Supernatural Werewolf GAME THREAD

Derry WW · 21-10-2020 10:52am

I agree with Tegan that Katie is unlikely to be a shapeshifter based on Conor's vote last night, but it doesn't mean she's not a hunter.

The sheer amount of subs in this game is making it very difficult to keep track of people.

Patrick WW · 21-10-2020 10:53am

Angus WW wrote: »

It’s possible. We also don’t know how many sks are in the game so with one dead it may be moot yet. Lots of questions we need to work out today and numbers aren’t great at this stage - it’s possible that there’s 4 baddies and no sk left in which case we’re In endgame

Good point on the SK.

nigel... was your power replicated before or after the Shapeshifter was killed?

Phil WW · 21-10-2020 10:54am

Nigel WW wrote: »

just in case i die...

phil replicated my powers

I honestly have no idea what you are talking about

Patrick WW · 21-10-2020 10:58am

Derry WW wrote: »

Posts are as follows:

1. I think any angels out there should be careful about giving names on angel radio--->dont forget the hunters have an angel too who could mayb listen in???

2. We should look closer at Jake, Clodagh, Katie and Angus. They're all a little suss and are getting a free ride. Angus has been off the mark on his ffas. I could cast a vote for Angus tonight, not sure. Where is Katie?

3. Does anyone know what the hell a leviathan is and what it does? The OP doesn't elaborate much.

You and Phil are the only two people who have used the word suss in the entire thread.

wonder if this is an implication of phil?

I only twigged, because it's not a word I ever use and it never really sits right with me when people say it.

Nigel WW · 21-10-2020 11:01am

Patrick WW wrote: »

Good point on the SK.

nigel... was your power replicated before or after the Shapeshifter was killed?

i got a message after 9 last night saying phil had replicated my powers.

Nigel WW · 21-10-2020 11:02am

if conor pretended to be phil to replicate, conor would have survived that bullet.

Patrick WW · 21-10-2020 11:02am

Tegan WW wrote: »

Here's last night's votes and explanations given at the time as best as I can make them out, apologies if I've missed anything:

Tegan (1713) Nigel (1) based on him saying Hunters = good and also not using his shot yesterday when Senan had been peeked.
Patrick (1746) Abi (1) based on her genie
Derry (1814) Abi (2) Doesn't say at the time but it's around when he has asked Abi about the poke and she hasn't explained it. Later FFA at 1834 puts Abi to the top of it for coasting.
Katie (1834) Mary (1) agrees with Derry's questions about Mary (haven't had time to dig out what these Qs were). Emily comments that she's made one post and voted for a dead person
Katie (1848) switches off dead Mary to Abi (3) No explaination on thread even though she posts around then (1851)
Emily (1853) Katie (1) "I can't believe Katie has voted for Abigail. She hasn't even read the thread"
Nigel (1903) Tegan (1) Follows Angus's theory below about my questions
Angus (1907) Tegan (2) Because I was fishing about Nigel's shot, Angus thought I might be the SK
Phil (1935) Abi (4) Because Abi was looking "a bit suss"
Jake (1940) Derry (1) Can't see an on thread explanation at the time of vote
Abi (1959) Derry (2) Can't see an on thread explanation at the time of vote
Clodagh (2003) Derry (3) Because she doesn't agree with him voting for Abi based on her genie
Angus (2015) switches off Tegan to Katie (2) Names 3 (Nigel, Emily, Katie) as players who ignored Des's slip
Conor (2040) Katie (3) Conor # 2 apopears at 2039 and immediately votes Katie with no explanation. I'd be happy to say Katie's definitely not team SS based on that
Wendy (2045) Katie (4) Can't see an on thread explanation at the time of vote
Gertie (2050) Katie (5) Basically votes Katie because she believes Derry & Emily
Gabriel (2050) Nigel (2) Can't see an on thread explanation at the time of vote
Emily (2054) switches off Katie to Abi (5) Because Abi was part of the Derry wagon

the last minute emily switch really doesn't sit well with me. She'd been giving out that people had started voting for her because she genied, and that it was an easy wagon. then she jumps on last minute?

Patrick WW · 21-10-2020 11:03am

Nigel WW wrote: »

if conor pretended to be phil to replicate, conor would have survived that bullet.

so that more or less confirms at least one additional SK

Angus WW · 21-10-2020 11:04am

ok. We're all afraid to claim, so we dont know the state of play. lets try something

24 players started the game. 6 are hunters leaves 18. Lets assume 2 shapeshifters (no reason except the math works as you'll see). That leaves 16

The OP roles for village are as follows:

Archangels
Ghosts
Leviathans
Angels
Red Eyed Demons (Team MacLeod)
Yellow-Eyed Demons (Team Azazel)
Horsemen
Shapeshifters
Ghostfacers

That's 8 excluding shapeshifters

Based on Abi I'm assuming (again cause the math works) that each role is a team of 2. So lets see what we have left. I suggest the following:

If you have lost a teammate (ie a shared role) post to indicate
If you haven't lost a teammate also indicate this
And if you didnt know there were teamates as you sat alone like billy no mates also indicate this

I figure we may be able to get a steer on what we still have in the tank going into the endgame. Not going to force this on people so happy to discuss before we start giving the info out

Katie WW · 21-10-2020 11:06am

Tegan WW wrote: »

Here's last night's votes and explanations given at the time as best as I can make them out, apologies if I've missed anything:

Tegan (1713) Nigel (1) based on him saying Hunters = good and also not using his shot yesterday when Senan had been peeked.
Patrick (1746) Abi (1) based on her genie
Derry (1814) Abi (2) Doesn't say at the time but it's around when he has asked Abi about the poke and she hasn't explained it. Later FFA at 1834 puts Abi to the top of it for coasting.
Katie (1834) Mary (1) agrees with Derry's questions about Mary (haven't had time to dig out what these Qs were). Emily comments that she's made one post and voted for a dead person
Katie (1848) switches off dead Mary to Abi (3) No explaination on thread even though she posts around then (1851)
Emily (1853) Katie (1) "I can't believe Katie has voted for Abigail. She hasn't even read the thread"
Nigel (1903) Tegan (1) Follows Angus's theory below about my questions
Angus (1907) Tegan (2) Because I was fishing about Nigel's shot, Angus thought I might be the SK
Phil (1935) Abi (4) Because Abi was looking "a bit suss"
Jake (1940) Derry (1) Can't see an on thread explanation at the time of vote
Abi (1959) Derry (2) Can't see an on thread explanation at the time of vote
Clodagh (2003) Derry (3) Because she doesn't agree with him voting for Abi based on her genie
Angus (2015) switches off Tegan to Katie (2) Names 3 (Nigel, Emily, Katie) as players who ignored Des's slip
Conor (2040) Katie (3) Conor # 2 apopears at 2039 and immediately votes Katie with no explanation. I'd be happy to say Katie's definitely not team SS based on that
Wendy (2045) Katie (4) Can't see an on thread explanation at the time of vote
Gertie (2050) Katie (5) Basically votes Katie because she believes Derry & Emily
Gabriel (2050) Nigel (2) Can't see an on thread explanation at the time of vote
Emily (2054) switches off Katie to Abi (5) Because Abi was part of the Derry wagon

Nice table. In defense of old katie, she did make a post about abigail being evasive in regard to the accusations. Youre just copying and pasting the falsity being claimed by emily there.

Katie WW wrote: »

Abigail needs to be facing down her accusers imo. It's not a good look.

I've edited out the rest of the post, just to highlight the abigail bit

Jake WW · 21-10-2020 11:09am

Emily WW wrote: »

LISTEN UP VILLAGE

I was the one who killed Steve the hunter.

More will be revealed tomorrow. It's important you do not kill me!

Waiting for Emily to explain this

Jake WW · 21-10-2020 11:12am

Angus WW wrote: »

Based on Abi I'm assuming (again cause the math works) that each role is a team of 2. So lets see what we have left. I suggest the following:

If you have lost a teammate (ie a shared role) post to indicate
If you haven't lost a teammate also indicate this
And if you didnt know there were teamates as you sat alone like billy no mates also indicate this

I figure we may be able to get a steer on what we still have in the tank going into the endgame. Not going to force this on people so happy to discuss before we start giving the info out

Well ye know I lost Abigail so that is one team

Derry WW · 21-10-2020 11:14am

Patrick WW wrote: »

You and Phil are the only two people who have used the word suss in the entire thread.

wonder if this is an implication of phil?

I only twigged, because it's not a word I ever use and it never really sits right with me when people say it.

I never even twigged that to be honest because I do say it. Good catch

Derry WW · 21-10-2020 11:15am

Nigel WW wrote: »

if conor pretended to be phil to replicate, conor would have survived that bullet.

...so you tried to shoot Katie and failed.
Someone replicated your powers which would allow them to shoot or be protected, you were told it was Phil, and Phil says it wasn't

hmmmm

Angus WW · 21-10-2020 11:17am

Katie WW wrote: »

I'm trying to think of a way to describe without claiming and I cant, so I'm just going to say "that depends"

I'll get back to you on this one

would appreciate that, mainly trying to fit people against the relationships from the OP, but its risky since we cant afford to lead the hunters to a ghostfaceer for example

Derry WW · 21-10-2020 11:17am

Patrick WW wrote: »

the last minute emily switch really doesn't sit well with me. She'd been giving out that people had started voting for her because she genied, and that it was an easy wagon. then she jumps on last minute?

yes I thought it was a bit suss, and her reasoning a bit soft

Nigel WW · 21-10-2020 11:18am

Derry WW wrote: »

...so you tried to shoot Katie and failed.
Someone replicated your powers which would allow them to shoot or be protected, you were told it was Phil, and Phil says it wasn't

hmmmm

dont think i ever said 'or'.

Derry WW · 21-10-2020 11:19am

Nigel WW wrote: »

dont think i ever said 'or'.

you didn't.but that wasn't the point I'm getting at. so you can shoot and be protected.

Derry WW · 21-10-2020 11:20am

I'll be gone from 11:45 to 2:15 in meetings so please don't do anything mental while I am gone

Angus WW · 21-10-2020 11:23am

I wish for a correct full role peek too

Tegan WW · 21-10-2020 11:27am

@ Nigel, since Phil has supposedly "replicated" your powers rather than stolen them, does that mean you still have them? i.e. do both of ye have your powers?

Katie WW · 21-10-2020 11:31am

Not sure how I feel about it angus. I think if you still have a teammate you shouldnt say that you do because that could make you a target for the wolves/neutrals who might be targeting teams ?

Not saying I have one, but if I do/did have one they may be alive still but that's not saying I have one. Cryptic enough wolves ?

It's probably safe to say if your teammate has died though

Phil WW · 21-10-2020 11:33am

Nigel WW wrote: »

didnt think of that. maybe XXXXXX appeared as phil when my powers were replicated.

With the whole twisted thing in this game, I can only think something is afoot. I have not replicated Nigel, I just can't work it out. When I get home later I will do my best. But race me tonight and see how it goes, we might get good info. That is all I can suggest.

Necro · 21-10-2020 11:40am

Mod Announcement:

Jake WW has been Smited by the Mark of Cain

He is now DEAD

Jake WW was

Evil

Angus WW · 21-10-2020 11:41am

Ok, I have a theory, but I don't know if I can share it completely yet.

@Katie do you have any special protections?

Angus WW · 21-10-2020 11:43am

Necro wrote: »

Mod Announcement:

Jake WW has been Smited by the Mark of Cain

He is now DEAD

Jake WW was
Evil

Oh dear god I hope that was a kill by the Hunters or shapeshifters

Cause if any villager took it upon themselves to just kill a player who had been peeked as village they need their head looked at

Nigel WW · 21-10-2020 11:44am

Angus WW wrote: »

Oh dear god I hope that was a kill by the Hunters or shapeshifters

Cause if any villager took it upon themselves to just kill a player who had been peeked as village they need their head looked at

that was my power, smiting with the mark of cain

Angus WW · 21-10-2020 11:45am

Nigel WW wrote: »

that was my power, smiting with the mark of cain

so why the hell did you use it on Jake

or are you saying someone else did?

Nigel WW · 21-10-2020 11:46am

Angus WW wrote: »

so why the hell did you use it on Jake

or are you saying someone else did?

phil (or possibly someone else) used it.

i tried to use it on katie

Phil WW · 21-10-2020 11:48am

Nigel WW wrote: »

phil (or possibly someone else) used it.

i tried to use it on katie

Don't you think that would be stupid? Like seriously. Something isn't right and something/someone is trying to stitch me up.

Supernatural Werewolf GAME THREAD

Comments