Werewolf: Father Ted 2 GAME THREAD

LadySkunk

Deleted User wrote: »

I couldn't be any clearer.

I've talked ye through things step by step.


I'm surprised I haven't gotten a warning from the mods for being so open.

I won a prize...I bricked Jake

I said I was going to shoot Whippy...dead


I mean, how more transparent can I be without sacrificing the entire spirit of the game?

Trigger

[Deleted User] wrote: »

I couldn't be any clearer.

I've talked ye through things step by step.


I'm surprised I haven't gotten a warning from the mods for being so open.

I won a prize...I bricked Jake

I said I was going to shoot Whippy...dead


I mean, how more transparent can I be without sacrificing the entire spirit of the game?

More about the bJ part of the post H2.

Probably way off here but the only way I can see that being the truth is that you won 3 prizes in the raffle, 2 shots and a peek, you could probably give them away if you wanted to but as it was day one you kept all 3 to yourself, which is fair enough if you have no reads on anyone else.

JP Liz V1

Deleted User wrote: »

I'd like to thank the inhabitants of Craggy Island for the warmth in which you've received me.

Alas, I can no longer tarry. The morning's tempest I must cross.

I must return home.





BeakerJoe is a wolf.

Are you fearing a munch in the morning, hence goodbye message and shooting Whip tonight instead of the morning?

JP Liz V1

JP Liz V1 wrote: »

Are you fearing a munch in the morning, hence goodbye message and shooting Whip tonight instead of the morning?

Well, if the wolves have seen what I saw, I won't be going anywhere in the morning.

beakerjoe

Frank WW wrote: »

I recall.

I don't get the play here though. You went strongly after Rik when the wolves were already a man down, so if you were a wolf you'd be bussing. It's not a believable story, so why does H2D put it out there?

I dont get it either.

Frank WW

Frank WW wrote: »

I don't get the play here though. You went strongly after Rik when the wolves were already a man down, so if you were a wolf you'd be bussing. It's not a believable story, so why does H2D put it out there?

Two expandawolves playfight and the winner coasts all the way to the final day.

It was the only sensible thing wolves could have done after I bricked their buddy.

beakerjoe

Deleted User wrote: »

Two expandawolves playfight and the winner coasts all the way to the final day.

It was the only sensible thing wolves could have done after I bricked their buddy.

I shall wait for evidence.

Oh wait.... ya ain't got none.

Lucy WW

sullivlo wrote: »

I voted Rikand at about 8.58 (Necro can verify time). It wasn't a power play or anything, it was poor time management on my behalf.

I voted for Rikand as a semi random pick. I think it was Beakers original post calling him out that stuck in my head so I went for it and now I am glad.

Can Necro please verify this please.

Lucy WW

beakerjoe wrote: »

I shall wait for evidence.

Oh wait.... ya ain't got none.

Hi Beaker, why shouldn't I vote for you tomorrow?

beakerjoe

Lucy WW wrote: »

Hi Beaker, why shouldn't I vote for you tomorrow?

Well played.

Ive voted for a known wolf and was first to do so. Other than that, fire away.

Rikand

I bricked Paddy Mustard and followed up with...

Rikand wrote: »

I wonder can I get mislynched while also being the villager with the most posts. Worth a try imo

Deleted User wrote: »

Do I see some sweat upon your brow, dear child?

A wolf that thought they'd go gung-ho and it isn't quite working out as planned perhaps...


My confession box is always open.

beakerjoe wrote: »

I shall wait for evidence.

Oh wait.... ya ain't got none.

Your pretending to be calm isn't working. You're scrambling.

The Parish Priest has you sussed.


If the village followers my lead, we'll have this game done and dusted in record time. The mods won't get a chance to use all their fancy gimmicks.

Deleted User wrote: »

A fair warning.


The Father - Jake

The Son - Whiplashy

The Holy Ghost -

You'll note how Whippy is The Son...he had to be sacrificed for the sake of the village. Him turning green was all I needed.

beakerjoe

Im cool. Tell me 2D..... why would a villager trust you..... youve presented zero evidnece to back your claim,

However Im trying to figure out you.

Why pull this move?

Rustling trees? Better options than me. Its pluasible. It be a stupid move to pull if your a wolf because when I die and cime vack villager youll be lynched.

Give up the ghost 2d......see what I did there?

Ive done my part for the village, we can afford a mislynch.

Deleted User

Deleted User wrote: »

These seven people thanked the above post. There's a wolf among them.

JP Liz
Lucy WW
Mary WW
Rikand
Riona WW
Strawberry Milkshake
TheValeyard

The wolves have a tricky choice in the morning...

They can get rid of the obvious poster that I mentioned earlier

or

They can get rid of me, the one that is decimating their pack...

beakerjoe

beakerjoe wrote: »

Im cool. Tell me 2D..... why would a villager trust you..... youve presented zero evidnece to back your claim,

However Im trying to figure out you.

Why pull this move?

Rustling trees? Better options than me. Its pluasible. It be a stupid move to pull if your a wolf because when I die and cime vack villager youll be lynched.

Give up the ghost 2d......see what I did there?

Ive done my part for the village, we can afford a mislynch.

Who's going to lynch the Parish Priest?

Who's going to lynch the person that's carrying the village?

I may be munched at some point, but I won't be lynched.

Lucy WW

beakerjoe wrote: »

Well played.

Ive voted for a known wolf and was first to do so. Other than that, fire away.

I wouldn't put it past you to bus. You have history of it. Not just standard bus, but bus on team mates without prior consent.

beakerjoe

Lucy WW wrote: »

I wouldn't put it past you to bus. You have history of it. Not just standard bus, but bus on team mates without prior consent.

Guilty as charged. Thats why I never shut down possibilities completely. Wolves do anything to win.

Anything is possible.

If you think ive bused my teammate Rikand, by all means vote for me.

LadySkunk

Tried to put together when people voted from their posts and try show how many votes were on each player from what was announced. Don't know if I have the brain to think about it properly but if being followed it would have shown Senan and Clodagh up for lynch and not Rikand but I don't know what to make of that yet. I realised we have a player called Liam too which made me laugh because I'd no clue who that was :pac: . Anyways off to bed for me, chat you guys in the morning.

17:35 Rikand votes Senan (1)
17:42 Clodagh votes Strawbs (1)
17:46 Frank votes Senan (2)
18:09 Beaker votes Rikand (1)
19:20 Whip votes Senan (3)

19:22 9 votes left
19:27 Doris votes Whip (1)
19:27 Lucy votes Clodagh (2)
19:31 Mary votes Senan (4)
19:59 Orla votes Clodagh (3)
20:24 Riona votes Clodagh (4)
20:27 LeVar votes Doris (2)

20:33 3 votes left
20:37 LadySkunk votes Lucy (2)
20:58 Sulli votes Rikand (4)

Unknown

??:?? JP Liz votes Rikand (2)
??:?? Liam votes Rikand (3)
??:?? Strawbs votes Clodagh (1)
??:?? Trigger votes Doris (1)
??:?? H2 votes H2 (1)
??:?? Valeyard votes Lucy (1)
??:?? Senan votes LadySkunk (1)

Lucy WW

LadySkunk wrote: »

Tried to put together when people voted from their posts and try show how many votes were on each player from what was announced. Don't know if I have the brain to think about it properly but if being followed it would have shown Senan and Clodagh up for lynch and not Rikand but I don't know what to make of that yet. I realised we have a player called Liam too which made me laugh because I'd no clue who that was :pac: . Anyways off to bed for me, chat you guys in the morning.

17:35 Rikand votes Senan (1)
17:42 Clodagh votes Strawbs (1)
17:46 Frank votes Senan (2)
18:09 Beaker votes Rikand (1)
19:20 Whip votes Senan (3)

19:22 9 votes left
19:27 Doris votes Whip (1)
19:27 Lucy votes Clodagh (2)
19:31 Mary votes Senan (4)
19:59 Orla votes Clodagh (3)
20:24 Riona votes Clodagh (4)
20:27 LeVar votes Doris (2)

20:33 3 votes left
20:37 LadySkunk votes Lucy (2)
20:58 Sulli votes Rikand (4)

Unknown

??:?? JP Liz votes Rikand (2)
??:?? Liam votes Rikand (3)
??:?? Strawbs votes Clodagh (1)
??:?? Trigger votes Doris (1)
??:?? H2 votes H2 (1)
??:?? Valeyard votes Lucy (1)
??:?? Senan votes LadySkunk (1)

Lucy WW wrote: »

How many people said they were voting for rikand? Would the wolves have known there was a wagon there?

Nice work. Seems to back up my thoughts post lynch that the rikand wagon was not something that was divinable.
It also puts muck to those that believe the counter wagons were wolf saving wagons.
Senan v Clodagh were the declared wagons. The rikand wagon crossed an unexpected threshold for the wolves.

Clodagh WW

Lucy WW wrote: »

Nice work. Seems to back up my thoughts post lynch that the rikand wagon was not something that was divinable.
It also puts muck to those that believe the counter wagons were wolf saving wagons.
Senan v Clodagh were the declared wagons. The rikand wagon crossed an unexpected threshold for the wolves.

I'd be very confident there's at least 1 wolf in the votes for me, either in retribution for naming Strawberry Milkshake or as an easy target when I was being called out for doing so. Lucy is the one I'm most curious about seeing the alignment of at this point

Morning all

Skunk, I voted around 7

Trigger

My vote for Doris was placed around 7.30 while running around tesco

Liam is an interesting on.. 5 posts, all fluff, nothing of any substance at all, and a late enough vote on Rikand.

Liz posted an FFA after 8.30 I think with Rikand top.. she was also a late Rikand poster

Trigger

Voter*

I don’t get your play 2D probably because you’re talking in riddles. But your shot on whippy shows you’re not always right. In fact you’re only 50/50 only 50/50 right now.

Trigger

The low posters are interesting, barely making the treshold

Clodagh WW wrote: »

No reason to keep the raffle prize secret I don't think, more information for us the better

Clodagh WW wrote: »

I take it that was the prize, bit odd to not have a but of discussion on it

Clodagh WW wrote: »

Nevermind all is forgiven ha

Clodagh WW wrote: »

We can't clear Lucy based on that at all, perfectly legitimate wolf tactic to highlight one of their own early on to avoid being linked later in the game.

Suggesting it clears her is the most suspicious thing I've read so far and I'll be voting Strawberry Milkshake as a result

Clodagh WW wrote: »

I just think you were going too far with the idea that Lucy was somehow cleared, it's Day One, not a lot to go on yet and that's the best logic I've got so far

5 posts yesterday

Clodagh WW wrote: »

I'd be very confident there's at least 1 wolf in the votes for me, either in retribution for naming Strawberry Milkshake or as an easy target when I was being called out for doing so. Lucy is the one I'm most curious about seeing the alignment of at this point

Clodagh zones in on SM pretty early and doesnt waver from that, looking at the votes. nothing really substantial about her posts. Hopefully see a bit more of her today.

Frank WW

Morning. Not sure how important times are but I voted later than that Skunk..closer to 7ish. I think you're getting that from me saying I'd be willing to lynch Senan but it was actually their reaction that made me vote there.

Trigger

Liam WW wrote: »

Morning hows it going just having a nice cuppa tae

Liam WW wrote: »

haha thats what I was going to ask

Liam WW wrote: »

Its on Youtube

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R1ZU6UMDfgY

Liam WW wrote: »

WhenI started playing first players always said check the high and low posters then check the middle

Liam WW wrote: »

Lucy come back, it can be intense when people are questioning you but no harm meant. It is just part of the mechanics of the game.

All Fluff, nothing aimed at a poster, nothing substantial at all. Late vote then thrown on Rikand. Possible a bus maybe, as we know know that Rikand didnt look like he was going to be gone by vote tallys, so may have thought he was safe jumping on that wagon.

I'd also like to see a bit more from Liam today

Liam WW

Morning all hows it going. I voted for Rikamd somewhere around 8

Trigger

Liam WW wrote: »

Morning all hows it going. I voted for Rikamd somewhere around 8

Well speak of the Devil

What made Rikand stand out to you yesterday Liam?

Liam WW

Trigger wrote: »

Well speak of the Devil

What made Rikand stand out to you yesterday Liam?

Hey Trig, I started reading the thread around 20 to 8 and he first thing that stood out to to me was him on Doris, so I read through it twice adn he stood out more then any other player I play by gut and always on firtst day I find it very fast and when I go to comment someone else gets there first so I weht with my gut on Rik. I wasnt part of any bus.

Trigger

Liam WW wrote: »

Hey Trig, I started reading the thread around 20 to 8 and he first thing that stood out to to me was him on Doris, so I read through it twice adn he stood out more then any other player I play by gut and always on firtst day I find it very fast and when I go to comment someone else gets there first so I weht with my gut on Rik. I wasnt part of any bus.

So just him on Doris stood out, not him on Doris, Lucy & Skunk.. thats interesting

Trigger

Actually apologies, thats me misremembering.. that was Jake..

as far as i recall Rikand was f the opinion that Doris was Village

Liam WW

Trigger wrote: »

So just him on Doris stood out, not him on Doris, Lucy & Skunk.. thats interesting

WHat I said was that was the first thing that stood out for me and as I read on he continued to stand out for how he was playing. I had 4 players in my head and he stood out the oddest by the end for his play, It was a gut instinct vote versus other three.

Trigger

Liam WW wrote: »

WHat I said was that was the first thing that stood out for me and as I read on he continued to stand out for how he was playing. I had 4 players in my head and he stood out the oddest by the end for his play, It was a gut instinct vote versus other three.

Ah ok, so something that didnt happen stood out for you..

Rikands 2 posts mentioning Doris

Rikand wrote: »

Doris >rand to be a villager




Lucy >rand to be a villager.


H2D
Doris
Lucy

3 likely villagers and we're not even half way through day 1 is a good start

Rikand wrote: »

Well thats how I base most of my reads.

I have a feeling that Doris and Lucy are likely villagers based off Jakes posts

Which one stood out as Rikand being ON Doris

Liam WW

Trigger wrote: »

Ah ok, so something that didnt happen stood out for you..

Rikands 2 posts mentioning Doris




Which one stood out as Rikand being ON Doris

The first one

Trigger

Liam WW wrote: »

The first one

What about that post made you think that Rikand was on Doris, remember those are your words.

Liam WW

Trigger wrote: »

What about that post made you think that Rikand was on Doris, remember those are your words.

In this game most people play by gut, they go a missing letter or how a sentence is phrased so now you are examining me cos I said on Doris, I also said the first thing that struck me. So work away I went with my gut out of the 4 people who stood out to me.

Strawberry Milkshake

Strawberry Milkshake wrote: »

I don’t get your play 2D probably because you’re talking in riddles. But your shot on whippy shows you’re not always right. In fact you’re only 50/50 only 50/50 right now.

If you think I'm only 50/50 you're away with the fairies.

Out of 20 odd players I just fluked into Pat Mustard and just happened to not only pick out Rikand, but also tell ye exactly how he was playing the game...not even the mods or a wolf could be so accurate.

Seems like I'm the only one paying attention.

Whippy had to go. A peek would have been no good as they could have peeked good. I suspected Beaker and Rikand were playfighting and Whippy was a loose end.

If Whippy was a wolf...Beaker was a villager.

The dearly parted Whippy was a humble villager and now Beaker is a big bad expendawolf.

Trigger

Liam WW wrote: »

In this game most people play by gut, they go a missing letter or how a sentence is phrased so now you are examining me cos I said on Doris, I also said the first thing that struck me. So work away I went with my gut out of the 4 people who stood out to me.

Who were the other three and why?

Riona WW

Deleted User wrote: »

If you think I'm only 50/50 you're away with the fairies.

Out of 20 odd players I just fluked into Pat Mustard and just happened to not only pick out Rikand, but also tell ye exactly how he was playing the game...not even the mods or a wolf could be so accurate.

Seems like I'm the only one paying attention.

Whippy had to go. A peek would have been no good as they could have peeked good. I suspected Beaker and Rikand were playfighting and Whippy was a loose end.

If Whippy was a wolf...Beaker was a villager.

The dearly parted Whippy was a humble villager and now Beaker is a big bad expendawolf.

Why not go straight for Beaker over Whippy though?

Riona WW

Liam WW wrote: »

WHat I said was that was the first thing that stood out for me and as I read on he continued to stand out for how he was playing. I had 4 players in my head and he stood out the oddest by the end for his play, It was a gut instinct vote versus other three.

Who were the other 3?

Riona WW

Riona WW wrote: »

Why not go straight for Beaker over Whippy though?

Deleted User wrote: »

A fair warning.


The Father - Jake

The Son - Whiplashy

The Holy Ghost -

The Son must be sacrificed.

Liam WW

Riona WW wrote: »

Who were the other 3?

JP, Frank and SM

Riona WW

Clodagh WW wrote: »

I'd be very confident there's at least 1 wolf in the votes for me, either in retribution for naming Strawberry Milkshake or as an easy target when I was being called out for doing so. Lucy is the one I'm most curious about seeing the alignment of at this point

When were you called out for naming Strawbs and why?

This is the only post I can find from you - and there doesn't seem to be much follow up:

Clodagh WW wrote: »

We can't clear Lucy based on that at all, perfectly legitimate wolf tactic to highlight one of their own early on to avoid being linked later in the game.

Suggesting it clears her is the most suspicious thing I've read so far and I'll be voting Strawberry Milkshake as a result

A few people have said for that for them they thought the likelihood was Lucy was leaning village - why just jump on Strawbs for this? I get what you are saying about it being a wolf tactic, but why just this poster? Rikand and beakerjoe were having a major discussion on the thread about this and you picked up on Strawbs post over that back and forth?

Riona WW

Liam WW wrote: »

JP, Frank and SM

Why?

The wolves must be pissing themselves.

The only known villager and the one that is picking them apart is currently under the most scrutiny.

Doris WW

[Deleted User] wrote: »

The wolves must be pissing themselves.

The only known villager and the one that is picking them apart is currently under the most scrutiny.

Are you under scrutiny? Think you are confusing legit questions with scrutiny

Liam WW

Riona WW wrote: »

Why?

Because when I did the read through of the days posts they were the ones that grated with me. We all have our ways of coming to these decisions and I read it those 4 stood out but Rik seemed more icky so I voted with him.

Riona WW

Deleted User wrote: »

The wolves must be pissing themselves.

The only known villager and the one that is picking them apart is currently under the most scrutiny.

I'm not scrutinizing you - I am trying to make sense of what you did! I just can't see why Whippy is all.

Doris WW

The Rikand wagon is not one I'd be examining for wolves tbh. If someone voted there, then they are high probability village. Last night was a crap shoot, wolf on wolf I dont think is happening given Pat Mustard took a brick in the skull during the day