Werewolf - Winter Is Here - Game of Thrones II Game Thread

Necro

Deleted User wrote: »

Fair enough, I do that myself sometimes with the lingo in games depending on the theme/timeline.

Anyway, the evil fecker who I'd associate with a crossbow is likely not in this game on further thinking.




Just putting it out there Drummer. Quite a few of your posts I've read imply that you haven't really read the OP, yet you were one of the people who thanked a post from Necro yesterday which implored everyone to read the OP. Not reading the OP or not being too familiar with it is not a villager attribute.



I didn't get to enter the joust, just to let the village know. I have no prizes/powers, and haven't been converted.

Yay I'm not going crazy!!

Lord TSC

Evening all,

Back in for the evening now. Done a quick scan and not noticed huge revelations, other than we have a few bullets? Will do a deeper scan over the evening now.

beakerjoe

Green&Red wrote: »

Absolutely but why would someone claim someone else’s role? Also why would the person who’s role was claimed not come out?

FWIW I doubt the NK has claimed a role because if their convert is killed then they’re outted

That makes the case for a mass reveal

I dont understand this. How is he outted?

Green&Red

Who has that list of claims?

sKeith

beakerjoe wrote: »

I dont understand this. How is he outted?

If NK has decided to use one of the converts identities, and we kill that convert, the auto-priest will give us the name of the person that NK has given us. So we kill that person. ;p

Drumpot

Green&Red wrote: »

Absolutely but why would someone claim someone else’s role? Also why would the person who’s role was claimed not come out?

FWIW I doubt the NK has claimed a role because if their convert is killed then they’re outted

That makes the case for a mass reveal

I have to go for a workout now. .

But there are one or two things here. 21 people played the game, 12 of them with set roles, 9 without. . NK is actually in the list of 9. Did they and their general get a false name to use ?

Even if they did does that not mean a mass reveal will mean that in the list of 9 (in my group of undeclared houses) will yield us either 2 walkers (who swapped roles with NK) or NK and his general ?

So we kill 4 of the non declared houses (me included in that list) which increases our chances ?.. . For what its worth I am Melisandre

beakerjoe

sKeith wrote: »

If NK has decided to use one of the converts identities, and we kill that convert, the auto-priest will give us the name of the person that NK has given us. So we kill that person. ;p

I get ya now.

Necro

sKeith wrote: »

If NK has decided to use one of the converts identities, and we kill that convert, the auto-priest will give us the name of the person that NK has given us. So we kill that person. ;p

Finally the fooking logic in me not using my power is explained.

Instead of 'don't do that unless we tell you to'

That I can get on board with, not just being told to sit in the corner like a bold boy and play with myself:p

Lord TSC

Ectoplasm wrote: »

Yep. I'm Daenerys Targaryan so it was an appropriate prize.

beakerjoe

Necro wrote: »

Finally the fooking logic in me not using my power is explained.

Instead of 'don't do that unless we tell you to'

That I can get on board with, not just being told to sit in the corner like a bold boy and play with myself:p

I didnt say play with yourself, i said people will think that

Ectoplasm

Lord TSC wrote: »

That a claim?

Drumpot

Drumpot wrote: »

I have to go for a workout now. .

But there are one or two things here. 21 people played the game, 12 of them with set roles, 9 without. . NK is actually in the list of 9. Did they and their general get a false name to use ?

Even if they did does that not mean a mass reveal will mean that in the list of 9 (in my group of undeclared houses) will yield us either 2 walkers (who swapped roles with NK) or NK and his general ?

So we kill 4 of the non declared houses (me included in that list) which increases our chances ?.. . For what its worth I am Melisandre

In fact we don’t need a mass reveal I think all or most of us have already admitted not being alligned? So kill 4 of us and surely that narrows the pool in which NK can hide? A mass reveal seems unfair as I’m not sure how nk can hide if we keep picking off non house affiliated players

sKeith

Drumpot wrote: »

In fact we don’t need a mass reveal I think all or most of us have already admitted not being alligned? So kill 4 of us and surely that narrows the pool in which NK can hide? A mass reveal seems unfair as I’m not sure how nk can hide if we keep picking off non house affiliated players

You want to play fair with the white walkers?

Lord TSC

Ectoplasm wrote: »

That a claim?

Necro

Lol Lord is claiming Ser Jorah Friendzone.

I think

sKeith

lord, ecto, wanna put in an ffa for the record?

Drumpot

sKeith wrote: »

You want to play fair with the white walkers?

It’s more mass reveals in general seem a bit unfair IMO. I don’t see how the NK can hide if we just pick off the non alligned players

Ectoplasm

Necro wrote: »

Lol Lord is claiming Ser Jorah Friendzone.

I think

Which is interesting as that's exactly who I thought Lord was.

Ectoplasm

sKeith wrote: »

lord, ecto, wanna put in an ffa for the record?

I'll put mine up but want to look at my notes first. Probably be close to 7pm.

sKeith

Drumpot wrote: »

It’s more mass reveals in general seem a bit unfair IMO. I don’t see how the NK can hide if we just pick off the non alligned players

Almost every game in the last 2 years ended with a mass reveal.


Its usally pretty slow, but still a mass reveal.


Due to conversions, we need to get it over with earlier this game.


The game was designed this way, and this is the obvious course.


It was obvious sunday too, but really wanted to find better way, but game is closing now to be solved by any other method.

sKeith

Ectoplasm wrote: »

I'll put mine up but want to look at my notes first. Probably be close to 7pm.

okay, but i'll dump what i have at half 6, and you can add to that. as i have to go at 6:30, should be back by 7:30.

Ectoplasm

Drumpot wrote: »

It’s more mass reveals in general seem a bit unfair IMO. I don’t see how the NK can hide if we just pick off the non alligned players

I don't see it as unfair at all. Evils will have been given aliases. Every chance that they've converted aligned players by now too.

Choc Chip

sKeith wrote: »

okay, but i'll dump what i have at half 6, and you can add to that. as i have to go at 6:30, should be back by 7:30.

I've the current #FFAs in a spreadsheet sk so I can add to that while you're away if you like.

I'm interested by Drumpots proposal - should we stick to the non-house roles? I currently have beaker, skunk, mick and necro but I think skunk claimed a character in the OP. Anyone any thoughts on whether I should change. Unfortunately Drumpot was next on my list...

Necro

Choc Chip wrote: »

I've the current #FFAs in a spreadsheet sk so I can add to that while you're away if you like.

I'm interested by Drumpots proposal - should we stick to the non-house roles? I currently have beaker, skunk, mick and necro but I think skunk claimed a character in the OP. Anyone any thoughts on whether I should change. Unfortunately Drumpot was next on my list...

There are definitely liars in there. I'm not one of them but there are too many named characters

Choc Chip

Deleted User wrote: »

Just talk to me. Use your words. Spell it out to me like I'm 4 years old.

sKeith

Choc Chip wrote: »

I've the current #FFAs in a spreadsheet sk so I can add to that while you're away if you like.

I'm interested by Drumpots proposal - should we stick to the non-house roles? I currently have beaker, skunk, mick and necro but I think skunk claimed a character in the OP. Anyone any thoughts on whether I should change. Unfortunately Drumpot was next on my list...

I'll post what i have here anyhow.


Then you can check my work easily.

Necro

Necro wrote: »

There are definitely liars in there. I'm not one of them but there are too many named characters

Unnamed

Choc Chip

Choc Chip wrote: »

Deleted User wrote: »

Just talk to me. Use your words. Spell it out to me like I'm 4 years old.

I've condemned someone that you haven't mentioned in your list.

Choc Chip

Deleted User wrote: »

I've condemned someone that you haven't mentioned in your list.

In my FFA or in the list of non-house associated people?