South Park WW ROLE MADNESS - Game Thread

Brendan WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

I don’t think he’s worth peeking. He’s a wolf.

Lot of people adamant Ewan is a wolf. From what Ive read I wouldnt call him wolfy yet. Interesteing

Regan WW

Phil WW wrote: »

This sounds like a desperate attempt by a wolf to move votes. Where did Eva come from? Derry and Lucy are possibly self resolving.

or just being honest lynch ne tomorrow whats the difference between losing a villager tonight or tomorrow cept tomorrow we will know role.

Patrick WW

Regan WW wrote: »

Could be Im actually honest. which tbh in previous games hasnt served me well but feck it why change now. ONe way to find out is to hold lynch till tomorrw btw if it helps Im aligned good so whatever role i have is beneficial to villagers. That should encourage wolves to vote or villagers to change their vote to find out role

This is pretty poor plea for people to save you:D I'm gonna read back see where the wagon started on you but your not really helping yourself, your aligned good but could be a wolf cub or anything!

Brendan WW

Regan WW wrote: »

Your posting style

Elaborate

What about my posting style suggests Im a Jester?

Explain or is this a throw away excuse

Eva WW

Patrick WW wrote: »

There's not much to go on tbh, it's a weak FFA! Like why the Lucy voters, her alignment isn't verified yet unless Derry dies or she dies so including people who voted for her is odd if that's your only basis

It's an FFA based off my posts all evening. I outlined my reasoning in post 1080. Trying to bat it away as a "Weak FFA" after I've spent hours outlining how I got there makes me think you're just not bothering to read the thread....

Phil WW wrote: »

I was the first no lynch voter not the latest. Well, Vernon was first much earlier in day but changed their vote.

The order I have is...

No lynch - Barbara / Regan / Ewan / Oisin / Conor / Phil / Liam / Lucy

Vernon WW wrote: »

Huh? My role in voting Lucy? Can you expand on that a little please?

I explained it in an earlier post. I think there's a wolf in the Lucy posters. That's....

Lucy - Wendy / Winifred / Orla / Vernon / Henry

I've decent village leans on Wendy, Wini and Henry, so worry there's a wolf in either you or Orla.

Regan WW

Brendan WW wrote: »

Elaborate

What about my posting style suggests Im a Jester?

Explain or is this a throw away excuse

jester tries to confuse and cause chaos I think that is what you are doing

Vernon WW

Doris WW wrote: »

Morning all. Didn’t cop this started yesterday so only here now. Thanks for not leaving me 30 pages to catch up on

Phil WW wrote: »

This sounds like a desperate attempt by a wolf to move votes. Where did Eva come from? Derry and Lucy are possibly self resolving.

this is the nail in teh coffin for me. I'm going to vote regan

Angus WW

FFA#1

1. Regan
Is not a newbie. The no role thing, why even say it. Posted this on consecutive days "Well after a long stroll today around Southpark I've decided we all need to get high. Seriously some of the stuff out there is unreal". Seems tasky. Tasks could be good or bad. But I'd normally suggest probability is bad. Might be a requirement to get bullets. Bullets have killed goodies so far and one definitely wasn't random

2. Fiona
As per ISO low poster, little engagement and appears to be purposely steering clear of any type of meaningful interactions with other players

3. Ewan
Not strong feeling really. Hasn't done a lot, good or bad, mostly a gut feeling,.

Eva WW

Phil WW wrote: »

This sounds like a desperate attempt by a wolf to move votes. Where did Eva come from? Derry and Lucy are possibly self resolving.

What's weird is I'm one of the few people actually on record as saying I'm inclined to trust Regan.

Orla WW

Regan WW wrote: »

Could be Im actually honest. which tbh in previous games hasnt served me well but feck it why change now. ONe way to find out is to hold lynch till tomorrw btw if it helps Im aligned good so whatever role i have is beneficial to villagers. That should encourage wolves to vote or villagers to change their vote to find out role

But you could currently believe yourself to be good but actually be a wolf cub waiting to be turned. If you are, then letting everyone know you’ve no role yet wasn’t a great play for team village. I am open to having my mind changed but there’s no point voting Derry or Liam, Lucy has to be presumed village until we get a Derry flip, and there’s no way I’m voting for Wendy. Anyone else come up with any other options with good reasoning behind it, I’ll consider switching.

Phil WW

Regan WW wrote: »

or just being honest lynch ne tomorrow whats the difference between losing a villager tonight or tomorrow cept tomorrow we will know role.

Because you are saying lynch Derry tonight but we know they’ve been poisoned so why would we lynch there?

Brendan WW

Winifred WW wrote: »

Why are you convinced he's a wolf?

You were wanting to pick him earlier? Interesting

Brendan WW

Regan WW wrote: »

jester tries to confuse and cause chaos I think that is what you are doing

Do they?

Thats bollox

Jesters try get lynched

Lucy WW

Regan WW wrote: »

I dont trust Derry's reading of Lucy. Im also suspicious of people who are all over the posts trying to help and point people in a certain direction to help the team, question is which team are they helping, I am trying to decide between Derry Lucy or Eva for my vote at the minute.

This is total BS out of the Wendy book of insanity.

I'll make it East for you. I'm voting you as you're trying to restart issues that were solved earlier. Like a wolf trying to create a fog of war.

Liam WW

Reagen posting style is all over the shop, I dont know what to make of it?

Regan WW

Phil WW wrote: »

Because you are saying lynch Derry tonight but we know they’ve been poisoned so why would we lynch there?

Im not saying lynch Derry tonight never did I say that. I did say dont lynch me so we can find out what the role is. But sure feck it your loss. I dont trust Derry though

Eva WW

Lucy WW wrote: »

This is total BS out of the Wendy book of insanity.

I'll make it East for you. I'm voting you as you're trying to restart issues that were solved earlier. Like a wolf trying to create a fog of war.

Or a jester trying to annoy people

Angus WW

Regan WW wrote: »

jester tries to confuse and cause chaos I think that is what you are doing

I think they try to be more subtle, depending on the player. Being a noticeable problem should create fear in the village about a a lynch.

Regan WW

I have expressed my doubts aout him as one of the poisons we were told is fake. so we gave Derry the peek and he said Lucy is good. I asked both Derry and Liam for reasons they should be given antidote at 1854 neither came back about it but at 1909 Derry voted for me and now so has Lucy. Wolves gathering youve been warned

Vernon WW

Lucy bothers me that they won't answer my questions, given she is village this seems odd. I wanted to know to help me understand Orla which leads me to
Orla - feels very wolf, don't understand why Lucy was trying to get her opinion. Don't understand her and why more people don't have her on FFA
Gabriel has not been on my radar
Eva scares me I need to go read back but leaning wolf
Same Isla

Lots of people voting with no reason / posting - that I have seen have not trawled through posts

Emliy - voted Angus?
Abigal on Doris

Wendy WW

Regan WW wrote: »

well either way Derry voted for me, I know a guy called Derry

Where’s he from!

Lucy WW

Vernon WW wrote: »

Lucy bothers me that they won't answer my questions, given she is village this seems odd. I wanted to know to help me understand Orla which leads me to
Orla - feels very wolf, don't understand why Lucy was trying to get her opinion. Don't understand her and why more people don't have her on FFA
Gabriel has not been on my radar
Eva scares me I need to go read back but leaning wolf
Same Isla

Lots of people voting with no reason / posting - that I have seen have not trawled through posts

Emliy - voted Angus?
Abigal on Doris

What questions? You're barely on to be counted as playing.
Ask away now, I'm here.

Regan WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

Where’s he from!

Wexford

Brendan WW

Patrick WW wrote: »

Scratch that, I get you, choose one of the two posoined players to make the peek. Good shout

I like this post

Brendan WW

So far.....uo to 1pm..... happy to say Regan Wini and Senan are my wolf picks thus far.

Patrick WW

Eva WW wrote: »

It's an FFA based off my posts all evening. I outlined my reasoning in post 1080. Trying to bat it away as a "Weak FFA" after I've spent hours outlining how I got there makes me think you're just not bothering to read the thread....



The order I have is...

No lynch - Barbara / Regan / Ewan / Oisin / Conor / Phil / Liam / Lucy



I explained it in an earlier post. I think there's a wolf in the Lucy posters. That's....

Lucy - Wendy / Winifred / Orla / Vernon / Henry

I've decent village leans on Wendy, Wini and Henry, so worry there's a wolf in either you or Orla.

Hang on its weak cause you think for whatever reason there is a wolf in lucy voters, I'm pointing Lucy could still be a wolf and you've arbitrarily picked two out. I've no issue with your initial thought process but you've not dug into those people and Wendy is one of the wolfiest people in here.

Also I'm reading the thread hence me pointing it out

Senan WW

ISO of Ewan, he only has 19 posts so wasn't hard

Makes a valid point on the wishes

Ewan WW wrote: »

All the people posting wishes, is no one concerned that there will be a cost to them? If it was that easy we'd just need to ask for a dead wolf until we win.

Votes no lynch, which I don't like

Ewan WW wrote: »

Voting no lynch. Can't read thread right now.

Questions Wendy on her hunting of Lucy, reasonably so

Ewan WW wrote: »

Can you gimme a quick recap as to why chief?

Defends his no lynch vote

Ewan WW wrote: »

While I was in the thread I couldn't see much going on. Steve maybe role hunting but felt villager tree shaking to me. After that I wasn't able to keep up with what was going on for my own reasons. Better to vote no lynch than lynch without doing the proper research with a jester in play.

Makes a fair point about Steve, I came to a similar conclusion when I ISO'd him

Ewan WW wrote: »

I had a look back over Steves posts but i See Reading back nothing that would make me think anything other than tree shaking villager.

Has a strange interaction with Wendy

Ewan WW wrote: »

Ok, there's a sort of logic there for me. I don't agree with it but I can see it. I wasn't online all day yesterday though so its faulty logic. Why no Derry as they were not online at all?

What about the rest of the list?

Explains his vote on Liam

Ewan WW wrote: »

Not active until suddenly they became the centre of attention along with Derry re: peak. Best suspicious behavior I could see so far in my skim through.

Accuses Barbara of fluff

Ewan WW wrote: »

Any front runners? Your posts have been pure fluff so far.

Guys i don't know where yer getting a wolf here, the worst thing that can be said about Ewan is that he hasn't defended himself, I'll have to check when the first accusation came in, he hasn't been here for six hours. But other than that he's not posted much but his posts have been fairly engaging, not a lot of fluff

I don't really see him as a wolf


¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Lucy WW

Regan WW wrote: »

Wexford

No one's Wexford. That's a story made up at bedtime to scare misbehaving children.

Orla WW

Liam - Why on earth are you voting no lynch?

Regan WW

Brendan WW wrote: »

So far.....uo to 1pm..... happy to say Regan Wini and Senan are my wolf picks thus far.

Well up to 1pm I hardly posted as I wa sout in Southpark doing my job offering helpful advise to the people of Southwest Southpark.