Werewolf: SAW - Gamethread

Abigail WW

Vernon WW wrote: »

But she’s have had to put in the order to protect him on D2 either at 9pm D1 or 9am D2. He hadn’t revealed himself at this stage and she still had him on her FFA

Very simple here

Monday - Protected someone
Tuesday- Protected Conor
Wednesday- Protected someone
Thursday - Protected Conor

As regards my FFA, i didn't like Conor cause he was inoffensive, I also protected him cause he got zero votes in the lynch so was a good target for an SK IMO. I also said after I protected him I still didn't like Conor, same reasoning, he was inoffensive.

Abigail WW

Lads I've no clue of Conors alignment, none! I picked him on the basis of the lynch the night before! Simple

Abigail WW

Vernon WW wrote: »

But she’s have had to put in the order to protect him on D2 either at 9pm D1 or 9am D2. He hadn’t revealed himself at this stage and she still had him on her FFA

I have till 10am each morning to select a name

Abigail WW

Vernon WW wrote: »

Where is Abbi to discuss this?

Do me a favour, I'll be here when I can be, and I'll respond to questions but I wont be here at anyones convenience other than my own. I've posted when I can which is evening times.

Vernon WW

Abigail WW wrote: »

Very simple here

Monday - Protected someone
Tuesday- Protected Conor
Wednesday- Protected someone
Thursday - Protected Conor

As regards my FFA, i didn't like Conor cause he was inoffensive, I also protected him cause he got zero votes in the lynch so was a good target for an SK IMO. I also said after I protected him I still didn't like Conor, same reasoning, he was inoffensive.

But that’s not quite what you said, you said you were leaning evil

gail WW View Post
I dont like Conor, I'm not sure if that's cause he doesn't like me or just cause his name is floating around a lot. I'm not clear on my train of thought on him at the moment tbh but leaning evil

Abigail WW

Vernon WW wrote: »

I wouldn’t criticise her for that in fairness, if it had happened then she wouldn’t want to blow her cover

I just don’t see anyway that Conor was protected from that bullet. It clearly said that the gun was empty


So now we just have Abbi’s word that she’s the BG, no proof. So why would she pick Conor?

Well she tells us he was the most likely village


Originally Posted by Abigail WW View Post
If I was an sk, you were the most likely villager at the time i picked you, I still didn't have a clear view on whether you were villager or sk but felt you'd be a good target for the SKs


But that’s at odds with her FFA at the time she would have had to be choosing

Am I missing something here?

Where is Abbi to discuss this?

Vernon, what are you? Of course I've no proof, I'll tell ya what though, it's a damn well more believable story than Emily's but yet you've an issue with what I'm saying, want the village to lynch the BG? At the end of the day, I've zero reason to come out when I did yesterday other than to nail Steve, who I felt was last sk.

Abigail WW

Vernon WW wrote: »

But that’s not quite what you said, you said you were leaning evil

gail WW View Post
I dont like Conor, I'm not sure if that's cause he doesn't like me or just cause his name is floating around a lot. I'm not clear on my train of thought on him at the moment tbh but leaning evil

Let me explain in very simple English, I dont "know" who is good or evil, I protected who I thought would most likely be targeted by wolves.

Your infatuation with me hard claiming yesterday, along with wanting to know who I specifically protected each day and timeframes is bizarre. I said as much yesterday, the person that information is most valuable to is on the opposite team to me

Conor WW

Abigail WW wrote: »

Very simple here

Monday - Protected someone
Tuesday- Protected Conor
Wednesday- Protected someone
Thursday - Protected Conor

As regards my FFA, i didn't like Conor cause he was inoffensive, I also protected him cause he got zero votes in the lynch so was a good target for an SK IMO. I also said after I protected him I still didn't like Conor, same reasoning, he was inoffensive.

Got any sellotape in that bag of yours to patch me back together after Derry blows me to bits?

Vernon WW

You're story isn't really stacking up though

You're saying that you protected Conor cause he was inoffensive and someone with no votes

Inoffensive - you said at the time you were "leaning evil" - evil enough to be on a three person FFA

Someone with no votes - well you had a host of people, six in fact - Conor, Vernon, Lucy, Doris, Wendy and Orla but you chose the one who was on your FFA - it makes no sense

beakerjoe wrote: »

[/I]Lynch votes (in no particular order)[/I]

Senan WW (4) : Derry WW, Emily WW, Abigail WW, Angus WW
Steve WW (2) : Jake WW, Senan WW
Nigel WW (2) : Vernon WW, Steve WW
Derry WW (2) : Nigel WW, Wendy WW
Emily WW (1) : Conor WW
Jake WW (1) : Orla WW
Angus WW (1) Barbara WW
Abigail WW (1) : Frank WW
Holly WW (1) : Lucy WW
Barbara WW (1) Doris WW

Vernon WW

Abigail WW wrote: »

Vernon, what are you? Of course I've no proof, I'll tell ya what though, it's a damn well more believable story than Emily's but yet you've an issue with what I'm saying, want the village to lynch the BG? At the end of the day, I've zero reason to come out when I did yesterday other than to nail Steve, who I felt was last sk.

I explained this morning about Emily. Very easy to prove

@Emily - I'm going to put my vote on you tonite. If you can actually vote tamper will you move it to Abbi

If Emily can't move the vote then shes lying and we can lynch her next time around

Conor WW

Things in favour of Abi:

She had literally zero reason to claim yesterday, in fact she didnt actually initially claim but tried to mask protection through winning a prize, which I was willing to let slide because I figured it anyways and I think she knew that

The timeline is a bit awry but I sort of buy her reasoning

Not in favour

Timeline as documented

The fact the SK didnt even try to kill her


I dunno, I think shes on the level tbh

Vernon WW

@Derry -whats your thoughts on Abbi and the argument I've put up against her?

Would you consider it stronger than the case you think there is against Conor?

Vernon WW

Conor WW wrote: »

Things in favour of Abi:

She had literally zero reason to claim yesterday, in fact she didnt actually initially claim but tried to mask protection through winning a prize, which I was willing to let slide because I figured it anyways and I think she knew that

The timeline is a bit awry but I sort of buy her reasoning

The counter argument to this is that she saw an opening to claim a protect and took it. We've seen it before that people claim stuff.

This quote is also stinky. She's lining up to kill you and is already lining up Steve afterwards because apparently if you died it would show that it was her protect that worked the other day cause Steve was evil

Abigail WW wrote: »

Die, to see him live and prove myself, if he dies I'll get lynched and when I come back good then lynch Steve to end game, either way I'm happy cause village win

Go back to her explanation yesterday when she revealed. Her words are that you were "the most likely villager at the time". So likely that she had you in her FFA. Out of 15 people left she though you were in the top three to be a wolf and shes spinning that as most likely to be a villager? Gimme a break

Abigail WW wrote: »

If I was an sk, you were the most likely villager at the time i picked you, I still didn't have a clear view on whether you were villager or sk but felt you'd be a good target for the SKs

Derry WW

Vernon WW wrote: »

@Derry -whats your thoughts on Abbi and the argument I've put up against her?

Would you consider it stronger than the case you think there is against Conor?

No idea if it's quiet and Conor hasn't found a way to ice me, then later in the car I'll do a trawl and see what I find. At the moment other than the evil lean early it's a toss up.


I would also think that the unloaded gun was a moral test but there's no proof either way.



Just as there's no proof that Nigel was the supplier of his bullets, can't ask him because he's dead, so very convenient.


BTW I was reading that post and just wondering

Originally Posted by Conor WW
Current postcounts


Derry WW 370
Conor WW 303
Vernon WW 216
Steve WW 192
BulletmanNigel WW 168
beakerjoe 127
Orla WW 127
Jake WW 115
Frank WW 92
Lucy WW 87
Wendy WW 72
Doris WW 66
Abigail WW 64
Senanrv WW 51
Emily WW 45
Barbara WW 39
Kantian WW 38
Holly WW 36
Angus WW 23
Patrinrvck WW 10
nIsrla WWv 7
Clarabel 5
Drumpot 3
Persepoly 1
khalessi 1


And so the end is near I fear for me.

My protection is up

Senanrv whats that roled villager?
Kantian WW ?????

Patrinrvck Non Roled Villager
nIsrla WWv 7 ?????

Derry WW

Vernon WW wrote: »

The counter argument to this is that she saw an opening to claim a protect and took it. We've seen it before that people claim stuff.

This quote is also stinky. She's lining up to kill you and is already lining up Steve afterwards because apparently if you died it would show that it was her protect that worked the other day cause Steve was evil





Go back to her explanation yesterday when she revealed. Her words are that you were "the most likely villager at the time". So likely that she had you in her FFA. Out of 15 people left she though you were in the top three to be a wolf and shes spinning that as most likely to be a villager? Gimme a break

Originally Posted by Abigail WW
Die, to see him live and prove myself, if he dies I'll get lynched and when I come back good then lynch Steve to end game, either way I'm happy cause village win


Does that actually work though?

Steve WW

So. Where are we.

Abigail I failed a moral test when I shot Conor therefore he got a prize. You didn't protect him.
Also you were one of the first people at the beginning to go after another player for being a wolf, why? What was it that stood out so much that you went straight in?

Doris WW

Derry WW wrote: »

No idea if it's quiet and Conor hasn't found a way to ice me, then later in the car I'll do a trawl and see what I find. At the moment other than the evil lean early it's a toss up.


I would also think that the unloaded gun was a moral test but there's no proof either way.



Just as there's no proof that Nigel was the supplier of his bullets, can't ask him because he's dead, so very convenient.


BTW I was reading that post and just wondering





Senanrv whats that roled villager?
Kantian WW ?????

Patrinrvck Non Roled Villager
nIsrla WWv 7 ?????

Can't help with Katie, but think NRV for Isla

Vernon WW

I think we all believe that when Steve shot Conor it didn't work because the gun wasn't loaded


Yet Abbi wants us to let Conor die so it can prove that he was protected when Steve shot him cause Steve was evil


Its a nice little plan to get rid of Conor and then get people to turn their attention to Steve who is already under huge scrutiny

Vernon WW

Derry WW wrote: »

Originally Posted by Abigail WW
Die, to see him live and prove myself, if he dies I'll get lynched and when I come back good then lynch Steve to end game, either way I'm happy cause village win


Does that actually work though?

She my post above, its nonsense IMO

Derry WW

Derry WW wrote: »

Originally Posted by Abigail WW
Die, to see him live and prove myself, if he dies I'll get lynched and when I come back good then lynch Steve to end game, either way I'm happy cause village win

Does that actually work though?

It would prove BG claim if he lived without intervention from Jiggy


Then Lynch would supposedly show Abigail as good, which should suggest that she at least thought she'd protected him


Does it prove Steve as bad?

Vernon WW

@Steve

How'd the interview go?

Quick recap for you

Jigsaw has trapped Conor and left it up to Derry whether he will die or not @6pm

Derry has left it open to us to vote, its a tied vote currently and you have the casting vote



Before you do anything I'd like you to read this post

Steve WW

Abigail WW wrote: »

Do me a favour, I'll be here when I can be, and I'll respond to questions but I wont be here at anyones convenience other than my own. I've posted when I can which is evening times.

Very snippy here

Vernon WW

Derry WW wrote: »

It would prove BG claim if he lived without intervention from Jiggy


Then Lynch would supposedly show Abigail as good, which should suggest that she at least thought she'd protected him


Does it prove Steve as bad?

Absolutely it would BUT it would prove you to be evil as according to Abbi her protect only works again evil. Thats her reason for say Steve must be evil.
Conor was protected by her both times, he lived the first one

Vernon WW

Also competition of some form at 5pm

Derry WW

Derry WW wrote: »

It would prove BG claim if he lived without intervention from Jiggy


Then Lynch would supposedly show Abigail as good, which should suggest that she at least thought she'd protected him


Does it prove Steve as bad?

The lynch pin ( no pun ) is does it prove Steve bad if Abigail dies good, I don't think it actually does but I also don't see what Abigail could gain other than proof of BG power

Derry WW

Vernon WW wrote: »

Absolutely it would BUT it would prove you to be evil as according to Abbi her protect only works again evil. Thats her reason for say Steve must be evil.
Conor was protected by her both times, he lived the first one

Yeah but I am good despite all people's negative vibes, so in that scenario Conor dies, lynch Abigail (she shows good) does that prove Steve as bad?


I don't see how it does, especially if the unloaded gun was the morality test. Though it still brings in Steve and his wanting to shoot Conor!

Much the same as I want to lynch him because I just don't feel right, something niggly, gut feeling about him.

Steve WW

Vernon WW wrote: »

@Steve

How'd the interview go?

Quick recap for you

Jigsaw has trapped Conor and left it up to Derry whether he will die or not @6pm

Derry has left it open to us to vote, its a tied vote currently and you have the casting vote



Before you do anything I'd like you to read this post

Interview went well I think, thank you. No big table with four faces staring at me which was great and I said as much at the end


Ok I had a read. I need to think. Also need to read Jigsaw's set up for Conor.

beakerjoe

THE COUNTDOWN CONTINUES.....be alert at 5 players

Steve WW

Derry WW wrote: »

Yeah but I am good despite all people's negative vibes, so in that scenario Conor dies, lynch Abigail (she shows good) does that prove Steve as bad?


I don't see how it does, especially if the unloaded gun was the morality test. Though it still brings in Steve and his wanting to shoot Conor!

Much the same as I want to lynch him because I just don't feel right, something niggly, gut feeling about him.

I can see how you would wonder about me here and throughout the game. I have flip flopped with my choices. That's party because as time goes on I'm getting different vibes and new information, and partly because I haven't a notion so am a bit scatter gunned.

I will continue to protest my innocence. My eyes have now moved to Abigail. In fact they landed briefly on her when she first appeared.

Vernon WW

Derry WW wrote: »

The lynch pin ( no pun ) is does it prove Steve bad if Abigail dies good, I don't think it actually does but I also don't see what Abigail could gain other than proof of BG power

I think she saw an opportunity to claim a protect and took it

Her subsequent reasons for protecting Conor are bogus IMO and she was lining up to take out Steve after Conor