Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie

Classic insurance - companies & brokers

1141517192038

Comments

  • Registered Users Posts: 132 ✭✭pachanco


    Just reading through the policy document,which applies to my current policy regarding "salvage rights".

    Policy document- concours classic car insurance. AXA insurance

    Except where a vehicle is stolen and not recovered, when we settle a claim as a total loss we will normally allow you to keep the salvage and will reduce the amount we pay you to reflect the value of that salvage. However we retain the right to own the salvage if we so decide.

    And

    Unless we have expressly agreed the value of your vehicle with You, we will not pay more for a claim than the market value of the vehicle immediately prior to the loss or damage, and in any event we will not pay more than the value advised by You to Us.


  • Moderators, Motoring & Transport Moderators Posts: 2,957 Mod ✭✭✭✭macplaxton


    Having had a theft claim with AXA on a standard motor policy (but with a classic), I was able to retain to the salvage, so I could gut it before weighing it in.

    Also due to a third party running into my (10 year old) car last year, I kept the salvage of that too.

    In the first case, the car was stuck in the pound until Garda had done with their bit, then I had to pay to get it transported back to the house along with a couple of days of storage (AXA paid the storage until the Garda had released it, I had to pay from that point)

    In the second case, I sorted getting the car recovered to my house. Unless I never want to see it again, I won't let them shift it to their "preferred repairers" and run up costs if I don't decide to use them.


  • Registered Users Posts: 132 ✭✭pachanco


    macplaxton wrote: »
    Having had a theft claim with AXA on a standard motor policy (but with a classic), I was able to retain to the salvage, so I could gut it before weighing it in.

    Also due to a third party running into my (10 year old) car last year, I kept the salvage of that too.

    In the first case, the car was stuck in the pound until Garda had done with their bit, then I had to pay to get it transported back to the house along with a couple of days of storage (AXA paid the storage until the Garda had released it, I had to pay from that point)

    In the second case, I sorted getting the car recovered to my house. Unless I never want to see it again, I won't let them shift it to their "preferred repairers" and run up costs if I don't decide to use them.

    Thanks for the information regarding your experience with how Axa dealt with the salvage in your case. That's a run of bad luck you've had there for sure.

    Also that's interesting that you mentioned that your classic was insured on a standard policy with Axa. I made inquiries about having a classic car as my main car before with Axa and I was told it was a no go. Perhaps they've changed the rules recently. (last year I inquired) I note that you had two cars so perhaps that explains how you managed to get the classic insured on a standard policy. I asked about it in the local Axa office, perhaps I should have contacted somebody in the classic car department.

    Are you able to share any more detail on the conditions of this policy. I presume you are not restricted with mileage limitations etc. Was your classic of the age that it would require an nct or was it pre 1980 If it was nct exempt were you required to furnish an engineers report before cover commenced?

    I'm sure I'm not the only one who wouldn't mind hearing further details of how you insured your classic on a standard policy, if you don't mind sharing of course.


  • Moderators, Motoring & Transport Moderators Posts: 2,957 Mod ✭✭✭✭macplaxton


    Well underwriting criteria changes but at the time, 2007, AXA and Hibernian were game to insure a 34 year-old car on a standard motor policy. My hand was forced at the time to get "normal" insurance as there were no specialist policies for a main vehicle/unlimited mileage classic.

    1203144417_89f0509deb_z.jpg?zz=1
    DAF 66 SL now 73D978 by macplaxton, on Flickr

    This was my main and old car at the time and was costing ~€400. The vehicle was initially insured for €750 (well market value, but they asked). On renewal as there was no way of doing "agreed value", the only course of action was to aim high and it was down for €2500 (or €2250, can't remember) partly as a reflection of the work put into it and partly given the more expensive Irish used car market.

    It was stolen from outside my house in Lucan and got as far as Liffey Valley. Reported it, then I borrowed a car to get to work down at Grange Castle (5am) and driving the work lorry back up another road I found the car before ever hearing from the Garda. Phoned the location in, but could not wait around for them to turn up. Again I reported it to a motorcycle cop in town. Eventually found out Irish Towing had it, but wouldn't be released pending Garda technical Investigation (2 days).

    2847613339_2e80331d1a_z.jpg?zz=1
    p9110014 by macplaxton, on Flickr

    When it came to the crunch, I was initially offered €1500 which I declined as too low. The assessor didn't really know where to start as market value on an usual car is hard enough to work out, so I guess he was working backwards from the declared market value. As there was no hope of getting a replacement regardless of money within a reasonable timescale, I did express an interest that an alternative turn-key/tested car was an option and I had one in mind for £1400 (~€1800 at the time) and that I really wanted to retain salvage given the work/parts I'd put into the car. It was agreed that a cheque for €1750 would suffice (€2000 PAV (pre-accident value) less €250 salvage).

    Hopped on a boat and bought a 1978 Citroen GS which I still have.

    Whilst AXA still look at stuff over 15 years old, Aviva doesn't entertain it now. I also see from the current AXA policy wording the following:

    "Salvage (if your car is written off)
    We will settle your claim by replacing your car or by paying the market value (or purchase price of your car whichever is the lower) of your car before it was damaged. As part of settling your claim, your car will become our property and you must send us the vehicle licensing document and keys. We will be entitled to take possession of and dispose of your damaged car, at any time during the course of a claim. If we know that your car is covered by a hire purchase or contract-hire agreement, we will pay any claim to the owner described in the agreement."

    If I find an old t&c's booklet I'll see what the wording was at the time. I suspect it was similar. I guess as long as they don't lose money on the salvage and you make your interest known before anything else is agreed, you'll stand the best chance of keeping it.

    I took the insurance out in the Lucan office. For the initial business, AXA required a NCT or engineer's report. It was NCT exempt at the time, but they were happy to take a current MOT in lieu. For the further renewals I didn't have to produce any NCTs or engineer's reports. There was no mileage restrictions, it was a main and only vehicle. The price was similar if not more expensive than run-of-the-mill stuff. (Certainly way more than £105 a year I was paying for two cars on a comprehensive classic policy as a main/only/unlimited mileage vehicle in the UK!)

    I did have the Citroen with AXA for a short while, but as the premium crept up, I moved to First Ireland, who would insure it as a main/only car, but with a mileage restriction max 10k miles p.a. Then I got a modern to move the classics onto "second car" policies with them and instead of paying €600, it was nearer €230. I did have four cars insured at one point and it was base premium + about €60-70 for each extra added.


    Third party crashing into me (Non-fault) other party's insurance (AIG) paid me PAV €5500 on a 9 year-old Honda Jazz 1.4SE CVT less €1440 salvage, a uneconomic write-off, I kept it as it was repairable (n/s frontal damage) and the shunt was low-speed and airbags hadn't popped.


    In attempt to save some cash last year, I removed all the vehicle I wasn't using from my classic car policy. Two months later, one got burnt out in storage. €2500 up in smoke...


    Never had a car/motorcycle nicked in the UK, destroyed by fire or paid through the nose for insurance. The only event I can think of was a car of mine was pushed on its side. It wasn't a three-wheeler, but it was a Reliant.


  • Registered Users Posts: 132 ✭✭pachanco


    Thanks Macplaxton, that's some great practical information of how the salvage process works and good to know. It must have been gut wrenching when your car was stolen and crashed.

    And then the uninsured car going up in smoke... I feel your pain.

    Thanks also for updating with annual insurance premiums and terms.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,011 ✭✭✭ht9zni1gs28crp


    Some good reading, on the verge of renewing my classic insurance and its down to the nitty gritty after some initial stupid quotes. The agreed value v market rate policy isn't worth much as it always seems to be superceeded by them 'not paying over the current market rates' get out clause....

    Mine is high €300's point at moment.....anyone else to try beyond Autoline and First Ireland?


  • Registered Users Posts: 132 ✭✭pachanco


    These are the companies that I called when looking for quotes, I suppose they are all worth a call and you can decide then, which policy suits you best.



    Autoline (broker) cover through Allianz 028 7034 4321

    http://www.autoline.co.uk/Motor-Insurance/Classic-Car-Insurance


    Axa 1890 200 016

    https://www.axa.ie/car-insurance/classic-car/


    Barrett Dunlaoghaire (broker) cover through Chubb 01 284 5401

    http://bprivateinsurances.com/


    Brophys Portlaoise (broker) cover through Axa 057 868 2130

    http://www.brophys.ie/


    Campion Portlaoise (broker) cover through FBD 057 862 2100

    https://www.campionins.com/vintage-classic-insurance/


    Carole Nash (broker) cover through Ageas 1800 800 843

    https://ireland.carolenash.com/classic-car-insurance/


    FBD 01 7617 617 or 1890 617 617

    https://www.fbd.ie/car-insurance/


    First Ireland (broker) cover through AIG 01 882 0818

    http://www.firstireland.ie/index-2-personal-classic.php


  • Registered Users Posts: 466 ✭✭phester28


    Bad news went through the list looking for a quote on a 98 BMW. None of the above would quote as the car now needs to be at least 20 years. (some said 25 Years) and it could not be your only car.

    I have asked when did this change but I got the short shift. When I mentioned people are all over the web saying that they are getting quotes for cars older than 15 years I was told I was lying. ?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 269 ✭✭Lellostag


    phester28 wrote: »
    Bad news went through the list looking for a quote on a 98 BMW. None of the above would quote as the car now needs to be at least 20 years. (some said 25 Years) and it could not be your only car.

    I have asked when did this change but I got the short shift. When I mentioned people are all over the web saying that they are getting quotes for cars older than 15 years I was told I was lying. ?
    Hi phester,
    My advice would be to go and talk to them in person at their offices, I was advised to do that by an AXA sales rep I spoke to on the phone inquiring about classic car insurance for my '95 Starlet. At least the rep said it shouldn't be a problem, but they AXA seemingly won't do classic car insurance over the phone... I haven't been to their offices yet as there is no mad rush for me, but you should definitely try doing it in person and hopefully that'll resolve your insurance issues.
    Good luck!


  • Registered Users Posts: 466 ✭✭phester28


    95 would be over the 20 year limit so they will talk to you. I got a call back as I requested to know when it changed. and they were adamant that it has always been a 20 year limit. that was axa.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 269 ✭✭Lellostag


    phester28 wrote: »
    95 would be over the 20 year limit so they will talk to you. I got a call back as I requested to know when it changed. and they were adamant that it has always been a 20 year limit. that was axa.
    Yeah I know, the problem seem to be more with it being a Japanese car and not so much with its age... Most insurance companies just point blank refuse classic car insurance for a Starlet out of principle. A broker previously agreed such insurance for me but their underwriter then refused it on the grounds that a Japanese car isn't considered a classic car... They probably just don't break down often enough!! :)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 797 ✭✭✭cplwhisper


    phester28 wrote: »
    95 would be over the 20 year limit so they will talk to you. I got a call back as I requested to know when it changed. and they were adamant that it has always been a 20 year limit. that was axa.

    Anchor car for AXA Concours policy is 25yr old car and any additional car(s) can be as young as 20years young... Same rule for last 13yrs .

    Jap cars like starlets/civics/subarus etc are not acceptable anymore(they were for a while) but due to customers abusing the policy terms it was stopped) - a 95 Civic was insured as standard 1.4 granny car but Lambo doors, 1.6 type R running gear and fully mods later is just 1 example why now exempt .. Almera was a pulser 2.0 gtiR


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 269 ✭✭Lellostag


    Jap cars like starlets/civics/subarus etc are not acceptable anymore(they were for a while) but due to customers abusing the policy terms it was stopped) - a 95 Civic was insured as standard 1.4 granny car but Lambo doors, 1.6 type R running gear and fully mods later is just 1 example why now exempt .. Almera was a pulser 2.0 gtiR

    Which of course goes to show that insurance companies rather discriminate against ALL drivers (regardless of driver's age and impeccable no claims history) of older Japanese cars instead of assessing each case on their own individual merit. If they suspect foul play in regards to the originality of the car they could just demand a third party assessment of the car, like the AA, NCTS or some other suitable organization, at the customer's expense to ensure that there are no mods done to the car in question.

    Then again it is of course much easier to just blindly assume every Starlet or Civic owner is a hooligan driving around like they've stolen the car.... ;)


  • Registered Users Posts: 466 ✭✭phester28


    I got a quote of normal insurance of the 1.8i E36 BMW of 960 euro. Fully clean license. She was trying to make out that that was with several discounts on top of it. Somewhere in the region of 20% discounts and that does not include the no claims discount of the max 50%.

    So in all an old car for a noob on the ncb scale would be somewhere in the region of €2000


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 797 ✭✭✭cplwhisper


    Yes there are individual exceptions to some jap cars... we have a Mazda Rx1 and few limited cars so any idea/wish list cars then please let me know by PM and I'll assist where I can


  • Registered Users Posts: 20 j<>c


    pachanco wrote: »
    These are the companies that I called when looking for quotes, I suppose they are all worth a call and you can decide then, which policy suits you best.



    Autoline (broker) cover through Allianz 028 7034 4321

    http://www.autoline.co.uk/Motor-Insurance/Classic-Car-Insurance


    Axa 1890 200 016

    https://www.axa.ie/car-insurance/classic-car/


    Barrett Dunlaoghaire (broker) cover through Chubb 01 284 5401

    http://bprivateinsurances.com/


    Brophys Portlaoise (broker) cover through Axa 057 868 2130

    http://www.brophys.ie/


    Campion Portlaoise (broker) cover through FBD 057 862 2100

    https://www.campionins.com/vintage-classic-insurance/


    Carole Nash (broker) cover through Ageas 1800 800 843

    https://ireland.carolenash.com/classic-car-insurance/


    FBD 01 7617 617 or 1890 617 617

    https://www.fbd.ie/car-insurance/


    First Ireland (broker) cover through AIG 01 882 0818

    http://www.firstireland.ie/index-2-personal-classic.php

    Wow "pachanco" thank you so much for all your effort on this thread. It is very much appreciated. How do you find the time! Pachanco for moderator!!:)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 797 ✭✭✭cplwhisper


    Email for Axa Concours is also Paul.callaghan@axa.ie as phone lines can be costly and sometimes sloooooowwww


  • Registered Users Posts: 30 Glencree


    Looking to get classic insured, (have own policy...daily car)anyone know if any policies allow 2nd driver? Looking to buy from inlaws, but they want visitation rights for the occasional spin.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,033 ✭✭✭Silvera


    Glencree wrote: »
    Looking to get classic insured, (have own policy...daily car)anyone know if any policies allow 2nd driver? Looking to buy from inlaws, but they want visitation rights for the occasional spin.

    I have a classic policy (2 x cars) via Autoline and a friend is covered as a named driver (inclusive in price...additional drivers would be a small extra charge). They're nice people to deal with too!

    Autoline (broker) cover through Allianz 028 7034 4321

    http://www.autoline.co.uk/Motor-Insu...-Car-Insurance


  • Registered Users Posts: 132 ✭✭pachanco


    I'm sure most companies, will cover your situation. If I'm understanding you right, you want to have your in laws as named drivers on your policy. As Silvera has stated there will be an extra charge with some companies for this and the named drivers will usually have to meet certain criteria set out by the insurance company.

    The campions policy I came across during my research offered open driving for all drivers 25-71, so might be worth a call too, depends what type of cover you're after really.

    pachanco wrote: »
    Contacted Campions Insurance broker

    Insurance through FBD

    MGB Roadster 1800 cc : Value €6000

    As my car is a Roadster (convertible) they will only insure third party only. They didn't ask the value.

    Membership of a classic car club is mandatory. They can offer membership through themselves to IVETA for €25.

    Third party only
    No breakdown or windscreen cover

    5000 miles : €125

    Interestingly the cover includes open driving for all drivers 25-71 years of age with three or less penalty points and no claims or convictions etc.

    My car is 1979 and nct exempt, because there are no modifications, no engineers report is required.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,525 ✭✭✭Titzon Toast


    I'm waiting on First Ireland to get back to me today about a classic quote for my 97 Prelude, I rang Campions the other day and they refused to quote me because it's a Honda, it didn't matter a bit to them that it's a completely stock, Irish car.

    The guy I'm dealing with @ First Ireland seems very helpful, I had to send him some pictures of the car to show the underwriters that it's not modded.

    I have two policies already running, one commercial, one private, fingers crossed they'll play ball with me.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,105 ✭✭✭hi5


    Contact Honda Ireland to let them know their cars are being discriminated against by insurance companies.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,033 ✭✭✭Silvera


    hi5 wrote: »
    Contact Honda Ireland to let them know their cars are being discriminated against by insurance companies.

    They - like most distributors - wont care as their interest lies with new / nearly new vehicles.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,525 ✭✭✭Titzon Toast


    LIGHTNING wrote: »
    Campion insured my 1991 Honda with no questions asked.

    They wouldn't even quote me. They didn't want to know.
    I'm 37, full licence 13 years, and two policies already out in my own name.
    Here's my car, same as it left the factory.


  • Moderators, Motoring & Transport Moderators Posts: 2,957 Mod ✭✭✭✭macplaxton


    Silvera wrote: »
    They - like most distributors - wont care as their interest lies with new / nearly new vehicles.

    True, but changing the query slightly, where do they get their insurance cover from? Haven't Universal Honda Ltd got a 1978 Civic? I'm sure I've seen it both inside and outside the building at City West.

    95819_60_news_hub_multi_630x0.JPG


  • Registered Users Posts: 418 ✭✭quattro777


    I need to get my cars independently valued for Autoline's agreed value policy.

    Who does this in Ireland?


  • Registered Users Posts: 44 rhino1


    It is an absolute disgrace that blanket bans are allowed.Who decides that a Ford Escort is a classic but a honda Prelude is not.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 269 ✭✭Lellostag


    quattro777 wrote: »
    I need to get my cars independently valued for Autoline's agreed value policy.

    Who does this in Ireland?
    Depending on the car my guess some classic car club might be able to help with that. Are you a member of classic car club, and what's the car you need to get valued?


  • Registered Users Posts: 418 ✭✭quattro777


    Lellostag wrote: »
    Depending on the car my guess some classic car club might be able to help with that. Are you a member of classic car club, and what's the car you need to get valued?

    I'm a member of the IVS.

    Audi 200
    NSU Ro80
    Eunos Cosmo


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 269 ✭✭Lellostag


    quattro777 wrote: »
    Lellostag wrote: »
    Depending on the car my guess some classic car club might be able to help with that. Are you a member of classic car club, and what's the car you need to get valued?

    I'm a member of the IVS.

    Audi 200
    NSU Ro80
    Eunos Cosmo
    Nice collection! Contact your club coordinators and they should be able to advice you best on how to get your cars valued.


Advertisement