South Park WW ROLE MADNESS - Game Thread

Henry WW

Regan WW wrote: »

What happened to the bullet from the other day?

Seriously?

Isla WW

Henry WW wrote: »

Misinterpreted, not misrepresented - from a quick search I was thinking about missing the timestamps on the steve votes which then missed the point I was making with the post (which is an irrelevant point if lucy is good)

I also didn't like pushing that I could be poisoner which would be a bad call if it had been me (it wasn't) and if it was a good role.

Anyways, I do appreciate the FFA. Agree with parking Lucy and Liam for now.

Need to have a think about the rest. Will do ISOs if get time.

re The poisoner thing, even if you were that person roles do not equal alignment so you could be a good poisoner. As odd as that sounds we had a good Satan

Regan WW

Henry WW wrote: »

Seriously?

Ill read back

Lucy WW

Patrick WW wrote: »

Has to be the wolf team, why would a villager shoot him?

It's Southpark. The entire village is filled with simple folk...

You know,


Morons

Henry WW

Isla WW wrote: »

re The poisoner thing, even if you were that person roles do not equal alignment so you could be a good poisoner. As odd as that sounds we had a good Satan

totally agree - i wouldn't mind you calling me out as a bad poisoner

I've an issue with you potentially calling out a good role



NB. I'm not the poisoner.

Emily WW

Regan WW wrote: »

What happened to the bullet from the other day?

yeah that was odd.

There was just the mod announcement that a shot had been fired but then nothing else afterwards I dont think

Doris WW

Senan WW wrote: »

That makes no sense, why would wolves kill Des? He’s confirmed village maybe?

But he’d shot his load in so far as using his power? Surely you shoot him before he allows someone to peek?

Maybe wolves felt it wasn’t a one time power. Maybe des was gift giver and satan was something else. I think resurrector probably needs to act on that basis

Henry WW

Regan WW wrote: »

Ill read back

munch post this morning - gertrude died from being shot

Derry WW

Unless that bullet was a delayed bullet and was the one that killed gertie

Doris WW

Lucy WW wrote: »

It's Southpark. The entire village is filled with simple folk...

You know,


Morons

Filled you say

Like 100% :pac:

Lucy WW

What do we think about Wendy as the Jester?

Patrick WW

Henry WW wrote: »

munch post this morning - gertrude died from being shot

I thought this was the case but Dessie and his (apparently) instant hit is unusual in that case

Isla WW

Henry WW wrote: »

totally agree - i wouldn't mind you calling me out as a bad poisoner

I've an issue with you potentially calling out a good role



NB. I'm not the poisoner.

I think were kind of on the same side of the discussion here but my point was that a role does not matter with regards good/bad. Making that comment gets a person talking, a person talking could lead to a person slipping. That said your in my good lean list atm and it has nothing to do with the poison... well it has to do with you making a good non wolfy suggestion about giving the peek to someone who might use it.



The wolves know who is good anyway so no harm in saying I think your good unless I am completely wrong. Not saying your everyones favorite WW term (Lock Clear) or anything.

Frank WW

Maybe Des is kenny and he'll be alive again tomorrow

Vernon WW

Derry WW wrote: »

Unless that bullet was a delayed bullet and was the one that killed gertie

I dunno there could be more people who have guns/bullets. Or multiple bullets per person per day. Combinations are endless (there's a pedant waiting to correct this statement)

Patrick WW

Frank WW wrote: »

Maybe Des is kenny and he'll be alive again tomorrow

4th post from you, two of which are howdy and howdy again! Any thoughts Frank

Lucy WW

Doris WW wrote: »

Filled you say

Like 100% :pac:

Totes


Also I'm. Looking into ways to have Orla killed.

Conor WW

Isla WW wrote: »

A wolf act makes sense as Des is not someone I saw as wolfy so far. The ressurector could still act yet though if they are on team village. Def hope they aren't on the wolf team

If my theory was right you could be the one with the gun. No surprises why you would have me on your FFA

Frank WW

Patrick WW wrote: »

4th post from you, two of which are howdy and howdy again! Any thoughts Frank

Not really. I'm really struggling to get into this. Had almost no time to post over the weekend and playing catch up

Conor WW

sKeith wrote: »

Mod Announcement.

A shot has been fired.

Desmond WW has been hit.

Desmond WW is dead.

So we should get Des role in a few mins which suggests somebody has a power to save him...

Conor WW

In terms of the Lucy sort of clear now, we are happy it wasn’t two wolves concocting a plan to protect another wolf and sort of clear another ? (If we are to believe the power used that we got no mod verification on?). And isn’t the role/character alignment irrelevant?

Wendy WW

Lucy WW wrote: »

Totes


Also I'm. Looking into ways to have Orla killed.

You’ve really gone nuts. Fair play.

Winifred WW

Conor WW wrote: »

In terms of the Lucy sort of clear now, we are happy it wasn’t two wolves concocting a plan to protect another wolf and sort of clear another ? (If we are to believe the power used that we got no mod verification on?). And isn’t the role/character alignment irrelevant?

If lucy is good, she'll be munched as the most cleared villager, so we can park her for now.

Patrick WW

Conor WW wrote: »

In terms of the Lucy sort of clear now, we are happy it wasn’t two wolves concocting a plan to protect another wolf and sort of clear another ? (If we are to believe the power used that we got no mod verification on?). And isn’t the role/character alignment irrelevant?

Tbh until one of Derry or Lucy dies then we can't really discount either of them. If Derry dies and is good then Lucy is lock clear. If Lucy dies and is good then Derry is just neutral really. We will know tonight if Derry was poisoned so id park discussion on those two till tomorrow at least.

Liam WW

Henry WW wrote: »

Ah, fun times. Was not expecting that.

I'm going to assume you're legit for now Derry-Berry.

For me, I'm guessing that leaves us with a couple of wolves in here:

No lynch - Barbara / Regan / Ewan / Oisin / Conor / Phil

And a couple in here:

Lucy - Wendy / Winifred / Orla / Vernon / Henry

Since I know I'm good, that gives me Vernon, Orla, Winifred and Wendy. If there's 2 in there, that's a 50% chance of hitting a wolf.

Why cant wolfs be in the single voters. Wolfs are or aren't jumping on bandwagons for the sake of it

Conor WW

Patrick WW wrote: »

Tbh until one of Derry or Lucy dies then we can't really discount either of them. If Derry dies and is good then Lucy is lock clear. If Lucy dies and is good then Derry is just neutral really. We will know tonight if Derry was poisoned so id park discussion on those two till tomorrow at least.

Thanks, that’s sort of what I was thinking.

Necro

Desmond WW was





Mr Hankey the Christmas Poo - Wish Granter


And also....

Good

Emily WW

Yeah was it Henry that put up a really good post with the 6 potential scenarios of the peek? Ill try and find it now.

It is definitely possible that it was a wolf plan. It is also possible that it is legitimately the truth.

I wont go as far to say that Derry and Lucy are lock clear but definitely villagae lean for them from me

Derry WW

Aw bye Des.

So if he was the wish granter what was Steve?

Conor WW

Liam WW wrote: »

Why cant wolfs be in the single voters. Wolfs are or aren't jumping on bandwagons for the sake of it

Yep, mad to think it’s inconceivable that wolves would vote independent targets. Also there a few people whinging before about no lynch so I’d argue no lynch was a higher risk place for a wolf.

Angus WW

Derry WW wrote: »

Aw bye Des.

So if he was the wish granter what was Steve?

Ultimate wish granter.

Frank WW

Patrick WW wrote: »

Tbh until one of Derry or Lucy dies then we can't really discount either of them. If Derry dies and is good then Lucy is lock clear. If Lucy dies and is good then Derry is just neutral really. We will know tonight if Derry was poisoned so id park discussion on those two till tomorrow at least.

I think that's a fair assessment of the peak

Fiona WW

Angus WW wrote: »

Ultimate wish granter.

Whats the difference?

Patrick WW

Necro wrote: »

Steve WW was




Satan - Ultimate Power Granter

And...

Good

Gertrude WW was




Scott Tenorman, Eric Cartman hunter


And also...

Good

Ultimate power granter

And a wish granter!

So two big loses today, Fcuk me

Doris WW

Necro wrote: »

Desmond WW was





Mr Hankey the Christmas Poo - Wish Granter


And also....

Good

Ok, wishes have to be in bold. Who asked for the peek in bold, I.e. who had figured out he was the wish granter from early on

Frank WW

I know it's not a good look for me, but that it was mentioned that non posters/voters over the weekend would get a pass, makes the non voting a very safe harbour for wolves.

Frank WW

Doris WW wrote: »

Ok, wishes have to be in bold. Who asked for the peek in bold, I.e. who had figured out he was the wish granter from early on

Where does it say in the reveal that wishes have to be in bold ?

Doris WW

Frank WW wrote: »

Where does it say in the reveal that wishes have to be in bold ?

In the op

Vernon WW

Winifred WW wrote: »

If lucy is good, she'll be munched as the most cleared villager, so we can park her for now.

Or not, I guess they could leave her to see doubt over her and Derry.

Right?

Frank WW

Doris WW wrote: »

In the op

Oh. Ty

Oisin WW

At this stage i dont know where to dive in, but ill give it a shot. Suffice to say its been a bad day for us so far.

From my reading, we are parking Derry and Lucy until one dies and we go from there.

Wendy is coming under heat for.....? Opposition to Lucy?

From the vote analysis that has been posted, its 2 from Barbara / Regan / Ewan / Conor / Phil (i know im in the lynch of no voters, but im village so....)

or 2 from the Lucy voters Wendy / Winifred / Orla / Vernon / Henry

Above is blatantly stolen from Henry btw.

I havent seen anything in terms of consensus on revealing, but i take it we shouldnt (not suggesting we do yet, just want to make sure we are clear on why not). We have lots of roles so would it not be possible to identify some wolves by everyone declaring powers and seeing how everyone uses their power (i.e. for the village). I dont mind us waiting on this btw, but its something we are going to have to decide eventually. There is a serious lack of info and clarity going around imo. Its D2 now so we dont even have the excuse of saying 'ah its only D1'.

Vernon WW

Oisin WW wrote: »

At this stage i dont know where to dive in, but ill give it a shot. Suffice to say its been a bad day for us so far.

From my reading, we are parking Derry and Lucy until one dies and we go from there.

Wendy is coming under heat for.....? Opposition to Lucy?

From the vote analysis that has been posted, its 2 from Barbara / Regan / Ewan / Conor / Phil (i know im in the lynch of no voters, but im village so....)

or 2 from the Lucy voters Wendy / Winifred / Orla / Vernon / Henry

Above is blatantly stolen from Henry btw.

I havent seen anything in terms of consensus on revealing, but i take it we shouldnt (not suggesting we do yet, just want to make sure we are clear on why not). We have lots of roles so would it not be possible to identify some wolves by everyone declaring powers and seeing how everyone uses their power (i.e. for the village). I dont mind us waiting on this btw, but its something we are going to have to decide eventually. There is a serious lack of info and clarity going around imo. Its D2 now so we dont even have the excuse of saying 'ah its only D1'.

That's fine but I think reveals make some roles easy munched for wolves.

Let's say someone says they seer or have a gun. The wolves can then risk / reward the munch on all players.

I don't like the idea of reveal at all. Unless you're about to die and have info. Then spill the beans!

Vernon WW

I don't get the Wendy horn.

Lucy any thoughts on why you're connected to Orla. Did I see you want to shoot her? Why is that?

Henry WW

Regan WW wrote: »

Ill read back

Nah - i was being snappy. Sorry about that.

We don't know 100% that it was the gertie bullet anyway. just wasn't in a great mood at that point.

Oisin WW

Vernon WW wrote: »

That's fine but I think reveals make some roles easy munched for wolves.

Let's say someone says they seer or have a gun. The wolves can then risk / reward the munch on all players.

I don't like the idea of reveal at all. Unless you're about to die and have info. Then spill the beans!

Well it just seems to me that powers are being used blind, which may (MAY) be a bigger risk to the village?

Like wolves are gonna wolf and lets hope their kill rate is limited or mitigated by some of the powers; hiding villager powers will mitigate who they kill i guess but.....well i guess what im trying to say is they cant kill all of us at once, and the longer we have some sort of core based off power declarations, the better.

I wont lie i was thinking about this before the game started, as everyone was going to have a power, so its a bit of a unique mechanic in itself.

Henry WW

Liam WW wrote: »

Why cant wolfs be in the single voters. Wolfs are or aren't jumping on bandwagons for the sake of it

You take a look at the single voters then, and i'll concentrate on the wagons.

Oisin WW

Its 3.30 - are we doing FFAs?

Winifred WW

Vernon WW wrote: »

Or not, I guess they could leave her to see doubt over her and Derry.

Right?

They could, but that's a dangerous game.

Right?

Senan WW

I’ll repeat, I don’t see any correlation between Lucy’s voters and wolves? Are we just randomly saying there’s two wolves in that group?

Oisin WW

Senan WW wrote: »

I’ll repeat, I don’t see any correlation between Lucy’s voters and wolves? Are we just randomly saying there’s two wolves in that group?

The two apparent wagons, it seems, were no lynch and lucy. It would stand to reason, imo, that wolves would hop on these.