South Park WW ROLE MADNESS - Game Thread

Liam WW

Regan WW wrote: »

And again what are the numbers in the ffa

How many votes they have each got.

Senan WW

Henry WW wrote: »

Thanks. Interesting, cos this isn't remotely reflected in the voting:

Senan - Gabriel Holly
Gabriel - Senan Oisin Fiona
Lucy - Wendy
Liam - Ewan
Eva - Isla
Regan - Frank Orla Clodagh Wendy
Ewan - Winifred
Frank - Conor
Vernon - Henry

On one FFA

Two votes

Obvs

Conor WW

Abigail WW wrote: »

Not voting is about as much of a wolf tactic as voting I reckon. I know I'm in the no vote pile and I'm not a wolf and there are probably wolves in the group of people who voted.

That’s fine but I’m not having a go at people for not voting. I’m having a go at somebody who didn’t vote at all and is having a go at people who voted “no lynch”.

Eva WW

Senan WW wrote: »

I presume if there’s poison there’s an antidote somewhere?

I’d be inclined to use it on Derry

I liked the way he acted around the peek, it felt village and I didn’t like Liam just popping up when there was a peek on offer


What do others think?

Neither has made massive arguments to do so.

If the antidote is a one time use, then I don't know if Derry is worth it. If its used to heal Derry and, say, a stronger role is poisoned latter, then it could be a waste.

If it's useable every day, sure.

But that's going to be something the healer needs to work out.

Emily WW

Frank WW wrote: »

You missed my ffa there emily. Regan, ewan, barbara were the 3

Apologies Frank. As I said I’ve never done it before

Liam WW

Senan WW wrote: »

I presume if there’s poison there’s an antidote somewhere?

I’d be inclined to use it on Derry

I liked the way he acted around the peek, it felt village and I didn’t like Liam just popping up when there was a peek on offer


What do others think?

I think I had nothing to do with the poisoning and my appearance was my appearance.

And if I hadn't been 50/50 poisoned you wouldn't be making anything of when I got on thread.

You are going all beautiful mind on this.

Your adding 2 plus 2 and getting 53

Senan WW

@ Doris - ur someone whose posts I find myself agreeing with, you’re in my village pile - why Vernon? He hadn’t been on my radar at all?

@Lucy - same question since In my book you’re cleared for the time being

Thanks

Regan WW

Abigail WW wrote: »

What your role is? I mean you may as well claim if you're going to be lynched, but what does your role actually tell us? Roles are not indicative of alignment.

True but it could be an advantage to either side so youd think someone would go hmmm could be something could be nothing but hold off 24 hours see what happens

Senan WW

Liam WW wrote: »

I think I had nothing to do with the poisoning and my appearance was my appearance.

And if I hadn't been 50/50 poisoned you wouldn't be making anything of when I got on thread.

You are going all beautiful mind on this.

Your adding 2 plus 2 and getting 53

Is that not the whole point of this game!!

Liam WW

Regan WW wrote: »

True but it could be an advantage to either side so youd think someone would go hmmm could be something could be nothing but hold off 24 hours see what happens

The only thing i know about you regan is you play a lot of fifa

Senan WW

FWIW I’ve been here saying we shouldn’t vote for you tonite!

Liam WW

Senan WW wrote: »

Is that not the whole point of this game!!

to go all beautiful mind I dont think so?

Regan WW

Can Derry and liam gives us reasons to give them antidote

Phil WW

Frank WW wrote: »

You missed my ffa there emily. Regan, ewan, barbara were the 3

Amended to include Frank

FFA Round Up

Patrick: Wendy, Frank, Brendan, Vernon
Holly: Senan, Vernon, Frank
Emily: Wendy, Angus
Doris: Wendy, Gabriel, Henry
Henry: Vernon, Regan, Ewan
Winifred: Ewan, Liam, Vernon
Oisin: Gabriel, Fiona, Angus
Isla: Eva, Liam, Conor, Orla
Phil: Regan, Wendy, Liam

I think they are all in order with the exception of Phil cos his initial one wasnt #ed

Totals:
Wendy 4
Vernon 4
Liam 3
Regan 3
Angus 2
Frank 2
Ewan 3
Brendan 1
Eva 1
Conor 1
Orla 1
Gabriel 2
Senan 1
Henry 1
Fiona 1
Barbara 1

Liam WW

Senan WW wrote: »

FWIW I’ve been here saying we shouldn’t vote for you tonite!

I'm merely pointing out the logic is faulty, I dont mind just pointing

Regan WW

Liam WW wrote: »

The only thing i know about you regan is you play a lot of fifa

Liverpool ftw

Liam WW

Regan WW wrote: »

Liverpool ftw

Shoot this one quick :P

Eva WW

Regan WW wrote: »

Liverpool ftw

Never mind, vote this man out.

Brendan WW

Catching up now from 1030 onwards so 8f any questions seem odd its just cause im not caught up

Ewan WW wrote: »

I had a look back over Steves posts but i See Reading back nothing that would make me think anything other than tree shaking villager.

Steve appeared to he powerful enough, I must admit he did not play like a shaken villager?

He played as if he was a bit fearless.

Ewan, what made you think he was shaken?

Eva WW

#FFA1

Orla
Vernon

(For their roles in voting Lucy)

Phil

(as the latest voter on No Lynch whom I can't place into my trust pile yet)

Brendan WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

Ok guys here it is.
The eagerly awaited South Park Jester & Wolf list:

Jester: Regan
Wolf: Orla AKA Double Agent LuLa
Wolf: Lucy AKA Double Agent LuLa
Wolf: Ewan
Wolf: Desmond
Wolf: Senan - Still 50/50 on him but worth lynching anyway.

What made you think Regan was a Jester...... specifically

Frank WW

Conor WW wrote: »

How is not voting any better then voting “no lynch”!
.

Oh no, you're right there. Not voting is way worse than no lynch. But I believe that when given the option of no lynch or lynching someone, the village should be opting to lynch someone

Brendan WW

Lucy WW wrote: »

So, let's shoot Wendy and Lynch Orla.

Youve probably already explained.....

But Im catching up...... why shoot Wendy

Why lynch orla

Phil WW

Eva WW wrote: »

#FFA1

Orla
Vernon

(For their roles in voting Lucy)

Phil

(as the latest voter on No Lynch whom I can't place into my trust pile yet)

I was the first no lynch voter not the latest. Well, Vernon was first much earlier in day but changed their vote.

Vernon WW

Angus WW wrote: »

Hello to all my southern parkian friends.

Are we allowed reveal our roles?

I'm not quite sure what to do with the tiny horse the mods gave me.

Slight role reveal which I note no one else picks up on

Angus WW wrote: »

I wish that Gertrude would truthfully state her alignment

Wish - Gertrude was good

Angus WW wrote: »

Good evening. Sorry I missed today had a friend visiting from abroad and in truth I'm still too depressed from yesterday to do any south parking.

Motoring my way through the thread and posts. I'm not sure what the Orla Lucy thing is about. It seems nothing to me and I wonder about those pushing for something that seems of little consequence.

I haven't read the companion back, is it required? Presume it is.
Will try catch up on that tonight.

Execuses and CBA (ambivalent low poster wolf?

Angus WW wrote: »

Actually where is it?

More CBA, didn't come back to say he had read or found anything in it

Angus WW wrote: »

You're firing blanks Venom

Joke about my lack of ability to attach document

Angus WW wrote: »

So not a great start to life in the town.
Losing the Satan role seems like it could be a major sting in the tail.
Hard to tell in a game full of roled players but we may also have lost an SK hunter. I wouldnt have thought the cartman character fits well with a Jester role but then the mods have warned that characters don't necessarily fit with an expected alignment.

I presume Steve getting munched was because he screamed wish granter, at least in hindsight. Or possibly it was just Jester hunting.
Given the field of play I wouldn't be surprised if not a single wolf voted for Steve. But potentially anyone who switched from an earlier Steve vote will be suspect. Which I'll check.

Nothing wolfy here, offering suggestions and solutions

Angus WW wrote: »

Ultimate wish granter.

Mechanics

Angus WW wrote: »

You will have to ask Steve and Desmond or the mods

Smartarse mechanics

Angus WW wrote: »

?

query over post I assume was an attempt to get him to talk. Still not really talking

Angus WW wrote: »

Or a sleeper wolf, wolf cub etc.

Angus WW wrote: »

Hi Conor I'd like to talk further about your theory earlier that I think you left unfinished. It, or perhaps it was more your approach to it seemed odd, even if you thought/think your protecting something. Have thought any further? Can you elaborate? Does Desmond's death change your theory?

Okay now he'e chatting

There are some wolfy posts, mainly CBA and low posting but he has started to question and post things. I'd be saying village - one to watch

Wendy WW

Brendan WW wrote: »

What made you think Regan was a Jester...... specifically

Good question. Maybe I’ll switch to Ewan!

Conor WW

Frank WW wrote: »

Oh no, you're right there. Not voting is way worse than no lynch. But I believe that when given the option of no lynch or lynching someone, the village should be opting to lynch someone

Are you not part of that village?:pac:

Liam WW

Id say its optimal to vote no lynch untill the seer comes out or is dead but aint nobody going to agree to that so its a moo point

Derry WW

Evening all. I haven’t seen anything to changed my mind in Regan so gonna stick a vote in now.

Brendan WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

Good question. Maybe I’ll switch to Ewan!

Ok, why did you think Regan was the Jester this morning?

You avoiding the question.