Werewolf: Father Ted 2 GAME THREAD

Lucy WW

Mary WW wrote: »

I know everybody says it but I am absolute villager. If I was wolf would I be drawing attention to the munches being unexpected people and looking for a pattern there?

they are unexpected because bodyguard is still in play. It they went for expected, then bodyguard would save and they wouldn't have a munch.

JP Liz V1

Lucy WW wrote: »

@ Liz

Can you recall at what time you voted for rikand on monday.

6ish 7ish it was early in the evening

Mary WW

Liam WW wrote: »

Ok first every game I play I come cross as fluffy so it aint going to change now I go by gut which is annoying for others but its how I play. Secondly off allday because it is the first time in 6 weeks I have been able to spend time with kiddo without going, have you done your maths now and I am caching up on housework christmas decs to attic etc. I will post in the morning then evening.
thirdly #FFA

I think Lucy its been bothering me since yeserday that Rik was using Doris to cover for Lucy have read today and still cant get it out of my head.
Sulli suggesting to shoot H2D odd
Still JP Liz from yesterday reaction to Lucy similar to Rik
I've 2 other people I am also looking at but want to go over their post before I vote

Liam WW wrote: »

In this game most people play by gut, they go a missing letter or how a sentence is phrased so now you are examining me cos I said on Doris, I also said the first thing that struck me. So work away I went with my gut out of the 4 people who stood out to me.

Liam WW wrote: »

WhenI started playing first players always said check the high and low posters then check the middle

Liam has definitely played before. Would seem experienced by these comments.

Liam WW

Mary WW wrote: »

Liam has definitely played before. Would seem experienced by these comments.

yup have confirmed have played before

Frank WW

Lucy WW wrote: »

on the quote, you can click the blue arrow and it brings you to the post in the thread where you can read it in full.

Yes, I know that and as I was involved in the conversation, I know the context. I also know that most people don't do that.


My point is that Mary chose a random quote from Doris and posted that it was directed at me. Why? Why quote that? Doris made more than 4 posts.

Lucy WW

Frank WW wrote: »

Yes, I know that and as I was involved in the conversation, I know the context. I also know that most people don't do that.


My point is that Mary chose a random quote from Doris and posted that it was directed at me. Why? Why quote that? Doris made more than 4 posts.

i thought the 2nd quote was the most agenda driven. you though 4th.
They are in my POE (process of elimination list)

Mary WW

Frank WW wrote: »

Yes, I know that and as I was involved in the conversation, I know the context. I also know that most people don't do that.


My point is that Mary chose a random quote from Doris and posted that it was directed at me. Why? Why quote that? Doris made more than 4 posts.

She did but a lot of them say nothing really. You may notice I kept some posts out but didn't keep out the one about me. I have nothing to hide.

JP Liz V1

LadySkunk wrote: »

Sorry sorry sorry I’m just awake, was a struggle to peel myself out of bed

It’s my birthday today

This game is mad it has it all doesn’t it :pac:

Happy Birthday

Lucy WW

Mary WW wrote: »

She did but a lot of them say nothing really. You may notice I kept some posts out but didn't keep out the one about me. I have nothing to hide.

The post that says you are unlikely a wolf. :pac::P:cool::D

Frank WW

Lucy WW wrote: »

i thought the 2nd quote was the most agenda driven. you though 4th.
They are in my POE (process of elimination list)

I see your point. I'm self-involved I guess and notice things directed at me :pac:

JP Liz V1

Father Dougal Maguire - Vigilante. Can take aim at a player once per cycle (Cycle = 1 day and 1 night phase)

Have we a vig shot today?

We need to win this for Ted / BJ, come on village

Mary WW

Doris WW wrote: »

The Rikand wagon is not one I'd be examining for wolves tbh. If someone voted there, then they are high probability village. Last night was a crap shoot, wolf on wolf I dont think is happening given Pat Mustard took a brick in the skull during the day

Doris WW wrote: »

Are you under scrutiny? Think you are confusing legit questions with scrutiny

Doris WW wrote: »

Mary on the counter wagon, can't see any reasoning for her vote.

Not sure would a wolf ask on thread where a lynch code is or an intentional question to look like they'd no backroom

Doris WW wrote: »

From the votes

Liam
Sully
Liz
Bj
Senan smell good to me

Doris WW wrote: »

Why did you vote for yourself

Doris WW wrote: »

Senan looks good from this

Doris WW wrote: »

Hes at least 50% right anyway

Doris WW wrote: »

Haha my days! Best ever village start?

Fair play BJ, great shout, didn't see it at all tbh

Doris WW wrote: »

Not particularly, I like to have a point of reference to look back at people's thoughts and how they evolve over the game rather than throwing a dart at a board. My instincts are flawed like everyone else but if someone has sound logic then i can forgive poor instincts and hopefully that works both ways

Doris WW wrote: »

This post felt a bit odd to me. To be fair, I've misread it on my skim read and had a note on that you were fishing if H2D was Jack with the brick thing but you were talking about the the Milk float brick I presume?

Doris WW wrote: »

Lack of FFAs or where people are voting is a bit worrying

Whippy for me

I'd have Frank as a bit bogey too. His questioning of the brick stood out as weird

BJs popping at Rikand feels a bit off. Not a lynchable offence from reading what Rikand actually said

Ffa1
Whippy
Frank
BJ

Doris WW wrote: »

Check your PM id say Mary or PM the mods

Doris WW wrote: »

I thought the favour was funny. I also thought Jake diving on me as a wolf was a bit ****ty tbh so was happy enough with him getting bricked

Doris WW wrote: »

H2D is not getting lynched full stop, he didn't just take out a vanilla wolf, he took out a roled wolf. No wolf team does that

Doris WW wrote: »

Where is Triggers TMI?

Doris WW wrote: »

Oh sorry, that was the TMI

Those are the last few.

Mary WW

Lucy WW wrote: »

The post that says you are unlikely a wolf. :pac::P:cool::D

Actually I didn't see it that way. She said there was a possibilty I asked it to make it look like I had no backroom so the post about me could be taken either way.

Mary WW

Mary WW wrote: »

Those are the last few.

The ones I left out @Frank were the ones to do with H2D and Jake really.

TheValeyard

JP Liz V1 wrote: »

Have we a vig shot today?

We need to win this for Ted / BJ, come on village

Yeah, come on, we can do this!!!

Frank WW

beakerjoe wrote: »

In Fantasy land

Trigger was peeked good.

Happy Liz?

Seriously though, no one has claimed to have peeked anyone, we are all as eligible to be wolves at this stage bar H2D, who bricked a roled wolf.

Take your pick.

Reading back through BJ's posts and think this is definitive confirmation.

TheValeyard

Frank WW wrote: »

Reading back through BJ's posts and think this is definitive confirmation.

We need more proof

Also Starring LeVar Burton

Trigger wrote: »

Currently on a con call at the moment.

May want to have a look at LeVars posts, he is playing to the newbie role in a few posts possibly pocketing Lucy & BJ asking "What is the play here" while in other posts he seems to come off like an experienced player knows what he is doing.

Will have a deeper look after lunch

Just skimming thread now while I have a minute, but will have to go AWOL again, but just to address your point, I have only claimed that I am new to Werewolf on boards and online versions, but have played IRL ; there are differences between what I'm used to and the boards versions. I've not claimed to be an absolute noob.

Not entirely sure what pocketing is. I did ask BJ and Lucy what they would do in certain scenarios, but as part of a greater dialogue ; had been having a back and forth with BJ as he was wondering why I voted Doris, and my back and forth with Lucy is well documented.

You only have my word that I'm a villager, so dissect my posts all you need, and if I'm one of the only few with a question mark, by all means take a shot, better me than a roled villager at this stage.

Riona WW

Frank WW wrote: »

Morning all. Just finished a virtual meeting with the bank which wasn't at all scary.

So Valewolf shot our seer BJ and tried to shoot Skunk but missed. So we lynch there and we are down to a single wolf. Not likely to get anything from the lynch votes tonight.

Just on the lynch tonight - I hope our vig still has a shot today. If the vig missed taking out Vale earlier, does that mean they will have a shot after 9pm again?
Then is there anything to be said for not lynching Vale, just to see how the chips fall so we do get something from tonight's vote? At 9:01pm then the vig can just take out Vale? Or am I missing something major with a strategy like this?

Trigger

Senan WW wrote: »

Still think Mary is worth a bullet tbh

TheValeyard wrote: »

Prefer to wait for a seer check. Might have gotten two wolves already. Or the raffle prize could give us a peek at someone.

Searching through Vales posts and this is really the only thing that got my attention through the endless droves of fluff. its small, but really the only thing i could take from his posts so far

Trigger

Riona WW wrote: »

Just on the lynch tonight - I hope our vig still has a shot today. If the vig missed taking out Vale earlier, does that mean they will have a shot after 9pm again?
Then is there anything to be said for not lynching Vale, just to see how the chips fall so we do get something from tonight's vote? At 9:01pm then the vig can just take out Vale? Or am I missing something major with a strategy like this?

One shot per cycle, so if they shoot during the day they cant shoot during night again

JP Liz V1

LadySkunk wrote: »

I've gotten two so far, the brick and another one I'm keeping secret for the moment so as to not give anything away to wolfies but will let you all know tomorrow

Did you reveal?

LadySkunk

Jake

Feck first post
Says Doris smells of wolf
Asks did we find any wolves yet?
Questions Lucy about being Jack
Agrees with Strawbs about Lucy pretending to be Jack
Says what nice teeth Ladyskunk has

Rikand

Says H2D had great shot, laughed so hard at Jake dying
Says H2D, Doris and Lucy likely villagers
Says Lucy comes off good from exchange with Jake
Says case against Lucy is too convoluted to be directed at a wolf
Missed post about LadySkunk and when questioned by Trigger, says it’s null
Questions going after low posters on day 1
Backed down on Doris and Lucy when questioned by Beaker
When asked by Senan what he proved, says “oh I think you know what is proven”
Says Senan, Clodagh and Sulli genie when mentioned by Riona, must be a wolf in here
Says Sulli might be only villager in there
Votes on Senan for genieing
Names Senan, Clodagh and Frank as suspicious
Thinks NRVs should come out of seer cover (LOL)

Strawbs/Desmond

First post saying wolf catching is easy
Questions Lucy over alluding to be Jack
Says H2D definitely a villager, no way does a wolf take out one of their own like that
Asks can we clear Lucy now
Questions whether it would be a risk bussing Lucy on day 1
Asks Clodagh about her thinking Strawbs, Jake and Lucy were bussing on day 1
Says she suspected Lucy before Jake died but now leaning village
Says Beaker voting Rikand is a good look for him
Voted for H2D
Says time to look and see did anyone take H2D up on his wolf bait
Questions H2Ds claim about Beaker being a wolf and whether he won a peek for his prize
Says going to read back over Beaker to see what he saw in him as a wolf

TheValeyard

Suspect of Lucy, not set in stone
Suspicious of Clodagh and Liam
No read on Frank
Wants Lucy looked at as two different players

LadySkunk

JP Liz V1 wrote: »

Did you reveal?

Yeah I was able to track a player and I tracked Beaker and found out he visited Valeyard last night so I knew he knew he was a wolf from what he was saying this morning

TheValeyard

LadySkunk wrote: »

Yeah I was able to track a player and I tracked Beaker and found out he visited Valeyard last night so I knew he knew he was a wolf from what he was saying this morning

Hey that was a private visit!!!

TheValeyard

LadySkunk wrote: »

Jake

Feck first post
Says Doris smells of wolf
Asks did we find any wolves yet?
Questions Lucy about being Jack
Agrees with Strawbs about Lucy pretending to be Jack
Says what nice teeth Ladyskunk has

Rikand

Says H2D had great shot, laughed so hard at Jake dying
Says H2D, Doris and Lucy likely villagers
Says Lucy comes off good from exchange with Jake
Says case against Lucy is too convoluted to be directed at a wolf
Missed post about LadySkunk and when questioned by Trigger, says it’s null
Questions going after low posters on day 1
Backed down on Doris and Lucy when questioned by Beaker
When asked by Senan what he proved, says “oh I think you know what is proven”
Says Senan, Clodagh and Sulli genie when mentioned by Riona, must be a wolf in here
Says Sulli might be only villager in there
Votes on Senan for genieing
Names Senan, Clodagh and Frank as suspicious
Thinks NRVs should come out of seer cover (LOL)

Strawbs/Desmond

First post saying wolf catching is easy
Questions Lucy over alluding to be Jack
Says H2D definitely a villager, no way does a wolf take out one of their own like that
Asks can we clear Lucy now
Questions whether it would be a risk bussing Lucy on day 1
Asks Clodagh about her thinking Strawbs, Jake and Lucy were bussing on day 1
Says she suspected Lucy before Jake died but now leaning village
Says Beaker voting Rikand is a good look for him
Voted for H2D
Says time to look and see did anyone take H2D up on his wolf bait
Questions H2Ds claim about Beaker being a wolf and whether he won a peek for his prize
Says going to read back over Beaker to see what he saw in him as a wolf

TheValeyard

Suspect of Lucy, not set in stone
Suspicious of Clodagh and Liam
No read on Frank
Wants Lucy looked at as two different players

TheValeyard

Trigger wrote: »

Searching through Vales posts and this is really the only thing that got my attention through the endless droves of fluff. its small, but really the only thing i could take from his posts so far

Mary WW

Trigger wrote: »

Searching through Vales posts and this is really the only thing that got my attention through the endless droves of fluff. its small, but really the only thing i could take from his posts so far

I have said I am village already and have been trying to work through posts to find the last wolf.
People can read what they want in it but anyone thinking I am a wolf is wrong.

LadySkunk

All the wolves mentioned Lucy in some form and a lot saying she's likely village. I don't know does a whole wolf team do something like that? But why were they all so on her side at the same time it's mad like was it a case where they were role hunting on day 1 then when Jake got the brick in the face they got freaked? And they wanted to keep her on their good side maybe but if they suspected anything why didn't they munch her?


Hmmmm honorable mentions of Senan, Clodagh, Doris, Frank and Sulli too

TheValeyard

Trigger wrote: »

Searching through Vales posts and this is really the only thing that got my attention through the endless droves of fluff. its small, but really the only thing i could take from his posts so far

Hang on now, I was calling 2D out on his madness. That aint fluff.