Beakerjoe vs The Walrus - THE REVEAL!

phatkev

oh sh1t!

beakerjoe

phatkev wrote: »

oh sh1t!

ShaneU

beakerjoe wrote: »

Very happy with this and you don’t get enough on the first listen. This track is so good, it makes you..... no, compels you to revisit it in order to get the good feels. Very impressed with this.

I listened about ten times in a row when I first heard it!

beakerjoe

In at the end, 19th place and 1 pointy, its....


Imagine Dragons - Thunder, submitted by

JP Liz V1

Have I listened to this artist before? Yes
Have I listened to this song before? Yes

I am not a huge fan of the band, they have their moments, but ultimately they aren't for me. This song is uninspiring for me...... wait Im being nice as Liz is probably reviewing my walrus submissions..... this song is horrible.

The sample used is so grating, which makes it a choir to listen to. It's nothing I would add to my playlist sadly and a miss for me, it feels like a very lazy song and one that would make me change hit next in an instant. Sorry Liz.... it's just one round right.

Looks at the views of this song on Youtube .....YOU PEOPLE SICKEN ME!

beakerjoe

That means that the following track picks up a "massif" 19 points. At number 1, it is......

Brutus - War, submitted by

Phatkev

Have I listened to this artist before? No
Have I listened to this song before? No,

I like the intro, its a nice slow build and the vocalist has a wonderful voice, slightly similar (slightly) to Dolares of the Cranberries. Was disappointed at first that the song didnt kick in.,........then it kicked in.

Fcuk me I am loving this much needed change of pace. Very impressed with the sound, the vocalist steps it up too as we continue, its quite amazing. Defo one for my playlist, love it!

A rollercoaster of a song and I really enjoyed it. It was very close between 1st and 2nd, like apples and organges... I loved them both. However, Brutus just about inched it. A deserved number 1.

JP Liz V1

beakerjoe wrote: »

In at the end, 19th place and 1 pointy, its....

Imagine Dragons - Thunder, submitted by JP Liz V1
Have I listened to this artist before? Yes
Have I listened to this song before?

I am not a huge fan of the band, they have their moments, but ultimately they aren't for me. This song is uninspiring for me...... wait Im being nice as Liz is probably reviewing my walrus submissions..... this song is horrible.

The sample used is so grating, which makes it a choir to listen to. It's nothing I would add to my playlist sadly and a miss for me, it feels like a very lazy song and one that would make me change hit next in an instant. Sorry Liz.... it's just one round right.

Looks at the views of this song on Youtube .....YOU PEOPLE SICKEN ME!

Like the Dail I will be going into isolation, hibernation scarleh for me

beakerjoe

So after round 1, we have the score board.

Phtakev 19 points
ShaneU 18 Points
s1ippy - - 17 Points
Kolido - 16 Points
Mustang shelly - 15 Points
Fixxxer - 14 Points
the purple tin - 13 Points
Gru - 12 Points
Osh - 11 Points
Rikand - 10 Points
Electric Nitwit - 9 Points
Iris Aris - 8 Points
Argus - 7 points
ASLVB - 6 points
Reberetta - 5 Points
Sawduck - 4 Points
Necro - 3 Points
JohnGreenFan - 2 Points
JP Liz V1 - 1 Point

phatkev

beakerjoe wrote: »

That means that the following track picks up a "massif" 19 points. At number 1, it is......

Brutus - War, submitted by

Phatkev

Have I listened to this artist before? No
Have I listened to this song before? No,

I like the intro, its a nice slow build and the vocalist has a wonderful voice, slightly similar (slightly) to Dolares of the Cranberries. Was disappointed at first that the song didnt kick in.,........then it kicked in.

Fcuk me I am loving this much needed change of pace. Very impressed with the sound, the vocalist steps it up too as we continue, its quite amazing. Defo one for my playlist, love it!

A rollercoaster of a song and I really enjoyed it. It was very close between 1st and 2nd, like apples and organges... I loved them both. However, Brutus just about inched it. A deserved number 1.

Woohoo! Glad you liked it! I've only come across they recently and was super impressed with the wall of sound they're able to create as a 3 piece. Also the fact that the vocalist is also the drummer is really impressive, I've seen many a talented musician try and fail this miserably

beakerjoe

phatkev wrote: »

Woohoo! Glad you liked it! I've only come across they recently and was super impressed with the wall of sound they're able to create as a 3 piece. Also the fact that the vocalist is also the drummer is really impressive, I've seen many a talented musician try and fail this miserably

She's a regular Phil Collins.

A wall of sound is a very fitting description, it's a wild ride and happy to buy a ticket again.

Congrats Kev.

Irish Aris

beakerjoe wrote: »

Coming in at number 5 , putting 15 points in their pockets is......

Alice Merton - No Roots, submitted by

Mustang Shelly.

Have I listened to this artist before? No
Have I listened to this song before? No

Really like the intro, very smooth and eases me into the verse nicely. Very funky melody and the voice of Ms Merton (tee hee) reminds me of Florence of The Machine fame. It's an easy listen, my toe is tapping and I quite enjoy it. It hasn't blown me away but it has made its way into my latest playlist. As I get through my first listen it sounds familiar, so I may have heard it before. I really like this.

On further listens its appearing more catchy and encourages me to sing along. The voice of Alice is beautiful and someone I would like to check out more.

Great choice Shelly, I really like her!! Saw her live couple of years ago at Whelan's, she was very pleasant.

Also Starring LeVar Burton

beakerjoe wrote: »

Coming in at number 5 , putting 15 points in their pockets is......

Alice Merton - No Roots, submitted by

Mustang Shelly.

Some great songs put forward, but this one is definitely the discovery of the round for me personally. An instant favourite.

beakerjoe

Also Starring LeVar Burton wrote: »

Some great songs put forward, but this one is definitely the discovery of the round for me personally. An instant favourite.

I knew 3 songs I think, really was enjoyable from my POV. So many new bands in my cross hairs.

Tauriel

I don't know how many times I have wanted to put this song in a walrus only to subsequently forget about it when doing up my list.

With the three walrus' that came up close together, I was determined that she would fit into one. I'm glad this song has gone down well, it's a very nice, catchy tune and her voice is amazing.

beakerjoe

So do you all agree with my ratings?

While you discuss the first round, the next round shall hopefully begin tomorrow around 1130am , that ok?

Sorry the first round was all over the shop in terms of revealing. Real life kicked my behind

fixXxer

Well I think my song was clearly best. Apart from that I'd say spot on! Maybe put Necro last in one of the upcoming categories just to be safe.

beakerjoe

I can easily say in terms of one round, my goal to get awesome new music and broaden my horizons has been completed.

And thats just one round. Some great tracks have been discovered all the way through.

Reberetta

I could not think of any songs from the last five years. I just went for the Daddy Yankee & Janet Jackson collaboration. I don't listen to it even semi-regularly and I don't know who Daddy Yankee is but I thought to myself "Decent tune, this will do!":pac:

beakerjoe

Round 2 will begin later this morning. Lots of songs which haven't graced my ears, from bands I didnt know I existed.

1130am..... its on

Also Starring LeVar Burton

If this is the music video round, I'm fully prepared to be in last place. Don't really watch enough music videos and I definitely panicked a little with my choice.

beakerjoe

Also Starring LeVar Burton wrote: »

If this is the music video round, I'm fully prepared to be in last place. Don't really watch enough music videos and I definitely panicked a little with my choice.

On that note this was a fun round, I feel I got double the treats with some new and very enjoyable tunes, plus a wide variety of different videos.

Are we ready?

Electric Nitwit

Yeah, I struggled with this round too. I never watch videos, I had to go back to mtv days!

Who's that band with the treadmills in one vid, and the zero G plane in another? I presume we'll see them

Also Starring LeVar Burton

Electric Nitwit wrote: »

Yeah, I struggled with this round too. I never watch videos, I had to go back to mtv days!

Who's that band with the treadmills in one vid, and the zero G plane in another? I presume we'll see them

OK Go.
I did consider them myself, but figured other people would too and wanted to go for something a bit less obvious.

beakerjoe

In at 10th post , with 10 pointarinnos, its...

The Gaslamp Killer - In the dark, submitted by

Phatkev

Have I listened to this artist before? No
Have I listened to this song before? No,

A haunting piece, very Massive Attack-esque, or maybe DJ Shadow like. Its very well paced and it’s a satisfying listen

The video compliments it very well. Its visually stunning and the song. I wont lie, I have an urge for a 99 after watching it, I dont know why!?!

Overall its a great piece with a suited video, it would have placed higher but for other submissions

beakerjoe

In at 11th spot with 9 pointos, its

Red Vex - Itch -, submitted by

Reberetta.

Have I listened to this artist before? no
Have I listened to this song before? No

The song for me is very familiar, it reminds me of another track I just can't put my finger on.

After my first listen I get “if Alanis Morrissette had a nu-metal band” vibes. It also has hints of Chester Benningtons “Why wont you die”, but thats not the track it reminds me of. Fake bonus point for helping me figure this track out.

But I ramble. I like the track. Its something i clearly missed out in my youth. The video suits and its very par for the course for when it was released, but does it improve the song….. I think not.

The track is a fine addition to my playlist. It brings me right back to Fibbers. (is that a good thing though?)

Irish Aris

Also Starring LeVar Burton wrote: »

If this is the music video round, I'm fully prepared to be in last place. Don't really watch enough music videos and I definitely panicked a little with my choice.

Electric Nitwit wrote: »

Yeah, I struggled with this round too. I never watch videos, I had to go back to mtv days!

Who's that band with the treadmills in one vid, and the zero G plane in another? I presume we'll see them

I think I might also be in contention for the last place. I took a big gamble with a song in a foreign language, so don't expect much. . .

beakerjoe

Irish Aris wrote: »

I think I might also be in contention for the last place. I took a big gamble with a song in a foreign language, so don't expect much. . .

beakerjoe

In at 9th spot, collecting 11 points in the process .....

JSBX - Wail, submitted by

Rikand

Have I listened to this artist before? No
Have I listened to this song before? No

Weird Al is directing you say? Sign me up.

So first you have DNCE…..now JSBX…. I notice a trend here.

I like this song immediately, it has a great sound and it's a nice driving song (my first listen I was behind the wheel.) I'm not able to make out every lyric, but I am partial to a song that is not fully clear. Gives me scope to sing what I like.

The lead singer gives me a nice OTT Elvis homage to his performance (or parody, whichever) which has me enjoying the overall sound.

Does the video improve it? Its a fun video, its a fun song and the visual madness does compliment the tune very well. An enjoyable listen.

beakerjoe

In at 12th position, collecting 8 points is....

Sledgehammer - Peter Gabriel submitted by

Osh.

Have I listened to this artist before? Yes
Have I listened to this song before? Yes

Ah nostalgic 80’s track and video. Groundbreaking at the time (well for me anyway) and I still love watching this track. The song itself is fun track and the video certainly enhances it. Am I he only person who tries to mimic Gabriels movements when I heard the track ?


Overall its a song I enjoy, but with tough competition, this one wont be placing any higher sadly.

Irish Aris

beakerjoe wrote: »

In at 12th position, collecting 8 points is....

Sledgehammer - Peter Gabriel submitted by

Osh.

Have I listened to this artist before? Yes
Have I listened to this song before? Yes

Ah nostalgic 80’s track and video. Groundbreaking at the time (well for me anyway) and I still love watching this track. The song itself is fun track and the video certainly enhances it. Am I he only person who tries to mimic Gabriels movements when I heard the track ?


Overall its a song I enjoy, but with tough competition, this one wont be placing any higher sadly.

Ah, a classic indeed.
Some great selections so far. I'm putting down The Gaslamp Killer and JSBX for further investigation.

beakerjoe

8th spot, with a smooth 12 points is....

November rain - Guns N’ Roses, submitted by

ShaneU

Have I listened to this artist before? yes
Have I listened to this song before? yes

While Im sure Its not a popular opinion I didnt like this when it was first released. It was no Welcome to the Jungle or Paradise City .... or even You will be mine for that matter. Yet people loved it. (cue backlash from boardies everywhere).

As I grew, I appreciated it more as my taste evolved and I believe it to be a fine track, in which Slash excels.

The video is iconic, its pure 80’s band bollox and I love it.

Over all I enjoy it, but other songs will push it down my ranking sadly

beakerjoe

13th position, picking up 7 points is.......(as predicted)

OK GO - Here it goes again- submitted by

Kolido

Have I listened to this artist before? Yes
Have I listened to this song before? yes

A song I know very well. A fun, high energy track and with a decent sound. It's nothing that ever wowed me though, despite it being enjoyable. But it is a song I do like.

The video is impressive and very enjoyable, as are most OK GO videos. It adds to the song no doubt and makes the song more memorable.

A good song, with an enjoyable video but nothing more.

Tauriel

Surely Christopher Walken will make an appearance....

beakerjoe

13 points goes to 7th spot, which is......

The 1975 - Girls submitted by

Also Starring Le Var Burton

Have I listened to this artist before? Yes
Have I listened to this song before? No

I know of the band, but no nothing about their work. I toyed with placing GnR higher as its so iconic, but this song deserved its due. Yeah its not a huge mega track, but its very enjoyable for different reasons.

I enjoy this. Its a simple riff and a simple vocals, its nothing grand, but it works. Its easy going and its a fine track.

The video is cute. Again, its a simple concept but simple works and the video does enhance my overall experience.

A track that would place higher but for other, better submissions. A good song IMO

Electric Nitwit

mustang shelly wrote: »

Surely Christopher Walken will make an appearance....

beakerjoe

Settling in at 14th spot, gaining a 6 point allocation, it is....

Weezer - Pork and Beans , submitted by

Gru

Have I listened to this artist before? Yes
Have I listened to this song before? Yes

I like Weezer, very easy to listen to and this track is typical Weezer. A song I happily have on my active playlist.

The video is a nice homage to internet fads (remember the Britney one, eeek.... and was that K-Fed?) and its quite a decent video, esp at the climax.

While I like the track, there are better entries this round to keep it from placing higher. Its good, but not great.

beakerjoe

6th place, winning 14 points in the process, is.....

Mylene Farmer - California , submitted by

Irish Aris

Have I listened to this artist before? No
Have I listened to this song before? No

A beautiful track, well paced with soft, delicate vocals. Its very smooth to listen to and the accompanying video is captivating to say the least. Very impressed with this unknown to me artist.

Overall its a nice combo to artistic imagery, interesting story and an easy to listen to sound. Nice choice.

Also Starring LeVar Burton

beakerjoe wrote: »

13 points goes to 7th spot, which is......

The 1975 - Girls submitted by

Also Starring Le Var Burton

Have I listened to this artist before? Yes
Have I listened to this song before? No


I know of the band, but no nothing about their work. I toyed with placing GnR higher as its so iconic, but this song deserved its due. Yeah its not a huge mega track, but its very enjoyable for different reasons.

I enjoy this. Its a simple riff and a simple vocals, its nothing grand, but it works. Its easy going and its a fine track.

The video is cute. Again, its a simple concept but simple works and the video does enhance my overall experience.

A track that would place higher but for other, better submissions. A good song IMO

Considering I was gearing myself up for last place, I'm damn happy with 7th place here. Wasn't sure if the song would go down well, as its definitely a bit of a "marmite" song.

beakerjoe

15th position, with a 5 point haul, it's...

Fountains of Wayne - Staceys Mom, submitted by

Sawduck

Have I listened to this artist before? Yes
Have I listened to this song before? Yes

Now I don't hate this song despite its placing, its fine. Its easy to sing along to but I feel its just performs badly compared to the other tracks submitted. Its goofy, funny and easy to listen but its not going to knock others above it from their perches.

The video is what it is, it fits the song perfectly and I don't think any other video would do it justice. A fun romp.

osh

I changed to this one beaker, no matter

beakerjoe

Really sorry I didn't get an entry in for this BJ, I had intended to but pesky real life just got in the way.

Am enjoying being a lurker here though, lots of new stuff to look forward to when time allows. I might even PM you on a belated "what would have been my entry" when you're finished, help with the Walrus withdrawals a little!

beakerjoe wrote: »

Propping up 4th spot, swirling in 16 points......

LP - Lost on you - submitted by

Kolido

Have I listened to this artist before? No
Have I listened to this song before? No


I like the vocals and it’s pleasing my ears initially. By the time we hit the chorus, I feel the song improves and meets its potential. On repeatedly listens the song continues to please me. Very No Doubt/Gwen Stefani sound from this. An enjoyable listen.

Its a perfect song for a day lounging at the front porch in the sun…..why do I live in Ireland. Look forward to researching the artist.

Lovely choice. I'd also recommend checking out her live performance of this on Jools Holland. Her voice is astonishing, she can actually do that whistling thing in the verses and those remarkable high notes in the bridge even without studio trickery.

I saw her perform live at The Academy in Dublin a few years ago, back in the days when live gigs were still a thing.

Irish Aris

beakerjoe wrote: »

6th place, winning 14 points in the process, is.....

Mylene Farmer - California , submitted by

Irish Aris

Have I listened to this artist before? No
Have I listened to this song before? No


A beautiful track, well paced with soft, delicate vocals. Its very smooth to listen to and the accompanying video is captivating to say the least. Very impressed with this unknown to me artist.

Overall its a nice combo to artistic imagery, interesting story and an easy to listen to sound. Nice choice.

Glad you liked it beakerjoe.
Fun fact: the video was directed by American director Abel Ferrara, who in the 90s worked extensively with Christopher Walken and Harvey Keitel - the latter was very impressive in Bad Lieutenant.

beakerjoe

15 points goes to 5th place, and it that spot is,

Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers - Last dance with Mary Jane, submitted by

the purple tin

Have I listened to this artist before? Yes
Have I listened to this song before? No

Now I can get on board with this, its got a nice melody, smooth riffs and a good chorus. How have I never heard this before. It transitions nicely and is anything but a choir to listen to, especially as the guitar solo kicks in at the end. (why did it end there ?)

The video doesn't suit it at all though in my opinion. Nothing wrong with the video, it is just not what I expected and it didn't enhance it for me.

beakerjoe

osh wrote: »

I changed to this one beaker, no matter

God Osh, I have done you a disservice here.

I worked off your original list and forgot about your update.

All i can say is thats on me, my bad. I am a fan of Star Guitar, would be believe I never saw the video. I am a big CB fan. It probably would have ranked higher than your previous entry, not too much though.

I still did you wrong and all I can do now is apologies.

Irish Aris

beakerjoe wrote: »

15 points goes to 5th place, and it that spot is,

Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers - Last dance with Mary Jane, submitted by

the purple tin

Have I listened to this artist before? Yes
Have I listened to this song before? No

Now I can get on board with this, its got a nice melody, smooth riffs and a good chorus. How have I never heard this before. It transitions nicely and is anything but a choir to listen to, especially as the guitar solo kicks in at the end. (why did it end there ?)

The video doesn't suit it at all though in my opinion. Nothing wrong with the video, it is just not what I expected and it didn't enhance it for me.

ah, excellent choice, purple tin.
A great song - and Kim Basinger looks stunning in the video!!

beakerjoe

In at 16th place, notching up 5 Points is

Gotye - Someone I used to know, submitted by

Fixxxer

Have I listened to this artist before? Yes
Have I listened to this song before? Yes

Man this is a good song I liked it way back when, but the fact it was so overplayed did it huge damage. I got sick of it years ago, but I did initially like it. But sadly for fixxxer, my ears aren't fond of it now.

The video suits it well, simple yet visually pleasing but it cant make up for the damage done years before your submission.

osh

beakerjoe wrote: »

God Osh, I have done you a disservice here.

I worked off your original list and forgot about your update.

All i can say is thats on me, my bad. I am a fan of Star Guitar, would be believe I never saw the video. I am a big CB fan. It probably would have ranked higher than your previous entry, not too much though.

I still did you wrong and all I can do now is apologies.

No worries at all man, at least you've now seen the video

It's pretty cool, all the things in the scenery are lined up to match the beats of the music

beakerjoe

In at 4th position, gaining 16 points, is.....


See you again - Wiz Khailifa and Charlie Puth submitted by

JP Liz V1

Have I listened to this artist before? Yes
Have I listened to this song before? Yes

Ah this song gets me every time. A wonderful blend of rap and beautiful vocals, swirled together with a subtle piano melody. I really enjoy this track and the video and the circumstances around it will always play on my emotions.

Im a fan of the movies and while they are mindless fun, you get an emotional connection to the characters, thanks to the chemistry between the cast. It makes the video here very sad and I cant not appreciate it.

(wipes tears) A good choice Liz.

beakerjoe

The sinister six for this round are as follows:

Necro
Mustang Shelly
JohnGreenFan
S1ippy
Electric Nitwit
Arghus

Necro

Here I Go Again On My Own...

Electric Nitwit

Necro wrote: »

Here I Go Again On My Own...

You're never alone in Forum Games, Necro


...unless you're last