Supernatural Werewolf GAME THREAD

Derry WW

Vernon WW wrote: »

Can I make a suggestion

We have a village vig shot coming today. Can we leave Senan to that person.

That we get a Lynch that’s voted for by everyone, get some wagonomics and don’t have one person deciding who gets killed

Think that's a good call Vernon

Clodagh WW

Not everyone has posted Wendy, think there are 3/4 yet to post.

Holly WW 51
Oisin WW 30
Vernon WW 28
Derry WW 24
Angus WW 23
Jake WW 22
Nigel WW 17
Clodagh WW 16
Desmond WW 16
Patrick WW 13
Wendy WW 12
Eva WW 9
Senan WW 6
Tegan WW 6
Mary WW 6
Frank WW 4
Gertrude WW 3
Phil WW 2
Steve WW 2
Katie WW 1

Vernon WW

Oisin WW wrote: »

Just reading back the thread and I want to acknowledge that Angus was the first to say that evil = good. Frank then agreed. Vernon mentioned it next.

My earlier post makes it sound like Vernon was the first to say it and I don’t want Angus to feel like I ignored him saying it first

I thought I was too but a reread has Angus saying it. I was the first to say I was an evil FWIW

Wendy WW

Vernon WW wrote: »

Can I make a suggestion

We have a village vig shot coming today. Can we leave Senan to that person.

That we get a Lynch that’s voted for by everyone, get some wagonomics and don’t have one person deciding who gets killed

Is that not at the same time as the lynch though? So if the shot is blocked it would be a missed kill of a confirmed baddie.

Nigel WW

Jake WW wrote: »

Sorry is this written or did you come across it online?

in the op

Eva WW

I'd be looking at Derry and Angus following on if Holly's legit tbh! Wolfie

Wendy WW

Oisin WW wrote: »

Still to post
Abigail WW
Conor WW
Emily WW
Gabriel WW

Clodagh WW wrote: »

Not everyone has posted Wendy, think there are 3/4 yet to post.

Holly WW 51
Oisin WW 30
Vernon WW 28
Derry WW 24
Angus WW 23
Jake WW 22
Nigel WW 17
Clodagh WW 16
Desmond WW 16
Patrick WW 13
Wendy WW 12
Eva WW 9
Senan WW 6
Tegan WW 6
Mary WW 6
Frank WW 4
Gertrude WW 3
Phil WW 2
Steve WW 2
Katie WW 1

Thanks am playing on the phone so can't look properly

Eva WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

Is that not at the same time as the lynch though? So if the shot is blocked it would be a missed kill of a confirmed baddie.

Is it? Didnt see specifics in the OP! Where did you see that? I must be going blind

Wendy WW

Eva WW wrote: »

Is it? Didnt see specifics in the OP! Where did you see that? I must be going blind

From the op:

There will be a second munch each night which is competed for by all of the evil teams with the exception of the Shapeshifters - details of the contest have been provided where required.

Each night, so I assumed it happened the same time as the other night kills - lynches. If it doesn't then it happens after the lynch in the night phase so could still end up as a missed killed

Clodagh WW

Might need a bit of context there though vernon. I will admit that I didn't twig the evil teams = villager in the beginning, but my post was challenging your assertions about the shapeshifters and something in the OP about the evil teams. I hadn't at the time considered that the evil teams might be villagers because I've not played with village teams before.

Vernon WW wrote: »

Hi guys, just checking in


So looking like Hunters are wolves, shapeshifter is the SK and everyone else is village

Nice and confusing. Can I suggest a ban on the word “evil”

Clodagh WW wrote: »

Don't know if that's right Vernon. OP says each of the evils teams, excluding the shapeshifters, have the chance for a second kill. Seems like three bad teams, hunters, shapeshifters and evils. The op also mentions shapeshifters so don't think they are a lone SK.

Eva WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

From the op:



Each night, so I assumed it happened the same time as the other night kills - lynches. If it doesn't then it happens after the lynch in the night phase so could still end up as a missed killed

Thats about a second munch, not a vig! Do we even have a vig? In a role heavy game you'd presume so

Nigel WW

Holly WW wrote: »

Soooooo. Frank turned up as evil. Which makes him good. Senan turned up as a Hunter. Which makes him bad.

*shakes head quietly

was there 2 peeks?

Patrick WW

Guys, i get the logic behind leaving senan to the vig, but the golden rule stands.

Catch a wolf, kill a wolf!

Clodagh WW

Again context Vernon, I was challenging Eva's call on their being two teams. I said there had to be at least 3 for the OP to have made sense. I got the make-up of the teams wrong though.

Eva WW wrote: »

So evils are villagers
Hunters and Shapeshifters are wolves on seperate teams?

Clodagh WW wrote: »

From OP
There will be a second munch each night which is competed for by all of the evil teams with the exception of the Shapeshifters - details of the contest have been provided where required.

There has to be at least three bad teams. I'm going with evils, hunters and shapeshifters. Although maybe there are two teams of hunters.

Clodagh WW

Nigel WW wrote: »

was there 2 peeks?

Frank be dead

Wendy WW

Eva WW wrote: »

Thats about a second munch, not a vig! Do we even have a vig? In a role heavy game you'd presume so

It was mentioned earlier in the thread that this will be like a vig kill, as it is competed for by villagers

Nigel WW

Vernon WW wrote: »

Can I make a suggestion

We have a village vig shot coming today. Can we leave Senan to that person.

That we get a Lynch that’s voted for by everyone, get some wagonomics and don’t have one person deciding who gets killed

not a bad idea. i'm terrible at these games and wagonomivs are always a welcome help.

Wendy WW

Nigel WW wrote: »

was there 2 peeks?

No Franks death notice stated he was evil

Eva WW

Patrick WW wrote: »

Guys, i get the logic behind leaving senan to the vig, but the golden rule stands.

Catch a wolf, kill a wolf!

I dont think anyone is advocating otherwise. The idea being put out is the vig kill him and we reset and have a good wagonomics info going forward

Eva WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

It was mentioned earlier in the thread that this will be like a vig kill, as it is competed for by villagers

Odd wording to say competing for a munch! Villagers don't munch

Holly WW

It's a good summary Vernon.

But, to be totally honest, I wasn't so sure of the alignments when I made that table.

But the pile you put me in is correct.

Phil WW

Desmond WW wrote: »

Seriously, someone's going to have to explain this game to me like they would to a 5 year old. Totally lost

I feel a bit like Dessie here

Athough our Holls seems to have made it a bit more simple. The one that died was a NRV then going by what we think?

Seenan hasn't answered anything on Hollys peek (great peeking Holly)

With the kill rate this could be over by Wednesday!
I would prefer to lynch Seenan and not take a Vig shot, if Sennan turns out to be team village, the vig shoots Holly? But I think she is on the level.

Oisin WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

It was mentioned earlier in the thread that this will be like a vig kill, as it is competed for by villagers

I said that because even though it’s at much time tomorrow it will be the goodies doing it so it’s similar to a vigilante rather than a baddie.

Patrick WW

Eva WW wrote: »

I dont think anyone is advocating otherwise. The idea being put out is the vig kill him and we reset and have a good wagonomics info going forward

eh that's exactly what people are saying...

someone said it earlier. Vig shots can be blocked or protected against. Lynch cannot. If we don't kill him with lynch then he could survive...

I agree that wagonomics would be great, but even better is actually ensuring a wolf get's killed!

Nigel WW

the wagon firmly on senan thus far.

Nigel WW

Clodagh WW wrote: »

Frank be dead

so whats the working theory here. a mod kill just to get the game going, or killed by a team.

to answer my own question, looks like a legit kill given frank had 4 posts

Oisin WW

Who thinks there will be a shot before tonight’s lynch?

I’m inclined to think it will be
Lynch
2 munches (one of the munches from the goodies)

Oisin WW

Oisin WW wrote: »

Who thinks there will be a shot before tonight’s lynch?

I’m inclined to think it will be
Lynch & shapeshifters
2 munches (one of the munches from the goodies)

Edited to add the shifters.

Wendy WW

Nigel WW wrote: »

so whats the working theory here. a mod kill just to get the game going, or killed by a team.

to answer my own question, looks like a legit kill given frank had 4 posts

It was a legit kill, in this game the villagers are called evil. The wolves are called Hunters and the SK is the shapeshifter

Nigel WW

Oisin WW wrote: »

Who thinks there will be a shot before tonight’s lynch?

I’m inclined to think it will be
Lynch
2 munches (one of the munches from the goodies)

why would there be a shot?

if the vig is going to kill senan, better it it well in advance of much so its not a cluster****. though, that may not be a bad thing