Daft.ie and MyHome.ie listing wrong address

Bigmac1euro

Both websites inaccurately list multiple properties in the total wrong location. Sifting through ****e constantly.
It’s frustrating beyond belief.
Anyone find this ? I’m looking in a certain area for a certain price range and what I get is. 90 properties with 15 of those being in the actual area I specified on the filter. It’s clear as day the addresses stated in most ads are miles away from the area they specify.

In some cases more than 3 km away from an area. How in this day and age can daft not run a cross check with google maps. Or better yet why don’t ads have an approval process before being published. Rant over

Baby01032012

It’s the agent or seller who is listing the property not the portal. They don’t check addresses. They have algorithms to check that no illegal information such as discriminatory information.

Bigmac1euro

Baby01032012 wrote: »

It’s the agent or seller who is listing the property not the portal. They don’t check addresses. They have algorithms to check that no illegal information such as discriminatory information.

That’s desperate, I still put the blame on daft/MyHome as they are the ones advertising the property. They should be verifying the information is correct. It’s terrible from an end user perspective. It can’t be that hard to have google maps integrated and checking locations are matching positively when publishing an ad.

Caranica

There's also an issue of postal addresses not reflecting actual location. Blackrock now covers a sizeable amount of South County Dublin and villages near my home town have a postal address of the nearest large town which is 20 miles away.

Baby01032012

I totally agree. But they particularly daft have an monopoly on the property market. They’re not going to do something they don’t have to. They are cleaning up in their advert charges.

Gumbo

Google maps are not always correct either so I wouldn’t be trusting that at all.
it’s all based on what the seller puts in.

L1011

I have some Daft alerts for various areas/price brackets I was looking at moving to (and now aren't, so I should remove them) and today I got a wonderfully mangled address of "Castaheany, Mount Merrion"

Neither area is in my saved search extent and neither could be confused for each other so I have no idea how that happened.

I suspect some of the listing tools could be improved to make it harder to put in inaccurate addresses; for real or spurious reasons.

awec

L1011 wrote: »

I have some Daft alerts for various areas/price brackets I was looking at moving to (and now aren't, so I should remove them) and today I got a wonderfully mangled address of "Castaheany, Mount Merrion"

Neither area is in my saved search extent and neither could be confused for each other so I have no idea how that happened.

I suspect some of the listing tools could be improved to make it harder to put in inaccurate addresses; for real or spurious reasons.

"Castaheany, Mount Merrion" is a lovely spot, but personally I prefer "Swords, Stillorgan"

Bigmac1euro

kceire wrote: »

Google maps are not always correct either so I wouldn’t be trusting that at all.
it’s all based on what the seller puts in.

The data on google maps is 100 times better than some of the ads I’ve seen on daft.

Now I’m heading to Coolock in Wicklow for some cans using me google map sat nav

Hercule

Both sites need significant improvements to their user experience - Myhome has a much more powerful set of filters, but it could still be better.

I'd love the option to hide/dismiss properties that aren't of interest to me - I keep getting the same premium property / regular properties at the top of results that is totally irrelevant to my search

There's also a few estate agents who play fast and loose with addresses - Straffan in Kildare is a popular address, so this tiny village ends up covering a massive area of nearby towns - there's houses that are ~10km away from it being marked as "Straffan"

Mrs OBumble

How do you define the "correct" area for an address though?

I'm not familiar with "Swords, Stillorgan" - but suspect that it's similar to "Fort Lorenzo, Knocknacarra". Even B&Q describe their store as being in Knocknacarra intsead of Rahoon or Westside.

Bigmac1euro

Mrs OBumble wrote: »

How do you define the "correct" area for an address though?

I'm not familiar with "Swords, Stillorgan" - but suspect that it's similar to "Fort Lorenzo, Knocknacarra". Even B&Q describe their store as being in Knocknacarra intsead of Rahoon or Westside.

Swords Stillorgan was a joke they are on opposite sides of the city.
As was Coolock in Wicklow.

It’s very easy to see a locality from google maps. It has the general area in big letters when you zoom out slightly.
According to daft 90% of finglas is actually in glasnevin
The amount of properties addressed Glasnevin and are actually finglas is ridiculous.

Same with looking at properties in Raheny
Turns out most are actually Edenmore.

Same goes for blanchardstown every house is in clonsilla apparently yet here’s the different districts below.

Huntstown
Hartstown
Clonsilla
Ongar
Rusheeney village
Tyrrelstown
Mulhuddart
Corduff
Coolmine
Fortlawn

So when you want to see houses in clonsilla only, you get everything because the estate agents are messing with the ads and want everyone to think they are beside clonsilla because of the train station . When In fact they are nowhere near a train station and they are looking for hits on their ads at the users expense. It’s nearly worth avoiding EA’s who do this because they are clearly lying from the get go but the problem is most do it. It should be illegal imo. False advertising comes to mind.

Weepsie

Hartstown would be considered part of Clonsilla though and Hunstown part of Mulhuddart (and a bit of it part of Clonsilla). I've always considered Clonsilla and Mulhuddart to be wider areas with these various places in them.

Now, Roselawn can rightly eff off thinking it's in Castleknock though as it is now listed (residents got it changed) as it's very much in Coolmine/Blanchardstown.

Caranica

Weepsie wrote: »

Hartstown would be considered part of Clonsilla though and Hunstown part of Mulhuddart (and a bit of it part of Clonsilla). I've always considered Clonsilla and Mulhuddart to be wider areas with these various places in them.

Now, Roselawn can rightly eff off thinking it's in Castleknock though as it is now listed (residents got it changed) as it's very much in Coolmine/Blanchardstown.

Again it's the point I made about postal addresses. Roselawn is most definitely in castleknock according to An Post.

Mrs OBumble

Bigmac1euro wrote: »

It’s very easy to see a locality from google maps. It has the general area in big letters when you zoom out slightly.

But who says Google is right?

According to Google, neither Westside (1) nor Taylors Hill (2) exists. But they'd be better known than some of the other locality names that are given, eg Fort Lorenzo is an estate, not a locality.

I'm sure Dublin has similar things on Google Maps.

Bigmac1euro

Weepsie wrote: »

Hartstown would be considered part of Clonsilla though and Hunstown part of Mulhuddart (and a bit of it part of Clonsilla). I've always considered Clonsilla and Mulhuddart to be wider areas with these various places in them.

Now, Roselawn can rightly eff off thinking it's in Castleknock though as it is now listed (residents got it changed) as it's very much in Coolmine/Blanchardstown.

Clearly Hartstown is separated from clonsilla by the Ongar Distributor road.
To think otherwise is dreaming imo.
Because Blanchardstown has become such a densely populated area in recent times with so many housing estates you need to be clear on where you actually live especially if selling a house to someone who’s making arguably the most important decision in their lives.
Anyone on the Northside of the ongar road claiming clonsilla is clearly wrong, it’s like being over the border and claiming your still in the republic.
People need to get realistic.
Look at numerous maps.
Roselawn is 100% Coolmine at least we can agree on that 😂

Bigmac1euro

I do agree some locations are a bit tricky but what estate agents are doing is ridiculous.

L1011

Mrs OBumble wrote: »

I'm sure Dublin has similar things on Google Maps.

Google has made people use old Dublin electoral ward names as actual area names, e.g. "North Dock" or "Inns Quay" - both confusing as there's an office block called North Dock and an actual quay called Inns Quay.

awec

Bigmac1euro wrote: »

I do agree some locations are a bit tricky but what estate agents are doing is ridiculous.

Yes, there are definitely some ambiguous places especially along the border of different areas.

But what we're talking about is when it's blatantly wrong. According to EAs, half of south Dublin is Rathfarnham for example.