Silence of the Wolves - A Game of Werewolf GAME THREAD

quickbeam

Okay, feck it. I'm gonna stick the kettle on and grab myself a sandwich and start Fixxxer's. It's only half the posts of Strawbs, so should only take me half the time right?

Baggly

quickbeam wrote:

Okay, feck it. I'm gonna stick the kettle on and grab myself a sandwich and start Fixxxer's. It's only half the posts of Strawbs, so should only take me half the time right?

I think fixxxer and duffers isos need to be a priority for the village.

quickbeam

Pter wrote: »

I think fixxxer and duffers isos need to be a priority for the village.

You mean Duffers' full 12 posts?? :P Knock yourself you!

Baggly

At family dinner with my parents. They think I have a dodgy stomach I'm going in and out of the loo so much to post.

Baggly

I mean I will do it later, but if anyone wants at it in the meantime, go for it.

Dublinandy2

So, who is the prime suspect now?

Baggly

This. This is it. **** sake duffer that's shocking. There is nothing here. You have been 100% coasting by.

I don't think there is anything here to hang him, so the absence of NY substance will have to do. I don't want to kill him today because we won't get any info out of it if he flips good. But duffer, tb, crosstown are all in the same boat imo.

Baggly

Dublinandy2 wrote: »

So, who is the prime suspect now?

Need skunks list.

Baggly

*absence of any substance

Dublinandy2

Bounty Hunter wrote: »

They have kind of dried up. Now that I am leaning him village I am more open to a good yarn from him, what ever happened to that face changing agent? Where there any more bricks thrown? Will we ever find out?

like me and my gifs drying up I suppose, the having a laugh element can some time go by the wayside but i'd like it be known im just having a good time and no offense is meant to any other players if I think your a hairy wolf. '

I’ll do one now if you like but yesterday was the first day without one because I was doing sk (not literally)

Dublinandy2

Kolido wrote: »

Right, got the lawn mowed, headphones on and doing some thinking about the game. I know its Sunday but the weather is good and forcast for the week isnt great. Just had my lunch and a coffee, looking forward to the footy later.

Not sure what all the lists are about but here is where I stand.

Wolf lean:
Cross: Ghost voter
TB: possible middle of the road wolf is there is one

Less wolf lean:
Strawbs: cant shake the feeling she is wolf but some of her reactiobs lately have lowered my suspicions
Duffers: being unusually quiet, a wolf lying low in a long game
Gnr: not holding back but that could be his game plan
Ecto: flying under the radar possibly
Dandy: a wolf trying to charm us with his short stories.

Null:
Fixxxer: I cant get any read on him but he us gaining heat with others. Will look further
Lady skunk: unsure at this time
QB: if there is a wolf or 2 in the digi5, I would be looking here. First vote on digi.
Clarebel: no read yet

Vil lean:
BH
SK
Pter
Tusk

Kolido and one of his village for the two remaining wolves?

quickbeam

Maybe the wolves are taking the game title seriously and staying "Silent"???

Ectoplasm

quickbeam wrote: »

Maybe the wolves are taking the game title seriously and staying "Silent"???

Honestly it is my concern and why I brought it up earlier. Like they're just sitting back and watching all us villagers tear each other apart

sKeith

quickbeam wrote: »

Can you not assign a number to each category, eg: everyone in the "lynchable" gets 5, everyone in the "bad feeling" gets 4, etc, then tot up who's highest?

Can you sort from null to wolf, above null no sort in groupings is fine.

Kolido

Pter wrote: »

Is everyone in order within the groups

Wait, they need to be in order? I will have to redo mine. I also seem to have the wrong group formats. Can someone post the group list please.

Dublinandy2

Kolido wrote: »

Wait, they need to be in order? I will have to redo mine. I also seem to have the wrong group formats. Can someone post the group list please.

Be more useful if you copy and paste what’s in the wolves den if you don
T mind?

Baggly

Kolido wrote:

Wait, they need to be in order? I will have to redo mine. I also seem to have the wrong group formats. Can someone post the group list please.

Do. I'm only totting up the digi5 but more info is better than less so sorting the list is useful.

Baggly

quickbeam wrote:

Maybe the wolves are taking the game title seriously and staying "Silent"???

Imagine they had a lower number of posts they were allowed make. Classic Necro and sully move.

sKeith

Dublinandy2 wrote: »

Lynchable

Pter
Fixxxer
Duffman

Bad feeling about

Tusk
Tb
Kolido

Dublinandy2 wrote: »

Kolido and one of his village for the two remaining wolves?

Kolidos viallage leans.

Vil lean:
BH
SK
Pter
Tusk

---

You tell us.


so not BH, not me, pter is in your lynchable.
and kolido and tush are in your feels bad.

---

want to revise your sorts list?

Dublinandy2

sKeith wrote: »

Kolidos viallage leans.

Vil lean:
BH
SK
Pter
Tusk

---

You tell us.


so not BH, not me, pter is in your lynchable.
and kolido and tush are in your feels bad.

---

want to revise your sorts list?

Not at the moment.

Kolido

Lynch able
Cross
TB

Bad feeling about
Strawbs
Grn
Duffer
Ecto
Dandy

Null
Clarebel
Fixxxer

Seems ok
Skunk
QB

Villager
Pter
Sk
Bh
Tusk

sKeith

Dublinandy2 wrote: »

Lock
Me
Skunk

dubandy,


how will you game evolve if you are proven wrong?

sKeith

so far

Baggly

God I love diagonal text in excel.

quickbeam

Okay, here's Fixxxer:


Up to first lynch
5 – OP, fluff followed by three more fluff
438 – Nothing then over the long weekend until Tuesday
439 – Query re Auto-Priest
440 – Answers own question
462 – (12.58) First proper contribution, says surprised at sKeith not being munched and a newcomer was
463 – Shade on numerous players: Trit and Barney (now both confirmed by munch as villagers) mostly but also Skunk and sKeith - frame job?
465 – Again shade on Trit; checks in with GnR
475 – Queries who the wolf characters are. This is actually a big red flag to me. I remembering thinking so at the time, but then it slipped to the bank of my mind (Tuesday wasn't a good day for me!) and then I forgot who posted it
476 – Backtracks on Barney
487 – Responds to Tusk's "what type of villager I am" post
507 – Queries why sKeith is calling Lough a shader after only two posts
512 – More between him and sKeith re Lough
543 – FFA: sKeith, GnR, possibly Succy
595 – Interested to know if Lough will get modkilled (a lot of posts devoted to Lough this early?)
677 – Stressing his suspicions on GnR, said he "rolled back" on calling for a bandwagon; but also considering moving to sKeith
(688 – In response to #463 and #677, sKeith calls Fixxxer out as wolf and said he wasn't munched as he (Fixxxer) was hoping for a mislynch but wasn't saying it outright that he (sKeitih) was a wolf so he (Fixxxer) would have plausible deniability)
690 – In response to sKeith's 688, Fixxxer said no plausible deniability required, he's outright calling him a wolf
875 – Calls Strawbs a wolf (for her #871 where she said she might jump from Kolido to Fixxxer) and calls her out on a failed CFD

Up to second lynch
922 – First post after munch, says he'll review Trit's posts
929 – Says Strawbs' martyr post was dodgy
953 – Sus of sKeith surviving another munch; says he'll look again at GnR
966 – Calls out Strawbs for switching from kitten to him the previous lynch, wants explanation
968 – Explains why wolves would munch someone who voted for kitten in the lynch
970 – Calls out sKeith for continuing to have him as wolf for nothing more than failed gifs
972 – Queries with Strawbs why he's on her suspect list (her response - because he's one of her 11)
976 – Calls out her logic in using a list of 11 for finding a wolf
(987 – sKeith asks for "gun to your head" opinion on Pter, GnR and Dandy
994 – Asks sKeith for his "gun to your head" opinion on Strawbs, GnR and Tusk first
999 – In response to sKeith's answer, he asks for reasons why (VVV)
1003 – Gives his answer to sKeith (VWV)
1271 – Then, nothing for nearly a day but chimes in on the vote off low posters / voters / non voters argument, interesting that it was after Strawbs' #1258 (which is fresh in my head from her ISO) where she said anyone not chiming in would be suspicious
1277 – More on the low posters argument (agrees with me and Strawbs, fwiw)
1285 – More on Strawbs' martyr offer
1349 – (15.48) votes Strawbs
1410 – Answers me on why we're declaring our votes on thread, says it was Strawbs' suggestion
1561 – Agrees with GnR's post (#1282) against Strawbs
1564 – Asks sKeith again for reasons why he (sKeith) is voting for him - this is fair, Ecto asked sKeith why and his answer was "he's my wolfiest read", some actual facts would from sKeith would be nice sometimes!
1568 – Says he was warming to sKeith as villager, but changing his mind due to sKeith pushing Fixxxer with lack of good reasons
(1572 – sKeith responds that he'll do an ISO on Fixxxer tomorrow (yesterday!). No sign of it yet. But why is he, sKeith so sure Fixxxer is a wolf without doing an ISO??)
1584 – Replies to me: reiterating Strawbs as wolf
1588 – Replies to me: saying it's always a shambles when a wolf is being lynched (second response to me - pocketing?)
1618 – Calls Clarabel out for voting Digi when she thinks Strawbs is a wolf

Up to present (8 hours before 3rd lynch)
1992 – First post since the last
1998 – Thinks Strawbs is a wolf; thinks we should lynch sKeith - is this not just the exact same thing he called Clarabel (#1618) out on before??
Nothing since



I would say still a strong (but not definite) possibility of wolf off this read. Two things I noticed, in #953 he said he'd look in to GnR again. If he did, he didn't post about it. And in #966 he calls out Strawbs for switching to him in the kitten lynch, and asks for explanation but doesn't follow up on it. He follows up plenty chasing sKeith on explanations but not these two things? Just a lazy villager, or a not-bothered wolf?



One thing's for sure, he's not on the same team as sKeith or Strawbs (or if they are, then super-well played guys!!). I think for info purposes it'd be worth lynching any of these three to see how they flip and then reassess the other two. As I now think Strawbs is more likely to be Villager, I'd say not her, but I'm kinda easy as to whether it's Fixxxer or sKeith that goes.



Though it was Fixxxer's ISO, I found it quite telling about sKeith too. Fixxxer's post #1564 (as well as Ecto's question previously) were fair, and I did not like sKeith's answer, especially his promise to do an ISO on Fixxxer that never came about.

quickbeam

Strawberry Milkshake wrote: »

I’m on phone and out and about today but could someone take a look at the possibility of a fixxxer / triceratops double act? Fixxxer was well pissed off that votes were going off me. Triceratops was defending Fixxxer last night too.

Do I have to do all the work around here?????



(:))



When doing Fixxxer's ISO, this is the only bit where Triceratops came in. Inconclusive, I think. It started with me about to switch from Digi to Fixxxer on sKeith's advice:

quickbeam wrote: »

Reread my read on Fixxxer. There’s no new wolfiness from when I wrote it straight after last munch, but nothing swaying me away from him either. He made my FFA. I don’t think Strawbs is a wolf so I could get on the Fixxxer train alright.

Triceratops Ballet wrote: »

You got a post number for that?

Triceratops Ballet wrote: »

Is this it? If he hasn't done anything wolfy since then what basis are we proposing hanging him on?

quickbeam wrote: »

Yeah that’s it. That was wolfy enough and he didn’t sway me back since. He’s not my first choice but I’m more comfortable voting him than Strawbs.

Triceratops Ballet wrote: »

I don't know if it's enough on fixer to hang him on and I have a feeling the analysis on strawbs is gonna be too long to review, and I have 8 mins to vote so I'll have flip between digi or ctk I think. Unless anyone has any quivk alt suggestions

fixxxer wrote: »

Vote strawbs, get a wolf.

sKeith

so lynchable
skeith x6
fixxxer x6
strawbs x5

I will flip villa, what does that prove, straw could still be wolf.
If straw flips villa, whats that prove, i could still be wolf and what does it prove about fixxxer.
if fixxxer flips wolf, then me and straw can't both be wol and most likely both me and straw are just villa.


fixxxer is the info lynch here.

quickbeam

sKeith wrote: »

so lynchable
skeith x6
fixxxer x6
strawbs x5

I will flip villa, what does that prove, straw could still be wolf.
If straw flips villa, whats that prove, i could still be wolf and what does it prove about fixxxer.
if fixxxer flips wolf, then me and straw can't both be wol and most likely both me and straw are just villa.


fixxxer is the info lynch here.

This is so-oooo leading!!


"I will flip villa...
If straw flips villa...
if fixxxer flips wolf..."


Fair enough you're not gonna say "I will flip wolf" whether you are one or you're not.


But what about the possibility of Strawbs flipping wolf, or Fixxxer flipping Villager?



Shouldn't you consider all possibilities?

quickbeam

I think Fixxxer is probably a wolf
I think sKeith is probably a wolf

I also think I’m probably wrong about one of the above two statements but I think they’re probably not on the same team.

sKeith

quickbeam wrote: »

This is so-oooo leading!!


"I will flip villa...
If straw flips villa...
if fixxxer flips wolf..."


Fair enough you're not gonna say "I will flip wolf" whether you are one or you're not.


But what about the possibility of Strawbs flipping wolf, or Fixxxer flipping Villager?



Shouldn't you consider all possibilities?

We'll cross that bridge when we get there.


You ask why i am still alive.


https://www.boards.ie/vbulletin/showpost.php?p=110102222&postcount=184




either i got my wolves right, or i village leaned a wolf,


lets look at that.


leaning village

quickbeam - very slight vaiilage lean (was i wrong here, you know the answer to that.)

Strawberry Milkshake - Like answers given when i asked about why she like the fact there was no village alligned power roles. (was i wrong here, strawberry knows the answer to that.)

tritium - nice acknolegement of mountainous (for newbies, the nice picture of the mountains was a ref to the type of game we are currently playing, mountainous, no power roles, and only vanilla wolves) shade / not shade on me and pter, or just trying to game solve. Dont lynch here first. Reevaluate the here on day 2. There posts so far are pro village. (was i wrong here, No.)

Barney92 - some shade but is honest about it, game solvey? depends how pter flips, not w/w with pter. (was i wrong here, No.)

Green&Red - decent read of me, advancing player or TMI? (for newbies 'too much information') ah feck, barney can keep an eye on him, consider me slightly pocketed here. (was i wrong here, GnR knows the answer to that.)





very slight inkling of wolf equity

Kolido - shader

Loughc - shader (I was wrong here)

Triceratops Ballet - she says she has to watch what she says, nothing further



The skunk pre lynch, she new i was wolf reading her.





Hmm,



skunk and tb maybe.




I dont know.


I forgot how I wolf leaned her night 0.


when did i get my fixxxer wolf lean and why did i stop hounding tb?