Vote - Best Animation of 2004

ixoy

Vote for the Best Animation of 2004. Although I think I can safely predict the winner in this category...

Stark

Is it Shark Tale?

My choices are
1) Shrek 2
2) The Incredibles

Basq

Think 'The Incredibles' will walk this - got my vote!

weerez

basquille wrote:

Think 'The Incredibles' will walk this - got my vote!

I agree

pickarooney

shrek 2 shades it for me (and not over a shark's tale)

Raoul Duke

Is there even much point in voting here?

Mimikyu

This post has been deleted.

pickarooney

Actually, is this category for the best animation (technical achievement) or best animated film (artistic merit)?

Gilgamesh

thikn this should be called 'Best CG Movie of 2004' seems to be more appropreate (sp?)

weerez

pickarooney wrote:

Actually, is this category for the best animation (technical achievement) or best animated film (artistic merit)?

In either case The Incredibles is the best by a mile. Shrek 2 and Shark Tale base their humour too much on pop culture.

ixoy

pickarooney wrote:

Actually, is this category for the best animation (technical achievement) or best animated film (artistic merit)?

Best Animated Feature. I'm not bothered doing technical awards.

Gilgamesh wrote:

thikn this should be called 'Best CG Movie of 2004' seems to be more appropreate (sp?)

I don't think so. I'm taking my cue from the Oscars - it's the best animated feature category. People were free to nominate more traditional fare like "Home on the Range" and it would have been here if there was the appropriate response. It's just a reflection of the current trend in animation that all the nominees are CG affairs.

Lump

Shrek 2.... Funniest there and the animation is great too.


John