Boardsies Decide - Cartoon Wars 2: South Park vs Family Guy

Rikand

I love chris, but randy is iconic

Randy marsh for 2 days before the day after tomorrow..... That's Today!

RobbingBandit

Randy has been great for me but he sort of died the last two seasons he's just not funny anymore

Chris is good but he's not good enough to beat Randy

Randy for me damn this was a difficult one

Guitar hero episode Randy playing Kansas for the kids still makes me laugh old school Randy wins Hipster Weed Farmer doesn't

Necro

Also Starring LeVar Burton wrote:

Has to be Randy Marsh for me - best overall character of either show. Shame Chris came up against him here as he probably deserves to survive a bit longer in the tournament.

My sentiments exactly re: Randy.

He just has to progress here.

Revit Man

Randy Marsh, no quibbles.

Too many classic moments, he has almost become the central character of the show as the seasons progressed. It started out all about the boys, but it's become the Randy show to a degree. Many Randy-centric episodes, even down to the latest Tegridy Farms plots.

Agree with above poster, his Kansas guitar moment was brilliant.

TheValeyard

Id vote PC Principal, he is hilarious

And Randy, the legend

Aceandstuff

I vote for Lorde.

Omackeral

Randy progresses. We'll kick off Round 2 later on this evening and it will have a bit of a kicker as promised. See you then hopefully

Omackeral

We are upping the ante to 5 votes here. In this round however, you may use a Double Jeopardy vote. Your Double Jeopardy vote will count double but may only be used once in this round, so choose wisely when you play it. Let's get on with the first bout.

TheValeyard

Omackeral wrote: »

We are upping the ante to 5 votes here. In this round however, you may use a Double Jeopardy vote. Your Double Jeopardy vote will count double but may only be used once in this round, so choose wisely when you play it. Let's get on with the first bout.

Ooooohhhh

Omackeral

It's a family affair to start us off. Grandson vs Grandad.

Stewie Griffin



VS

Carter Pewterschmidt

PsychoPete

Stewie, no contest

Also Starring LeVar Burton

Carter because he's just a better character. Not a big fan of the talking baby.

Omackeral

PsychoPete wrote: »

Stewie, no contest

Can we throw in a reason please P?

PsychoPete

PsychoPete wrote: »

Stewie, no contest

His flamboyant homosexuality moments are a hoot

Krombopulos Michael

Carter. He was down right evil, funny and even mocked his voice acting sounding like other characters.

Stewie went from super evil at the start of the show to just being a camp troll

Necro

Stewie. Best character bar none in Family Guy imo

Omackeral

2-2. Forgot to mention that it's 45min time limit this round.

martyos121

Stewie, he’s great in the early seasons and the evil baby character is something original.

jimmymack

Carter, to break the deadlock and send one of the big guns out early.

South Park all the way!

Edit: Too slow haha

Also Starring LeVar Burton

Can the Double Jeopardy be used at any point, or do you have to state it at the same time as your vote?

Not saying I want to use mine right now, just, er, asking for a friend.

Omackeral

jimmymack wrote: »

Carter, to break the deadlock and send one of the big guns out early.

South Park all the way!

Edit: Too slow haha

Your vote was cast just at literally the last minute so it counts. It's a tie. It's now my call. Stewie is unreal. I love him. I think he's one of the best on it. But Carter is such an amazing megalomaniac yet still curmudgeonly. I think Stewie is more iconic obviously and I do love him but I actually think pound for pound I enjoy Carter more.

Carter wins.

Gru

Stevie has been excellent throughout and doubles up well with Brian. He gets the vote.

Carter is also great but not great enough.

Omackeral

Also Starring LeVar Burton wrote: »

Can the Double Jeopardy be used at any point, or do you have to state it at the same time as your vote?

Not saying I want to use mine right now, just, er, asking for a friend.

Must be used before the match time limit expires. Once used, can't be taken back. Can be subsequently applied following a vote.

Omackeral

A giant and possible favourite has fallen early here! Another could well bite the dust here. Two addicts go head to kinda head.

Towelie



VS

Glenn Quagmire

PsychoPete

Glen! Towelie gets very tedious after a while

martyos121

Towelie gets my vote, I found Quagmire quite grating after a couple of seasons but a cartoon towel who loves to get high is the perfect level of absurd. He had some great episodes too.

Cienciano

Towelie. Funny joke spread thin so it works. Quagmire's one joke over and over again is dragging the arse out of it

Also Starring LeVar Burton

Towelie, is much more bearable than Quagmire the sex pest.

Gru

Towelie has to win here. Actually improved over the seasons into a funny character.

Quagmire was really funny in earlier seasons but like Brian was turned into a more **** character.

TheValeyard

Quagmire , because of what happened when he discovered internet porn.