The Witcher Werewolf - GAMETHREAD

Ewan WW

Barbara WW wrote: »

Noticed this started off the wagonomics, and whilst he is right Ewan breezes past a few issues with this. I'm a strange choice to try and pocket Ewan.

More like signing my death warrant being linked to you again

That's what the votes told me, take in further context and it changes granted but a pure look at data says to me you're more likely to be village than not....

Angus WW

Can someone put up a new table of votes, thanks

Ewan WW

Shamelessly stolen from Gertie:


Lynch Results Day 1

Player | Votes
Lucy WW | Gertrude, Holly, Ewan, Angus, Barbara
Barbara WW | Patrick, Gabriel, Nigel, Conor
Phil WW | Abigail, Phil, Emily
Conor WW | Lucy, Jake
Gabriel WW | Vernon
Jake WW | Derry
Liam WW | Eva
Angus WW | Orla
Holly WW | Liam



Lynch Results Day 2

Player | Vote
Jake WW | Derry, Gabriel, Patrick, Barbara, Orla, Ewan, Angus
Barbara WW | Vernon, Gertrude, Conor, Jake
Angus WW | Emily, Eva
Holly WW | Liam
Gabriel WW | Holly
Eva WW | Phil

Vernon WW

Emily WW wrote: »

So what was your post "derry :mad:" in relation to if not the fact that Derry instigated the lynching of your wolf teammate Jake?

i thought we had just lynched the healer and i would be dead today

Phil WW

Vernon WW wrote: »

i thought we had just lynched the healer and i would be dead today

Why did you think Jake was the healer?

Phil WW

I wonder whether I'll be 1, 2 or 3 in Emily's FFA today.

Ewan WW

Why you voting me Phil?

Vernon WW

Phil WW wrote: »

I really doubt it.

I think just Ciri will be pm'd and will make the decision.

thats why i picked phil.

i thought the mistake was on purpose, and letting me know about the decision to peek him.

ewan was just a random choice

Vernon WW

Phil WW wrote: »

Why did you think Jake was the healer?

got mixed up between triss and fringilla

Gertrude WW

Okay so I'm trying to be more well rounded so I've started doing reads of all remaining players starting from the bottom up

Holly

- Asks questions about voting on lynch thread
- Only people that stuck out to her are Phil and Lucy, votes Lucy
- Has an FFA in mind but doesn’t want to post without proper reasoning, will post later
- Says she will post FFA after omellette
- Voted Lucy for aggressive switch, gave Phil benefit of the doubt
- ISOs Liam, Jake and Derry
- Thinks Liam is playing like someone clued in but also acting like noob
- Says Jake wasn’t up to much when he flipped out, could be frustrated villager or agro wolf
- Questions Derry BG protect
- Can’t understand hard on for Jake
- Notes interaction between Barbara and Phil as cosy
- Thinks Nigel was trying to pocket Barbara and distance himself from Gabriel
- Thinks Gabriel is Nigels team mate
- FFAs Gabriel, Liam and Phil. Votes Gabriel
- Questions Gabriel over interest in monster team and if role hunting Derry
- Says she’s mentioned Nilfgards and Striga
- Admits theory on Gabriel is unbalanced but supported her theory of Nigel/Gabriel team
- Questions Orla being confirmed by Derry and Phil, says this could happen with non-NRV roles with two baddie teams
- Asks Emily does Jake know her identity from the BR



Not sure what to make of Holly, having more posts to go through would definitely help. She voted in the main wagon on Day 1 and an outlier vote on Day 2. She got heat for her vote on Lucy so could have changed tactic to an outlier. At time of voting Lucy wasn’t looking like she would turn into a wagon so maybe by the time she realised it was too late to change? She ISOs Jake and then questions if he’s a frustrated villager or agro wolf and doesn’t understand the hard on for him, this would normally stand out to me but as it’s similar to what I was thinking last night I can’t read into it too much. She was pretty strong in her efforts against Gabriel yesterday and stuck with her vote, this could be a wolf monster hunting though. I don’t understand the non-NRV thing in regard to baddies, it’s a weird way of phrasing it if she can confirm that? Questioning Orla, Phil and Derry after Derry got a wolf kill is strange, not that I’m saying they should be believed blindly but it’s looking pretty good for those three. As it stands I could see her being a potential wolf but she hasn’t got enough posts to make a solid argument so that’s something I’d like to see more of today

Ewan WW

Ewan WW wrote: »

Why you voting me Phil?

Same question to Conor, what did I do this morning to ruffle y'all

Never did get that ISO of myself done. Curious that.

Phil WW

Vernon WW wrote: »

thats why i picked phil.

i thought the mistake was on purpose, and letting me know about the decision to peek him.

ewan was just a random choice

It was part of my task haha.

Vernon WW

anyway, i have 1 more peek tonight. best case scenario is i find cahir

Conor WW

Sorry Vernon for doubting you. There’s no need for Ciri to stay hidden now Derry has gone so without anyone else staking claim, I’m taking it that you are who you are.

Village core
Orla
Vernon
Phil

Gertrude WW

#VOTES

Day 1

12:43 Barbara votes for Gabriel
Gabriel = 1 vote

18:00 Ewan votes for Eva
Gabriel = 1 vote
Eva = 1 vote

18:12 Patrick votes for Barbara
Gabriel = 1 vote
Eva = 1 vote
Barbara = 1 vote

18:43 Vernon votes for Barbara
Gabriel = 1 vote
Eva = 1 vote
Barbara = 2 votes

18:47 Lucy votes for Conor
Gabriel = 1 vote
Eva = 1 vote
Barbara = 2 votes
Conor = 1 vote

18:53 Abigail votes for Phil
Gabriel = 1 vote
Eva = 1 vote
Barbara = 2 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Phil = 1 vote

19:02 Phil votes for Phil
Gabriel = 1 vote
Eva = 1 vote
Barbara = 2 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Phil = 2 votes

19:21 Gabriel votes for Barbara
Gabriel = 1 vote
Eva = 1 vote
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Phil = 2 votes

19:28 Gertrude votes for Lucy
Gabriel = 1 vote
Eva = 1 vote
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Phil = 2 votes
Lucy = 1 vote

19:45 Holly votes for Lucy
Gabriel = 1 vote
Eva = 1 vote
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Phil = 2 votes
Lucy = 2 votes

19:51 Nigel votes for Barbara
Gabriel = 1 vote
Eva = 1 vote
Barbara = 4 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Phil = 2 votes
Lucy = 2 votes

19:54 Jake votes for Conor
Gabriel = 1 vote
Eva = 1 vote
Barbara = 4 votes
Conor = 2 votes
Phil = 2 votes
Lucy = 2 votes

19:55 Emily votes for Phil
Gabriel = 1 vote
Eva = 1 vote
Barbara = 4 votes
Conor = 2 votes
Phil = 3 votes
Lucy = 2 votes

20:04 Vernon unvotes Barbara votes Gabriel
Gabriel = 2 votes
Eva = 1 vote
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 2 votes
Phil = 3 votes
Lucy = 2 votes

20:31 Derry votes Jake
Gabriel = 2 votes
Eva = 1 vote
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 2 votes
Phil = 3 votes
Lucy = 2 votes
Jake = 1 vote

20:34 Eva votes Liam
Gabriel = 2 votes
Eva = 1 vote
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 2 votes
Phil = 3 votes
Lucy = 2 votes
Jake = 1 vote
Liam = 1 vote

20:40 Conor votes Abigail
Gabriel = 2 votes
Eva = 1 vote
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 2 votes
Phil = 3 votes
Lucy = 2 votes
Jake = 1 vote
Liam = 1 vote
Abigail = 1 vote

20:47 Orla votes Liam
Gabriel = 2 votes
Eva = 1 vote
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 2 votes
Phil = 3 votes
Lucy = 2 votes
Jake = 1 vote
Liam = 2 votes
Abigail = 1 vote

20:54 Conor unvotes Abigail votes Barbara
Gabriel = 2 votes
Eva = 1 vote
Barbara = 4 votes
Conor = 2 votes
Phil = 3 votes
Lucy = 2 votes
Jake = 1 vote
Liam = 2 votes

20:55 Orla unvotes Liam votes Angus
Gabriel = 2 votes
Eva = 1 vote
Barbara = 4 votes
Conor = 2 votes
Phil = 3 votes
Lucy = 2 votes
Jake = 1 vote
Liam = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote

20:57 Ewan unvotes Eva votes Lucy
Gabriel = 2 votes
Barbara = 4 votes
Conor = 2 votes
Phil = 3 votes
Lucy = 3 votes
Jake = 1 vote
Liam = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote

20:59 Liam votes Holly
Gabriel = 2 votes
Barbara = 4 votes
Conor = 2 votes
Phil = 3 votes
Lucy = 3 votes
Jake = 1 vote
Liam = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote
Holly = 1 vote

20:59 Angus votes Lucy
Gabriel = 2 votes
Barbara = 4 votes
Conor = 2 votes
Phil = 3 votes
Lucy = 4 votes
Jake = 1 vote
Liam = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote
Holly = 1 vote

20:59 Barbara unvotes Gabriel votes Lucy
Gabriel = 1 vote
Barbara = 4 votes
Conor = 2 votes
Phil = 3 votes
Lucy = 5 votes
Jake = 1 vote
Liam = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote
Holly = 1 vote

Lynch Results

Player | Votes
Lucy WW | Gertrude, Holly, Ewan, Angus, Barbara
Barbara WW | Patrick, Gabriel, Nigel, Conor
Phil WW | Abigail, Phil, Emily
Conor WW | Lucy, Jake
Gabriel WW | Vernon
Jake WW | Derry
Liam WW | Eva
Angus WW | Orla
Holly WW | Liam

---

Day 2

10:04 Derry votes Jake
Jake = 1 vote

11:42 Gabriel votes Jake
Jake = 2 votes

14:52 Vernon votes Barbara
Jake = 2 votes
Barbara = 1 vote

17:04 Ewan votes Conor
Jake = 2 votes
Barbara = 1 vote
Conor = 1 vote

18:29 Gertrude votes Barbara
Jake = 2 votes
Barbara = 2 votes
Conor = 1 vote

19:08 Conor votes Barbara
Jake = 2 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote

19:19 Patrick votes Jake
Jake = 3 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote

19:20 Emily votes Angus
Jake = 3 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote

19:41 Barbara votes Jake
Jake = 4 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote

19:49 Orla votes Jake
Jake = 5 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote

19:57 Liam votes Holly
Jake = 5 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote
Holly = 1 vote

19:58 Holly votes Gabriel
Jake = 5 votes
Barbara = 3 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote
Holly = 1 vote
Gabriel = 1 vote

20:14 Jake votes Barbara
Jake = 5 votes
Barbara = 4 votes
Conor = 1 vote
Angus = 1 vote
Holly = 1 vote
Gabriel = 1 vote

20:22 Ewan unvotes Conor votes Jake
Jake = 6 votes
Barbara = 4 votes
Angus = 1 vote
Holly = 1 vote
Gabriel = 1 vote

20:24 Angus votes Gabriel
Jake = 6 votes
Barbara = 4 votes
Angus = 1 vote
Holly = 1 vote
Gabriel = 2 votes

20:48 Phil votes Conor
Jake = 6 votes
Barbara = 4 votes
Angus = 1 vote
Holly = 1 vote
Gabriel = 2 votes
Conor = 1 vote

20:52 Phil unvotes Conor votes Angus
Jake = 6 votes
Barbara = 4 votes
Angus = 2 votes
Holly = 1 vote
Gabriel = 2 votes

20:54 Angus unvotes Gabriel votes Jake
Jake = 7 votes
Barbara = 4 votes
Angus = 2 votes
Holly = 1 vote
Gabriel = 1 votes

20:55 Eva votes Angus
Jake = 7 votes
Barbara = 4 votes
Angus = 3 votes
Holly = 1 vote
Gabriel = 1 votes

20:59 Phil unvotes Angus votes Eva
Jake = 7 votes
Barbara = 4 votes
Angus = 2 votes
Holly = 1 vote
Gabriel = 1 votes
Eva = 1

Lynch Results

Player | Vote
Jake WW | Derry, Gabriel, Patrick, Barbara, Orla, Ewan, Angus
Barbara WW | Vernon, Gertrude, Conor, Jake
Angus WW | Emily, Eva
Holly WW | Liam
Gabriel WW | Holly
Eva WW | Phil

Angus WW

Conor WW wrote: »

Sorry Vernon for doubting you. There’s no need for Ciri to stay hidden now Derry has gone so without anyone else staking claim, I’m taking it that you are who you are.

Village core
Orla
Vernon
Phil

How did Phil make your village core?
Also Orla could be the guy who peeks good first time round - I’d park her for now but just saying she could be

Gertrude WW

Sorry for that guys I needed them all together for easy referencing, it was a pain searching for them all individually

Conor WW

Ewan WW wrote: »

Same question to Conor, what did I do this morning to ruffle y'all

Never did get that ISO of myself done. Curious that.

Well I like Phil so if he’s happy to vote for ya then so am I.

Gertrude done an iso off you. There was a part about the way you jumped votes which was interesting.

Conor WW

Angus WW wrote: »

How did Phil make your village core?
Also Orla could be the guy who peeks good first time round - I’d park her for now but just saying she could be

Seriously, how are people still doubting Phil being a roled villager? He had tasks and won prizes. Peeked Orla first, poisoned Vernon (oops) second.

Derry says Orla is DOUBLE CONFIRMED

Gertrude WW

Angus WW wrote: »

How did Phil make your village core?
Also Orla could be the guy who peeks good first time round - I’d park her for now but just saying she could be

Phil done tasks and won prizes which he used on thread and there's been no counterclaim. If Orla was the black knight then Phils peek would have game back good but Derrys would have came back bad but both came back NRV

Ewan WW

Conor WW wrote: »

Well I like Phil so if he’s happy to vote for ya then so am I.

Gertrude done an iso off you. There was a part about the way you jumped votes which was interesting.

Right... so no independent thought just piggyback on someone cos they're seemingly a roled villager. And piggyback on someone else's work rather than doing what you said you were gonna do yesterday and ISO me yourself.

Doesnt seem very villagery to me.

Gertrude WW

Conor WW wrote: »

Seriously, how are people still doubting Phil being a roled villager? He had tasks and won prizes. Peeked Orla first, poisoned Vernon (oops) second.

Derry says Orla is DOUBLE CONFIRMED

Ohhh mind meld

Ewan WW

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Phil done tasks and won prizes which he used on thread and there's been no counterclaim. If Orla was the black knight then Phils peek would have game back good but Derrys would have came back bad but both came back NRV

It's the Doppler that peeks as NRV first but the rest of your post is fairly bang on tbf

Ewan WW

Conor WW wrote: »

Seriously, how are people still doubting Phil being a roled villager? He had tasks and won prizes. Peeked Orla first, poisoned Vernon (oops) second.

Derry says Orla is DOUBLE CONFIRMED

I'm not doubting Phil, but blindly following him in your vote screams to me that you're trying to pocket the life out of him.

Clear, sure.

Infallible... sweet jesus no.

Gabriel WW

Confirmed good added to tables:

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Lynch Results

Player | Votes
Lucy WW | Gertrude, Holly, Ewan, Angus, Barbara
Barbara WW | Patrick, Gabriel, Nigel, Conor
Phil WW | Abigail, Phil, Emily
Conor WW | Lucy, Jake
Gabriel WW | Vernon
Jake WW | Derry
Liam WW | Eva
Angus WW | Orla
Holly WW | Liam


Lynch Results

Player | Vote
Jake WW | Derry, Gabriel, Patrick, Barbara, Orla, Ewan, Angus
Barbara WW | Vernon, Gertrude, Conor, Jake
Angus WW | Emily, Eva
Holly WW | Liam
Gabriel WW | Holly
Eva WW | Phil

Looking at the first night's voting I think there's at least one wolf on the Lucy voters. There's not much space left on the board then.

Emily WW

Phil WW wrote: »

I wonder whether I'll be 1, 2 or 3 in Emily's FFA today.

You would be tbh but others not doubting you and Jake putting focus on you several times moves you down the list. Derry's read on Orla matching yours also moves you well down.

Phil WW

Angus WW wrote: »

How did Phil make your village core?
Also Orla could be the guy who peeks good first time round - I’d park her for now but just saying she could be

Nearly 1,500 posts in this thread and the above is the worst contribution so far.

If you're a villager, you're not fit to work this Kingdom's fields.

Ewan WW

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Confirmed good added to tables:



Looking at the first night's voting I think there's at least one wolf on the Lucy voters. There's not much space left on the board then.

I'd say you're right, that wagon hasnt been touched by either team in two days for munches.

Barbara WW

Angus WW wrote: »

How did Phil make your village core?
Also Orla could be the guy who peeks good first time round - I’d park her for now but just saying she could be

If someone comes up with a legit reason for Phil not being bad I'd say fair play because I can't think of a single one. That's how he's in my core at least.

Vernon WW

Gabriel WW wrote: »

Confirmed good added to tables:



Looking at the first night's voting I think there's at least one wolf on the Lucy voters. There's not much space left on the board then.

based on those votes, i think we still need to resolve barbara. she was 2nd both nights.

if she is bad, it is likely ewan or angus are the 3rd wolf.