Ultimate Battle of The Beatles

Declan A Walsh

Group M

Getting Better vs When I'm 64

And I Love Her vs Got to Get You Into My Life

It Won't Be Long vs For No One


Group N

Helter Skelter vs I'll Follow the Sun

Savoy Truffle vs Girl

Carry That Weight vs All You Need is Love

loyatemu

Group M

Getting Better vs When I'm 64 - a lot of Sgt Pepper leaves me cold. Getting Better is alright, 64 is annoying.
And I Love Her vs Got to Get You Into My Life - both good tunes, I love the bit at the end of GTGYIMYL where it goes psychedelic ("I was alone...)
It Won't Be Long vs For No One - as in round one, love the call and response in IWBL

Group N

Helter Skelter vs I'll Follow the Sun - Helter Skelter sounds like nothing else in their catalog.
Savoy Truffle vs Girl - I'm probably the only person who'll vote for George's weird desert-themed song, there's something about it I like (possibly the ultra-compressed production)
Carry That Weight vs All You Need is Love - not much between these two.

Declan A Walsh

loyatemu wrote: »

Group M

...................................

Group N

.................................................
Savoy Truffle vs Girl - I'm probably the only person who'll vote for George's weird desert-themed song, there's something about it I like (possibly the ultra-compressed production)

No you're not - look at the post before yours!

loyatemu

Declan A Walsh wrote: »

No you're not - look at the post before yours!

Savoy Truffle to go all the way in a major shock outcome to this competition?

Declan A Walsh

loyatemu wrote: »

Savoy Truffle to go all the way in a major shock outcome to this competition?

It might beat Girl but it could be against a lot of heavy hitters in the next round. It would depend on what song it is drawn against, should it get through this round. If it did manage to get past the next round, I believe the round after will be the furthest that it will get. At that stage, it will be all heavy hitters.

EmmetSpiceland

Declan A Walsh wrote: »

It might beat Girl but it could be against a lot of heavy hitters in the next round. It would depend on what song it is drawn against, should it get through this round. If it did manage to get past the next round, I believe the round after will be the furthest that it will get. At that stage, it will be all heavy hitters.

The “popular” vote, ugh!

Reberetta

I really enjoy Savoy Truffle, the verse and brass (?) section leading into the odd chorus with the higher vocals, all supreb.

Girl, with what I think is an acoustic twelve stringed guitar, has a 'busker wearing a beret outside a French cafe feeling'; a romantic, sugary yet lovelorn loveable melody, but it loses out here to the more adventurous and sassy song.

Group M

Getting Better
And I Love Her
It Won't Be Long

Group N

I'll Follow the Sun
Savoy Truffle
All You Need is Love

Nerdlingr

Group M

Getting Better
Got to Get You Into My Life
For No One

Group N

Helter Skelter
Savoy Truffle (gotta go for George's song about Clapton getting his teeth out!)
All You Need is Love

rainbowtrout

Group M

When I'm 64
Got to Get You Into My Life
For No One - one of my favourite Beatles songs.

rainbowtrout

Group N

Helter Skelter
Girl
All You Need is Love

Rigor Mortis

Most of these would have been knocked out by songs that were knocked out yesterday.

Group M

Getting Better
Got to Get You Into My Life
For No One

Group N

Helter Skelter
Girl
Carry That Weight

Also Starring LeVar Burton

Group M

Getting Better
And I Love Her
For No One

Declan A Walsh

Rigor Mortis wrote: »

Most of these would have been knocked out by songs that were knocked out yesterday.

Group M

Getting Better
Got to Get You Into My Life
For No One

Group N

Helter Skelter
Girl
Carry That Weight

Interesting point. There's a good chance then that most of the songs that get through from here will be knocked out by the songs that knocked out the other ones you referred to!

Also Starring LeVar Burton

Group N

Helter Skelter
Savoy Truffle
All You Need is Love

Purgative

Group M

Getting Better
And I Love Her
For No One

Purgative

Group N

I'll Follow the Sun
Girl
Carry That Weight

EmmetSpiceland

Group M

When I'm 64
Got to Get You Into My Life
For No One

Group N

Helter Skelter
Savoy Truffle
All You Need is Love

Eggonyerface

Group M

Getting Better
Got to Get You Into My Life
It Won't Be Long

Group N

Helter Skelter
Savoy Truffle
All You Need is Love

Ficheall

Group M
When I'm 64
Got to Get You Into My Life
For No One


Group N
I'll Follow the Sun
Girl
Carry That Weight

Zaph

Group M

Getting Better
Got to Get You Into My Life
For No One


Group N

Helter Skelter
Savoy Truffle
All You Need is Love

abff

Group M

Getting Better vs When I'm 64

And I Love Her vs Got to Get You Into My Life

It Won't Be Long vs For No One


Group N

Helter Skelter vs I'll Follow the Sun

Savoy Truffle vs Girl

Carry That Weight vs All You Need is Love

JP Liz V1

]Group M

When I'm 64

Got to Get You Into My Life

It Won't Be Long


Group N

Helter Skelter

Savoy Truffle
All You Need is Love

Arghus

Group M -

Getting Better vs When I'm 64: Because it can't get no worse.

And I Love Her vs Got to Get You Into my Life: And I Love Her is fantastic, GTGYIML is just alright.

It Won't Be Long vs For No One: For No One is first rate real depressing shit. It's great.

Group N -

Helter Skelter vs I'll Follow The Sun: Helter Skelter is a bit of a mad one, so it gets my vote here.

Savoy Truffle vs Girl: I said it during round one that Savoy Truffle is a low key classic, with lots of little elements to like about it. I do like Girl quite a bit as well though too - very cold and weirdly menacing number it is - so I'd be alright with it going through as well, but Savoy Truffle edges it.

Carry That Weight vs All You Need is Love: Carry that Weight is fine, but it's really just a part of a bigger whole, so I'll vote for AYNIL... what an acrynom.

There's a pun in there too.

ShaneU

Group M

When I'm 64
Got to Get You Into My Life
For No One

Group N

Helter Skelter
Girl
All You Need is Love

Collie D

Group M

Getting Better vs When I'm 64
And I Love Her vs Got to Get You Into My Life
It Won't Be Long vs For No One

El Gato De Negocios

Through to the next round

Group M

Getting Better
Got to Get you into my life
For No One


Group N
Helter Skelter
Savoy Truffle
All You Need is Love

El Gato De Negocios

There are 5 pairings left so Im just going to lash them all into this post.

Group O

I Am The Walrus

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t1Jm5epJr10

vs

Honey Pie

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Sr0efOe8yk

The Fool on the Hill

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wsRatIMUSu8

vs

All I've Got to Do

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=anMW41uvb_s

She Came in Through the Bathroom Window

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NVv7IzEVf3M

vs

Cant Buy Me Love

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h3WJiqc_bEs

Michelle

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WoBLi5eE-wY

vs

Magical Mystery Tour

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l8WMGBuNaus

Here Comes The Sun

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xUNqsfFUwhY

vs

All My Loving

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TSpiwK5fig0

Group O

I Am The Walrus vs Honey Pie
The Fool on the Hill vs All I've Got to Do
She Came in Through the Bathroom Window vs Cant Buy Me Love
Michelle vs Magical Mystery Tour
Here Comes The Sun vs All My Loving

ShaneU

Group O

I Am The Walrus vs Honey Pie
The Fool on the Hill vs All I've Got to Do
She Came in Through the Bathroom Window vs Cant Buy Me Love
Michelle vs Magical Mystery Tour
Here Comes The Sun vs All My Loving

Rigor Mortis

I Am The Walrus
The Fool on the Hill
She Came in Through the Bathroom Window
Magical mystery tour
Here Comes The Sun

Collie D

Group O

I Am The Walrus vs Honey Pie
The Fool on the Hill vs All I've Got to Do
She Came in Through the Bathroom Window vs Cant Buy Me Love
Michelle vs Magical Mystery Tour
Here Comes The Sun vs All My Loving