The Werewolf Nightmare Before Christmas Game Thread

Deleted User

Deleted User wrote: »

Im voting Gnr only real strong lean i have

Ted_YNWA wrote: »

Placeholder is on Spook, that whole wasting a vote on BH just doesn't sit right with me.

If he does flip green, it is a terrible fence sitting strategy.

Necro wrote: »

Seems to be a wagon forming on Spook, what you make of it

Rikand wrote: »

I'm on mick atm. Dont really know where to go. Hate not knowing the lie of the land

Uriel. wrote: »

I've been on mick for awhile..
Oh yeah.

Barney92 wrote: »

I'm going for FixXxer, not because he's on me but because of his reason.

Ted_YNWA wrote: »

This is looking like a scattergun of a vote going by the declares on thread.

Clarabel wrote: »

Green&Red, the melting man was exiled. He was a WOLF

I'm not sure there is anything in this tbh, i was going to at kalhessi a bit more but i think her vote on me came before rikand and uriel declared on me so

also thought there was more declares but unless ive missed some i guess not

LadySkunk

LadySkunk wrote: »

FFA Day1

1. Spook - The whole voting BH when he’s cleared just doesn’t sit right with me. Complete backtrack when called out on it and now changed vote, if you really believed in your logic you wouldn’t be changing it because someone as you say yourself “doesn’t get the logic”

2. Ted - FFAs Mick connecting him to Spook when he had the same line of thinking as I had which was that Spooks logic was flawed, can’t see the connection being made there and nothing was said about me when I said the same thing, feels a bit flimsy

3 . Yoss - Probably busy with RL, would never knock someone for that but first post in two days asking did we get a wolf yet, find it hard to believe he didn’t read anything at all back before posting

Keeping an eye on G&R still, weary of tunnelling due to past games but the pushy nature of his posts to just about anyone has my eyes peeled so will see on this one.

Votes going on Spook anyway unless anything else’s comes up in the time before lynch, stood out the most to me out of everyone

LadySkunk wrote: »

@Necro I didn’t react to Green&Red because there was nothing to react to, it was an obvious case of OMGUS and clutching at straws really and it’s not worth the headache of me saying no you suck back when I already have an eye on him :pac:

and a vote time of 19:30 is pretty consistent outta skunk

kitten_k wrote: »

OK vote gone in for Spook as I can't see much happening between now and lynch.

voting times consistent but a lack of reasoning of any kind of spook, i mean he certainly gave enough and i dont really understand the I cant see much changing bit like why?

it ww **** can change fast

Yoss has nothing on spook or anything much pre lynch just solely focused on Rikand

So hard to tell

he votes spook 7 minutes after his last pre munch post without a mention of spook (unless i missed it)

Ted was first to vote so dont think it means much for wagonomics for just day 1 purposes

Kitten and Yoss look bad outta this not sure which is worst though

O my biggest soul read is vale just lots of post agreeing with others and not much of an acussing nature

O ya good chance this is my last post but we have Christmas villagers and Halloween villagers in this game

There has to be some reason for this,

Like is villager powers are just being dished out in random prizes then its possible Xmas ones are real and Halloween ones are fake or something.

I can't quite work out the angle but i really dislike the lock clear narrative that has been jumped on my necro (even if he is talking sense) and bounty and others

Whatever it is there is a reason, for 2 set of NRVS .

Barney
Fixxer
Khalessi
KKitten
Ladyskunk
Spook
Ted
Uriel
Vale
Yoss

The list if we take the two peeks as level, the gnr voters as villa and rikand as not evil

10 players good chance at least 2 wolfs there maybe more so its 50/50 in my books even as a random choice

Now thats me after casting a **** load of doubt on the peeks but still it something to work with for day 2

And a list we should use for day 2

O ya if someone has an a ability to find like jack skellington or some other possible bad dude only, you might consider a peeked player.

As you wouldn't have that ability unless a bad player cant be seen by peeks

I've no idea if it exists but i wanted to point out it could be a mechanic of the game

Deleted User

Deleted User wrote: »

Barney
Fixxer
Khalessi
KKitten
Ladyskunk
Spook
Ted
Uriel
Vale
Yoss

The list if we take the two peeks as level, the gnr voters as villa and rikand as not evil

10 players good chance at least 2 wolfs there maybe more so its 50/50 in my books even as a random choice

Now thats me after casting a **** load of doubt on the peeks but still it something to work with for day 2

And a list we should use for day 2

I would say im not trying to clear the people i've left off the list just i feel there is more then likely to be 2 wolfs maybe more here. giving us the best chance of hitting another on day 2.

Given current info

Spook_ie

Deleted User wrote: »

O ya if someone has an a ability to find like jack skellington or some other possible bad dude only, you might consider a peeked player.

As you wouldn't have that ability unless a bad player cant be seen by peeks

I've no idea if it exists but i wanted to point out it could be a mechanic of the game

Jack wasn't a bad dude in the film though, he was just misguided, in the fact he wanted to be like Santa and give presents, the bad character in the film was Oogie Boogie.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_The_Nightmare_Before_Christmas_characters

However, having read the wiki about Oogie

He, meanwhile, lives in an underground lair full of torture devices, each of which features a casino-like appearance, suggesting an addiction to gambling (this is enforced by his use of dice).

can't help but wonder about the playing cards being a clue?

Ted_YNWA

Deleted User wrote:

Like is villager powers are just being dished out in random prizes then its possible Xmas ones are real and Halloween ones are fake or something.

Brain is still very sleepy here, so this thought process is fuzzier than usual.

Presents must mean something. GnR ended up with a forfeit prize due to PM discussion.

This forfeit was 4 socks. He was a wolf

Wolf = 4 feet. Was this an ultimate forfeit outing him my mods?

Ted_YNWA

*by mods.

kitten_k

[Deleted User] wrote: »

and a vote time of 19:30 is pretty consistent outta skunk




voting times consistent but a lack of reasoning of any kind of spook, i mean he certainly gave enough and i dont really understand the I cant see much changing bit like why?

it ww **** can change fast

Yoss has nothing on spook or anything much pre lynch just solely focused on Rikand

So hard to tell

he votes spook 7 minutes after his last pre munch post without a mention of spook (unless i missed it)

Ted was first to vote so dont think it means much for wagonomics for just day 1 purposes

Kitten and Yoss look bad outta this not sure which is worst though

I gave my reasons in an earlier post (the insistence on voting BH). Thread was quiet at the time I was voting so it did not look like something else was gonna happen to make me vote elsewhere

Bounty Hunter

First off, great to have gotten a wolf and although I didn't like and somewhat suspected him for trying to seem too villagery, rattling cages etc early on I'm not going to go all captain hindsight on it as I did not vote GnR, don't think he even made my FFA so fair play those who did vote for him.

The lack of late votes suggest the wolves were mistakenly confident that he or another wolf would not top the voting. This makes me think that Spook (who imo was who I was expecting a wagon to form on when reading through it this morning) is good and I kind of expect at least one Spook voter to be a wolf (but maybe not more as they might want to avoid all being on the same wagon).

I would also agree the votes make me think Drummer is good as his vote condemned GnR, but that does not clear him imo.

A big part of why I voted Fixxer was gut as it was D1 and also as I didn't want to vote the same person I was tracking and Necro who was also on my FFA had just flipped Green.

I think this is a vanilla-ish game so think that people suggesting unpeekable wolves are going a bit overboard. Almost has me thinking wolves as a wolf more so than anyone would want to discredit mod cleared players (GnR was the other one calling me & Necro too good to be true iirc)... but then again as 1 of only 2 of those I would say that tbh.

I know a lot has happened but it is still pretty vanilla-ish, maybe 1/2 roles such as a BG and everyone can ask Santa for 1 present (you can only send him one letter right?) but many of those have been duds anyway.

MrsFlushdraw

Deleted User wrote: »

I kind of get where he was coming for a bounty was like voting no lynch but its also a bit if a cop out

But like I just dont know im so paranoid

I do remember back to a past life, that when I said these things people automatically said I was a wolf. I made no secret of my opinion on FFA for day one and suggested spreading votes to stop wolves bandwagoning.

And good morning everyone

Bounty Hunter

MrsFlushdraw wrote: »

I do remember back to a past life, that when I said these things people automatically said I was a wolf. I made no secret of my opinion on FFA for day one and suggested spreading votes to stop wolves bandwagoning.

And good morning everyone

Morning Flushy,

For the reason you are saying I could easily see wolves thinking people would be jumping on Spook. Maybe why there was no scrambling around to save GnR as they didn't think he would get as many votes as Spook who was a more obvious wagon for people to hop on.

TheValeyard

khalessi wrote: »

Night Vale. Did someone give him sleeping potion?

Morning.
No sleeping potion. Just tired.

Necro

Morning all.

I'm pretty wrecked myself tbh.

I've looked at those votes and Rikand is probably right, there isn't too much massively damaging to anyone as it stands.

We need to find some way to clear or flip Spook and we'll get a better sense of what might be the case I think.

y0ssar1an22

morning y'all

Bounty Hunter

Necro wrote: »

Morning all.

I'm pretty wrecked myself tbh.

I've looked at those votes and Rikand is probably right, there isn't too much massively damaging to anyone as it stands.

We need to find some way to clear or flip Spook and we'll get a better sense of what might be the case I think.

At the moment I am suss of the people who voted for Spook. He imo was the easiest wagon to jump on. The other most voted for person ended up being a wolf. So I would think there is at least 1 wolf among those 4 Spook voters.

LadySkunk
Kitten K
Ted
Yoss

y0ssar1an22

Bounty Hunter wrote: »

At the moment I am suss of the people who voted for Spook. He imo was the easiest wagon to jump on. The other most voted for person ended up being a wolf. So I would think there is at least 1 wolf among those 4 Spook voters.

LadySkunk
Kitten K
Ted
Yoss

unless of course he is good and then the wolves wouldn't have cared where their votes were. either way, we need to know his alignment, will be very telling IMO

Baggly

Correction to votes: Barney92 voted for Fixxxer. Does not impact results. Apologies for this error.

Baggly wrote: »

Votes

Whose exile would you like to see this evening? Who are you? Timestamp Total
Green&Red Duffers 12/16/2019 19:33:04 1
Drumpot 12/16/2019 20:31:32 1
MrsFlush 12/16/2019 19:46:54 1
Mick 12/16/2019 19:58:14 1
Green&Red Total 4
Spook_ie LadySkunk 12/16/2019 19:31:40 1
Kitten K 12/16/2019 20:17:39 1
Ted 12/16/2019 19:08:20 1
Yoss 12/16/2019 20:08:40 1
Spook_ie Total 4
MicksJaguar Uriel 12/16/2019 19:33:26 1
Rikand 12/16/2019 20:03:36 1
Khalessi 12/16/2019 20:30:07 1
MicksJaguar Total 3
FixXer Bounty Hunter 12/16/2019 16:46:30 1
Barney92 12/16/2019 20:46:51 1
FixXer Total 2
y0ssar1an22 Valeyard 12/16/2019 19:34:38 1
y0ssar1an22 Total 1
MrsFlushDraw Necro 12/16/2019 20:17:59 1
MrsFlushDraw Total 1
Bounty Hunter spook 12/16/2019 17:37:06 1
Bounty Hunter Total 1
Drumpot G&R 12/16/2019 19:45:35 1
Drumpot Total 1
Uriel spook 12/16/2019 18:45:54 1
Uriel Total 1
Barney92 Fixxxer 12/16/2019 17:43:10 1
Barney92 Total 1

y0ssar1an22

never mind. forgot GNR was bad

Necro

y0ssar1an22 wrote:

never mind. forgot GNR was bad

*Stupid read of the day*

I don't think a wolf forgets this LOL

*End stupid read*

duffman13

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

if spook is good then we'll have to look at those 4 voters, including myself

Weird hedging straight after we caught a wolf, you then say you forgot GnR was bad despite being on after the lynch last night. Your posts are odd, I'm on mobile but I dont like your current history of posts!

y0ssar1an22

duffman13 wrote: »

Weird hedging straight after we caught a wolf, you then say you forgot GnR was bad despite being on after the lynch last night. Your posts are odd, I'm on mobile but I dont like your current history of posts!

hedging or not, you decide.

from me, just trying to catch a few wolves

duffman13

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

evening folks. have we got a wolf yet?

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

cant argue with that. just reading back now. busy in work, etc

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

this is why rikand has been cleared i'm guessing. could still be bad. i suppose put in the good basket for the minute

quote="y0ssar1an22;112035778"]too many people rikand the benefit of the doubt. surely there's a wolf there and can be confident in their appraisal[/quote]

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

the people who were happy to take rikand at face value

This one quotes a list of people who include spook, Necro, GnR, BH and Skunky I think who believed Rikand to be good

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

i find it interesting also

Finds the fake munch theory interesting. Feels like subtle shade again towards Rikand, weird! No real discussion on his decision to vote Spook and voted shortly after his last post at 8 before popping back on after 11. All feels a little sussy to me tbh

Why after reading 600 odd posts to catch up would he fixate on Rikand, I've a rabbit hole theory popping into my head here but I'll hold off for now. Yoss would be on the firm peek pile of we had one

duffman13

y0ssar1an22 wrote: »

hedging or not, you decide.

from me, just trying to catch a few wolves

Not really evidenced by your contribution so far tbf, it's hedging and your posts all about Rikand prelynch stand out as odd to me

Baggly

If anyone has not submitted a letter to Santa already, maybe you should do so.

kitten_k

Necro wrote: »

Morning all.

I'm pretty wrecked myself tbh.

I've looked at those votes and Rikand is probably right, there isn't too much massively damaging to anyone as it stands.

We need to find some way to clear or flip Spook and we'll get a better sense of what might be the case I think.

I reckon if any peeks are given out today they should be used on Spook

duffman13

kitten_k wrote: »

I reckon if any peeks are given out today they should be used on Spook

All of them or just one? You think spook is bad?

I'd be happy with a 3 way race between kitten, yoss and spook today