The Walking Dead 2: Game Thread

Barbara WW

Brendan WW wrote: »

Give a toss? Get off your hogh horse, I have a life outside of Werewolf

Very aggressive/strange posting from someone who has just come on and their sole contribution is to say bravo village

Gertrude WW

Angus WW wrote: »

Please correct me if im wrong but if there ARE walkers in the original 6 and they keep getting rotated, wont that mean that munches / conversions wont happen within those 6? As in, the walkers will be in the village and can convert whomever.

Like conversions are (imo) likely to start tonight/tomorrow, so that there was none yesterday wouldnt mean we should keep the same 6 on the basis of no walker being there.

It's hard to know with the walkers, we have no way of knowing if a walker was in the original group. And if there was no walker in the original group there will defo be one after the first conversion, leaving the walkers to convert whoever they want to.

WerewolfGM

The scavengers took a little while to rest themselves then headed to their next location.

Again en route the roads were quiet and they arrived without any issues.

The tavern doors were shut, and one scavenger attempted to open the doors - which were unlocked.




On entering the tavern they saw various posters adorning the wall. Some printouts from MSPaint, pictures of sheep, spreadsheets for various tournaments, a Codenames game on a table, some sort of sign-up list to run games of werewolf and even a small nook marked 'D&D'.

The scavengers gathered the liquor they could find but there was nothing else of note.

As they were leaving however, they heard a slight ping as Riona WW made to go through the back door into the kitchen.

The door swung open and an axe shot out and cleaved half of their head off.

The last image Riona ever saw was the writing on the axe as it swung towards them - 'Simon was ere'

Riona WW collapsed to the ground, dead.

She was




Michonne - Walker Hunter

Angus WW

I havent explained that well at all babs.

Basically im saying i dont think its a 72% chance there isnt a walker in that group.

And that if there is, any data we would get from the walker being in that group goes out the window if they get a job tonight.

Its been a long day. I could be crazy. Please point out if i am.

Barbara WW

Angus WW wrote: »

Please correct me if im wrong but if there ARE walkers in the original 6 and they keep getting rotated, wont that mean that munches / conversions wont happen within those 6? As in, the walkers will be in the village and can convert whomever.

Like conversions are (imo) likely to start tonight/tomorrow, so that there was none yesterday wouldnt mean we should keep the same 6 on the basis of no walker being there.

Yes, thats why I'm saying its statistically 72% there isn't a walker there based on there being one walker to start off with

However, IF there was a walker in that 6 and the wolves do as I predict then they have a 1 in 5 shot of hitting them tomorrow morning and in theory they should keep shooting there in the absence of any better information.

Like I said earlier, these are just theories based on limited info

Angus WW

Well ****. RIP Riona.

Winifred WW

Balls to that. Not a good trip. I don’t really know the series. Is Simon a character in it?

Gertrude WW

Ok what just happened? Was not expecting that.

Have the other scavengers escaped?

Angus WW

Winifred WW wrote: »

Balls to that. Not a good trip. I don’t really know the series. Is Simon a character in it?

Yeah Negan's right hand man.

Henry WW

Wasn't Riona the one to actually nominate the Tavern?

Gertrude WW

Interesting though that there was also nothing of note in this location - so that is two trips with no rewards, just a lost villager (I'm assuming Michonne is good?)

Nigel WW

Gathered the liqor
"Simon was here" axe killed Riona/Michonne (Walker hunter)

Okay that sucks.

See no reason to return to the barracks yet myself

Simon was Negan's guy played by the dude from GTA V iirc

Gertrude WW

Riona WW wrote: »

Right to the Forum games tavern please

Henry WW wrote: »

Wasn't Riona the one to actually nominate the Tavern?

You're right, must be why she died over the others?

Derry WW

Angus WW wrote: »

Please correct me if im wrong but if there ARE walkers in the original 6 and they keep getting rotated, wont that mean that munches / conversions wont happen within those 6? As in, the walkers will be in the village and can convert whomever.

Like conversions are (imo) likely to start tonight/tomorrow, so that there was none yesterday wouldnt mean we should keep the same 6 on the basis of no walker being there.

This is true, but right now is statistically the least likely there is a walker in the group.

Just a general question here. Can we in theory keep rotating the same players ? like it says you cant have security guards on consecutive nights but can you keep rotating them between security and Scavenge ?

The risk is of course you are letting a Zombie into the village (which will always be a risk). But if we in essence keep killing off (wolves and village) the first 7 players (between today and tomorrow) from the security/scavange, we guarantee a walker at least. The benefit is of course killing at least one walker and protecting Rick. Downside is that we dont learn much else and by not taking risks we probably leave wolves safe as houses so its a bad plan on that logic (just statistically killing off a load of villagers to maybe get one walker and protect Rick).

Gertrude WW

Nigel WW wrote: »

Gathered the liqor
"Simon was here" axe killed Riona/Michonne (Walker hunter)

Okay that sucks.

See no reason to return to the barracks yet myself

Simon was Negan's guy played by the dude from GTA V iirc

Agree, we have no keys or anything. The question is do we risk going to the garden centre or not? Could be another trick or would the mods be so cruel to have two location out of three as death traps?

Nigel WW

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Agree, we have no keys or anything. The question is do we risk going to the garden centre or not? Could be another trick or would the mods be so cruel to have two location out of three as death traps?

I would not think they would but that may not have been the mods, Simon is Negan's man afterall so maybe it was his power to be able to booby trap a location.

Derry WW

So there is booby traps on the scavenger hunt . .

Hmm , so do we think that if one of the 3 is a wolf they can turn it against the others ? Or do we think its just flavor using Simons name ? Or is one of the scavenger games potentially a "simon" game until he dies ?

Also, does this mean we can use this like the last game whereby we try and get suspected people (on the 3 scavenger list) to choose one of these potential booby traps ? So if you refuse to make a choice, we lynch you ? (Baddies wont want to take the risk of being killed like Riona).

Patrick WW

I think you have to go to all the locations rather than return empty handed, maybe another will die but nothing ventured and all that

Patrick WW

Derry WW wrote: »

So there is booby traps on the scavenger hunt . .

Hmm , so do we think that if one of the 3 is a wolf they can turn it against the others ? Or do we think its just flavor using Simons name ? Or is one of the scavenger games potentially a "simon" game until he dies ?

Also, does this mean we can use this like the last game whereby we try and get suspected people (on the 3 scavenger list) to choose one of these potential booby traps ? So if you refuse to make a choice, we lynch you ? (Baddies wont want to take the risk of being killed like Riona).

Possibly but there's no guarantee that who suggests the location will be killed and instead get a reward, so why wouldn't a wolf if there is one not do it, half a chance rather than a lynch

Patrick WW

13 minutes to name the 3rd location if either of the 2 remaining scavengers are here

Phil WW

Barbara WW wrote: »

Its quiet a complex problem so I don't think there is a right or wrong answer.

I would agree with the above though, that by limiting the people sent out you are more likely to force the walker (or walkers) to pick from that group (As its more likely the walker is not in that group 72%). By doing that we are also likely to be forcing the wolves to hunt in that group because they want the walkers dead even more than we do.

In a normal game wolves like to keep the SK alive to keep the kill rate high but in this wolves will need to be catching those b@stards immediately

So statistically I think we are better to keep the group together, lynch outside it and just add people to it as they are munched.

IMO this theory stands whether there are 1 or 2 or 3 walkers to begin with, the odds are still that they are not in that original group. Obviously the odds change as new people are added

I'm sure that you mean well but as soon as a walker is not selected then a walker is converted and so the group will have a walker..

Winifred WW

Have to go to the flower shop. No way we’ve been given 3 locations, 3 visits and we only get dead goodies out of it. If there is nothing there then I might have a theory brewing but I’ll hold off on putting it out for the minute

Nigel WW

Winifred WW wrote: »

Have to go to the flower shop. No way we’ve been given 3 locations, 3 visits and we only get dead goodies out of it. If there is nothing there then I might have a theory brewing but I’ll hold off on putting it out for the minute

need a scavenger to make the call and their time is running out

Winifred WW

Nigel WW wrote: »

need a scavenger to make the call and their time is running out

Did someone not say to you that they’d be online?

Nigel WW

Winifred WW wrote: »

Did someone not say to you that they’d be online?

Abigail

Patrick WW

Night Zero Security Gabriel WW ( Killed NRV ) Winifred WW Emily WW
DAY ONE Scavengers Henry WW Abigail WW Riona WW Killed Booby Trap 27/1 17.00

Sixtoes

Go to GARDEN CENTRE

Barbara WW

Phil WW wrote: »

I'm sure that you mean well but as soon as a walker is not selected then a walker is converted and so the group will have a walker..

Nice and patronizing but let me return the favour,

thats the whole point, if there isnt a walker in that group then there will be after the first conversion, we'll know for definite, so either way theres going to be a walker in that group after the first conversion, by keeping them together we're giving the wolves targets, at least up until Wednesday night.
I know its a difficult game Philly but you're doing great, keep it up sport

Nigel WW

Sixtoes wrote: »

Go to GARDEN CENTRE

put your clothes back on Abi (I guess)

Barbara WW

Sixtoes wrote: »

Go to GARDEN CENTRE

We can see all of your sixoes, please put on some socks