The Fall of the Simpsons

astrofool · 08-04-2018 12:22AM

LoughNeagh2017 wrote: »

I stopped taking following it when they made a jab about Northern Ireland saying "the Northern Irish are parading as well" something like that on a St Patricks Day episode maybe 10 years ago and they showed a load of orangemen, they assumed that all people from Northern Ireland were orangemen and Protestant. You know what some of us northerners are like, we don't forget little jabs like that. I didn't understand the joke, why wouldn't they be parading? St. Patrick is the patron saint of Northern Ireland isn't he?

I think you just summed up the problems in Northern Ireland rather than the Simpsons (i.e. everything is taken too seriously, normally I don't elaborate on my posts, assuming people will get it, but better to be more precise for this one).

PTH2009 · 08-04-2018 12:25AM

Will always watch the Simpsons no matter how ****e it gets. It will be a sad day when the last episode airs (it has to come someday)

Some classic moments which will never go out of date

Timelines are confusing as one min Marge and homer grew up in the 70s, then there's episodes where homer and marge were teens in the 90s

johnnyyesno · 08-04-2018 08:40AM

PTH2009 wrote: »

Will always watch the Simpsons no matter how ****e it gets. It will be a sad day when the last episode airs (it has to come someday)

Some classic moments which will never go out of date

Timelines are confusing as one min Marge and homer grew up in the 70s, then there's episodes where homer and marge were teens in the 90s

Thats the last "new" episode I watched, I gave up in despair after that, messing with the established Simpsons backstory.

briany · 08-04-2018 11:28AM

PTH2009 wrote: »

Timelines are confusing as one min Marge and homer grew up in the 70s, then there's episodes where homer and marge were teens in the 90s

Nothing confusing about it. It's called a sliding timescale, and it's a device a lot of animated shows have employed to keep their characters both ageless, while still living in the contemporary world.

It made perfect sense that Homer and Marge met in the 70s from the point of view of an episode from 1992. It makes no sense that they met in the 70s from the point of view of an ep from 2010. That is, if you also accept the characters are still both mid to late 30s.

I think why retconning rankles fans of the Simpsons so much is because it feels like crappy new Simpsons is not only being crappy, but is now encroaching on their beloved classic episodes in a tangible way. Though I would say that it's an animated show, and the concept of canon shouldn't be taken too seriously.

Funnily enough, the show really started to tank when the idea of Marge and Homer hooking in the 70s became increasingly untenable, given their respective ages. I wonder if there's a connection there... :pac:

09-04-2018 11:47AM

https://mashable.com/2018/04/09/the-simpsons-respond-apu/#GyaTl_NXJsqI

Apu is offending the SJW's

Mrcaramelchoc · 09-04-2018 11:50AM

When the hell are they going to stop it falling.cancel it and put it out of its misery.its like flogging a dead horse making any more episodes.

McLoughlin · 09-04-2018 12:35PM

Mrcaramelchoc wrote: »

When the hell are they going to stop it falling.cancel it and put it out of its misery.its like flogging a dead horse making any more episodes.

Well it keeps making money so why stop ? The Disney buying Fox deal if its passed might have some kind of impact on the show but its hard to say.

It is signed up till Season 30 in 2019 and after that who knows ?

DyldeBrill · 09-04-2018 12:40PM

The show went downhill ever since Conan O'Brien left as a writer. God, that man is funny...

The Simpsons of today is pure and utter trash.

razorblunt · 09-04-2018 12:58PM

Look, I'm a fan of The Simpsons, always have been, always will be.
I'll watch any of the episode, will I think some new ones are crap? Of course. Most of them? Probably.
Will I enjoy other new episodes? Yes. Will I recall the episode, scenes, and gags? Probably not.

But I'm in a much different place now, I was 10 in 95, I could sit down and watch 4 episodes back to back without a care in the world. Now I'm lucky to watch one. For this reason I rarely catch new ones "live" but I do on catch up.

There has been a trend though in the newer epsiodes and I use "newer" for the last 15 years or so where they really force jokes. Hard to explain, but they always try to add in another joke on top of it. I also hate it when they're singing it's just crap and filler e.g. when they're off to the steakhouse (turns out its Sideshow Bob setting a trap).

I do think they've improved the overall content by shortening the episode and adding in an additional scene that may or may not be related to the episode.

bucketybuck · 09-04-2018 01:20PM

McLoughlin wrote: »

Well it keeps making money so why stop ?

The bit that confuses me is how it is still making all this money?

The only relevance the Simpsons have had for about 15 years now is articles and discussions online about how bad it got and exactly when it jumped the shark, I've seen this topic discussed more times then I've had hot breakfasts. So who is still buying all the merchandise and watching all the new episodes?

Mutant z · 09-04-2018 01:30PM

I still watch it from time to time but not to the extent i used to and the classic episodes will always be there for us to enjoy but the fact remains it has dragged on for far too long and needs to come to its natural conclusion its had its time to shine but like most things the shine eventually starts to burn out.

valoren · 10-04-2018 09:05AM

LoughNeagh2017 wrote: »

I stopped taking following it when they made a jab about Northern Ireland saying "the Northern Irish are parading as well" something like that on a St Patricks Day episode maybe 10 years ago and they showed a load of orangemen, they assumed that all people from Northern Ireland were orangemen and Protestant. You know what some of us northerners are like, we don't forget little jabs like that. I didn't understand the joke, why wouldn't they be parading? St. Patrick is the patron saint of Northern Ireland isn't he?

The Prohibition episode had a deleted scene where everyone is getting pissed at the Parade and it cuts to "John Bulls Fish & Chip Shop" emblazoned with the Union Jack which then promptly explodes and to which everyone cheers. It was cut when shown here and in the UK.

Thargor · 10-04-2018 09:26AM

I saw that scene loads of times on RTE 2 back in the day.

Murdoc90 · 10-04-2018 09:30AM

How is it rating in America these days? My guess would be still well enough?

10-04-2018 09:35AM

valoren wrote: »

The Prohibition episode had a deleted scene where everyone is getting pissed at the Parade and it cuts to "John Bulls Fish & Chip Shop" emblazoned with the Union Jack which then promptly explodes and to which everyone cheers. It was cut when shown here and in the UK.

Yeah it's not always cut.

Franz Von Peppercorn · 10-04-2018 09:38AM

Apparently there’s a huge controversy in the US about the Apu character. Racist etc. Whites are treated well, apparently, if you ignore the laziness of homer, the dysfunction of most of the town, and all the ethnic jokes against ethnic whites.

Oafley Jones · 10-04-2018 09:38AM

DyldeBrill wrote: »

The show went downhill ever since Conan O'Brien left as a writer. God, that man is funny...

The Simpsons of today is pure and utter trash.

+1 Also, John Swartzwelder. His Frank Burley books are great (although diminishing returns rears its head here as well). They're essentially Homer the detective. I love the opening of "Dead Men Scare Me Stupid"...

Well, they found Amelia Earhart. That's the good news. Unfortunately, they found her in the trunk of my car. Boy, was my face red. I had a lot of explaining to do there. And after I had explained everything, they didn't believe me! You probably won't believe me either, come to think of it. Sometimes I wonder why I bother.

It all began a few month ago. I was in the middle of a murder investigation.

"SOMEONE IN THIS STADIUM IS THE KILLER...Killer...killer," I announced over the PA system.

A mighty roar of surprise and anger went up.

pickarooney · 10-04-2018 10:36AM

Franz Von Peppercorn wrote: »

Apparently there’s a huge controversy in the US about the Apu character. Racist etc. Whites are treated well, apparently, if you ignore the laziness of homer, the dysfunction of most of the town, and all the ethnic jokes against ethnic whites.

Jesus, imagine if everyone got that upset about every badly-done accent on The Simpsons.

Sephiroth_dude · 10-04-2018 01:08PM

One of my favorite scenes is this

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3pf_eW8Qnsw

"Right, no reporters".

Utopia Parkway · 10-04-2018 02:20PM

Franz Von Peppercorn wrote: »

Apparently there’s a huge controversy in the US about the Apu character. Racist etc. Whites are treated well, apparently, if you ignore the laziness of homer, the dysfunction of most of the town, and all the ethnic jokes against ethnic whites.

Haven't watched any new Simpsons in ages but Apu was always one of the better balanced characters in the show conmpared to how dysfunctional most of the rest were. Is this latest outrage purely because he has an Indian accent?

Unearthly · 10-04-2018 02:22PM

Example of the fake outrage modern world. Think there were a few sensitive souls offended by some things in Friends when they watched it last year on Netflix

EagererBeaver · 10-04-2018 02:25PM

LoughNeagh2017 wrote: »

I stopped taking following it when they made a jab about Northern Ireland saying "the Northern Irish are parading as well" something like that on a St Patricks Day episode maybe 10 years ago and they showed a load of orangemen, they assumed that all people from Northern Ireland were orangemen and Protestant. You know what some of us northerners are like, we don't forget little jabs like that. I didn't understand the joke, why wouldn't they be parading? St. Patrick is the patron saint of Northern Ireland isn't he?

A bit of a sad reaction to be honest.

riffmongous · 10-04-2018 02:51PM

I still watch the new ones if they are on, usually I put them on in the background. Sure the vast, vast majority of them are poor or just plain terrible, but there have been quite a few episodes that I have really enjoyed since season 11. And if I had to choose between getting to see those few episodes or the Simpsons having been 'put out of its misery' or whatever back in S10/11, it's a pretty straightforward choice. If you don't like it fine, but there is absolutely zero tangible benefit to it being shut down, every one episode that is good justifies it's existence.

Go Harvey Go · 10-04-2018 04:47PM

Mutant z wrote: »

I still watch it from time to time but not to the extent i used to and the classic episodes will always be there for us to enjoy but the fact remains it has dragged on for far too long and needs to come to its natural conclusion its had its time to shine but like most things the shine eventually starts to burn out.

Its natural conclusion was in the late '90s.

Season 8's "The Old Man and the Lisa" could have been a good final episode - ending with Homer suffering one final heart attack and dying.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AE33fbM6fqQ

riffmongous wrote: »

If you don't like it fine, but there is absolutely zero tangible benefit to it being shut down, every one episode that is good justifies it's existence.

Might have to agree to disagree with you on that one.

A 22-episode series, with one good episode and the other 21 all being poor at best, doesn't really justify its existence IMHO.

lorcand1990 · 10-04-2018 04:53PM

Go Harvey Go wrote: »

Its natural conclusion was in the late '90s.

Season 8's "The Old Man and the Lisa" could have been a good final episode - ending with Homer suffering one final heart attack and dying.

If you ended the Simpsons there, you would have missed out on one of the best episodes ever- Homer's Enemy. Definitely worth sticking around a bit longer to get that episode in!

Royale with Cheese · 10-04-2018 05:02PM

Funny how you don't see any prominent Scottish-American immigrants complaining about the portrayal of groundskeeper Willy. Why do these things only draw outrage when skin colour is involved?

dan1895 · 10-04-2018 05:20PM

Royale with Cheese wrote: »

Funny how you don't see any prominent Scottish-American immigrants complaining about the portrayal of groundskeeper Willy. Why do these things only draw outrage when skin colour is involved?

Haven't heard any slack jawed yokels complaining either.

Go Harvey Go · 10-04-2018 05:26PM

lorcand1990 wrote: »

If you ended the Simpsons there, you would have missed out on one of the best episodes ever- Homer's Enemy. Definitely worth sticking around a bit longer to get that episode in!

Unless, of course, you rearranged the order so that "The Old Man and the Lisa" aired *after* that episode and "The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson".

As I said before, Fox ultimately decided that the show must go on while it remains profitable. Troy McClure's words at the end of "The Simpsons 138th Episode Spectacular" turned out to be ominous...

Royale with Cheese wrote: »

Funny how you don't see any prominent Scottish-American immigrants complaining about the portrayal of groundskeeper Willy. Why do these things only draw outrage when skin colour is involved?

Because some people are unbelievably narrow-minded.

:rolleyes: :rolleyes:

riffmongous · 10-04-2018 05:37PM

Go Harvey Go wrote: »

Might have to agree to disagree with you on that one.

A 22-episode series, with one good episode and the other 21 all being poor at best, doesn't really justify its existence IMHO.

Justify it to who though? The people who don't watch it anymore?

I don't look at it as 1 < 21 but rather 1 > 0.

Thargor · 10-04-2018 09:25PM

Deleted User wrote: »

Yeah it's not always cut.

Its like when you hear people saying "Did you know about the banned episode of Star Trek where Data talks about Irish reunification in 2027 as an example of a time terrorism succeeded? The British had it banned and it was never shown over here...", except I remember seeing it on RTE2 and Sky back in the day, where else would you have seen it back then? There was no internet.

The Fall of the Simpsons

Comments

Welcome!