10 Player Secret Role

Green&Red

Clarabel

sKeith wrote: »

actually, G&R sums it up perfectly.

Jesus sK your memory is astounding. I'd even forget I'd called myself a boy

quickbeam

Green&Red wrote: »

I'm sorry but what?
Fair enough when I voted for BH I couldnt be sure he was a wolf, he was my best guess but when he was lynched he flipped as a wolf, so I have caught a wolf. That is literally the definition of catching a wolf

Are you deliberately misunderstanding me?

In the phrase "catch a wolf, lynch a wolf", it's where you've caught a wolf prior to lynch and don't let them live past the lynch. As in, you categorically know you have a wolf. You did not know Bounty was a wolf as you admit. Therefore this was not a "catch a wolf, lynch a wolf" situation like Fix was claiming it to be. It was a best guess that, thankfully, turned out for the good.

Clarabel

Green&Red wrote: »

@QB the only thing we KNOW about you is that you voted to lynch a guy who caught a wolf. You are in nobody’s village pile

On the bussing, in a two player game it’s unlikely to happen, very unlikely and too high risk

I'd agree with this entirely

Clarabel

khalessi wrote: »

Ok so going bu what everyone says here
10 players
BH wolf
Clara? VILLAGER
QB? Villager with role
GnR claims top villager claims poison
Keith also claims villager
Me always good

That leaves
Spook
Kitten
Fixer

So one wolf each group??

Kitten? Do we have a secret cat playing???

Bags is missing from your list I believe

Clarabel

Green&Red wrote: »

Clara any update on what happened to you?

Yes I was literally punished for not posting by being silenced.

I cannot apologise more. I'll get to responding to your gif post from last night. I saw sK response last night.... Thought of my reply and answered my phone.

quickbeam

Clarabel wrote: »

Yes I was literally punished for not posting by being silenced.

I cannot apologise more. I'll get to responding to your gif post from last night. I saw sK response last night.... Thought of my reply and answered my phone.

Punished by who? Game mod?

Spook_ie

Ok still picking up on this, is murderized the same as munched? If not how did he die?

Green&Red

That seems a little unbelievable since MrKingsley has 6 posts and he wasn't silenced?

Green&Red

Spook_ie wrote: »

Ok still picking up on this, is murderized the same as munched? If not how did he die?

That would be my reading, Tusk said the munch was around 9, SKeith was an NRV, you can assume its the munch

Green&Red

Punished for not posting or for not voting?

fixXxer

quickbeam wrote: »

I did not.

So in a game labeled Secret Role Singular, you didn't poison GnR but you still have a power?

Clarabel

quickbeam wrote: »

With a bit of luck, and a bit of deduction

I wish you'd give more here.

I get that we've had no counter claim. Yet

GNR what time were you poisoned? Could it have been related to you posted first after someone else. Like the munch or lynch results. Or first after QB claim?

Clarabel

Green&Red wrote: »

Punished for not posting or for not voting?

The PM did not say. The posts from tusk imply there'll be repurcussion for not lynching. I received the PM shortly after 10pm

I read it shortly before 11pm,

Clarabel

quickbeam wrote: »

Punished by who? Game mod?

Game mod

Green&Red

Clarabel wrote: »

The PM did not say. The posts from tusk imply there'll be repurcussion for not lynching. I received the PM shortly after 10pm

I read it shortly before 11pm,

So that would sound like you were silenced for not voting


So ..........why did you not vote?

Green&Red

Clarabel wrote: »

I wish you'd give more here.

I get that we've had no counter claim. Yet

GNR what time were you poisoned? Could it have been related to you posted first after someone else. Like the munch or lynch results. Or first after QB claim?

Came at the same time as the lynch result, I think SK was first to post

Clarabel

Green&Red wrote: »

If I had to pick a wolf partner for BH this is where I’d be looking, I called him out at 8.30 yesterday and these two moved to discredit that accusation. Obviously we now know it was correct, so we have to look at how provided any form of defence or deflection to protect BH. These are the two




Fixxxer sought to create a bit of confusion around my voting, very wolfie considering what I was talking about was basic enough, I’d lynch someone else rather than let myself be lynched. Was this laying ground work for later, that if I hadn’t voted BH he could have pointed to that and accused me of being BH’s buddy?



When I read through the thread BHs post on catching wolves stood out, IMO only a wolf would be so fascinated by wolf mechanics. I found it in the last game when I was SK, all I wanted to talk about was the SK, it’s natural.
Clara moves to discredit it.
She was also holding her vote until late, unfortunately for her the Superpower silenced her, meant she couldn’t get a vote in.

Given what we now know, there were three people left with a vote in the last 10 minutes. Two of those voted to lynch a wolf, was the other there trying to save her wolf buddy but got silenced?
Clara would be my top vote

#FFA1
Clara
Fixxxer

So I posted the gif cause I thought it funny that in a game where the objective is to discuss the wolf mechanics to find the wolves, sure we've done nothing but that since (bussing, grouping, why BH was caught etc) you think it's wolf behaviour.

I was not discrediting your finding BH. I'm really impressed and delighted.

Clarabel

Okay I think that's me caught up or do I need to answer anymore questions?

Green is clear for me
QB I'm inclined to believe you, I just wish you'd give more.

Clarabel

Green&Red wrote: »

So that would sound like you were silenced for not voting


So ..........why did you not vote?

I have apologised for this. I am sorry.

Real life stuff came up. I prioritied that over a game. This is not a game mechanic.

I may well be a wolf (I am not) but not voting was not a tactic. Jesus you see how much I post, it's literally not possible for me to watch people talk about me and not post!

quickbeam

fixxxer wrote: »

So in a game labeled Secret Role Singular, you didn't poison GnR but you still have a power?

I'm as confused as anyone. In a game labelled Secret Role Singular, there's been a silencing and a poisoning and an antidote and a munch, so colour me stumped.

quickbeam

Clarabel wrote: »

I get that we've had no counter claim. Yet

Of course there's no counter claim.

I'm saying as much as I think is useful for the village without being useful to the wolves.

Green&Red

Clarabel wrote: »

So I posted the gif cause I thought it funny that in a game where the objective is to discuss the wolf mechanics to find the wolves, sure we've done nothing but that since (bussing, grouping, why BH was caught etc) you think it's wolf behaviour.

I was not discrediting your finding BH. I'm really impressed and delighted.

I'm glad you've addressed this, I thought it strange that you wouldn't respond

I'm also happier that you were silenced for not voting, rather than couldnt vote cause you were silenced

Why did you not vote though?

Spook_ie

quickbeam wrote: »

I'm as confused as anyone. In a game labelled Secret Role Singular, there's been a silencing and a poisoning and an antidote and a munch, so colour me stumped.

When do we officially hear if an antidote has been given?

Green&Red

Sorry, see you've answered why you didnt vote

Green&Red

quickbeam wrote: »

I'm as confused as anyone. In a game labelled Secret Role Singular, there's been a silencing and a poisoning and an antidote and a munch, so colour me stumped.

No antidote, I could still die I presume

Spook_ie

In the general playing of the game do you not get told if you've been given an antidote or do you just have to wait and see?

fixXxer

Am I reading the OP wrong? Does it seem like a single RV game?

Green&Red

Spook_ie wrote: »

In the general playing of the game do you not get told if you've been given an antidote or do you just have to wait and see?

I would presume I would be, or that it would be posted on thread

I haven't been given any notice of that, just that QB has said she thinks I'll be ok


Look, we could spend all morning talking about me being poisoned, it'll get us nowhere, I'll live or I'll die

Lets get back to who we think are wolves?

I gave my opinion this morning, I'd like something similar from others. I've softened on Clara since then

Spook_ie

Well sorry if I'm asking more about the mechanics of what happens and how it happens in a game but I am a first timer and to me knowing when you get told you were given an antidote makes relevant sense to me given QBs claim of poisoning and antidote being used.

Spook_ie

Spook_ie wrote: »

Well sorry if I'm asking more about the mechanics of what happens and how it happens in a game but I am a first timer and to me knowing when you get told you were given an antidote makes relevant sense to me given QBs claim of poisoning and antidote being used.

And I'm still concerned about someone being murderized rather than munched?

Green&Red

Spook_ie wrote: »

Well sorry if I'm asking more about the mechanics of what happens and how it happens in a game but I am a first timer and to me knowing when you get told you were given an antidote makes relevant sense to me given QBs claim of poisoning and antidote being used.

Thats fair, sorry if I was short

Green&Red

Spook_ie wrote: »

And I'm still concerned about someone being murderized rather than munched?

I wouldn't be, its flavour

Clarabel

Spook_ie wrote: »

And I'm still concerned about someone being murderized rather than munched?

in other games I would be too but in this game there is nothing hidden and tusk said the munch was happening early.

I am 100% sure that it was the munch

Clarabel

fixxxer wrote: »

Am I reading the OP wrong? Does it seem like a single RV game?

This is a simple game with no hidden mechanics other than the Secret Role.

I am reading this as single role

Spook_ie

Ok next newbie question, if you're poisoned is it up to you to declare yours

Spook_ie

Spook_ie wrote: »

Ok next newbie question, if you're poisoned is it up to you to declare yours

Ignore that hit the post button prematurely, and decided better of asking the question

Green&Red

Spook_ie wrote: »

Ok next newbie question, if you're poisoned is it up to you to declare yours

I got a PM to say I had been poisoned and that I might die between 9am and 9pm

I took that to mean I would die unless someone gave me an antidote
I don't know why I wouldnt declare that on thread, I'd like someone to save me if they can. The PM would suggest that someone can save me because it wasn't 100% that I would die

khalessi

WOlf wise Im down to Spook Fixxer and maybe one other

Spook_ie

khalessi wrote: »

WOlf wise Im down to Spook Fixxer and maybe one other

Wolfwise I still need to know the difference between munched and murderized.

Also with regard to the mechanics of the game does a wolfteam have to munch each night?

fixXxer

Green&Red wrote: »

I got a PM to say I had been poisoned and that I might die between 9am and 9pm

I took that to mean I would die unless someone gave me an antidote
I don't know why I wouldnt declare that on thread, I'd like someone to save me if they can. The PM would suggest that someone can save me because it wasn't 100% that I would die

You should be feeling better soon.

Green&Red

fixxxer wrote: »

You should be feeling better soon.

Is that a claim?

Green&Red

Spook_ie wrote: »

Wolfwise I still need to know the difference between munched and murderized.

Also with regard to the mechanics of the game does a wolfteam have to munch each night?

Literally just flavour, ur reading too much into it, it was at the time we were expecting a munch so you can take it that it was the munch

There would be no sense in the wolf team not munching, its in their interest to kill off villagers

fixXxer

Green&Red wrote: »

Is that a claim?

Yup. I got to poison on person and I could choose to heal them after if I chose before Lynch. Posion order went in Yesterday at 19:59 and I've just put the heal order in now, So I'm now NVR as they were once off actions.

fixXxer

*one person

khalessi

So Fixxxer youre claiming the role? Or is the role separate to the poisoning and healing?
Is QB still claiming a roleor is he a wolf?

Green&Red

I've gotten no notice to say I'm healed

Clarabel

Spook_ie wrote: »

Ignore that hit the post button prematurely, and decided better of asking the question

That's a personal choice. I've seen games played where people hint rather than just say it.

I recall someone saying they had a stomach ache. That was a game with lots of roles though and people didn't want to put themselves.

So it depends. You have to judge what you think. Things will work in one game and not another.

Please don't stop asking questions!

MrKingsley

Morning all.

Just caught up from last night.

Good work on catching BH

Fixxxer- we will need to wait to see if GnR does actually heal

Clarabel

fixxxer wrote: »

Yup. I got to poison on person and I could choose to heal them after if I chose before Lynch. Posion order went in Yesterday at 19:59 and I've just put the heal order in now, So I'm now NVR as they were once off actions.

What....does this mean QB has a fake claim or the role is actually roles...