Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Werewolf: Friends
Options
Comments
-
-
-
-
-
-
Advertisement
-
-
-
-
-
-
Advertisement
-
Ok Angus, you're getting done :pac:Nobody positing first for fear of being called a wolf lol.. Screw it I’ll break the ice.
I’m Angus and I’m a werewolfaholic. Hi everyone!
I noted this earlier and it seems an incredibly self-aware post. That being said it would be pretty damn brazen to come out with it.Wolf! :pac:
No I’m kidding, hi Nigel!
Humourous response to Nigel posting prior to him. Meh. One thing that worried me re: Angus was that he just basically disappeared after these two posts until....Eek I missed 6 pages since I posted earlier. Got in from work and not one bit ashamed to say I watched Love Island(only god can judge me!)
Head is spinning a bit speed reading the pages to post before going to bed. I’m just going to leave it and get a good nights sleep, catch up properly in the morning. I’ll be much more helpful with a fresh head!
I saw someone said my post about posting first was an odd thing to be worrying about. Just to clarify it was more so tongue in cheek. I laughed because people were waiting for the game to start this morning and when I went on nobody had posted yet.
Night all, chat tomorrow
But, tbf it's a fair explanation. I too know the horrors of Sunday work
Also responds to a few noting his first post. I like that, he didn't just ignore it even though it was hours ago.Afternoon all, awake, caught up and ready for duty
Thoughts on kills: Barbara had to be targeted by both wolves and SK right? I tried thinking was it possible SK stabbed Barbara and then laughed thus causing the confusion on what killed her but as someone else pointed out that post had flavour and the shot fired one didn’t which is normally how it goes?
That’s a pretty impressive way to go as the first killed so be proud Barbara!
I don’t think it was Chandler that fired the shot. Why would a villager shoot someone who hadn’t really offered anything compared to other high posters? Maybe my logic here is different but it’s not how I’d do it.
Possible that Mindy was found but would that mean a conversion would take place? We’d surely get an on thread announcement for that.
So I’m left thinking it could only be Eddie right? He’s going to cause chaos each day so it fits.
Sorry guys you all had this conversation earlier, I don’t want to drag it on all day but I’m playing catch up and just want to clarify my thinking
Logs on this afternoon and has an in-depth catch up on the permutations and combinations.
I like this as well as there's original thought there as well as catch up, it's not posting for the sake of it.
The musing on Chandler stands out, why I'm not sure, did Angus ever follow up with another theory? I guess I'll find out.Yeah I’m only getting back on now, site loaded as interactive site and I thought it had been changed permanently, nearly died!
Meh.Can I just confirm that people have an issue with Phil ISOing Wendy was it? Just putting my thoughts out on it but if it’s to be believed that Chandler fired the shot then why is Phil suspicious for doing the ISO? If he was a wolf then he wouldn’t know she was going to die.
Ok so now he's onto the Phil ISOing Wendy, this is actually incorrect, it was Nigel who ISOed Wendy, Phil did one on Jake. Which... given some recent comments I might need to go back to after I'm done here.
Mentions now that Chandler fired the shot, don't think they're convinced yet but no alternative theory put forward.I was preparing this and wanted to throw my thoughts out on the Phil thing.
When I was catching up on this mornings antics after my delightful lie in there was one person who when reading a few of their posts I got that gut feeling alarm bells going off for:
Just before munch
Just after munch
After shot fired
Pre munch post felt very disingenuous like she knew she would be around afterward. Reactions feel off too. Not expecting 2 kills but correct me if I’m wrong the munch and SK kill always happen together so we were always going to have 2 kills. Possible wolf or SK in my opinion.
Holly what do you think of my reading?
Hmmmm... I'm not sure I agree with Angus on this but I like that it's another line of thinking being put forward. I'm worried Gabriel just grabbed this and used it as another stick to FFA Holly now though, not sure he brought it up himself at all.
Anyways re: Angus, it's ok and open for discussion, not sure if followed up on though I know Holly responded.Agree with you there Orla, that’s why when I asked I said I didn’t want it dragged on all day. I think we should do FFAs, they always help in the long run and from past experience games can be very chaotic without them which is a perfect climate for wolves to survive in!
Responding to Orla who wants to move on from the mornings kills. I guess my stuff really is invisible sometimesNo that’s fair Holly. As I said it was the only thing that jumped out at me with a gut feeling so wanted to put it out there. As it’s early doors and I’m doing a lot of catching up I’m not hell bent on anyone and so I wanted your thoughts on it. Satisfied with your response, if anything else jumps out I’ll say it
Ah here we go, yes it was followed up on re: Holly. More interesting that Gabs used this as a reason to FFA Holly given that Angus seems happy with the response.
So questioning and following through with a rebuttal, another good look imo.I hadn’t even thought of this. I’ve never played with this sort of conversion, would Mindy play as a villager or a wolf hoping to join the pack? So not only are we looking for four wolves and a SK but also for Mindy :eek:
Yeah I sort of wondered this myself, though I'll caveat this is that if we're looking for potential Mindys then this post itself might be no harm being tossed in the possible pile.Guys I’ll ISO one too, want to be helpful
Eh, a little pockety. Don't like the phrasing, seems a bit forced. First bit of an inkling re: Angus possibly being a wolf here.Thanks for that Isla! Used to the standard 4 wolves, didn’t even cop I only read three names in the OP
I was thinking bloody hell thats 5 wolves and a SK, god help us all
Meh. I don't think there's much to be read into this tbh.Ohhh could that mean that Holly is Barry and was asking about your teeth to see if you’re Mindy?
Angus introduces the line re: Holly being Barry in discussion with Isla. It's an interesting take on it, and I like that it differs from Brendan and his Mindy hunting.Fiona you’ve just came into the spotlight with these two posts..
I had said when I thought Phil ISOd Wendy it made no sense as she was shot not munched/SK kill so he wouldn’t have known she would die. This makes even less sense as Jake is still here. My reading is that he was doing the ISO and didn’t realise the time, they’re an absolute soul destroyer doing them so I could understand that.
I really REALLY dislike it when people claim NRV so early. It’s not even about being an NRV but just because someone suspects you does not mean you should say what you are. NRVs protect RVs and limiting the pool that RVs can hide in is never a good thing. You could have responded to that post without claiming anything, it’s what you say that matters when someone suspects you, not what you are.
I don’t know I just find these two posts very odd and I know wolves love a good NRV claim because it can’t be disproven
Challenges Fiona on two posts, again I like this, seems to be actively reassessing and open to change on his reads.I’ll agree to disagree on the first paragraph. I don’t think I’ve ever counter claimed NRV regardless of the role I was playing because another poster was accusing me of being wolfy. For me it’s just responding to what it is they’re saying about you. That in itself is denying their claim on you.
On the second paragraph though not directed towards me I can get behind looking at what you would do but not everyone plays the same.
Follow up response to Fiona, not backing down after the initial comment. I don't really have an opinion on the post, players gonna play how they like I suppose.Wanted to look back over Fionas posts and this is what has stood out to me.
Third post talks about Mindy leaving breadcrumbs, explains it away as making people aware of what to look out for but surely you can just look out for this yourself instead of bringing it up straight away.
Asks Barbara is she claiming a role when she said she could be useful to the village. Suspicious now that Barbara is dead and has been stated on thread she was targeted by both wolves and SK because of this comment.
Brings back up Phils ISO of Jake and says she doesn’t want to be accused of bandwagoning. Why even point out the potential bandwagon? Feels like she saw other people questioning him and thought of this as an easy way to get a real wagon going.
Claims NRV - I’ve already put my thoughts on this on thread.
Makes his case on Fiona. Again there's some good stuff here, much like my suspicion on Nigel for fishing Fiona deserves scrutiny over Babs.That's why I changed mine, I found it much easier to remember you from your avatar so thanks for the inspiration!!
Meh.I'm kind of torn on the Holly thing here. I see a few people are saying what I was earlier about the reactions to this mornings kills. I however was satisfied with her response.
When Brendan pointed out the Mindy thing I thought "oh yeah that makes sense" but with further posts and looking at who else spoke about teeth I do think it was a genuine mistake and fully believe the not knowing he was a dentist because I myself hadn't a breeze.
Her reaction when it was pointed out seemed genuine too, kind of a "crap how could I be so foolish?" moment. She's also fighting her corner here, not completely indicative of a villager but it does happen a bit where wolves just lay down and take it. Kind of what I thought of Fionas response to my suspicions. Just a tad meh.
Umprompted really they come out with a defence of Holly, of which I tend to agree.
What I like is that they brought it up first, aside from maybe Brendan I think.
No idea if it's true, or false re: Holly but it reads as genuine which is what mattersQuality over quantity my dear boy
I may be in the low posters but we've only begun day1. I was working yesterday but feel I am putting the work in today to redeem myself!
Have to agree. Early signs weren't good, improvement is noted and appreciated today though.This pleases me greatly, I've never been ISOd before and was going to ask somebody to do me but didn't want to come on too strong
I'll be doing my FFA shortly, enjoying playing the game live at the minute. Find it's helping me react to what people are saying better and helping me decide whether to look into them more or not.
Get outta my pocket you
Here's your wish granted. Jokes aside I find him looking forward to being ISOed a village trait.On the low posters hiding a wolf. I don't for one minute believe that to be true anymore and feel like we could waste a lot of time on the subject if we get into it each day. Speaking from experience and if the last game is anything to go by the wolves will challenge what people normally expect wolves to do. It's not to say there isn't a wolf in the lowest posters, there very well could be and it could depend on the players selected but it is not a done deal.
I've found things can easily be thrown off course by discussing low posters being wolves. I have no problem with having suspicions, everyone from low to high posters should be suspicious. I would just like it not to come up again and again distract from more pressing content if that makes sense?
And I fully understand the irony of this post not wanting to go on about it and in so going on about it. That's all I'll be saying on the matter.My post wasn't directed personally at you or anyone else just to clarify. I just wanted to put out my thoughts on the whole thing. I've seen a lot of time wasted previously on discussing low posters and when there wasn't even a wolf in those.
I do agree that it does the village a disservice if it goes on the whole game and would urge low posters to get more involved, granted RL does get in the way sometimes.. It's more fun that way for all involved anyway
Two sentiments on low posters and focusing on them too much to finish off. Again good, shows signs of independent thought, not stuck on one trail.
Conclusions:
Strong village lean, with maybe two slight caveats.
If we are to go down the line of potential Mindys then Angus' post above probably needs to be considered in a similar way to Fionas, and indeed Brendans. In fact it might explain in a wolf!Angus world why they're going after Fiona so strongly.
The other point is re: the offer to help with ISOs. I don't mind the sentiment, but just go off and do it, no need to ask permission
And as well, it wound up being Fiona who Brendan stated he would ISO anyways.
But I think that's being over nitpicky. Overall there's enough independent thought and attempts at gamesolving for me to be confident enough in my village read on Angus.
(Also side note I had to remove a couple of smilies from your posts to get this permissable, who knew they counted towards images huh)0 -
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Advertisement
-
-
-
-
Desmond WW wrote: »Thanks, that’s my next goal.
While we’re at it...
What’s ISO? :-)
Basically to ISOlate and analyse one player's posts 0 -
-
-
-
-
-
Advertisement
-
Advertisement