Today Show with Sarah McInerney

Irish Wolf

limnam wrote: »

It wouldn't be the first time.


But I just went back and read the first 3/4 pages of the thread.


Nope, not just me . :pac:

Read more.

The first ~60 posts were in her first week, and mostly others speculating on who they thought, or would like, to take over. Pick out the critical ones, and I'd say <10%.

Take the rest of the thread, I'd be surprised if it wasn't >70% positive for her work. Obviously open to correction, if you'll do the leg work

limnam

Irish Wolf wrote: »

Read more.

The first ~60 posts were in her first week, and mostly others speculating on who they thought, or would like, to take over. Pick out the critical ones, and I'd say <10%.

Take the rest of the thread, I'd be surprised if it wasn't >70% positive for her work. Obviously open to correction, if you'll do the leg work

I only need 1% not to be alone.

bookman2

lets see how she interviews eamonn ryan.

bookman2

bookman2 wrote: »

lets see how she interviews eamonn ryan.

she deffo wasn't as combative in that interview!

khalessi

bookman2 wrote: »

she deffo wasn't as combative in that interview!

She wasn't easy on him either and he did stutter a couple of times.

gifted

She caught him out on the school buses

RINO87

Much, much better than when she was in newstalk. More experience and not having to carry that other wet blanket makes a big difference.
I would tend to agree with those that say she should get the full time gig.

zerosugarbuzz

RINO87 wrote: »

Much, much better than when she was in newstalk. More experience and not having to carry that other wet blanket makes a big difference.
I would tend to agree with those that say she should get the full time gig.

Fully agree, newstalk seems to encourage their female presenters to be very shouty, no doubt they feel that makes them sound assertive, it doesn’t, it makes them sound aggressive. Claire Byrne also improved tremendously after moving to RTÉ. I really hope Sarah keeps the gig, best presenter on the airwaves currently imo.

HeidiHeidi

gifted wrote: »

She caught him out on the school buses

It shouldn't be about "catching them out" - it should be about extracting maximum relevant information (and allowing minimum irrelevant waffle!) - and I think she's very, very good at it.

Infoanon

bookman2 wrote: »

she deffo wasn't as combative in that interview!

In fairness Eamon Ryan was answering the questions and was willing to explain why they had ignored NPHET advice in some areas.

Michael McNamara was rather meek in his contribution today - someone might have had a word in his ear.

Combat in interviews is not always necessary as today's show proved.

wowy

https://twitter.com/KevDoyle_Indo/status/1296069177439027202?s=19

Claire Byrne gets the nod as the new permanent host. Kick in the teeth for McInerny imo.

HeidiHeidi

wowy wrote: »

https://twitter.com/KevDoyle_Indo/status/1296069177439027202?s=19

Claire Byrne gets the nod as the new permanent host. Kick in the teeth for McInerny imo.

:mad:

Odyssey 2005

HeidiHeidi wrote: »

:mad:

Thank God mcInerney didnt get it. Shes horrendous

Acosta

That's how it works in RTE. It's not about who's the best person for job, it's about who's turn it is.

wowy

wowy wrote: »

https://twitter.com/KevDoyle_Indo/status/1296069177439027202?s=19

Claire Byrne gets the nod as the new permanent host. Kick in the teeth for McInerny imo.

Disappointed with that, Claire Byrne is a very capable presenter, but she's not a journalist so shouldn't even have been considered.



Should have stuck with Sarah imo.

neris

Acosta wrote: »

That's how it works in RTE. It's not about who's the best person for job, it's about who's turn it is.

or whos managemnt conmpany gets them all the cosy media interviews to "plead" for their dream job through their buddies in various other media outlets

gifted

[Deleted User] wrote: »

Disappointed with that, Claire Byrne is a very capable presenter, but she's not a journalist so shouldn't even have been considered.



Should have stuck with Sarah imo.

Perhaps Claires face looks better....

Dempo1

Dissapointing but predictable news form RTE, I'm not doubting Claires ability but Sarah did a fine job and I've no doubt a new role be found for her soon.

Mantis Toboggan

Can't stand Mcinerney as she's painful to listen to so happy enough with this.

_Kaiser_

Sarah is very combative and this doesn't help when interviewees start getting frustrated as a result (Ben Dunne was a recent one I remember). I also dislike her style when it comes to "female/gender issues". Generally an all-female, one-sided panel chat ensues

Claire though isn't any better but she's likely better established within RTE so the "logical" choice for a flagship show. TD's are probably breathing a sigh of relief that they'll probably get an easier time of it going forward.

Ryaner179

What a mess

ford fiesta

My bets are that Claire Byrne won't allow this show to be video relayed on RTE News Now on TV/Web.
See how far she gets..

td1

CB has been responsible for/at the helm of some of the most incompetent (36th Amendment debate) and risible (so many of her Covid-19 programmes) TV in recent years ... hopefully this means no more of her on there!

KevRossi

I'd say the decision was made a long time ago. You couldn't really fault McInerney over the past few weeks, not always perfect, but well above average.

Claire Byrne on the radio has a habit of reading out prepared questions and can have difficulty developing an interview if it goes off on and interesting tangent. I also think she lacks tenacity.

Interesting to see what happens to Sarah McInerney now, and what role RTE can find for her.

Dempo1

Mantis Toboggan wrote: »

Can't stand Mcinerney as she's painful to listen to so happy enough with this.

Anyone who managed to get under the skin of Leo gets my vote

Acosta

td1 wrote: »

CB has been responsible for/at the helm of some of the most incompetent (36th Amendment debate) and risible (so many of her Covid-19 programmes) TV in recent years ... hopefully this means no more of her on there!

She should never manage another debate day's out from such an important referendum as the 36th amendment. She was so bad the Iona crazies online actually thought the No side would win after it.

limnam

Dempo1 wrote: »

Anyone who managed to get under the skin of Leo gets my vote

As someone mentioned earlier Heidi I think.


That's not the point and purpose of being a good interviewer.


Any gutter journo can upset a guest, it takes real talent, emotional intelligence etc to extract good useful information to inform and entertain the listener.


Not turn every interview into a boxing match. There's no talent in that. I could do it.

elperello

They are both good presenters in my opinion.

The only issue I have is why did they not put the replacement in immediately after S O'R's departure?

It's not as if he left suddenly.

dominatinMC

Haven't been reading all the posts, but I think it's fair to say Sarah is coming in for a fair bit of criticism. All I'll say is - be careful what you wish for. Sarah isn't perfect, but is a hell of a lot better than some of the other candidates being suggested for the role.

bookman2

that's good news - not too sure what the lovefest is with mcinerney but the combative gotcha type of interview is very tiresome IMO.

limnam

Odyssey 2005 wrote: »

Thank God mcInerney didnt get it. Shes horrendous

A small bit of faith has been restored in RTE for me. This would have been a step too far.


From Pat Kenny to McInerney. :eek:

limnam

bookman2 wrote: »

that's good news - not too sure what the lovefest is with mcinerney but the combative gotcha type of interview is very tiresome IMO.

People are getting used to dumbed down goading from the likes of sky


Thinking it's the sign of a strong woman etc. Where in fact it's just a petulant child with a radio show.

bureau2009

Claire Byrne is a weak interviewer in my opinion and unsuited to this role. Can't see this working out for RTE.

Thankfully the superb Pat Kenny is on air at this time. I suspect a lot of listeners will switch over to him.

Ryaner179

Trying to justify Byrne's massive wage by giving her this job....

limnam

Ryaner179 wrote: »

Trying to justify Byrne's massive wage by giving her this job....

You could say that about a few.


Marty
George Hamilton etc

Mav11

Very disappointed Sarah didn't get it. She was a breath of fresh air when compared to the usual RTE luvvies and a bloody good interviewer!!

ShamNNspace

wowy wrote: »

https://twitter.com/KevDoyle_Indo/status/1296069177439027202?s=19

Claire Byrne gets the nod as the new permanent host. Kick in the teeth for McInerny imo.

Just lost a listener here too and I hope I won't be the only one

hotmail.com

Sarah was just a temporary replacement, not even in the running.

Good news I think, Claire is alright.

I'll continue to listen to it.

EmptyTree

Mav11 wrote: »

Very disappointed Sarah didn't get it. She was a breath of fresh air when compared to the usual RTE luvvies and a bloody good interviewer!!

This. I think RTE have shown zero imagination here by giving it to Claire. Talented as she might be, I think this shows how RTE has not changed. Even the appointment of Sean was a step in the right direction at the time.

hurikane

Great news, couldn’t understand how Sarah had it temporarily.

Odyssey 2005

limnam wrote: »

A small bit of faith has been restored in RTE for me. This would have been a step too far.


From Pat Kenny to McInerney. :eek:

To be honest I think itll be PKfor me from now on

touts

#justiceforsarah

thesandeman

Sarah's new RTE gig to be announced in the next couple of weeks.

Brendan Bendar

thesandeman wrote: »

Sarah's new RTE gig to be announced in the next couple of weeks.

Radio or TV?

Invincible

Won't be listening to CB on Today from now on either!
Must be her acting skills from her shed episodes that clinched it for her.

Muahahaha

bureau2009 wrote: »

Claire Byrne is a weak interviewer in my opinion and unsuited to this role. Can't see this working out for RTE.

Thankfully the superb Pat Kenny is on air at this time. I suspect a lot of listeners will switch over to him.

Will give Claire a listen for a couple of weeks but yeah I could finally see a good few RTE listeners finally 'turning the dial' to Pat Kenny in that slot. Thats what Newstalk originally wanted to happen with the poaching of Kenny but it didnt as Sean o'Rourke was more than capable at holding his own.

Has it been said if Claire Byrne will continue on her Monday night show? If so shes going to be busy with 5 radio shows a week and the TV show on top. Mondays will be a long day for her with two shows on a single day.

thesandeman

Brendan Bendar wrote: »

Radio or TV?

Don't know. Kathryn Thomas was congratulating both of them and said it would be announced shortly.

limnam

Odyssey 2005 wrote: »

To be honest I think itll be PKfor me from now on

Agreed. It was more the decision not to go with SM rather than the choice of CB

Mantis Toboggan

Mav11 wrote: »

Very disappointed Sarah didn't get it. She was a breath of fresh air when compared to the usual RTE luvvies and a bloody good interviewer!!

Newstalk reject more like.

limnam

thesandeman wrote: »

Sarah's new RTE gig to be announced in the next couple of weeks.

I think she'd be ok on cbeebies or similar