Boards Werewolf: BCU

Isla WW

Emily WW wrote: »

So who are the evils? Am i one now since I voted for you

Originally Posted by Isla WW View Post
Players
My Village
Isla
Emily - mindmelds, top village read.
Nigel - erratic, comes across as villager to me.
Senan - I like senans posts, comes across as virtuous.

most likely wolves.

Holly - Has been lightly pushing the lynch Isla agenda since early yesterday, but not really owning it.
Lucy - Has been pushing the lynch Isla angle lightly, only really owning it last night.
Eva - pushing the perceived easy lynches.

Reminder of my earlier post.

Eva WW

Nigel WW wrote: »

hard support? look at me questioning her above.

left it sitting in the drafts too long, my apologies Nigel

Emily WW

Isla WW wrote: »

The isla wagon sticks of evils.

Why are the remaining villagers on the same waqon as the evils?

I dont believe you. Its not hard to see why right? If Im wrong Im wrong

Emily WW

Sure If I am wrong about Isla, her father will forgive me right.

Im off to watch the passion of the christ so I can get tips on how to best lynch Jesus.

Eva WW

Emily WW wrote: »

Let Nigel back who he wants, hes a big boy

Nigel is at perfect liberty to back whoever he likes but big boys get criticism too

Nigel WW

i believe isla. look at those night 2 votes.

jake and fiona were on different teams.

if isla is bad, she would have voted the other bad player to protect her own team mate

Eva WW

Nigel WW wrote: »

i believe isla. look at those night 2 votes.

jake and fiona were on different teams.

if isla is bad, she would have voted the other bad player to protect her own team mate

Nigel I don't understand what this means? How would Isla know who the other bad player was?

Nigel WW

Eva WW wrote: »

Nigel I don't understand what this means? How would Isla know who the other bad player was?

well that completely ruins that theory! back to the drawing board

Emily WW

Isla, or anyone else, convince me that Isla is Jesus

Nigel WW

Emily WW wrote: »

Isla, or anyone else, convince me that Isla is Jesus

we should believe her unless you believe jesus is dead.

do you believe jesus is dead? and if so, who do you think jesus was?

Eva WW

Nigel WW wrote: »

we should believe her unless you believe jesus is dead.

do you believe jesus is dead? and if so, who do you think jesus was?

Katie

Holly WW

If Isla is the last SK no association really matters.

If Isla is a wolf who are potential partners

Nigel is trying very hard to clear her. I'm not sure a wolf buddy does it so openly.

Vernon is absolutely a possibility, I don't think they interacted all that much.

Emily... it's very possible there. She waited a long time to see how the chips fell before making her decision. I know she was on about waiting for Nigel to post but meh, you can still say what way you're leaning imo

I don't think anyone else fits tbh. Senan voted Isla when he was under serious pressure, that's very very cool to vote a wolf buddy in that circumstance. Lucy went Isla yesterday and has been fairly consistent in pushing her.
Eva I don't see under any circumstances tbh.

Holly WW

Could be that we got Vern wolf last night and Isla is the last wolf. It would tie in with Isla voting late and not interacting with him that I can remember.

But that doesn't make sense as how would she know to claim Jesus

If Isla is evil, she's more likely to be the SK.

So...

Hmmm.

Eva WW

Holly WW wrote: »

If Isla is the last SK no association really matters.

If Isla is a wolf who are potential partners

Nigel is trying very hard to clear her. I'm not sure a wolf buddy does it so openly.

Vernon is absolutely a possibility, I don't think they interacted all that much.

Emily... it's very possible there. She waited a long time to see how the chips fell before making her decision. I know she was on about waiting for Nigel to post but meh, you can still say what way you're leaning imo

I don't think anyone else fits tbh. Senan voted Isla when he was under serious pressure, that's very very cool to vote a wolf buddy in that circumstance. Lucy went Isla yesterday and has been fairly consistent in pushing her.
Eva I don't see under any circumstances tbh.

Isla potentially SK and Nigel potentially a wolf, wouldn't know for sure the other is bad

Holly WW

Eva WW wrote: »

Isla potentially SK and Nigel potentially a wolf, wouldn't know for sure the other is bad

Yeah but why?

Say you're exactly right, Isla is the SK and Nigel is a wolf, why bother saving the opposing team when it could wipe them out


OH OH wait

The wolves need the SK to make another kill

If there are in fact 2 wolves left, lynching the SK tonight means it's LYLO tomorrow (3 v 2 after munch if I have it right)

If they keep the SK alive and kill them overnight, and the SK misses a wolf then it's game over and wolf win

Nigel WW

if isla is the last SK she would have voted fiona night 2 to try to save jake.

is isla is a wolf she have voted jake night 2 to be sure fiona survives.

based on the votes there is no way isla is bad

Lucy WW

Isla WW wrote: »

As I already stated this morning,
Vernon was not SK (SK got a kill)
Katie was not SK (abigail was iced)

There is some sense to this, I just need to figure out if it adds up or if there are holes in it...…..what would be the upshot of this theory Isla? Is it just that the SK is still alive? Or is there more?

Emily WW

Nigel WW wrote: »

we should believe her unless you believe jesus is dead.

do you believe jesus is dead? and if so, who do you think jesus was?

Can Jesus not just be hidden?

Nigel WW

Emily WW wrote: »

Can Jesus not just be hidden?

sure, but there would be a counter i'd say

Holly WW

Emily WW wrote: »

Can Jesus not just be hidden?

Surely he would counter Isla? It's a lock lynch if so and we nail a baddy?

Isla WW

Eva WW wrote: »

Isla potentially SK and Nigel potentially a wolf, wouldn't know for sure the other is bad

If there is only one munch tomorrow, it'll be the SK.

We know SK was alive to perform the munch, and the wolves attacked Abigail, therefore the SK is still alive now.

worst case

4 2 1
lynch me
3 2 1
SK munches village and wolves munch SK. game over, wolves win.

if one wolf left
5 1 1
lynch me
4 1 1
no overlap 2 1 1 then lylo or 3 1 then mylo


if no wolves
6 1
lynch me
5 1
sk munches villager 4 1
lynch wrong 3 1
sk munches villager 2 1
lylo




Lynching me is the wrong move, but we still have a chance.
Hopefully there is only one munch tomorrow, then we have more lynches available.

Lucy WW

Isla WW wrote: »

If there is only one munch tomorrow, it'll be the SK.

We know SK was alive to perform the munch, and the wolves attacked Abigail, therefore the SK is still alive now.

worst case

4 2 1
lynch me
3 2 1
SK munches village and wolves munch SK. game over, wolves win.

if one wolf left
5 1 1
lynch me
4 1 1
no overlap 2 1 1 then lylo or 3 1 then mylo


if no wolves
6 1
lynch me
5 1
sk munches villager 4 1
lynch wrong 3 1
sk munches villager 2 1
lylo




Lynching me is the wrong move, but we still have a chance.
Hopefully there is only one munch tomorrow, then we have more lynches available.

I think we can say for certain that there are at least two baddies remaining:

We know Vernon wasn't the SK (SK got a kill this morning) so at best he was a wolf.

Then this morning, Katie was killed first by the SK, Abigail was killed second by the wolves. So the SK is still alive because the wolves killed Abigail and (at least) one wolf is alive because they munched second

Unless I'm wrong on the above, only one of Katie/Vernon was a baddie. My money would be on Vernon

Nigel WW

i also think senan is good. after me trying to get him lynched that night!

Eva WW

Nigel WW wrote: »

if isla is the last SK she would have voted fiona night 2 to try to save jake.

is isla is a wolf she have voted jake night 2 to be sure fiona survives.

based on the votes there is no way isla is bad

Nigel while what you're saying here makes some sort of sense, Isla put in a vote 6 mins before votes closed and was the last vote. At that point I think it was clear Jake would be lynched, so better to distance herself and vote elsewhere? I don't think I was ever going to get Fiona lynched that night either.

I don't agree that there's no way Isla is bad... but I am waning slightly.
But if I don't lynch Isla tonight it's your head on the block Nigel

Isla WW

Isla WW wrote: »

If there is only one munch tomorrow, it'll be the SK.

We know SK was alive to perform the munch, and the wolves attacked Abigail, therefore the SK is still alive now.

worst case

4 2 1
lynch me
3 2 1
SK munches village and wolves munch SK. game over, wolves win.

if one wolf left
5 1 1
lynch me
4 1 1
no overlap 2 1 1 then lylo or 3 1 then mylo


if no wolves
6 1
lynch me
5 1
sk munches villager 4 1
lynch wrong 3 1
sk munches villager 2 1
lylo




Lynching me is the wrong move, but we still have a chance.
Hopefully there is only one munch tomorrow, then we have more lynches available.

if one wolf left
5 1 1
lynch me
4 1 1
no overlap 2 1 1 then lylo or 3 1 then mylo


That's wrong...

if one wolf left
5 1 1
lynch me
4 1 1
no overlap 2 1 1
2 1 1
lynch wrong and vilage lose
lynch right and village lose
If there is only one wolf, and if there is no overlap in munches, the game is lost.
Only if the last wolf or SK hits each other do we have a chance.

if one of them hits the other, sure, there is a chance in mylo.

Eva WW

Lucy WW wrote: »

I think we can say for certain that there are at least two baddies remaining:

We know Vernon wasn't the SK (SK got a kill this morning) so at best he was a wolf.

Then this morning, Katie was killed first by the SK, Abigail was killed second by the wolves. So the SK is still alive because the wolves killed Abigail and (at least) one wolf is alive because they munched second

Unless I'm wrong on the above, only one of Katie/Vernon was a baddie. My money would be on Vernon

I think you're right about this. Fingers crossed that our wolf teams are Fiona/Vernon/Nigel and SK is Isla/Jake.

Or Fiona/Vernon/Isla and Nigel/Jake.

Eva WW

Holly WW wrote: »

Surely he would counter Isla? It's a lock lynch if so and we nail a baddy?

I agree that if someone has a counter claim that there is zero point hiding it at this point

Isla WW

Lucy WW wrote: »

I think we can say for certain that there are at least two baddies remaining:

We know Vernon wasn't the SK (SK got a kill this morning) so at best he was a wolf.

Then this morning, Katie was killed first by the SK, Abigail was killed second by the wolves. So the SK is still alive because the wolves killed Abigail and (at least) one wolf is alive because they munched second

Unless I'm wrong on the above, only one of Katie/Vernon was a baddie. My money would be on Vernon

Both actions are usually done simultaneous, so its possible that Vernon and Katie were both wolves.

Isla WW

Eva WW wrote: »

I agree that if someone has a counter claim that there is zero point hiding it at this point

I am not hiding because 3 people put votes on me. Senan had intentions of voting me but had not cast vote. I had to come out then.

Eva WW

ok. I'm taking a break for an hour and I'll be back.