do analysis in this game as much as I normally like to.

sKeith

Pter wrote: »

I wasn't online for a good while this afternoon so I didn't see your ISO but it's excellent, if not a little confirmation biasy on some points.

However it's pretty damning of strawbs on a few points. The kitten switch after humming and hawwing with herself. The helpful unhelpful villagery whippy analysis.

Its a good piece of analysis, but if it does come down to a race I'd like to see you so the same for someone else.

Actually do it on me if you would. I know I'm good and if you finger me as bad it will tell me how much salt to take strawbs analysis with.

You know that feeling when you read something and you are just not sure if they actually just said it and your senses are playing tricks on you..
i want to say eeewwww!! but maybe i am reading it wrong.


Just so you do know that feeling of your senses playing tricks on you,
here's an example that you can try.

Baggly

If I don't use the phrase 'finger me' in a game at least twice, you know I'm a wolf.

Bounty Hunter

Reading back it really seems like Strawbs was the main one beating a Kolido drum, still not sure why but I was the same when the Kitten votes started to mount up and wasn't it strawbs who also started that one. Think I might look bad if she flips good with 2 votes on her but im more confident of her flipping bad than I would be of anyone else right now so will probably stick there unless something changes in the next few hours (time difference means I won't be voting late).

Green&Red

So votes, from what I can see (since last nite)

Skeith - Fixxer
Petr - Digi
Bounty Hunter - Strawbs
Fixxer - Strawbs
QB - Digi
Tusk - Skunk
G&R - Strawbs
Strawbs - Kolido

quickbeam

That’s pretty amazing. It’s like Yanni / Laurel and Brainstorm / Green Needle. I love stuff like that. Like the dress.

Triceratops Ballet

anyone wanna catch a girl up? I won't get a read through done before voting time maybe a little TL:DR