10 Player Secret Role

Clarabel

MrK. You're not new are you?

fixXxer

Green&Red wrote: »

I've gotten no notice to say I'm healed

Tusk is training, so we'll have to wait.

Green&Red

@Spookie - Its great that you're asking questions and you should continue to do so

I do get the impression you're coasting by though, it could be a good decoy for a wolf to play the newbie.

I'd like to hear more of what you think

Green&Red

fixxxer wrote: »

Yup. I got to poison on person and I could choose to heal them after if I chose before Lynch. Posion order went in Yesterday at 19:59 and I've just put the heal order in now, So I'm now NVR as they were once off actions.

Praise the lord, its a miracle


Thanks Fixxxer, I suppose it would be rude to lynch you now

fixXxer

Green&Red wrote: »

Praise the lord, its a miracle


Thanks Fixxxer, I suppose it would be rude to lynch you now

Not a good idea to lynch someone who is LOCK CLEAR

So, QB any info for us?

quickbeam

fixxxer wrote: »

Not a good idea to lynch someone who is LOCK CLEAR

So, QB any info for us?

None at all.

Green&Red

Well I wouldn't place you LOCK CLEAR just yet but after myself I'd have to trust you the most

Green&Red

Where is Baggly?

Spook_ie

Green&Red wrote: »

@Spookie - Its great that you're asking questions and you should continue to do so

I do get the impression you're coasting by though, it could be a good decoy for a wolf to play the newbie.

I'd like to hear more of what you think

It could be unless they are a newbie

Green&Red

Oh I get that and I know you’re an old fokey so I’ll make allowances for that too!!

but I’d like to hear more of your opinions.

If you had to vote now who would it be for?

MrKingsley

Clarabel wrote: »

MrK. You're not new are you?

No. Played 5/6 games on here and far more in RL

MrKingsley

Green&Red wrote: »

Praise the lord, its a miracle


Thanks Fixxxer, I suppose it would be rude to lynch you now

Right do we have a solid confirmed village population of 2 anyway?

Spook_ie

Green&Red wrote: »

Oh I get that and I know you’re an old fokey so I’ll make allowances for that too!!

but I’d like to hear more of your opinions.

If you had to vote now who would it be for?

At this moment I have 2 groupings formed in my mind, you and Fixxer and then QB, both of you are claiming to have or have had the special power used on or by you. Assuming this IS a one RV game one of the 2 groups is telling porkies.

Green&Red

QB hasn’t claimed to have used any powers, and I said yesterday I thought her claim was bogus

I had poison used on me, then healed. Fixxxer must be telling the truth cause shortly after he said I’d be healed I got a PM to say that I was. Of course he could be using that to curry favour but I doubt it

Clarabel

fixxxer wrote: »

Yup. I got to poison on person and I could choose to heal them after if I chose before Lynch. Posion order went in Yesterday at 19:59 and I've just put the heal order in now, So I'm now NVR as they were once off actions.

Why did you pick GnR?

Baggly

Hey guys; sorry have been slammed in work. Will do my best to catch up now.

Baggly

Ok so i read through the thread and know sKeith was NRV. Im taking that into account with the below.

Spook_ie wrote: »

Everything you've done could also be as a WW
trying to make people think you're a villager, the only person who would know would be the person who did have the superpower, you give the impression of having it by answering the questions and QB claims it, at least one of you isn't so likelihood is one of you is a WW

Dont think Spook throws this accusation at sK if he knows they are NRV. Its too ballsy a move for a wolf to do after BH died and flipped wolf.

quickbeam wrote: »

If GnR & sK are top of the village pile then I should be also. Not because of my role claim which is, as yet, unproven (wait though!), but because I called Bounty out too.

I don't *think* Clara is a wolf. It'd be silly, IMO, for a Bounty/Clara wolf team to both reply to sK in pretty much the same manner.

I also don't rule out bussing by anyone, so players may be top of the pile, but nobody is Lock Clear.

@spook, bussing is throwing a fellow team-mate under the bus to gain villager credibility.

Agree no-one is lock clear right now. I really want this role claim thing to resolve QB......i said it yesterday but undefined timelines for resolution make me edgy.

Green&Red wrote: »

Very unlikely.

SK cast the vote that lynched BH, he could have voted for any of the singles and saved the wolf. Couple that with BH leaving his vote on SK, that’s too risky a move for a wolf.

SK is village

He’s also favourite to be munched given he’s a good player and I’ve been poisoned

Good call.

fixxxer wrote: »

No one is believeable at this stage.

If I put on my paranoia hat, the time between sKieth and GnR banding together and suddenly finding a wolf is suspect. BH cant play, or expects o die as he's always a wolf. His buddies then dive on him and have super village cred...

Also putting on my paranoia hat, is this based on there being 3 wolves? Do we know this? Regardless, this theory is obviously out since sK flipped NRV. Does a wolf make this statement if they know that sK is going to flip village. Maybe actually. But the theory that there are 3 wolves....do you know something we dont Fixxxer?

quickbeam wrote: »

Definitely kitten. She's the hidden wolf. QED.

Or, Spook, Clara, Fix, Bags and Kingsley.

You seem to have dropped this QB - was this a joke or do you have any follow on for kitten?

fixxxer wrote: »

QB why did you poison GnR?

quickbeam wrote: »

I did not.

fixxxer wrote: »

Yup. I got to poison on person and I could choose to heal them after if I chose before Lynch. Posion order went in Yesterday at 19:59 and I've just put the heal order in now, So I'm now NVR as they were once off actions.

Right so the above was said when Fixxxer knew he had an antidote? Fixxxer gets slight village points for healing GNR, but the poison and antidote itself could still have been a wolf power, i think; so wouldn't be cleared imo.

fixxxer wrote: »

Not a good idea to lynch someone who is LOCK CLEAR

So, QB any info for us?

You ain't, imo.

Green&Red wrote: »

Well I wouldn't place you LOCK CLEAR just yet but after myself I'd have to trust you the most

I concur.

MrKingsley wrote: »

Right do we have a solid confirmed village population of 2 anyway?

Who is confirmed village? As far as i can see, only one confirmed village is sKeith and me.

quickbeam

My thoughts:

Baggly - 6 posts, popped in yesterday evening as a sub and radio silence since. Weird.

Bounty Hunter - dead Wolf, voted for by sKeith and GnR

Clarabel - village lean, I don't think both her and Bounty as a wolf team would both reply to the same post by sKeith in quick succession.

Fixxxer - claiming role to poison and cure. Curious role, but GnR saying he's poisoned would corroborate it.

GnR - voted first for wolf-Bounty, got poisoned, very likely villager

Khalessi - null

MrKingsley - null

sKeith - dead Villager

Spook - village lean, a newb wolf would be more likely asking team-mates questions

tusk - super, all round nice guy


And, quickbeam - villager


Best guess for wolves now: Khalessi, Baggly and Kingsley. I doubt there's three left, so max two maybe only one of those.

Spook_ie

Point of order

The only confirmed villager is sK

quickbeam

Baggly wrote: »

You seem to have dropped this QB - was this a joke or do you have any follow on for kitten?

A joke because there ain't no kittens playing this game.

quickbeam

Spook_ie wrote: »

Point of order

The only confirmed villager is sK

Correct! That was my point when I was saying nobody is Lock Clear no matter how they voted in last night's demise.

Baggly

Im not going to apologise for being quiet QB. I subbed in last night on short notice and went to bed soon after, having made sure to vote, in fairness to the game mod.

I got into work this morning intent on catching up on whatever had been posted and doing some analysis (this game is primed for interactions analysis) but had a tonne of work on my desk, so had to get it done.

You can add onto that that im as sick as a dog this morning. So yeah....im doing my best to contribute.

Baggly

quickbeam wrote: »

A joke because there ain't no kittens playing this game.

Ah jaysus :pac:

Spook_ie

Green&Red wrote: »

QB hasn’t claimed to have used any powers, and I said yesterday I thought her claim was bogus

I had poison used on me, then healed. Fixxxer must be telling the truth cause shortly after he said I’d be healed I got a PM to say that I was. Of course he could be using that to curry favour but I doubt it

Or you could both be WWs and self declaring you were poisoned and if Fixxer didn't pick up on the bluff just have it turn out as fake poison.


Likewise QB could be claiming powers and not have them.

Decisions decisions but at the moment without anything other than being a permanently suspicious taxi driver one of you three will probably get my vote

quickbeam

Spook_ie wrote: »

Likewise QB could be claiming powers and not have them.

Decisions decisions but at the moment without anything other than being a permanently suspicious taxi driver one of you three will probably get my vote

Well, I don't know if it will alleviate any confusion or add to it, but you can scratch me having a power from your deliberations.

Spook_ie

quickbeam wrote: »

Well, I don't know if it will alleviate any confusion or add to it, but you can scratch me having a power from your deliberations.

At the moment it's still enny meeny miney mo

Spook_ie

quickbeam wrote: »

Well, I don't know if it will alleviate any confusion or add to it, but you can scratch me having a power from your deliberations.

Of course according to Fixxer I could now scratch him from having any special powers as well but do I believe him or you, hmmm. Eeny meeny miney mo.....

Clarabel

I'm curious how both fixxxer and QB have roles/powers

The OP says ROLE very clearly.

Fixxxer can you explain a bit more please. Is your poison a role? How did it come to you?

Green&Red

Spook_ie wrote: »

Or you could both be WWs and self declaring you were poisoned and if Fixxer didn't pick up on the bluff just have it turn out as fake poison.


Likewise QB could be claiming powers and not have them.

Decisions decisions but at the moment without anything other than being a permanently suspicious taxi driver one of you three will probably get my vote

Why the f**k would you vote for me?
I literally convinced SKeith to vote for BH last nite, if I didn't urge him to then someone else was lynched and we might not have a wolf

Green&Red wrote: »

VOTE Bounty Hunter


It doesn't look like I'm in danger and I'd like either SKeith or Khalessi to follow my lead so hence I'm voting early

If I was a wolf I would have held off until closer to 10 and made my vote the decisive one. Instead I tried to get a villager to vote with me to lynch what I believed (correctly) to be a wolf

Theres not a massive amount more I can do for the village

MrKingsley

Ok perhaps I was being optimistic. I suppose it is possible that GnR and Fixxxer are both wolves but it would be incredibly risking for the 2 of them to bring so much attention on themselves this early.

Especially considering that GnR pointed BH out.

Could someone please give some logic as to why they might do this?

Green&Red

Clarabel wrote: »

I'm curious how both fixxxer and QB have roles/powers

The OP says ROLE very clearly.

Fixxxer can you explain a bit more please. Is your poison a role? How did it come to you?

QB doesn't have a role is my reading of her post below, as I guessed yesterday it was a ruse, one which I dont like

quickbeam wrote: »

Well, I don't know if it will alleviate any confusion or add to it, but you can scratch me having a power from your deliberations.

quickbeam

Spook_ie wrote: »

Of course according to Fixxer I could now scratch him from having any special powers as well but do I believe him or you, hmmm. Eeny meeny miney mo.....

I wouldn't believe me anyway.

Green&Red

MrKingsley wrote: »

Ok perhaps I was being optimistic. I suppose it is possible that GnR and Fixxxer are both wolves but it would be incredibly risking for the 2 of them to bring so much attention on themselves this early.

Especially considering that GnR pointed BH out.

Could someone please give some logic as to why they might do this?

High risk with zero reward, it doesn't make sense

I can see a scenario where Fixxxer is a wolf looking to get some street cred but there is zero benefit for me lying about being poisoned

quickbeam

Green&Red wrote: »

QB doesn't have a role is my reading of her post below, as I guessed yesterday it was a ruse, one which I dont like

Meh. Could have been played better, I agree.

If Fixxxer is telling the truth, it's a bit of a crap role to have tried to protect anyway. Poison then cure you and we're left back at square one.

Clarabel

quickbeam wrote: »

Meh. Could have been played better, I agree.

If Fixxxer is telling the truth, it's a bit of a crap role to have tried to protect anyway. Poison then cure you and we're left back at square one.

You calling tusk crap? He'll punish you!

MrKingsley

Green&Red wrote: »

High risk with zero reward, it doesn't make sense

I can see a scenario where Fixxxer is a wolf looking to get some street cred but there is zero benefit for me lying about being poisoned

This is my thinking.

But even the fixxxer Street cred angle doesn’t work for me. They could’ve just not said anything. Let you die and have gotten an active NRV out of the game whilst staying under the radar

Clarabel

quickbeam wrote: »

I wouldn't believe me anyway.

So don't believe that you do or don't have a power?

Can you be specific here please

Green&Red

MrKingsley wrote: »

This is my thinking.

But even the fixxxer Street cred angle doesn’t work for me. They could’ve just not said anything. Let you die and have gotten an active NRV out of the game whilst staying under the radar

I'd agree, while I wouldn't clear Fixxxer, he is currently top of my most village people

quickbeam

Clarabel wrote: »

You calling tusk crap? He'll punish you!

Lies!!!!

quickbeam wrote: »

tusk - super, all round nice guy

Spook_ie

MrKingsley wrote: »

Ok perhaps I was being optimistic. I suppose it is possible that GnR and Fixxxer are both wolves but it would be incredibly risking for the 2 of them to bring so much attention on themselves this early.

Especially considering that GnR pointed BH out.

Could someone please give some logic as to why they might do this?

It's a short game,

Assume 3 wolves, 7 villagers, need to eliminate 4 villagers for parity and win. Sacrifice one WW for credibility, munch down on a villager, gain on credibility and still have number of villagers to gain parity at 4.

Doesn't mean I'm still not eeny meeny moing between 3 as I don't get why QB would claim to have a power then refute it.

Green&Red

Spook_ie wrote: »

It's a short game,

Assume 3 wolves, 7 villagers, need to eliminate 4 villagers for parity and win. Sacrifice one WW for credibility, munch down on a villager, gain on credibility and still have number of villagers to gain parity at 4.

Doesn't mean I'm still not eeny meeny moing between 3 as I don't get why QB would claim to have a power then refute it.

Thats a fairly detailed and nuanced post for a beginner

quickbeam

Spook_ie wrote: »

I don't get why QB would claim to have a power then refute it.

-->

Green&Red wrote: »

QB is a villager, trying to draw the munch, that will fail and we will spend tomorrow talking about lynching QB which we will end up doing, a villager gone - bad play by QB

Bad play indeed. But the role could have been worth protecting and the one with the role is still alive.

Spook_ie

Green&Red wrote: »

Thats a fairly detailed and nuanced post for a beginner

I spend a lot of time sitting on ranks I have time to analyse most things.

Green&Red

Subtle as a brick in the face QB :pac::pac:

Spook_ie

quickbeam wrote: »

-->



Bad play indeed. But the role could have been worth protecting and the one with the role is still alive.

Which makes out that Fixxer is also telling porkies but I think I'm down to eeny meeny now

Green&Red

My point Spookie was that its hard to marry how the person who made this post today

Spook_ie wrote: »

It's a short game,

Assume 3 wolves, 7 villagers, need to eliminate 4 villagers for parity and win. Sacrifice one WW for credibility, munch down on a villager, gain on credibility and still have number of villagers to gain parity at 4.

Doesn't mean I'm still not eeny meeny moing between 3 as I don't get why QB would claim to have a power then refute it.

Was asking this question yesterday?

Spook_ie wrote: »

What's autopriest in effect?

So you have all the lingo about parity etc but you don't know what autopriest means?

MrKingsley

Spook_ie wrote: »

It's a short game,

Assume 3 wolves, 7 villagers, need to eliminate 4 villagers for parity and win. Sacrifice one WW for credibility, munch down on a villager, gain on credibility and still have number of villagers to gain parity at 4.

Doesn't mean I'm still not eeny meeny moing between 3 as I don't get why QB would claim to have a power then refute it.

Yeah that’s possible(as almost everything is) but I just don’t get why the 2 remaining wolves would do this.

Let’s say the role is a Seer then by checking one of them the other is screwed. It’s such a high risk strategy

Spook_ie

Green&Red wrote: »

My point Spookie was that its hard to marry how the person who made this post today




Was asking this question yesterday?



So you have all the lingo about parity etc but you don't know what autopriest means?

Found a nice thread for beginners

https://touch.boards.ie/thread/2057951273/1/#post110180517

MrKingsley

My reads at the minute:

GnR: Village

Fixxxer: most likely village

Clarabel: village lean(as I think QB said earlier it would be madness for both her and BH to question QBs claim back to back)

QB: the false claim is odd but again a wild strategy if a wolf

So then Baggly, Spook and Khalessi I’ve nothing on. I m would guess that there is a wolf in that group and possibly 2

fixXxer

Spook_ie wrote: »

Which makes out that Fixxer is also telling porkies but I think I'm down to eeny meeny now

I don't understand your reasoning here, please elaborate.