Roy Carroll is a Clown!

LegacyUser · 15-05-2005 3:12pm #1

He has just ****ed up AGAIN against Southampton.

:eek:

Chong · 15-05-2005 3:13pm

No suprises there then, as a manu fan I hope southampton win.

LegacyUser · 15-05-2005 3:16pm

HE HAS JUST ALMOST DONE IT AGAIN! He came out in a one on one at the corner of the box towards the right hand corner flag and he could not get the ball. OMG HE IS DREADFUL!

zAbbo · 15-05-2005 3:18pm

Someone explain exactly what happened.

He is indeed a no talent ass clown

LegacyUser · 15-05-2005 3:34pm

For the goal, it was a corner, Le Saux whipped in a ball, he ran out to paff it with his hands but he missed and it then went in off O'Sheas leg.

eirebhoy · 15-05-2005 3:56pm

Must be one of those days. Rab Douglas tried to catch the ball 3 times today and dropped it each time.

thejollyrodger · 15-05-2005 4:11pm

haha carroll the clown !!

unlucky for any man utd supporters out there but funny as fúck.

impr0v · 15-05-2005 5:36pm

cheesedude wrote:

For the goal, it was a corner, Le Saux whipped in a ball, he ran out to paff it with his hands but he missed and it then went in off O'Sheas leg.

It was an ill-advised rush from goal, but in fairness to him a defender took it away from him with their head, brown or fortune, didn't get a good look.

Pigman II · 15-05-2005 6:24pm

I don't think Chelsea would have even managed 3rd this year with that ass in goal.

quarryman · 15-05-2005 6:46pm

other than those two mistakes he had a great game.

judge his entire performance before referring to the guy as an "ass-clown".

The Muppet · 15-05-2005 6:51pm

quarryman wrote:

other than those two mistakes he had a great game.

judge his entire performance before referring to the guy as an "ass-clown".

Thats the problem with Roy. He can be very good but is always liable to gift a goal by a sloppy mistake which he does too often to be number one keeper at United IMHO.

LegacyUser · 15-05-2005 7:05pm

I don't get what is going on to be honest. Surely they knew he was pants years ago...

Jivin Turkey · 15-05-2005 7:15pm

quarryman wrote:

other than those two mistakes he had a great game.

judge his entire performance before referring to the guy as an "ass-clown".

If a keeper gifts a one goal to the opposition, and almost gifts another, no matter how well he does in the rest of the game I wouldnt say he had a good game.

Its a harsh position to play in, but thats the criticism you have to take. He is not good enough for a club with Uniteds aspirations. He makes mistakes that are taking points about every two or three games he plays.

LegacyUser · 15-05-2005 7:26pm

And goalkeeping errors have fundamentally cost Utd or have had an influence on them being knocked out in Europe. How the hell did Jerzy Dudek get so lucky? he is just as pants I reckon.

Jivin Turkey · 15-05-2005 7:27pm

cheesedude wrote:

And goalkeeping errors have fundamentally cost Utd or have had an influence on them being knocked out in Europe. How the hell did Jerzy Dudek get so lucky? he is just as pants I reckon.

Dudek is a better keeper than Carroll. His problem is that generally his mistakes come in more high profile games so they are scrutinised more.

LegacyUser · 15-05-2005 7:30pm

I rate Timmy Howlard/Roy Caroll/Jerzy Dudek and Lehmann all in the same category for slightly different reasons. Clowns!!!!

PHB · 15-05-2005 7:35pm

Dudek is a lot more consistant and better than Caroll.

I think Howard should be brought back in for the FA Cup

I think the United goal will be under lots of pressure and Howard is a better shot stopper

Dcully · 15-05-2005 9:12pm

LOL certainly a fun time for Man u

DoctorEdgeWild · 15-05-2005 9:25pm

Throughout the season I have thought that Roy Carroll was the better keeper in the United squad but now I'm not too sure. Anyone know what the story with Ricardo is? I know he's 34 and I think I saw a quote from him which was basically saying that he is great and wasted at United.

There seems to be a lack of good goalkeepers in world football today. Is this my ignorance or is there a genuine shortage of keepers?

The PSV goalkeeper Gomes is the only one who springs to mind who might even become available over the Summer.

Guy:Incognito · 15-05-2005 9:40pm

Surely Given must be available to anyone half decent.

Sponge Bob · 15-05-2005 10:35pm

DoctorEdgeWild wrote:

There seems to be a lack of good goalkeepers in world football today. Is this my ignorance or is there a genuine shortage of keepers?

In rich countries , yes, Lots of them in Eastern Europe .

Cech, Dudek, Niemi are a few come to mind. Cech was worth 5 yards to Chelsea all season .

LegacyUser · 15-05-2005 10:50pm

The Espanyol keeper is good. Kameni...young and i doubt he would cost that much.

Guy:Incognito · 15-05-2005 11:47pm

I'd imagine Cudicini will be moving in the summer aswell. So thats two very good ones in th epremiership.

Lex Luthor · 16-05-2005 8:33am

I'm not a fan of Given.....Cudicini would be a safer buy.

cournioni · 16-05-2005 9:35am

Cudicini is prone to his mistakes aswell. I think that if United are to win anything we'll need a keeper like Buffon, Casillas or Kameni and only one of those seem to be available at the moment. United should go for him because the keepers look like they are more interested in Circus jokes rather than keeping the ball out of the net.

elbow316 · 16-05-2005 9:40am

Surely Given must be available to anyone half decent.

Given appears the be the last player left who is actually loyal to his club....regardless of how much they screw up

Reckon he should have left 2 or 3 years ago and went to Arsenal or United....fair enough he still gets credit for being a top keeper but he'll have no medals to show for it.

_blank_ · 16-05-2005 2:04pm

The thing about Given is this injury he has, is it his hip?

I don't think United would be interested.

The Espanyol goalkeeper looks a class act, and would be my choice, him or Cudicini.

The_B_Man · 16-05-2005 3:30pm

Im startin to think that Kiely is better than Given. I think hes had a better season this year.

PS Howard signed a 2 year extension to his contract with United to keep him at Old Trafford til June 2009!!!

BaZmO* · 16-05-2005 4:54pm

The_B_Man wrote:

PS Howard signed a 2 year extension to his contract with United to keep him at Old Trafford til June 2009!!!

I'd say that's more of a back up keeper to whom ever they buy in the summer.

B.

LegacyUser · 16-05-2005 5:07pm

Where is Bannor this week? I bet he has tons of info about everything!!!!!

Chucky the tree · 16-05-2005 6:54pm

seansouth wrote:

The thing about Given is this injury he has, is it his hip?

I don't think United would be interested.

.

that all cleared up now, only time he has been injured in 4 seasons isnt it? not too shabby.

kiely is another excellent keeeper, kept west brom is the premiership yesterday. Niemi is available now aswell.

RObert green and the palace goaly(not even gonna try and spell his name) are both good keepers aswell. If i was a mid-table premiership team or on the way up they are definitly worth a try.

The ipwich keeper has had some excellent performances aswell from the matches i have seen.

case n basket · 16-05-2005 11:25pm

Kameni is a tremendous shot stopper but very erratic and does some crazy stuff, I'm not sure he'd be any more popular than Howard is...

Jivin Turkey · 16-05-2005 11:36pm

case n basket wrote:

Kameni is a tremendous shot stopper but very erratic and does some crazy stuff, I'm not sure he'd be any more popular than Howard is...

Yeah, people seem to be harping on about this fella because he is being linked with whatever club they support.

I havnt seen that much of him, and what I have seen he has looked ok, but in all fairness I wouldnt have a huge amount of confidence in a young African keeper ruling the backline of my team based on one good season in Spain.

Roy Carroll is a Clown!

Comments