Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi all! We have been experiencing an issue on site where threads have been missing the latest postings. The platform host Vanilla are working on this issue. A workaround that has been used by some is to navigate back from 1 to 10+ pages to re-sync the thread and this will then show the latest posts. Thanks, Mike.
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Werewolf: Batman

1404143454670

Comments

  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,361 ✭✭✭Gertrude WW


    Wendy WW wrote: »
    So if we're looking at static voters then Holly is screaming out to me as another wolf.

    Early on the Orla wagon day 1, first on day 2.

    Literally no progression from her at all.

    Do I think that Brendan/Holly are teamed though? Fcuk knows.

    Both have trademark wolfy signs in their voting though.

    Angus being early on both wagons is my third takeaway.

    Still staring though :pac:

    Frank on Orla both days too actually.

    Brendan and Holly could be on opposite teams and if we take it that we just need to kill some damn wolves, then its not a bad direction to be looking in.

    One more evil and one more days voting might be enough to make some headway on it


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 2,749 ✭✭✭Frank WW


    Wendy WW wrote: »
    Two Face was a villager day 1 though, how would he know who was poisoned

    I think I’ve established that Liam had a motive to want Desmond dead. So He coin tossed to kill Desmond, how is that playing as a villager?

    Why waste a coin toss when he could Wait and see later? Why risk it when your coin toss might actually heal a player? This doesn’t make any sense to me. He wanted Desmond dead and didn’t have to panic because it was day 1 and if he didn’t know if Dessie had the fake poison there was already a 50/50 chance Dessie would die. Why toss a coin and risk actually losing your coin toss and saving Dessie?


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,104 ✭✭✭Wendy WW


    I don't like Abigail's mid wagon vote day 1 then jump to last vote day 2 either.

    I'm just not there in accepting she was real poisoned, I think the theory that Dent knew who was real/fake poisoned was flawed


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,104 ✭✭✭Wendy WW


    Frank WW wrote: »
    I think I’ve established that Liam had a motive to want Desmond dead. So He coin tossed to kill Desmond, how is that playing as a villager?

    Why waste a coin toss when he could Wait and see later? Why risk it when your coin toss might actually heal a player? This doesn’t make any sense to me. He wanted Desmond dead and didn’t have to panic because it was day 1 and if he didn’t know if Dessie had the fake poison there was already a 50/50 chance Dessie would die. Why toss a coin and risk actually losing your coin toss and saving Dessie?

    But that only works if Dent is in a backroom with the other wolves whilst being a villager. I get your point though, but there are some flaws to that thinking.


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 2,749 ✭✭✭Frank WW


    Wendy WW wrote: »
    I don't like Abigail's mid wagon vote day 1 then jump to last vote day 2 either.

    I'm just not there in accepting she was real poisoned, I think the theory that Dent knew who was real/fake poisoned was flawed

    Maybe... The joke would be on me then wouldn’t it!!

    Also was it not you that said the counterfeit role was to do with votes? So now you and Gertie are using potentially tainted information to draw your conclusions?


  • Advertisement
  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,736 ✭✭✭Eva WW


    Lynch Results Day 1 |
    Ewan WW| Angus WW, Wendy WW, Henry WW, Abigail WW, Desmond WW, Eva ww, Phil WW, Fiona ww
    Orla WW| steve ww, Holly WW, Gertrude WW, Frank WW, Jake WW
    Desmond WW| Liam WW, Clodagh WW, Brendan WW
    Eva WW| Doris WW, Conor WW
    Frank WW| Orla WW
    Liam WW| Riona ww
    Conor WW| Barbara WW
    Wendy WW| Ewan WW
    Fiona WW| Tegan WW

    Lynch Results Day 2 |
    Desmond WW | Brendan WW, Phil WW, Doris WW, Clodagh WW, Abigail WW
    Barbara WW | Conor WW, Jake WW, Eva WW
    Orla WW | Riona WW, Holly WW, Frank WW
    Brendan WW | Henry WW, Gertrude WW
    Clodagh WW | Wendy WW, Barbara WW
    Liam WW | Orla WW
    Eva WW | Angus WW


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 2,749 ✭✭✭Frank WW


    Wendy WW wrote: »
    But that only works if Dent is in a backroom with the other wolves whilst being a villager. I get your point though, but there are some flaws to that thinking.

    Why do you think dent, a confirmed baddy on that team, can’t communicate with his own team? I’ve played similar roles and had BR access. What makes you so confident that he definitely didn’t get to talk with them? I’m genuinely curious how you are so confident that this is just more then likely the case.


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,736 ✭✭✭Eva WW


    Wendy I know you don't like people posting with no conclusion but I like pulling them together and they're good to have to go back to and in in more data as we get it. I'm just pulling a few bits together then see where to start. Will keep you all updated


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,104 ✭✭✭Wendy WW


    Frank WW wrote: »
    Maybe... The joke would be on me then wouldn’t it!!

    Also was it not you that said the counterfeit role was to do with votes? So now you and Gertie are using potentially tainted information to draw your conclusions?

    Only person who has claimed to have votes affected is Clodagh. No one else is owning up to it, so we have to take everyone else's vote at face value.

    I mean if Clodagh is legit (and today I think she is) then she's not a wolf but could be part of team SK


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,104 ✭✭✭Wendy WW


    Eva WW wrote: »
    Wendy I know you don't like people posting with no conclusion but I like pulling them together and they're good to have to go back to and in in more data as we get it. I'm just pulling a few bits together then see where to start. Will keep you all updated

    It's fine. I've mine previewed and I'm staring at them in between calls lol.

    Will get to grips better when I have my break


  • Advertisement
  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,361 ✭✭✭Gertrude WW


    I didn't realise that Tegan was dead too. Polishing off the single day1 voters not working so well so far


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,361 ✭✭✭Gertrude WW


    I didn't realise that Tegan was dead too. Polishing off the single day1 voters not working so well so far

    Riona could still be a wolf though if they didn't know that Liam was Harvey


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,927 ✭✭✭Orla WW


    Liam WW wrote: »
    I didn't win the prize, but I do have a bullet. I am not Alfred. I will explain more later, but for now, please suggest who I shoot.

    Did Liam shoot?


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,736 ✭✭✭Eva WW


    Orla WW wrote: »
    Did Liam shoot?

    No, he said he had until 8 to shoot but Alfred beat him to the punch


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,927 ✭✭✭Orla WW


    I am going to sign off, so good night

    Hopefully tomorrow there is some wolf kills *coughs* Jake and Conor


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,104 ✭✭✭Wendy WW


    Frank WW wrote: »
    Why do you think dent, a confirmed baddy on that team, can’t communicate with his own team? I’ve played similar roles and had BR access. What makes you so confident that he definitely didn’t get to talk with them? I’m genuinely curious how you are so confident that this is just more then likely the case.

    I'm not confident either way, I have no clue. But I'm pointing out the other side of the coin (lol) and why it's not a good idea to clear Abi based off a possibly flawed theory


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 2,749 ✭✭✭Frank WW


    Mad how busy it is here tonight, could do

    I remember one night , was about 2am and the sk and 2 wolves were up all night beavering away. Scheming and organizing things for the village. And then the seer showed up and owned them all.. was actually hilarious... I am not the seer but I hope others are watching this playing out....

    It’s nearly like you guys have gotten a lease of life and have “come out” to bat for the village....

    Not sure why that came to mind..... I’m off to bed......


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,104 ✭✭✭Wendy WW


    Riona could still be a wolf though if they didn't know that Liam was Harvey

    Or SK, I can see an SK volunteering info for the village like Riona with her prize win yesterday


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,736 ✭✭✭Eva WW


    Player | Posts
    Wendy WW | 303
    Barbara WW | 177
    Frank WW | 162
    Eva WW | 135
    Desmond WW | 129
    Liam WW | 125
    Fiona WW | 107
    Angus WW | 104
    Phil WW | 74
    Conor WW | 72
    Orla WW | 66
    Henry WW | 65
    Gertrude WW | 64
    Clodagh WW | 59
    Tegan WW | 56
    Abigail WW | 51
    Jake WW | 50
    Gabriel WW | 48
    Holly WW | 45
    Steve WW | 42
    Doris WW | 37
    Riona WW | 36
    Ewan WW | 31
    Brendan WW | 17
    Isla WW | 9


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,104 ✭✭✭Wendy WW


    Frank WW wrote: »
    Mad how busy it is here tonight, could do

    I remember one night , was about 2am and the sk and 2 wolves were up all night beavering away. Scheming and organizing things for the village. And then the seer showed up and owned them all.. was actually hilarious... I am not the seer but I hope others are watching this playing out....

    It’s nearly like you guys have gotten a lease of life and have “come out” to bat for the village....

    Not sure why that came to mind..... I’m off to bed......

    Hope that doesn't include me lol.

    I was here all night last night too, all alone :(


  • Advertisement
  • Forum Games Player Posts: 2,749 ✭✭✭Frank WW


    Wendy WW wrote: »
    I'm not confident either way, I have no clue. But I'm pointing out the other side of the coin (lol) and why it's not a good idea to clear Abi based off a possibly flawed theory

    Aren’t all our unproven theories possibly flawed my old friend....

    tenor.gif?itemid=10227250

    Sleep well, please get some sleep at some stage ......


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,736 ✭✭✭Eva WW


    Wendy WW wrote: »
    Hope that doesn't include me lol.

    I was here all night last night too, all alone :(

    I thought I was up for work early this morning so that's why I wasn't around last night. I would normally be up during the night working away when I do play.

    Remember the night I spent five hours pulling stuff together that was grim :o


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,361 ✭✭✭Gertrude WW


    Eva WW wrote: »
    Player | Posts
    Wendy WW | 303
    Barbara WW | 177
    Frank WW | 162
    Eva WW | 135
    Desmond WW | 129
    Liam WW | 125
    Fiona WW | 107
    Angus WW | 104
    Phil WW | 74
    Conor WW | 72
    Orla WW | 66
    Henry WW | 65
    Gertrude WW | 64
    Clodagh WW | 59
    Tegan WW | 56
    Abigail WW | 51
    Jake WW | 50
    Gabriel WW | 48
    Holly WW | 45
    Steve WW | 42
    Doris WW | 37
    Riona WW | 36
    Ewan WW | 31
    Brendan WW | 17
    Isla WW | 9

    I'm not doing too bad seeing as I wasn't here Saturday, Sunday or most of today :)


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,104 ✭✭✭Wendy WW


    Eva WW wrote: »
    I thought I was up for work early this morning so that's why I wasn't around last night. I would normally be up during the night working away when I do play.

    Remember the night I spent five hours pulling stuff together that was grim :o

    I'm working till 8am, so I ain't going anywhere!


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,736 ✭✭✭Eva WW


    Frank WW wrote: »
    Mad how busy it is here tonight, could do

    I remember one night , was about 2am and the sk and 2 wolves were up all night beavering away. Scheming and organizing things for the village. And then the seer showed up and owned them all.. was actually hilarious... I am not the seer but I hope others are watching this playing out....

    It’s nearly like you guys have gotten a lease of life and have “come out” to bat for the village....

    Not sure why that came to mind..... I’m off to bed......

    Frank while that story is hilarious I'm a little offended. The village needs the digging to be done, we're making an absolute balls of it and we have more information to work off of now so no harm at all in butting our heads and trying to find some answers.


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,736 ✭✭✭Eva WW


    Wendy WW wrote: »
    I'm working till 8am, so I ain't going anywhere!

    Aww now I won't be up that long :pac:


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,361 ✭✭✭Gertrude WW


    After midnight, I better check out too.

    Not sure what plans the wife has for me for tomorrow, but hopefully I'll be a little more active during the day


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,736 ✭✭✭Eva WW


    Sorry just putting these together so I don't have to scroll back and forth

    Lynch Results Day 1 |
    Ewan WW| Angus WW, Wendy WW, Henry WW, Abigail WW, Desmond WW, Eva ww, Phil WW, Fiona ww
    Orla WW| steve ww, Holly WW, Gertrude WW, Frank WW, Jake WW
    Desmond WW| Liam WW, Clodagh WW, Brendan WW
    Eva WW| Doris WW, Conor WW
    Frank WW| Orla WW
    Liam WW| Riona ww
    Conor WW| Barbara WW
    Wendy WW| Ewan WW
    Fiona WW| Tegan WW

    Lynch Results Day 2 |
    Desmond WW | Brendan WW, Phil WW, Doris WW, Clodagh WW, Abigail WW
    Barbara WW | Conor WW, Jake WW, Eva WW
    Orla WW | Riona WW, Holly WW, Frank WW
    Brendan WW | Henry WW, Gertrude WW
    Clodagh WW | Wendy WW, Barbara WW
    Liam WW | Orla WW
    Eva WW | Angus WW

    Player | Posts
    Wendy WW | 303
    Barbara WW | 177
    Frank WW | 162
    Eva WW | 135
    Desmond WW | 129
    Liam WW | 125
    Fiona WW | 107
    Angus WW | 104
    Phil WW | 74
    Conor WW | 72
    Orla WW | 66
    Henry WW | 65
    Gertrude WW | 64
    Clodagh WW | 59
    Tegan WW | 56
    Abigail WW | 51
    Jake WW | 50
    Gabriel WW | 48
    Holly WW | 45
    Steve WW | 42
    Doris WW | 37
    Riona WW | 36
    Ewan WW | 31
    Brendan WW | 17
    Isla WW | 9


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 2,749 ✭✭✭Frank WW


    Eva WW wrote: »
    Frank while that story is hilarious I'm a little offended. The village needs the digging to be done, we're making an absolute balls of it and we have more information to work off of now so no harm at all in butting our heads and trying to find some answers.

    No harm in butting heads together. My paranoia can lead me down garden paths to nowhere. But it can also lead me to ruffle the right feathers. We all have our way of playing the game my good Eva so if you are good I mean no offense.

    However If you are bad I hope that you think you are cruising and just when you least expect it you get eliminated in the most gruesomely painful way possible.... Like accidently mixing up backrooms and posting on here instead. (I did that one game, that’s a horrible way to go!). Still haunts me

    giphy.gif

    Might need a sleeping tablet to settle down after bringing that up!!!


  • Advertisement
  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,736 ✭✭✭Eva WW


    Aww Doris is winding me up, pot kettle much? :pac:
    Doris WW wrote: »
    I'm here now for a bit and caught up and FWIW I think Des is a good choice for one of the bullets going by the 'healed from poison' theory.
    Doris WW wrote: »
    Ah ffs lads. Where the **** did the Babs shot come from? Absolute madness. Eva has to go tomorrow.


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,736 ✭✭✭Eva WW


    Frank WW wrote: »
    No harm in butting heads together. My paranoia can lead me down garden paths to nowhere. But it can also lead me to ruffle the right feathers. We all have our way of playing the game my good Eva so if you are good I mean no offense.

    However If you are bad I hope that you think you are cruising and just when you least expect it you get eliminated in the most gruesomely painful way possible.... Like accidently mixing up backrooms and posting on here instead. (I did that one game, that’s a horrible way to go!). Still haunts me

    giphy.gif

    Might need a sleeping tablet to settle down after bringing that up!!!

    That's grim Frank :eek:

    Nahh I get the paranoia though, it comes with the territory! Luckily for all involved I won't be going out like that. We'll figure this out, all we really need is to get one bad guy kill and it will open so many options to look into!

    Night anyway, chat in the morning.


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,104 ✭✭✭Wendy WW


    Lynch Day 1 Results


    Ewan WW: Angus WW, Wendy WW, Henry WW, Abigail WW, Desmond WW, Eva ww, Phil WW, Fiona ww
    Orla WW: steve ww, Holly WW, Gertrude WW, Frank WW, Jake WW
    Desmond WW: Liam WW, Clodagh WW, Brendan WW
    Eva WW: Doris WW, Conor WW
    Frank WW: Orla WW
    Liam WW: Riona ww
    Conor WW: Barbara WW
    Wendy WW: Ewan WW
    Fiona WW: Tegan WW

    Did not vote: Isla WW

    Ok. Lynch 1 and now we can try to analyse the top two wagons. So as you can see we have three flipped villagers on villager Ewan, Phil, Desmond and Fiona.

    All of those were killed today late on, Phil was targeted by the wolves for poisoning, Des was lynched and Fiona was frozen by Jake.

    So my thinking is that there is one wolf in Angus, Abigail, Henry, and Eva as I know I'm clean. As the numbers get tighter that wagon will be looked at most so I think they might have tried to avoid it.

    For me, right now, my money is on Abigail or Henry based on their position on the wagon. Nice and cushioned within it.

    Moving onto the Orla wagon is where for me it gets more interesting tbh.

    Only Steve has been flipped from there, which shows to me a reluctance to touch it at all by the wolves. Jake was fake poisoned, remember so even if he's a villager then they never had any intention of touching it.

    By that thinking I don't believe the SK is there either, given his killing of Steve this morning. My thinking is that he's on the main wagon, but it's hard to get a feel for that tbh. Maybe I'll get a better feel when Joker gains a team-mate for day 2 voting.

    So who do we have. Holly, Gertrude, Frank and Jake. Again, I'm thinking one wolf here. Holly has prime wolf position on the wagon, second from the front, not too early, not too late to draw enough attention. I'll get to the static voting on the next lynch. If it's not Holly though, we probably have to look at Frank. And I'll explain why later. The villagers on Orla know they are clean, so they have a better idea of this wagon imo.

    Below that we have Desmond and 3 voters on him. Liam who is now flipped Two Face, Clodagh and Brendan.
    Interestingly enough Clodagh claims she voted Steve so if she's being truthful then there's only Brendan left her from day 1.

    Doris and Conor are sat on Eva and this is actually interesting for day 2 when you look at the below wagon.

    Only single voters left alive from day 1 are Orla and Riona.

    I feel I was right about Orla, her not self-pressing especially looks good now.

    That leaves Riona and it depends on the spread of evils. Usually voting Liam would be a great look for Riona, but given she is A) a single voter and B) Two Face is kinda out on his own then it's hard to give her much village cred for this vote.

    Lynch Day 2 results:

    Desmond: Brendan, Phil, Doris, Clodagh, Abigail
    Barbara: Conor, Jake, Eva
    Orla: Riona, Holly, Frank
    Brendan: Henry, Gertrude
    Clodagh: Wendy, Barbara
    Liam: Orla
    Eva: Angus


    Ok day 2. So we can see that immediately, Brendan hasn't moved an inch from Desmond. This to me is a red flag, typically as well given so much went on throughout the day and Brendan conveniently missed it all and lumped an early vote on his day 1 choice.
    I'd be fairly confident Brendan is evil, though I'm not sure what team obviously.

    Doris, Abi, Clodagh. Again Clodagh says her vote was moved so it's hard to take anything from that really.

    Abi is on the main wagon both days. She was the last vote on Desmond this time though. I'm suspicious of this voting pattern, I'm not gonna lie.

    Doris sitting mid wagon here and first on Eva is a bit of a bla look too.


    Ok next wagon and this is where things get spicy.

    So we have Conor, Jake and Eva on this wagon - and Conor's vote really stands out here.

    His lynch target last night in Eva is now sitting on the same wagon, which makes me wonder about his intentions in his voting. Does he really believe what he's saying when he wants to lynch people and then sit side by side on the same wagon. Food for thought anyways. Makes me wonder are Conor and Eva our SK team a little.

    Orla's wagon is very very yuck, not gonna lie. You have Holly and Frank who have not adjusted their votes since yesterday.

    I'm almost 90 per cent confident one of these is evil. Tbh, my money is on Holly. I'm going to ISO her if I get time tonight because I need to try and see what her posts are saying, as her votes aren't really showing any progression at all.

    Frank is Frank. I lean village but there's this tiny knot gnawing at me that all these theories are deliberate ploys to distract the village.

    Brendan is next and his flip will say a lot about Henry/Gertrude tbh. If Brendan is evil like I suspect, then this is a good look for both, though not clearing because we have two teams in play. If Brendan is good well then we definitely have a wolf in Gertie or Henry.

    Votes on Clodagh are village Babs and me. I know I'm good so nothing to see here. Someone else can do wagonomics on me if they like though.

    Solo votes and Orla and Angus here. Orla is kinda in the clear anyways, based off last night and also the claim today. Again not self pressing when she's level with Babs as counter wagon (Clodagh's dodgy vote aside).

    Angus gives me red flags. I don't recall him telegraphing this vote on Eva, and again it's very very early.


    So...


    Conclusions:


    Brendan's votes stand out a country mile, as do Holly's.

    Static, no movement, there's just no progression at all.

    I'd be pretty confident one or both are evil.

    After that we have Abigail whose cushy wagon sitting day 1 then move to last has my interest piqued.

    Conor voting Eva and then voting alongside her flags up as fishy for me as well.

    That's 5. 5 evils? Maybe. I'm not that good though lol.

    There's only so much I can draw from village flips tbh and that's the problem here.

    But focus tomorrow imo should be on Holly and Brendan. Both skating by.

    Now I'm off to ISO Holly if I can keep my eyes open.


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,104 ✭✭✭Wendy WW


    Oy Eva, you were supposed to keep me company :(


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,104 ✭✭✭Wendy WW


    Ok so Holly's ISO

    Holly WW wrote: »
    Never fear Batman is here

    giphy.gif?cid=8fc3c8975d32cbdd554d483349e723f7&rid=giphy.gif

    Standard opening fare, no biggie.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    This must be the only game where people can claim the main role and it’s seems normal!!

    Fluff. I get the sentiment but meh, doesn't really add anything.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    I would say The Ridder over The Joker Wendy. But it doesn’t read like a riddle though?

    Responding to me about the pics by WWGM. Fair enough, no follow up though. Does not return until Monday post munch
    Holly WW wrote: »
    I am here after a busy weekend. Was expecting to see two deaths but looking back over the OP it seems like the SK kill isn't a night time action



    To the guys who received the flowers - do you get told by PM or did you just find out on thread? Have you received any other information? I assume Alfred can chose to save the person if he wants but means there will be no vig shot today if he does.

    No idea where she gets this from the OP tbh. There's a lot of hunting and sniffing around the poisoned, trying to get to grips with mechanics or fishing? I dunno, wolves probably know everything about the mechanic so...?
    Holly WW wrote: »
    Two things on this:
    1. There is no mention of having TO BE healed - just that one will survive. Does this mean Alfred doesn't get a choice between healing and his bullets?
    2. This was posted at bang on 11am - so appears to be a scheduled action rather than an anytime of day action

    Misunderstanding the mechanics. Hmmm... so far leaning not wolf on Holly, could be SK though.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    Thanks for the clarification

    Meh.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    That was partly my point but I read the roles wrong also but yes I wonder does he have a choice or must he heal over using his bullets.

    At this point he is better healing if he has a choice as it keeps our numbers and reduces the changes of hitting a villager with a bullet as we do not have much info to go on.

    More poison mechanics discussion. I agree with her bottom paragraph here.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    So it seems whoever made the connection about the time in the weather gif and the time of the comps were right

    Meh.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    I went 14

    Competition number. Fairly forthright iirc.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    I thought the point was that if the mods announce the correct answer and number we can narrow down who got the prize?

    Misunderstanding again. Glad she's not saying confused though.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    This is wrong, 12 hours would only cover lynch

    Catches Doris's mention on the thread of her protect.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    Can you give us anymore information (as long as it doesn't disadvantage the village)

    Hmmmm... I don't like this fishing, though it's caveated with the bracketed stuff I suppose.

    Gone again till the evening again.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    Hey guys I’m around a bit, mental day in work today, heading home now and will finishing catching up. Have been skimming the thread and have a vote in on Orla.

    RL is a thing I guess, not that I would know :D

    Vote in on Orla but why? I think this is my problem so far with Holly's ISO, she's too busy talking mechanics and competitions, an easy place for a wolf/SK to pump out content. There's no wolf hunting at all that I can see so far.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    No it was Oisin and Mary that were wrongly listed

    Wrong accounts listed talk, more mechanics.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    I was tempted to vote for Baggly :D
    Holly WW wrote: »
    I don’t know if they had the wrong names or just too many names listed
    Holly WW wrote: »
    I wonder what would happen if we all voted for the mods

    Blah. Like this is the sum total of her discussion points on Monday evening prior to the lynch. A vote for Orla, no reason given than skimming the thread, and then some jokey posts about voting for mods and wrong accounts being listed.

    It's just... like oatmeal porridge. Bland, no flavour, all business. Let's continue.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    Can someone with more Batman knowledge break this down - is this good / bad for us?

    Back this morning and jumps on this post. More fishing, and yet again, talking about roles and mechanics. There's a common theme in here somewhere.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    I am here, was out most of the weekend and busy in work yesterday so couldn't contribute as much as I wanted. Hopefully work should die down by this afternoon so I can get more involved.

    Third time she's said she's busy. Fair enough.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    What number will go for? Are we doing the same number for each comp?
    Holly WW wrote: »
    Have to go to a meeting so will go for 13 for both

    Back for competition. And straight to business. And gone for about an hour again then...
    Holly WW wrote: »
    Current postings:

    User Name Posts
    Wendy WW 223
    Barbara WW 130
    Liam WW 110
    Frank WW 106
    Fiona WW 97
    Angus WW 94
    Desmond WW 78
    Eva WW 68
    Tegan WW 55
    Abigail WW 41
    Gertrude WW 37
    Clodagh WW 36
    Orla WW 35
    Henry WW 34
    Conor WW 33
    Doris WW 32
    Phil WW 30
    Riona WW 28
    Jake WW 26
    Holly WW 21
    Brendan WW 8

    Post counts. I think this was in response to Tegan. Meh.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    If they are going for low posters they are possibly role hunting?

    Responds to me about my thoughts on low posters getting taken out earlier.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    Too obvious to say villagers won it?

    Brings up the prize and notes 'Citizen of Gotham' mentioned in competition post. It's a decent find. But if Jake is a wolf this could be a lowball attempt to clear him imo.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    Good call Frank, we will need to be more careful entering the competitions going forward if they mention The Riddler

    Compliments Frank, fair enough.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    She went for 7 for both.

    Do we think the mods picked a different number for each comp or did Tegan win both?

    Responding to me re: Tegan's number. Holly you are so helpful when it comes to mechanics yet there isn't a read on a player to be seen in your entire ISO. Why is that?
    Holly WW wrote: »
    I don't think it will be the same next time, I reckon it will be a different tactic from The Riddler as we are aware of that one now but we still need to make sure we analyse the wording and the answers

    Mechanics. Again.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    I didn't win - anyone else wanna say if they won?

    Holly WW wrote: »
    We wait and see if anyone claims the second prize
    Holly WW wrote: »
    She was pretty quick but she was online, the person who won could be AFK, I would condemn them yet
    Holly WW wrote: »
    Possibly not if the prizes were given out in order - prize 1 for the car colour and prize 2 - death without being able to use the first prize. Must look and see if Tegan gave her answer to the car colour
    Holly WW wrote: »
    It will be up to whoever wins it, only they know what the prize is and what the possible repercussions could be

    Competition talk.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    Doesn't mean he is not a wolf, could have gave the fake poison to a team mate to gain them some village points

    Oooh now we have a semblance of a thought on a player. I agree with this post tbh.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    giphy.gif

    Meh.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    So we currently have two bullets to use? We know Jakes has a time limit, still waiting on confirmation if there is a time limit on the second bullet so best deciding about Jakes one first.

    Mechanics on bullets.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    But at the moment there is no sign of you being in danger, why reveal now? Why not wait until nearer lynch and reveal if you are in trouble?

    Challenging Orla, this is the closest I've seen to a discussion not involving mechanics.

    Holly WW wrote: »
    I accept Jake's as a prize but that does not explain Liam's bullet

    Fair enough comment here.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    Yes I get that but I do not get the need to come out on thread :confused::confused:

    Back and forth with Holly again. Can't disagree with her here really tbf.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    No Liam hasn't said.

    In relation to the Dent theory floating around - we must remember he is evil today so would that tie in with Liam getting a bullet when it could possible take him out?

    Mechanics. Interesting that Liam was actually Dent though. Possibly TMI? Meh... maybe.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    As you are now here is there any other information you can give us on your bullet?

    Questions Liam on the bullet.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    This is interesting - if Orla flips red, I would be looking at Liam, a wolf including another wolf on their FFA's to distance themselves.

    Oh wow we finally have a read. But it's based off Orla flipping red as opposed to Dent. I like it, need more of this if you're village Holly.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    It would prove you are not a wolf but it wouldn’t prove that you are NRV

    Responding to Jake re: the bullet and poisoning. She's coming out of her shell a bit. I like this, shows she's thinking things through.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    Exactly it’s a role not listed in the OP so now way of proving it exists and her timing of the reveal is off. My only doubt is that the only way I can think of her being protected is by Batman’s protection and if he didn’t pick her then he would know she was lying

    Opening up on Orla, at least I can get a feeling for why she's voting for Orla today. Glad I did this now.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    Then who did Batman protect and who is supposedly protecting Orla?

    Meh. I don't really understand this post tbh.
    Holly WW wrote: »
    Very true that Riona! That’s what was stopping me voting her as I’ve found her very dodgy again today. Gonna place a vote on her now.

    And final post. Agrees with Riona, places vote. Gone again for the night.


    Conclusions:

    Well, one thing is certain: Holly loves her mechanics discussion.

    If there's talk being had about the ins and outs of various roles or competition talk, Holly is smack bang in the middle.

    Now I don't mind the mechanics talk, I'm fond of it myself at times but it needs to be supplemented by some more substance.

    I had to traverse to today to get some semblance of a read on any player from Holly, and that's not a good sign.

    Could she be RL busy, sure. That's acceptable. But when you pop on and spend all your time talking about mechanics or joking about voting for the mods then it starts to raise my suspicion levels.

    That's not to say she doesn't raise some decent points, but overall I just get an icky feeling about Holly.

    So she can slide right into my wolf leans alongside Brendan and Jake and stay there.


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,104 ✭✭✭Wendy WW


    Conor WW wrote: »
    Wendy, thanks for doing the ISO, it'll give me something concrete to come back on, I was busy yesterday and just couldn't give time


    I know all this is very unsatisfactory and theres a fair argument to be made that a lot of the things you like about what I’ve done are easy, likes its common sense that Alfred should heal and not kill just yet, likewise with Doris and her protect or not lynching Doris just yet. The argument about the numbers, I just believe I’m right about it and believe its best for the village, that above anything should have you putting me in your village pile

    Ok so Conor now I'm coming back to you:

    Here's what you gave me this morning:
    Frank Wolf lean
    Abigail Wolf lean
    Holly I genuinely am shocked to see we have a holly playing
    Gertrude I don’t know
    Desmond I think I like Dessie


    Yet you wind up on Barbara and don't discuss Frank or Abi at all.

    In fact I don't remember either even acknowledging that you had a wolf lean on them, but that might be my over tiredness kicking in.

    Why is that? When shots were being called for you were nowhere to be found.


    And then, there's this at 16.45:
    Conor WW wrote: »
    FWIW I doubt Orla or Barbara are wolves, they’re way too vocal on who to shoot


    But somehow you wind up changing to this by 20.45pm

    Conor WW wrote: »
    My vote is on Barbara FWIW


    You are a wolf, Conor.

    You're all over the shop.

    J'accuse!!


  • Advertisement
  • Forum Games Player Posts: 2,789 ✭✭✭Abigail WW


    Going by the read I got from my saved action, I was real poisoned.

    I have no real experience in vote analysis. RL dictates when I can vote. Yesterday I was up the walls busy. Seems no matter what time you vote, you could get flagged.

    Vote early - dodge
    Vote midpack - hiding
    Vote late - suspect


    Eva was very supportive of saving Des last night, was this villager loyalty, or Wolfie knowing he was good trying to cast a good light, as there was a wagon forming.


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,104 ✭✭✭Wendy WW


    Abigail WW wrote: »
    Going by the read I got from my saved action, I was real poisoned.

    I have no real experience in vote analysis. RL dictates when I can vote. Yesterday I was up the walls busy. Seems no matter what time you vote, you could get flagged.

    Vote early - dodge
    Vote midpack - hiding
    Vote late - suspect


    Eva was very supportive of saving Des last night, was this villager loyalty, or Wolfie knowing he was good trying to cast a good light, as there was a wagon forming.

    Can you explain the bolded part to me Abi please?

    I feel we haven't interacted at all much on thread, why is that?


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 2,789 ✭✭✭Abigail WW


    WerewolfGM wrote: »
    A Medic has acted


    A Citizen of Gotham City was stricken down by a potentially deadly virus. Although another may have also claimed such a predicament the vilagers ex-special forces medic Alfred has made his selection and treatment has been administered.

    tumblr_oqbkhlzr4T1r5zq6ao2_500.gif


    Abigail WW is no longer showing any symptoms of infection.
    Wendy WW wrote: »
    Can you explain the bolded part to me Abi please?

    I feel we haven't interacted at all much on thread, why is that?


    Going by the "no longer showing any symptoms of infection".

    Implies that I was affected by it.

    Interaction is a two way street Wendy, admittedly I am not the most prolific poster this game. I am only getting a couple of hours in evening to try and focus fully on it.


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,104 ✭✭✭Wendy WW


    Abigail WW wrote: »
    Going by the "no longer showing any symptoms of infection".

    Implies that I was affected by it.

    Interaction is a two way street Wendy, admittedly I am not the most prolific poster this game. I am only getting a couple of hours in evening to try and focus fully on it.

    I wouldn't read into that too much though, both of you as per flavour are technically poisoned but with one the effects wear off at the lynch and the other is fatal.

    I can see why you might think that though.

    Or want us to think it ;)


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,104 ✭✭✭Wendy WW


    Hope someone reads my overnight posts anyways. Tegan said she would yesterday but never did :(

    That made me a sad Wendy.


  • Advertisement
  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,760 ✭✭✭Angus WW


    Sorry for my absence yesterday. I’ve had a couple of hours sleep so all the posts I’ve just read have rolled into one long post :(


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,104 ✭✭✭Wendy WW


    Eva WW wrote: »
    Frank while that story is hilarious I'm a little offended. The village needs the digging to be done, we're making an absolute balls of it and we have more information to work off of now so no harm at all in butting our heads and trying to find some answers.

    I'm kinda weirded out by this.

    Eva starts off after the lynch subsides with a head of steam, she's digging out her laptop, posting lists etc.

    Then... nothing.

    Hopefully she's ok in RL, I have visions of her snoring on top of her laptop with just endless rows of zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz as her work :pac:


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,760 ✭✭✭Angus WW


    There were no FFAs yesterday?

    Can we do them today as the info we get from them alongside wagonomics should give us a good grasp on the state of play.


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,760 ✭✭✭Angus WW


    Ok. I’m talking to myself here so I’m going to read the thread again from yesterday afternoon onwards.


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 2,789 ✭✭✭Abigail WW


    Wendy WW wrote: »
    I wouldn't read into that too much though, both of you as per flavour are technically poisoned but with one the effects wear off at the lynch and the other is fatal.

    I can see why you might think that though.

    Or want us to think it ;)

    I am reading it as is, at face value.

    I am a NRV, I have no need to lie or try and deceive here. Assuming that is why the smiley is there.


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,104 ✭✭✭Wendy WW


    Angus WW wrote: »
    There were no FFAs yesterday?

    Can we do them today as the info we get from them alongside wagonomics should give us a good grasp on the state of play.

    Excuse me I did FFA mine was Jake, Clodagh and Brendan


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 2,749 ✭✭✭Frank WW


    So 15 left, possibly 13 after the morning which at worst leaves us 8 village, 3 wolves and 2 SKs. With maybe more poison (guaranteed death if Alfred is found) and maybe some more riddles that could take another. A bad lynch tonight after this sort of day would leave as little as 5 villagers remaining.

    What happens if there are more wolves then villagers but still an sk team?


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,104 ✭✭✭Wendy WW


    Frank WW wrote: »
    So 15 left, possibly 13 after the morning which at worst leaves us 8 village, 3 wolves and 2 SKs. With maybe more poison (guaranteed death if Alfred is found) and maybe some more riddles that could take another. A bad lynch tonight after this sort of day would leave as little as 5 villagers remaining.

    What happens if there are more wolves then villagers but still an sk team?

    Is it not 16?


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,104 ✭✭✭Wendy WW


    Also as per the OP, the evil teams have to kill each other to win.

    So if we get to that point we'll be witnessing a thunderdome play out as the wolves and team SK scream at each other lol


  • Forum Games Player Posts: 3,104 ✭✭✭Wendy WW


    1. Wendy WW 318
    2. Frank WW 166
    3. Eva WW 143
    4. Angus WW 107
    5. Conor WW 72
    6. Orla WW 67
    7. Gertrude WW 66
    8. Henry WW 65
    9. Clodagh WW 59
    10. Abigail WW 54
    11. Jake WW 50
    12. Holly WW 45
    13. Doris WW 37
    14. Riona WW 36
    15. Brendan WW 17


    Nah you're right Frank apologies


  • Advertisement
Advertisement