MCU Werewolf MAIN GAME THREAD

Orla WW

Orla WW wrote: »

I counted 24 + the face hiding in the background

Sorry I meant 24+1 in other photo.

I counted 35 in the bigger photo . 10’people floating (or hulky big) and 26 below that makes 36 but that doesn’t include weird face hiding in background.

Katie WW

Did it warrant being jumped on though is my point.

If I've got a peek and I ask everyone individually should I peek you?

How many people do you think would say yes peek me (and how many of these do you think would be wolves?)? How many do you think would say no (and how many of these do you think would be wolves?)?

I would hazard a guess that almost every wolf would say "yes peek me" to try to convince my not to peek them. I'd say it would be rare for a wolf to go "oh no don't peek me, peek someone else".

Katie WW

Barbara WW wrote: »

Practically self lynched, but its not a waste there is some info to be gained, interested in the votes and who jumped on the band wagon mid to late

Barbara here saying it would be interesting to see who jumped on the wagon, mid to late. Conveniently she was one of the first to vote so is not really in the mid to late range.

If Isla was a wolf I'd be more suspicious of people jumping on late for credit but when the wolves know Isla is good why wouldn't they be one of the first to vote for her?

Spook_ie

Orla WW wrote: »

Sorry I meant 24+1 in other photo.

I counted 35 in the bigger photo . 10’people floating (or hulky big) and 26 below that makes 36 but that doesn’t include weird face hiding in background.

Don't want to drag wolf hunting any further off course but regarding gameplay you have to count the weird face

https://www.boards.ie/vbulletin/showpost.php?p=113490670&postcount=1006

Katie WW

Conor WW wrote: »

Those posts do look pretty bad now you've highlighted them. Looks like a hard-defend of Nigel.

I dunno if Katie wolf defends Nigel wolf like that though, if either flip it looks awful for them

It wasn't a defence of Nigel. I just felt there may be a wolf in the two of them and Patrick wanted it known he was the one with reasons.

duffman13

Katie WW wrote: »

Did it warrant being jumped on though is my point.

If I've got a peek and I ask everyone individually should I peek you?

How many people do you think would say yes peek me (and how many of these do you think would be wolves?)? How many do you think would say no (and how many of these do you think would be wolves?)?

I would hazard a guess that almost every wolf would say "yes peek me" to try to convince my not to peek them. I'd say it would be rare for a wolf to go "oh no don't peek me, peek someone else".

Kind of yeah! Read back, its not the initial saying don't peek me, it was the, dont peek me, ill be munched, I mean no one is more valuable than than the next villager. She doubled down later when she tried to insinuate she could protect herself from lynch but wasn't confirming as she wasn't bothered to message them, even though she would have had to message them to use her protect.

Nothing added up about it. That being said it was an easy wagon for wolves to hop on or avoid completely

Katie WW

duffman13 wrote: »

Kind of yeah! Read back, its not the initial saying don't peek me, it was the, dont peek me, ill be munched, I mean no one is more valuable than than the next villager. She doubled down later when she tried to insinuate she could protect herself from lynch but wasn't confirming as she wasn't bothered to message them, even though she would have had to message them to use her protect.

Nothing added up about it. That being said it was an easy wagon for wolves to hop on or avoid completely

Some of the people who jumped on it though seemed to ignore that she'd already reacted to the same idea and did so in what I think was a fairly normal response for a villager. I think it would be better to find a wolf but also not the worst to get a clear villager. Following on from that getting munched is what would happen to a clear villager more than likely at some stage. She may have thought it would happen sooner than it might have and that's why they panicked and said they were protecting themselves.

Even the not messaging doesn't seem wolfy, surely a wolf would have just messaged and said one way or the other.

Conor WW

duffman13 wrote: »

Kind of yeah! Read back, its not the initial saying don't peek me, it was the, dont peek me, ill be munched, I mean no one is more valuable than than the next villager. She doubled down later when she tried to insinuate she could protect herself from lynch but wasn't confirming as she wasn't bothered to message them, even though she would have had to message them to use her protect.

Nothing added up about it. That being said it was an easy wagon for wolves to hop on or avoid completely

Yeah the problem with Isla is that she did theoretically hang herself.

First the reaction to the peek which people did seem to jump on.

But after that her actions in openly self protecting did her absolutely no favours.

I think of Katie's quotes Abigail is the most noteworthy. She kinda piled on immediately and didnt really comment much afterwards that I can remember of.

Orla WW

Anybody have any theory on why there was no wolf munch yesterday? Also there was 2 munches a day until islands merged, anything to that or do we think it was just as simple as when teams merged they simply lost one kill. Also curious if they had a BR while separated. Just curious if anybody has any theories. I’m thinking about the amount of players left on day 4, it’s quite crazy not to think that there’s a need for a bigger body count.

I’d suggest villagers be around for 1 just in case we have a competition, I’ve a feeling bullets may be going around and I guess wolves will go for certain targets immediately, possibly thin the “mostly village” herd.

Jake WW

@ Lucy,

Nice work, but the Isla thing was a bandwagon that got out of control because yesterday was a bloodbath and we had players coming back to life. bad job all round from most of the village yesterday, including me tbf, and including Isla herself for that matter.

This is a big thread and I'm going to revise for a mo. I will say one thing so far - I like the look of Gertude, because of this post

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Also, on your line of thinking you don't think our Nig is a wolf? I do and I don't think we can totally clear people just because they took a shot today.

I have an inkling about 1 or 2 posters.Give reasons later if i can find something substantial in yesterdays havoc

Senan WW

Well that was a stroke of luck getting a wolf mod killed. Pity about losing two villagers this morning though, although we must have nearly all the wolfs at this stage so that's a plus.

Conor WW

Orla WW wrote: »

Anybody have any theory on why there was no wolf munch yesterday? Also there was 2 munches a day until islands merged, anything to that or do we think it was just as simple as when teams merged they simply lost one kill. Also curious if they had a BR while separated. Just curious if anybody has any theories. I’m thinking about the amount of players left on day 4, it’s quite crazy not to think that there’s a need for a bigger body count.

I’d suggest villagers be around for 1 just in case we have a competition, I’ve a feeling bullets may be going around and I guess wolves will go for certain targets immediately, possibly thin the “mostly village” herd.

Necro was munched. It's like the fifth or sixth post in the thread. Everyone else yesterday bar Isla was shot

Jake WW

Sorry I meant Katie, nice work

Orla WW

Conor WW wrote: »

Necro was munched. It's like the fifth or sixth post in the thread. Everyone else yesterday bar Isla was shot

But weren’t all wolves dead in cosmos by yesterday’s munch? So why would the alive earth wolves munch Necro? I’m thinking from a wolf communication POV and even maybe when wolves can place orders, presumably outside our on thread curfew.. Maybe it doesn’t really help our cause , just trying to work on some angles.

Conor WW

Orla WW wrote: »

But weren’t all wolves dead in cosmos by yesterday’s munch? So why would the alive earth wolves munch Necro? I’m thinking from a wolf communication POV and even maybe when wolves can place orders, presumably outside our on thread curfew.. Maybe it doesn’t really help our cause , just trying to work on some angles.

Well Green&Red was shot by the redirected bullet too.

I can only presume that the wolves wanted strong villagers dead.

Neither were ever getting lynched in fairness.

The wolves from Earth would hardly munch in the Earth players either as it would thin the herd for themselves to hide in

As it stands only Drumpot is left standing from Earth after yesterday's genocide

Jake WW

Dunno if i'm allowed to ask this, but i wonder if all the alignments stayed the same > from usual username to anon account, could someone have gone from good to bad, bad to good?? That would be a mindbender from the Mods. Shouldnt discuss further than that in or I might get modkilled. Just a thought.

Gertrude WW

Glad to see that Nigel was a wolf, thought he took too long, hence my comment about him getting advice from his team.


I see someone asked about a current player list. I have been trying to keep up. Unfortunately I got called into a meeting today at 9am and only on a break. So much for a day off :rolleyes:




Abigail WW
Barbara WW
Conor WW - shot ALC
Doris WW
Drumpot
Duffman
Emily WW
Eva WW - shot Fixxxer
Ewan WW
Gertrude WW - Shot GnR after redirect
Holly WW
Jake WW
Katie WW
Lucy WW
Macdanger
Orla WW - Shot JGF
Senan WW
Spook
Steve WW
Wendy WW - shot Ecto (we think )


I still have Babs in my sights for a wolf and possibly Katie. I am also a bit unsure on what to do about Drumpot. Yes he is possibly a vilager, but if therer was more wolves on Earth since Cosmic had Thanos then he can still flip red.


I guess that would be by FFA for today


Barbara
Katie
Drumpot

Drumpot

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Glad to see that Nigel was a wolf, thought he took too long, hence my comment about him getting advice from his team.


I see someone asked about a current player list. I have been trying to keep up. Unfortunately I got called into a meeting today at 9am and only on a break. So much for a day off :rolleyes:




Abigail WW
Barbara WW
Conor WW - shot ALC
Doris WW
Drumpot
Duffman
Emily WW
Eva WW - shot Fixxxer
Ewan WW
Gertrude WW - Shot GnR after redirect
Holly WW
Jake WW
Katie WW
Lucy WW
Macdanger
Orla WW - Shot JGF
Senan WW
Spook
Steve WW
Wendy WW - shot Ecto (we think )


I still have Babs in my sights for a wolf and possibly Katie. I am also a bit unsure on what to do about Drumpot. Yes he is possibly a vilager, but if therer was more wolves on Earth since Cosmic had Thanos then he can still flip red.


I guess that would be by FFA for today


Barbara
Katie
Drumpot

Why would Earth have more wolves because Thanos was on Cosmos ?

Jake WW

Orla WW wrote: »

I’d suggest villagers be around for 1 just in case we have a competition.

I'm here. Where are you?

Orla WW wrote: »

But weren’t all wolves dead in cosmos by yesterday’s munch? So why would the alive earth wolves munch Necro? I’m thinking from a wolf communication POV and even maybe when wolves can place orders, presumably outside our on thread curfew.. Maybe it doesn’t really help our cause , just trying to work on some angles.

Suspect wolves are in the same BR from the start.

Orla WW

Jake WW wrote: »

I'm here. Where are you?



Suspect wolves are in the same BR from the start.

Looks like there’s no competition today. Bummer

Jake WW

Good genieing there Orla.;) Yeah, was enjoying the comps.I'm revising the thread, dunno where everyone is today.

Orla WW

Jake WW wrote: »

Good genieing there Orla.;) Yeah, was enjoying the comps.I'm revising the thread, dunno where everyone is today.

Everybody must be off scheming

Orla WW

Jake WW wrote: »

Good genieing there Orla.;) Yeah, was enjoying the comps.I'm revising the thread, dunno where everyone is today.

What do you mean Genieing? I suggested everybody for here for 1 and was here at 1 to respond to your post... So me being here when I suggested eveybdih else be here is somehow suspect? Go way outta that...

Senan WW

I think we definitely need to be taking a closer look at Katie today. Patrick was pretty on the ball with his thoughts and that seems to be the one lead we have from him. I've not got the willpower to try ISO Katie's posts from the mobile but perhaps someone else might be able to have a look at one for us?

Jake WW

Been going back to find out what went down, and here's a summary.this table is a bit wonky but handy.


Desmond WW Dead wolf
Green&Red Dead village
MicksJaguar Dead village
Mollyb60 Dead wolf
Necro Dead village
Phil WW Dead village
Shatterproof Dead village
Whiplashy Dead wolf
Yoss Dead village
AnLachaCorcra Dead village
Barney Dead village
Fixxxer Dead village
Gabriel WW Dead village
Johngreenfan Dead wolf
Khalessi Dead village
Oisin WW Dead village
Rikand Dead village
Tegan WW Dead village
Tritium Dead wolf
Duffman Village
Macdanger Village
Spook Village
Ectoplasm Dead wolf
Drumpot ??

Abigail WW ??
Angus WW dead villager
Barbara WW ??
Conor WW
Derry WW dead wolf
Doris WW ??
Emily WW ??
Eva WW Shot villager
Ewan WW ??
Fiona WW dead villager
Frank WW dead villager
Gertrude WW
Holly WW ??
Isla WW dead villager
Jake WW village to me
Katie WW ??
Lucy WW ??
Nigel WW dead wolf
Orla WW ??
Patrick WW dead villager
Senan WW ??
Steve WW ??
Vernon WW dead wolf
Wendy WW ??

Yesterday

Necro Munched

Shot 1 fired - Rikand dead, villager (likely shot by Earth player?)

Shot 2 fired - ALC dead, villager (claimed by Conor AFTERWARD)

Shot 3 fired - FixXxer dead, villager (soft claimed by Eva WW AFTERWARD)

Shot 4 fired - Tegan dead, villager (claimed by Fiona AFTERWARD, dead villager)

Shot 5 fired - GNR dead, villager (Gertrude claimed AFTERWARD she shot wolf JGF who redirected to GNR)

Shot 6 fired - JGF dead, wolf (claimed by Orla on second shot AFTER shot, AFTER Gertrude claimed)

Shot 7 fired - Trit dead, wolf (bussed by Nigel, wolf)

Shot 8 fired - ecto dead, wolf (claimed by Wendy BEFOREHAND when writing was on wall and Ecto was being voted off)

Isla lynched, villager

Shot 8 fired -Nigel dead, wolf (Patrick, dead villager)


Today

Patrick munched

Didnt mean to look like I'm shouting just emphasizing. Sort of hard to know who's on the level based on the shots and victims.

I like what I've seen from Conor so far.

Jake WW

Last nite's votes:

Isla WW (13): MacDanger, Wendy WW, duffman13, Barbara WW, Doris WW, Abigail WW, Senan WW, Orla WW, Steve WW, Eva WW, Spook_ie, Emily WW, Lucy WW
Patrick WW (2): Nigel WW, Katie WW
Barbara WW (2): Isla WW,
Katie WW (2): Conor WW, Holly WW
Conor WW (1): Ewan WW
Derry WW (1): Drumpot
Angus WW (1): Jake WW

I voted for Angus because only he and Derry weren't showing up for the vote and Drumpot had voted for Derry. Bit suss not to vote, but they're both gone now so irrelevant.

Dont know why Derry, as a wolf, wasn't told to post at least a bit in the backroom?Guess they weren't warned about potential modkill?

duffman13

So many unknowns on the board, and severe lack of posting today its going to be a real shot in the dark to find wolves. We've no real info on the anons after last night and even if you disregard a few arbitrarily, your still looking for 3 in probably 12

My other concern is there could be more wolves than we anticipate and without any way of knowing we are a little snookered.

I'll be needed a cup of coffee today and a good read back

MacDanger

Just looking at yesterday's votes pre-Isla

JGF (2) - Patrick, Eva
G&R (1) - Ewan

JGF shot and killed

Ecto (1) - Barbara
Trit (2) - Conor, Patrick

Trit shot and killed

Ecto - Barbara, Conor, Patrick, Ewan, Senan, Drumpot, Macdanger, Eva, Gertrude, Duffman, Fixxer, Frank
Drumpot - Ecto

Ecto shot and killed

Confirmed village (including Drumpot even if he's not 100% confirmed) are highlighted in bold.

I think the remaining wolves aren't in that list

Conor WW

MacDanger wrote: »

Just looking at yesterday's votes pre-Isla

JGF (2) - Patrick, Eva
G&R (1) - Ewan

JGF shot and killed

Ecto (1) - Barbara
Trit (2) - Conor, Patrick

Trit shot and killed

Ecto - Barbara, Conor, Patrick, Ewan, Senan, Drumpot, Macdanger, Eva, Gertrude, Duffman, Fixxer, Frank
Drumpot - Ecto

Ecto shot and killed

Confirmed village (including Drumpot even if he's not 100% confirmed) are highlighted in bold.

I think the remaining wolves aren't in that list

That's potentially a great spot Mac. Wish I could bookmark this post but I'll come back to it and cross reference the living posters VS this later

duffman13

Jake WW wrote: »

Last nite's votes:

Isla WW (13): MacDanger, Wendy WW, duffman13, Barbara WW, Doris WW, Abigail WW, Senan WW, Orla WW, Steve WW, Eva WW, Spook_ie, Emily WW, Lucy WW
Patrick WW (2): Nigel WW, Katie WW
Barbara WW (2): Isla WW,
Katie WW (2): Conor WW, Holly WW
Conor WW (1): Ewan WW
Derry WW (1): Drumpot
Angus WW (1): Jake WW

I voted for Angus because only he and Derry weren't showing up for the vote and Drumpot had voted for Derry. Bit suss not to vote, but they're both gone now so irrelevant.

Dont know why Derry, as a wolf, wasn't told to post at least a bit in the backroom?Guess they weren't warned about potential modkill?

I'm beginning to wonder on Katie a little bit, with Patrick coming good what are the likelihood of two wolves on Patrick. He nailed 3 for 3 and was on Nigel. Did wolves possibly buy the story Isla couldnt be lynched and chance getting Nigel on a well spread vote by "accident"

Also on the flip of them believing that story from Isla, Katie would have been 2nd in the lynch and if Isla is to be believed she could be at risk.

There is also the possibility of no wolves on the Isla wagon but it was so easy to get on board, would they all avoid it? Maybe fearful we would lynch through the wagon similar to the shooting through Earthlings yesterday