Werewolf: Father Ted 2 GAME THREAD

Mary WW

LadySkunk wrote: »

All the wolves mentioned Lucy in some form and a lot saying she's likely village. I don't know does a whole wolf team do something like that? But why were they all so on her side at the same time it's mad like was it a case where they were role hunting on day 1 then when Jake got the brick in the face they got freaked? And they wanted to keep her on their good side maybe but if they suspected anything why didn't they munch her?


Hmmmm honorable mentions of Senan, Clodagh, Doris, Frank and Sulli too

Unless Lucy is the last wolf.

What is genieing?

LadySkunk

None of the wolves mentioned each other at all until they died, so why would none of the 4 make any mention of each other and then all of them practically clear Lucy if she was the last

Frank WW

Riona WW wrote: »

Just on the lynch tonight - I hope our vig still has a shot today. If the vig missed taking out Vale earlier, does that mean they will have a shot after 9pm again?
Then is there anything to be said for not lynching Vale, just to see how the chips fall so we do get something from tonight's vote? At 9:01pm then the vig can just take out Vale? Or am I missing something major with a strategy like this?

Catch a wolf, kill a wolf.

I assumed that the vig hadn't taken a shot, but if they did then I think it's tomorrow morning they get their next bullet.

If we leave Vale alive and try to lynch elsewhere there is a danger that an RV gets targeted and has to out themselves. BG and Vig are still hidden and should stay that way as long as possible.

We had an announcement that there is another raffle at lynch time. Best case scenario a confirmed villager wins it. Odds are in our favour that a villager wins anyway. So lynch Vale and see where we go from there.

JP Liz V1

TheValeyard wrote: »

Yeah, come on, we can do this!!!

Surrender

Trigger

TheValeyard wrote: »

Hang on now, I was calling 2D out on his madness. That aint fluff.

LadySkunk

Mary WW wrote: »

Unless Lucy is the last wolf.

What is genieing?

You genie when you haven't been around and then your name is mentioned and you appear like magic, can be a sign of a wolf laying low and reading the thread and jumping in to defend themselves when they see their name mentioned

JP Liz V1

Frank WW wrote: »

Reading back through BJ's posts and think this is definitive confirmation.

Did BJ clear you too Frank?

Mary WW

LadySkunk wrote: »

You genie when you haven't been around and then your name is mentioned and you appear like magic, can be a sign of a wolf laying low and reading the thread and jumping in to defend themselves when they see their name mentioned

There's a fair bit of that going on.:D

TheValeyard

JP Liz V1 wrote: »

Did BJ clear you too Frank?

He did not.

TheValeyard

Trigger wrote: »

TheValeyard

JP Liz V1 wrote: »

Surrender

Lucy WW

Riona WW wrote: »

Just on the lynch tonight - I hope our vig still has a shot today. If the vig missed taking out Vale earlier, does that mean they will have a shot after 9pm again?
Then is there anything to be said for not lynching Vale, just to see how the chips fall so we do get something from tonight's vote? At 9:01pm then the vig can just take out Vale? Or am I missing something major with a strategy like this?

Have a read of the simpsons game.....

if not shot, lynch valewolf.

Only way i'm changing my vote of vale is if he is dead.

TheValeyard

Lucy WW wrote: »

Have a read of the simpsons game.....

if not shot, lynch valewolf.

Only way i'm changing my vote of vale is if he is dead.

TheValeyard

That was one time!!!!!!!!

Frank WW

JP Liz V1 wrote: »

Did BJ clear you too Frank?

Not definitively. He made this comment

beakerjoe wrote: »

Desmond threw this out earlier and Frank shut him down... Franks ok in my book. A wolf would just not respond here. They would allow the confusion to build.

but he didn't include me in his 9:59 post. He is right but only I know that.

TheValeyard

Frank WW wrote: »

Not definitively. He made this comment



but he didn't include me in his 9:59 post. He is right but only I know that.

LadySkunk

Does it not make more sense to shoot Vale so we have something to work with off of the votes? People will have to explain and back up their votes but if everyone votes Vale then 100% the last wolf will be hiding in their also

Clodagh WW

Valeyard has to go really, no other option for today based on what's come out. Lucy put in the hardyards overnight but something is still off with her for me and I'd be more than happy to see her killed by the vig to finally put my mind at ease one way or another.

Clodagh WW

LadySkunk wrote: »

Does it not make more sense to shoot Vale so we have something to work with off of the votes? People will have to explain and back up their votes but if everyone votes Vale then 100% the last wolf will be hiding in their also

Maybe I've completely misunderstoof but haven't we already taken a shot at Vale today and missed so no vig kill left today?

Mary WW

Clodagh WW wrote: »

Maybe I've completely misunderstoof but haven't we already taken a shot at Vale today and missed so no vig kill left today?

How could the shot miss though? Vale was not protected surely?
I thought that was a shot on Skunk and the bodyguard protected her.

Clodagh WW

What have the wolves got that allows a daytime kill?

Frank WW

Mary WW wrote: »

How could the shot miss though? Vale was not protected surely?
I thought that was a shot on Skunk and the bodyguard protected her.

That's what I assumed but I think Riona & Clodagh must be right. No way does the vig not shoot Vale by now and I think everyone has posted so far today.

LadySkunk

Senan and Clodagh were already under suspicion going off the wagons on Day 1 so it seems the wolves were going with the flow on those two because they were easy targets. Vale also mentions Liam who also had a lot of heat on him for not posting.

Rikand was suspicious of Frank but gave no reasoning for it and Vale said he had no read on Frank.

I wonder was Lucy mentioned much by other players with regard to looking good after the whole Jake thing as that could be another angle the wolves went along with to appear more villagey

JP Liz V1

LadySkunk wrote: »

None of the wolves mentioned each other at all until they died, so why would none of the 4 make any mention of each other and then all of them practically clear Lucy if she was the last

I'm still not convinced Lucy is the last wolf

Mary WW

Clodagh WW wrote: »

What have the wolves got that allows a daytime kill?

They don't I think. I presumed Vale wasn't lying about having 2 bullets from the raffle.

LadySkunk

Frank WW wrote: »

That's what I assumed but I think Riona & Clodagh must be right. No way does the vig not shoot Vale by now and I think everyone has posted so far today.

It seems our vig has been playing pretty careful thus far and it could be a case that they want to keep their shot until we have more information on the rest of the players but I do think the shot was on me but I was protected, Vale couldn't have protection and he said he was shooting me before it happened

Mary WW

JP Liz V1 wrote: »

I'm still not convinced Lucy is the last wolf

Who do you think is Liz?

JP Liz V1

LadySkunk wrote: »

Does it not make more sense to shoot Vale so we have something to work with off of the votes? People will have to explain and back up their votes but if everyone votes Vale then 100% the last wolf will be hiding in their also

Yes everyone is going to vote lynch Vale so are we better taking Vale out now by vig shot

LadySkunk

JP Liz V1 wrote: »

I'm still not convinced Lucy is the last wolf

No neither am I Liz, that's what I'm saying it would be madness for all of them to pretty much say she's village if she's actually a wolf. I mean if it came down to it where we'd killed loads of villagers and she was still alive then I'd maybe look back into her but for now I think it's unlikely

TheValeyard

Better off not lynching me and trying to out an actual wolf.

Think about it.

My cards are marked, I'm on the way out.

Why not hunt for your big bad wolf?

Then tomorrow could be a speed day to kill me


Makes sense

Trigger

Clodagh WW wrote: »

What have the wolves got that allows a daytime kill?

Nothing apart from if they win something. I seem to recall that Vale stated that he won "a bullet" not 2 or so he may have played that well enough..

He may have won a bullet and a protection maybe. and the vig took a shot.

He also may have stated that he one a single bullet to see how people would react and planned to use the 2nd bullet but was blocked by the BG

We have no real way of knowing without the Vig coming out and we do not want that to happen.

So best to lynch Vale and hope that we still have a bullet there

JP Liz V1

Mary WW wrote: »

Who do you think is Liz?

I just think from the start Lucy WW V1 and Lucy WW V2 has been angry frustrated very active vocal too much for a wolf imho, of course I could be wrong just think from the start Lucy has been pushed as a wolf, wagoned on but has survived

Trigger

TheValeyard wrote: »

I've a second bullet.

TheValeyard wrote: »

Bye bye LadySkunk

Nevermind part of my above post.. the Vig is still very much in play so

JP Liz V1

TheValeyard wrote: »

Better off not lynching me and trying to out an actual wolf.

Think about it.

My cards are marked, I'm on the way out.

Why not hunt for your big bad wolf?

Then tomorrow could be a speed day to kill me

Makes sense

I fear Vale has a plan, take him out now please vig

TheValeyard

Trigger wrote: »

Nothing apart from if they win something. I seem to recall that Vale stated that he won "a bullet" not 2 or so he may have played that well enough..

He may have won a bullet and a protection maybe. and the vig took a shot.

He also may have stated that he one a single bullet to see how people would react and planned to use the 2nd bullet but was blocked by the BG

We have no real way of knowing without the Vig coming out and we do not want that to happen.

So best to lynch Vale and hope that we still have a bullet there

Best to hunt for the real wolf amongst the village. You're wasting a day on me. You should know better.

LadySkunk

Cleared players

LadySkunk
Jp Liz
Trigger

Wolves mentioned and how many times

Lucy (13)
Senan (4) Up for lynch
Clodagh (4) Up for lynch
Frank (2)
Liam (1) Has suspicions on him
Riona (1) mentioned in passing

Remaining players

LeVar (0)
Mary (0)

How many known wolves mentioned each other in game

(0) Only after death and one post by Jake agreeing with Strawbs saying "this"

Mary WW

The point is right though. If we lynch Vale there is nothing more to learn from the votes tonight because everyone is on him.

Liam WW

Mary WW wrote: »

The point is right though. If we lynch Vale there is nothing more to learn from the votes tonight because everyone is on him.

then he should be shot or whatever to stop people hiding behind the vote

LadySkunk

Yeah look best we can do is try weed out the last wolf, hope the vig has a shot to take and does so before the lynch so we can then get the last baddie

Trigger

MAybe a village concensus on whether to take the shot or not?

Me: Aye

Riona WW

Frank WW wrote: »

Catch a wolf, kill a wolf.

I assumed that the vig hadn't taken a shot, but if they did then I think it's tomorrow morning they get their next bullet.

If we leave Vale alive and try to lynch elsewhere there is a danger that an RV gets targeted and has to out themselves. BG and Vig are still hidden and should stay that way as long as possible.

We had an announcement that there is another raffle at lynch time. Best case scenario a confirmed villager wins it. Odds are in our favour that a villager wins anyway. So lynch Vale and see where we go from there.

Good point - I suppose we could end up lynching the vig for example - didn't think of that. I am presuming the raffle prize is another bullet tonight, and I guess there is a chance that does fall into the hands of a wolf - and Vale would still be alive to win it.

LadySkunk

TheValeyard

Trigger wrote: »

MAybe a village concensus on whether to take the shot or not?

Me: Aye

Aye.

Mary WW

TheValeyard wrote: »

Baggly wrote: »

Mod accouncement

A shot was attempted but unfortunately the gun was held incorrectly and the shot went harmlessly into a bit of bog.

TheValeyard wrote: »

TheValeyard wrote: »

It will be all day. And all night. I wont be shot or lynched.

Trigger wrote: »

Nothing apart from if they win something. I seem to recall that Vale stated that he won "a bullet" not 2 or so he may have played that well enough..

He may have won a bullet and a protection maybe. and the vig took a shot.

He also may have stated that he one a single bullet to see how people would react and planned to use the 2nd bullet but was blocked by the BG

We have no real way of knowing without the Vig coming out and we do not want that to happen.

So best to lynch Vale and hope that we still have a bullet there

I think Trigger hit the nail on the head here.

Riona WW

Trigger wrote: »

MAybe a village concensus on whether to take the shot or not?

Me: Aye

Definitely - please spare us from Peter Capaldi!

Lucy WW

Mary WW wrote: »

Unless Lucy is the last wolf.

What is genieing?

Genieing is appearing when your name is mentioned.

Liam WW

LadySkunk wrote: »

Cleared players

LadySkunk
Jp Liz
Trigger

Wolves mentioned and how many times

Lucy (13)
Senan (4) Up for lynch
Clodagh (4) Up for lynch
Frank (2)
Liam (1) Has suspicions on him
Riona (1) mentioned in passing

"

Taking Lucy out of equation for minute in case it is a wagon, that leaves the rest of us, so of the mentions of Lucy how are they divided among us 4?

LadySkunk

Riona WW wrote: »

Good point - I suppose we could end up lynching the vig for example - didn't think of that. I am presuming the raffle prize is another bullet tonight, and I guess there is a chance that does fall into the hands of a wolf - and Vale would still be alive to win it.

I think if the vig or bodyguard NEED to come out before lynch then to do so and protect whoever it is for tomorrow. If we all lynch vale we get absolutely nothing out of the vote, it'll be a sure thing and the perfect place for the remaining wolf to hide. I think it's better if everyone has to work to find the last wolf, we do reads and FFAs and have something to work with after but that's just my opinion

JP Liz V1

Trigger wrote: »

MAybe a village concensus on whether to take the shot or not?

Me: Aye

Yes I vote shot

Aye

LadySkunk

Liam WW wrote: »

Taking Lucy out of equation for minute in case it is a wagon, that leaves the rest of us, so of the mentions of Lucy how are they divided among us 4?

For context, this is what I was working off

LadySkunk wrote: »

Jake

Feck first post
Says Doris smells of wolf
Asks did we find any wolves yet?
Questions Lucy about being Jack
Agrees with Strawbs about Lucy pretending to be Jack
Says what nice teeth Ladyskunk has

Rikand

Says H2D had great shot, laughed so hard at Jake dying
Says H2D, Doris and Lucy likely villagers
Says Lucy comes off good from exchange with Jake
Says case against Lucy is too convoluted to be directed at a wolf
Missed post about LadySkunk and when questioned by Trigger, says it’s null
Questions going after low posters on day 1
Backed down on Doris and Lucy when questioned by Beaker
When asked by Senan what he proved, says “oh I think you know what is proven”
Says Senan, Clodagh and Sulli genie when mentioned by Riona, must be a wolf in here
Says Sulli might be only villager in there
Votes on Senan for genieing
Names Senan, Clodagh and Frank as suspicious
Thinks NRVs should come out of seer cover (LOL)

Strawbs/Desmond

First post saying wolf catching is easy
Questions Lucy over alluding to be Jack
Says H2D definitely a villager, no way does a wolf take out one of their own like that
Asks can we clear Lucy now
Questions whether it would be a risk bussing Lucy on day 1
Asks Clodagh about her thinking Strawbs, Jake and Lucy were bussing on day 1
Says she suspected Lucy before Jake died but now leaning village
Says Beaker voting Rikand is a good look for him
Voted for H2D
Says time to look and see did anyone take H2D up on his wolf bait
Questions H2Ds claim about Beaker being a wolf and whether he won a peek for his prize
Says going to read back over Beaker to see what he saw in him as a wolf

TheValeyard

Suspect of Lucy, not set in stone
Suspicious of Clodagh and Liam
No read on Frank
Wants Lucy looked at as two different players