Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
The Witcher Werewolf - GAMETHREAD
Options
Comments
-
-
-
-
-
-
Advertisement
-
-
If people don't want to read what I have to say there isnt very much I can do about it..
I don't see why you're all defensive about people not reading your posts. I even said you made some good points earlier.
I have questions though that you didn't answer
A) why did you think Conor's switch from Abigail to Barbara was weird?
what makes it weirder than your switch from Eva to Lucy?
I think Barbara was on Conor's top 3 list that he posted earlier.0 -
-
-
-
Advertisement
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
So, cross referencing the vote sequence yesterday with the ffa's that were posted - unfortunately only a handful ffa'd.
Conor at 6.41 had an ffa of Abigail, Barbara and Vernon. At 8.40 he votes abi, which is consistent with his ffa. at 8.54 he switches to Barbara. Its a late switch to one of the wagons that later ran out of steam. It also remains consistent with his ffa. Overall I think its a solid look
Jake at 8.00 had an ffa of Conor, Phil Eva. At 7.54 he'd already voted Conor and stayed there. Its consistent, not really too much more I can see on it
Barbara at 20.08 had a two person ffa of Gabriel and Lucy, however they were adamant this was really a one hose race for them with Gabriel where they'd vote. Lucy is a distant second. At 12.43 they had voted Gabriel. At 8.59 they switched to Lucy, as the last voter there. Its self pres, which Barbara acknowledges, and that makes interpretation harder, but its a bad look nonetheless. Babs will be one of my FFa later unless something changes
For completeness I also FFA'd and voted with my FFA shortly after giving it
You dead Nigel
0 -
Meh days sort of disappeared into bad wifi and work
Based on so far #ffa1
Barbara:
Based on giving themselves lots of wriggle room earlier, feels like a baddie trying to hedge their bets
Gabriel:
Granted this was what led me to suspect Babs but his over enthusiastic defence this morning does stand out
Don't have a third yet tbh, a few posters have made points that I need to look back on and see how they look if I step back a bit but nothing else at the moment.
Not much from Nigel. Here's his FFA. Voted where he said he would.0 -
-
-
Advertisement
-
-
-
I don't see why you're all defensive about people not reading your posts. I even said you made some good points earlier.
I have questions though that you didn't answer
A) why did you think Conor's switch from Abigail to Barbara was weird? what makes it weirder than your switch from Eva to Lucy?
I think Barbara was on Conor's top 3 list that he posted earlier.
That's the same question.
And I'm not defensive, but if you want to make some silly claim that I'm not contributing maybe take a look at the post count first.
With Conors vote I find their overall approach weird.
The constant stating yesterday of their FFA being in alphabetical order, I dont get why that matters at all. Just post your FFA in whatever order, there isnt supposed to be weighting applied to it anyways.
All the ISOs and very very little real time interactions, it's how I've played as a wolf before and is raising my radar a lot today.
Conor won't even quote me when they're responding to me which is also irking me, it means I might miss a response. That's more an annoyance than anything inherently wolfy though tbh.0 -
-
-
-
@Ewan. So the first mention of task on thread was Orla mentioning a possible task for the first kill. Which would imply the two bad teams had tasks to complete to win the killIf no announcement tonight at lynch, might imply a task for the first kill maybe, doubtful but possible
Also possible Striga is in our no poster column at the moment and failed to make a selection
Now Eva mentions the potential task to win first kill. Asks a question in relation to the reason Frank was targetted as possibly he was one of those doing a task and the wolf team saw this and took him outWhat’s your gut telling you?
Yesterday was a fluff day. Somebody mentioned potential task to win first kill, maybe there is something in that. Did wolves target frank cause they thought he was on other wolf team and doing a task ? ( I’m not so sure, would of thought both bad teams would prioritize finding RVs).
Now Ewan you question Eva about the use of the word taskI've stuck a vote on Eva primarily for this post:
(Evas quote above)
This mention of task and Frank? How would you know about tasks given there is no mention in the OP of tasks?
(There's no mention of people not having tasks either but I find this a bit strange, seems like TMI)
Eva posts this and you say it firms up your suspicions of her, why was that? Then again you question her use of the word tasks and ask why she is so sure when clearly she said in her original post she wasn't so sureIm still only catching up. Its hard to not stay in the now as Phil is like watching Trump press conferences, you just cant help watching to see what's going to happen next!
I don't know, Ive seen posters in the past being very erratic and been good and bad so I am not sure what to make of it. Think Phil has surely taken TWTBAW a bit far, so sort of feel like maybe hes just a villager (or RV) having fun or a newb ? If hes a wolf its certainly an interesting style, I will give him that...
Ah, Eva - how nice of you to show up
While you're here you might respond to this post, which now firms up my suspicions of you unfortunately.
(Ewan quote above)
My question is this, why are you so sure that the wolves thought Frank was doing a task when tasks are not explicitly outlined in the OP?
Eva questions her post firming your suspicions and then goes on to explain she wasn't sure in original post and quotes Orla as being the first one to mention a task for the first kill(Ewans post above)
I don't get what you mean "firms up your suspicions, can you elaborate ?
Asides from that how did you get that "I am sure Frank is doing a task" from
(Evas original post talking about tasks)
If you do a simple search for "task" on the main menu, you will see I wasn't the only one thinking that there might be tasks and Orla actually brought it up before me:
Again you bring up her having inside information on tasks(Evas original post)
Post in question, nobody responded to me initially but now we are pretty much sure that Phil was tasking, this post by Eva seems even more like a TMI post.
Wolf tasks? I don't see that in the OP.
I don't get this, Eva said in her original post that maybe the wolves thought Frank was doing a task as they themselves were doing a task but you question why an NRV would do this and if Eva knows his role. You then go on to say her talking about rival tasking even though Orla was the first one to mention it and Eva even said somebody else had mentioned it in her post.(Evas reply above)
Nah you never said Frank is doing a task because why would an NRV do a task? You have his role
You were on about a rival group tasking - that's info not in the OP. I dunno how you'd jump to that immediately so has me very suspicious of you
This is the same answer that Eva has already given you but you seem to be ignoring what she is saying(Ewan post above)
There was only one kill this morning, I wasn't the only person who thought maybe the two wolves teams had to do a task to win this morning.
People were trying to work out if Wolves were Roll hunting with Frank (why did they target Frank?). I was wondering if maybe one wolf team thought Frank was on another team.
At 20:37 you post this at which point both Barbara and Phil both have three votes. Bringing Lucy into the equationDamn. Now this Eva I like but I can't shake my suspicion on that one post.
If I was voting elsewhere it would likely be Lucy for that outburst earlier and disappearance afterwards.
At 20:48 Angus comes on with this post bringing up voting for someone with two posts, someone who you just mentioned in your post before thisJust back on, I'll be voting obviously
I dont see Barbara as being an obvious wolf, her refusing to self-pres while daft is a good look
Phil - like I said earlier, head the ball, claiming BG & seer
So I'll likely vote one of the people on 2 votes
To which Conor repliesYou mean cast a last minute vote on a two person voter to bring them to 3 and therefore lynched as last player voted for?
Tempted to vote angus just for that!
You agree with Angus' plan put forth here and say you'd prefer Lucy gone over the other twoI kind of agree though, I'd sooner see Lucy swing than Phil or Babs being honest.
At 20:54 Conor changes his vote from Abigail to Barbara putting Barbara in the lead with four votes which throws a spanner in the works
At 20:57 you change your vote to Lucy because nobody joined you on Eva. At this point I'd like to add that you had said you wouldn't change your suspicions based off of one post by Eva but felt it okay to change your vote in the last three minutes before lynchNo point staying on Eva if no one is joining me so going my second best read so far
Angus then votes for Lucy at 20:58 and Barbara with last vote on Lucy at 20:59 and Barbara is saved.
Then moving onto this morning you again put Eva on your FFA for the same reasoning yesterday which at this point and along with the rest of your FFA comes across as flimsy reasoning at best. It's clear to everyone what Eva was at with that post and it was explained multiple times so why still carry the torch? Calling Vernon lazy for reasoning, Jake for possible connection to Eva with a tasky post and Conor for rhyming.
I originally had Barbara, Angus and Vernon on my possible wolf list because of the switches last night but when Vernon posted a suggestion to lynch Barbara tonight I thought surely a poisoned wolf doesn't throw another one under the bus but while I was looking through all of their posts I came across a few of yours that didn't sit right with me which is pretty much all of the above. I don't get it0 -
-
-
Advertisement
-
Gertrude WW wrote: »@Ewan. So the first mention of task on thread was Orla mentioning a possible task for the first kill. Which would imply the two bad teams had tasks to complete to win the kill
Now Eva mentions the potential task to win first kill. Asks a question in relation to the reason Frank was targetted as possibly he was one of those doing a task and the wolf team saw this and took him out
Now Ewan you question Eva about the use of the word task
Eva posts this and you say it firms up your suspicions of her, why was that? Then again you question her use of the word tasks and ask why she is so sure when clearly she said in her original post she wasn't so sure
Eva questions her post firming your suspicions and then goes on to explain she wasn't sure in original post and quotes Orla as being the first one to mention a task for the first kill
Again you bring up her having inside information on tasks
I don't get this, Eva said in her original post that maybe the wolves thought Frank was doing a task as they themselves were doing a task but you question why an NRV would do this and if Eva knows his role. You then go on to say her talking about rival tasking even though Orla was the first one to mention it and Eva even said somebody else had mentioned it in her post.
This is the same answer that Eva has already given you but you seem to be ignoring what she is saying
At 20:37 you post this at which point both Barbara and Phil both have three votes. Bringing Lucy into the equation
At 20:48 Angus comes on with this post bringing up voting for someone with two posts, someone who you just mentioned in your post before this
To which Conor replies
You agree with Angus' plan put forth here and say you'd prefer Lucy gone over the other two
At 20:54 Conor changes his vote from Abigail to Barbara putting Barbara in the lead with four votes which throws a spanner in the works
At 20:57 you change your vote to Lucy because nobody joined you on Eva. At this point I'd like to add that you had said you wouldn't change your suspicions based off of one post by Eva but felt it okay to change your vote in the last three minutes before lynch
Angus then votes for Lucy at 20:58 and Barbara with last vote on Lucy at 20:59 and Barbara is saved.
Then moving onto this morning you again put Eva on your FFA for the same reasoning yesterday which at this point and along with the rest of your FFA comes across as flimsy reasoning at best. It's clear to everyone what Eva was at with that post and it was explained multiple times so why still carry the torch? Calling Vernon lazy for reasoning, Jake for possible connection to Eva with a tasky post and Conor for rhyming.
I originally had Barbara, Angus and Vernon on my possible wolf list because of the switches last night but when Vernon posted a suggestion to lynch Barbara tonight I thought surely a poisoned wolf doesn't throw another one under the bus but while I was looking through all of their posts I came across a few of yours that didn't sit right with me which is pretty much all of the above. I don't get it
0
![[Deleted User]](/applications/dashboard/design/images/defaulticon.png)
Advertisement