South Park WW ROLE MADNESS - Game Thread

Patrick WW

Doris WW wrote: »

Actually, it’s interesting they have to find that specific player. Would that indicate cartman is separate to the wolf group?

I'm starting lean towards Cartman being the jester, I mean hunting a specific player is a strange role so it would only lend itself to Jester or SK IMO

Senan WW

Gertie's ISO, not a lot to go on if I was to pick one player who would have gone after her it would have been Steve!

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Morning all.

In relation to the non posters and non voters - this game wasn’t due to start until today so I don’t think we can hold it against people if they didn’t know the game had started.

Now people that don’t post / vote today is a different story!

Throws shade on Steve, understandably so

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Yes cause if he was a goodie then he would know there are goodies so would know everyone wasn’t a baddie.

Explains her vote on Steve

Gertrude WW wrote: »

I voted for Steve because I don’t like his constant questioning of people about their roles and how quick he was to agree with the possibility that everyone could be baddies

Defends Oisin

Gertrude WW wrote: »

I don’t think Oisin was saying ignore the jester, just that there is not much we can do about it at the moment and we shouldn’t have all our focus on the jester and none on the wolves.

Then a bit of chat around the Jester

Gertrude WW wrote: »

I've never seen the jester played before either, could be similar to a derp role but the derp can never usually win on its own. The OP doesn't say anything about the jester having a kill but there would have to more than just munches and lynches given the number of players or we could be playing for ages.

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Ok so I have checked the glossary of roles in the other thread and this is all it says for Jester:

the Jesters sole purpose is to get lynched. If they can get lynched, they win

To me it wouldn't make sense the Jester having a kill as it doesn't do anything to help its chances of winning.

Ewan WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

Ok guys here it is.
The eagerly awaited South Park Jester & Wolf list:

Jester: Regan
Wolf: Orla AKA Double Agent LuLa
Wolf: Lucy AKA Double Agent LuLa
Wolf: Ewan
Wolf: Desmond
Wolf: Senan - Still 50/50 on him but worth lynching anyway.

What's your reasons tho?

Senan WW

Patrick WW wrote: »

Not lovers anyway, Cartman killed Tenormans parents and fed then to him

I've had some girlfriends like that

Senan WW

Doris WW wrote: »

Actually, it’s interesting they have to find that specific player. Would that indicate cartman is separate to the wolf group?

I wouldnt jump to that conclusion, could be an apprentice looking to find one of the wolves and get converted if they do find them

Patrick WW

Senan WW wrote: »

I've had some girlfriends like that

Eh okay mental note not to trust your judgement

Lucy WW

So, let's shoot Wendy and Lynch Orla.

Patrick WW

Lucy WW wrote: »

So, let's shoot Wendy and Lynch Orla.

Is there a correlation between the two? Like if you shoot Wendy and she's good then you'd still lynch Orla or you'd have a change of tactic?

Angus WW

So not a great start to life in the town.
Losing the Satan role seems like it could be a major sting in the tail.
Hard to tell in a game full of roled players but we may also have lost an SK hunter. I wouldnt have thought the cartman character fits well with a Jester role but then the mods have warned that characters don't necessarily fit with an expected alignment.

I presume Steve getting munched was because he screamed wish granter, at least in hindsight. Or possibly it was just Jester hunting.
Given the field of play I wouldn't be surprised if not a single wolf voted for Steve. But potentially anyone who switched from an earlier Steve vote will be suspect. Which I'll check.

Wendy WW

Ewan WW wrote: »

What's your reasons tho?

The first 600 posts. Oh sorry....I forgot you missed most of yesterday and joined the no lynch wolf wagon. (Even though you were on line all day and posted 7 times!).

Game over mate, time to start running for cover.

Fiona WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

Ok guys here it is.
The eagerly awaited South Park Jester & Wolf list:

Jester: Regan
Wolf: Orla AKA Double Agent LuLa
Wolf: Lucy AKA Double Agent LuLa
Wolf: Ewan
Wolf: Desmond
Wolf: Senan - Still 50/50 on him but worth lynching anyway.

???

Wendy WW

Lucy WW wrote: »

So, let's shoot Wendy and Lynch Orla.

Wendy WW

Fiona WW wrote: »

???

????

Clodagh WW

Fiona WW wrote: »

"Eric Cartman Hunter"

Any ideas on what the Eric Cartman role would be? SK?

Hunter If you are killed, take someone down with you.

Derry WW

Get in to work, log on and find out I may have been poisoned - great start!

Fiona WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

????

Throwing darts at random

Wendy WW

Fiona WW wrote: »

Throwing darts at random

Logic to it all. Have you read all post since yesterday? Who’s on your list?

P.S.: I’m not sure if you’re new to this game but Team Village needs proactive players not negative non constructive comments.

Eva WW

Senan WW wrote: »

I'm not sure on that one, I didn't vote for him so I've no skin in the game but if you're the wolves you're jester hunting surely, so the people who voted steve are looking for the opposite?

I'd go so far as to say that I'd have Emily / Gertrude / Patrick on my lean village pile on that basis alone

Priority One for the wolves at lynch time will be not getting lynched. They might Jester hunt during their munches, but the chances of hitting the jester in munch one are the lowest they will ever be for them.

Given the wolves decided to munch Steve, it means they have some reason (no matter how small) to want Steve off the board. The fact Steve was high up the lynch list last night would have even meant that they could have left him in play in case he'd get lynched tonight.

Steve was the wish granter, which we can wager was a pretty powerful role. If the wolves, for instance, got a peek somehow, and learned Steve was Satan, maybe they felt it was necessary to burn him quickly. They could have tried to organize a lynch, and when that didn't work, they didn't take the risk of letting him get past munch today in case he could start granting wishes.

Eva WW

And worth a try....
Oh mighty Satan,

I wish our wish granter was not dead. I wish that Steve was brought back to life.

Senan WW

Steves ISO, lot of fluff. I'm always loathe to put too much stock in the early munches thoughts, they're shooting in the dark as much as the rest of us


Links Wendy and Wini, one I'll be putting in my notes although I'm not sure how much basis it has

Steve WW wrote: »

Unless they're the jester or a wolf... If she flips red I'll bet coming for you. Why her and not someone else

Pulls up Clodagh who arrives in after not voting with wise advice, I actually like this shout, Clodagh moves to the leaning wolf pile for me

Steve WW wrote: »

Handy time to come in with this info... 7 minutes after a Lynch would have occurred, had there been one...

Wolf

Had a go at Regan as well, another on my lean wolf list

Steve WW wrote: »

You still haven't answered a question here. You're just taking around yourself. Coming across very strange when I just asked a simple question

Cosied up to Henry

Steve WW wrote: »

Nice spot. Is like to hear these reasons too

Finally settles on Gertie and Ewan, doesn't give any reasons

Steve WW wrote: »

Gertrude and Ewan piqued my radar early on. I'm staying on Ewan unless something pops up.

In terms of jester I'm not sure. I think they're too afraid to push hard out of the gate, so I don't think we'll see anything huge from them until later.

Doris WW

Necro wrote: »

Mod Announcements





Steve WW has been found dead, mostly eaten.


Gertrude WW has been shot dead in the street

Their souls still hang by a thread however.... for another hour


Derry WW and Liam WW have been poisoned.

One of these is fake, one of these is real.

They have until lynch to be cured, or....






This concludes the mornings announcements.... for now

Can we assume based on two deaths that there is an sk role? Is this separate to the shot that was fired yesterday? The poison: this seems likely to be a wolf power?

Thoughts folks?

Wendy WW

Eva WW wrote: »

And worth a try....
Oh mighty Satan,

I wish our wish granter was not dead. I wish that Steve was brought back to life.

Desmond WW

Cant do this alone, get wishing people, and I'll see what I can do.

Derry WW

But was Steve not the wish granter or did I read that wrong?

Fiona WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

Logic to it all. Have you read all post since yesterday? Who’s on your list?

P.S.: I’m not sure if you’re new to this game but Team Village needs proactive players not negative non constructive comments.

I've skimmed some of it. Don't have time to read 600 posts right now tbh.

Anything of note in it all?

Desmond WW

Doris WW wrote: »

Can we assume based on two deaths that there is an sk role? Is this separate to the shot that was fired yesterday? The poison: this seems likely to be a wolf power?

Thoughts folks?

I dont think there is an sk role, its not in the win conditions, jester I guess is kinda like the sk in this game.

Senan WW

Angus WW wrote: »

So not a great start to life in the town.
Losing the Satan role seems like it could be a major sting in the tail.
Hard to tell in a game full of roled players but we may also have lost an SK hunter. I wouldnt have thought the cartman character fits well with a Jester role but then the mods have warned that characters don't necessarily fit with an expected alignment.

I presume Steve getting munched was because he screamed wish granter, at least in hindsight. Or possibly it was just Jester hunting.
Given the field of play I wouldn't be surprised if not a single wolf voted for Steve. But potentially anyone who switched from an earlier Steve vote will be suspect. Which I'll check.

Steve referred to his role as minor this morning, BS or truth I wonder?

I made the point around munch time that I'd nearly clear the three who voted for Steve on the basis that I think wolves are jester hunting so you wouldnt be voting for the same person you'd be munching if that makes sense

Emily, Gertie and Patrick voted for him. The remaining two are on my lean good list for the time being

Doris WW

Desmond WW wrote: »

Cant do this alone, get wishing people, and I'll see what I can do.

Meh, why not...

I wish that Steve was brought back to life.

Doris WW

Desmond WW wrote: »

I dont think there is an sk role, its not in the win conditions, jester I guess is kinda like the sk in this game.

But with no sk would that mean up to three wolf kills a day? Even with this many players that’s a lot of firepower

Derry WW

Doris WW wrote: »

Can we assume based on two deaths that there is an sk role? Is this separate to the shot that was fired yesterday? The poison: this seems likely to be a wolf power?

Thoughts folks?

Gertie was killed by a bullet - not usually the style of an SK??

Derry WW

Doris WW wrote: »

But with no sk would that mean up to three wolf kills a day? Even with this many players that’s a lot of firepower

I wonder if out vig is a night time vig and their kill gets announced with the munch?

Senan WW

Eva WW wrote: »

Priority One for the wolves at lynch time will be not getting lynched. They might Jester hunt during their munches, but the chances of hitting the jester in munch one are the lowest they will ever be for them.

Given the wolves decided to munch Steve, it means they have some reason (no matter how small) to want Steve off the board. The fact Steve was high up the lynch list last night would have even meant that they could have left him in play in case he'd get lynched tonight.

Steve was the wish granter, which we can wager was a pretty powerful role. If the wolves, for instance, got a peek somehow, and learned Steve was Satan, maybe they felt it was necessary to burn him quickly. They could have tried to organize a lynch, and when that didn't work, they didn't take the risk of letting him get past munch today in case he could start granting wishes.

Well with the stupid no lynch voting last nite we never got to see any panic, they were safe as houses
I think wolves are jester hunting first and foremost, agreed its hard now but thats still their priority, especially since everyone has a role, no matter which village they hit they're eliminating a role

My point was they wouldn't be trying to organise a lynch of their top priority i.e. the jester

Wendy WW

Fiona WW wrote: »

I've skimmed some of it. Don't have time to read 600 posts right now tbh.

Anything of note in it all?

Yes! A few good twists in the plot alright. I’ve listed all the wolves above so save yourself the trouble and just use that for your votes.

Ewan WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

The first 600 posts. Oh sorry....I forgot you missed most of yesterday and joined the no lynch wolf wagon. (Even though you were on line all day and posted 7 times!).

Game over mate, time to start running for cover.

Ok, there's a sort of logic there for me. I don't agree with it but I can see it. I wasn't online all day yesterday though so its faulty logic. Why no Derry as they were not online at all?

What about the rest of the list?

Wendy WW

Desmond WW wrote: »

Cant do this alone, get wishing people, and I'll see what I can do.

Henry WW

I think I'd like to see what Lucy flips.

If Lucy is good, I reckon wolves are split over her wagon and the no-lynch wagon.

If Lucy is bad, we can look mainly on the no-lynch wagon, and take a stronger look at the people who started voting steve and who wanted to move the lynch away from Lucy.

Any thoughts on that as a strategy?

Henry WW

Just in case Desmond has an actual theory about this repeated wishes thing:

I wish that Steve was brought back to life.

Wendy WW

Henry WW wrote: »

I think I'd like to see what Lucy flips.

If Lucy is good, I reckon wolves are split over her wagon and the no-lynch wagon.

If Lucy is bad, we can look mainly on the no-lynch wagon, and take a stronger look at the people who started voting steve and who wanted to move the lynch away from Lucy.

Any thoughts on that as a strategy?

Finally someone thinking sensibly.

Eva WW

Henry WW wrote: »

I think I'd like to see what Lucy flips.

If Lucy is good, I reckon wolves are split over her wagon and the no-lynch wagon.

If Lucy is bad, we can look mainly on the no-lynch wagon, and take a stronger look at the people who started voting steve and who wanted to move the lynch away from Lucy.

Any thoughts on that as a strategy?

My inital thoughts are I like this plan.

Desmond WW

Doris WW wrote: »

But with no sk would that mean up to three wolf kills a day? Even with this many players that’s a lot of firepower

My understanding is, 1 wolf kill, 1 shot from yesterday, and someone else has the ability to poison

Desmond WW

Ok here's the deal. Unless the mods are messing and my power is fake, I can grant one player an allignment peek. Sorry, I cant bring steve back.

But Im not going to give it to just anyone, we need to decide who we trust with it, then we should decide who they peek.

Isla WW

Senan WW wrote: »

Steve referred to his role as minor this morning, BS or truth I wonder?

I made the point around munch time that I'd nearly clear the three who voted for Steve on the basis that I think wolves are jester hunting so you wouldnt be voting for the same person you'd be munching if that makes sense

Emily, Gertie and Patrick voted for him. The remaining two are on my lean good list for the time being

Lean good for them makes sense. 100% do not clear them on that though but I've no reason to suspect them atm


After reading back on the thread, which seemed to kick it up a notch post after a slower weekend...


Steve and Gertie shot. an hour to be saved?
Derry/Liam poisoned

Henry quick to positively explain the poison targets... did he do it?


Eva then explains the wolves choice of Steve - focus on the steve wagon. Except I think they were going for Steve hoping to hit the Jester / thinking he would not be ressurected so the village could see who he was. Wolfy Gut feeling on Eva here

FFS ultimate power granter... And Satan & Scott Tenorman being good! ha

Don't think the Cartman hunter is neccesarily leading to Cartman (not me) being bad though as roles / characters don't = good/bad. The Devil was good too. Character wise

In my first post I questioned if the recent Hudra test would indicate the mods were going to do such a role in this game so I can see where the Orla/Lucy stuff originated but unless they both have access to both their accounts that is surely out the window as we have the same number of players sign up as accounts. Actually makes me slightly lean village on them as wolf team mates would probably tell them not to act the maggot like that behind closed doors.


I'm confused by Clodagh's

Hunter If you are killed, take someone down with you.

After the Catman Hunter has already been killed

Senan WW

Senan WW wrote: »

I wish for a peek.

@Dessie, this was my second post yesterday, I stand by it, I'm happy to peek and for you to pick the person I peek.

Obviously only I know I'm good and you have to pick someone you can trust but I think my offer above is as close to an assurance as you'll get

Obviously if I was a wolf and lying well it would only take my lie to be exposed and you'd have me nailed as a wolf

Holly WW

Desmond WW wrote: »

Ok here's the deal. Unless the mods are messing and my power is fake, I can grant one player an allignment peek. Sorry, I cant bring steve back.

But Im not going to give it to just anyone, we need to decide who we trust with it, then we should decide who they peek.

Is it worth peeking one of the poison victims? If they are bad then no cure

Eva WW

Desmond WW wrote: »

Ok here's the deal. Unless the mods are messing and my power is fake, I can grant one player an allignment peek. Sorry, I cant bring steve back.

But Im not going to give it to just anyone, we need to decide who we trust with it, then we should decide who they peek.

I'd like it for selfish reasons :P

But I'd think Lucy should be peaked to help along Henry's plan.

Isla WW

Desmond WW wrote: »

Ok here's the deal. Unless the mods are messing and my power is fake, I can grant one player an allignment peek. Sorry, I cant bring steve back.

But Im not going to give it to just anyone, we need to decide who we trust with it, then we should decide who they peek.

This sounds like a good power for you to come forward about. Whoever you choose can confirm your story and then we have a peek.



People will no doubt question if you would pick a wolf buddy for the peek and if we could believe what the result was but if the village decide there is a much better chance of the result being on the level.

Conor WW

I have a theory on who shot Gertie but if they are good it’s best i don’t share the theory cause they may have more opportunities. If they are bad then it means the wolves get two kills a day, I’m not sure which is worse/better.

Isla WW

Lots of people putting their name forward for a peek. If you had to pick someone else to get it who would you pick? we can't be sure a wolf wouldn't give this power to another wolf or a good might by mistake. Just saying they want it is not enough reason to pick someone

Conor WW

Conor WW wrote: »

I have a theory on who shot Gertie but if they are good it’s best i don’t share the theory cause they may have more opportunities. If they are bad then it means the wolves get two kills a day, I’m not sure which is worse/better.

Correction, if it’s right the wolves may get more then 1 Kill a day.

Patrick WW

Desmond WW wrote: »

Ok here's the deal. Unless the mods are messing and my power is fake, I can grant one player an allignment peek. Sorry, I cant bring steve back.

But Im not going to give it to just anyone, we need to decide who we trust with it, then we should decide who they peek.

I like Dessie, I think if your giving the power you should select who is peeked IMO but your call if you want consensus.