The wondrous adventures of Sinn Fein (part 3) Mod Notes and Threadbanned List in OP

So you call Micheal Martin a fraudster if he doesn't condemn DeValera or Leo Varadkar a Fascist regarding WT Cosgrave, or will they be writing him out like O'Duffy? I wouldn't go so far myself.

Your argument is built on hurt feelings because someone posted a photo of WT Cosgrave giving the Nazi salute at a fascist rally.

The Irish state was friendly with the Nazis, every party. They don't cancel each other out by any means. Difference between aiding for the benefit of your country and being a fascist by ideology.

George Bush was in the Taliban, who knew :)

While they've a lot to be weary of IMO, I'd take them over FF/FG any day.

Because you raised it in another thread and brought it over here because someone posted the photo of Herr Cosgrave.

You then tried to, as you are here, claim it was some natural progression in conversation.

As the face of SF in 2021 MLMD has to own everything SF. If Russell is part of that so be it.

but you have many many posts on here dismissing any notion they ( sf ) have any right to claim lineage back to 1916 , but now you are only to happy to link them to collaborating with nazis , even though in your opinion they are a different party lol

im sure the young people affected by the housing crisis , or those people affected by housing will take in to consideration your deranged ramblings about nazis and the ira when casting there votes by the way

sf now the largest seat share in the dail and you have been telling anyone who will listen about their imminent demise for years , I think you might even be a closet sinn fein vote gatherer lololol

great so you are dismissing their lineage to 1916 , and with it acknowledging the notion of marylou mcd having a Nazi connection ?

also, as you say present day sf can only trace there lineage back to 1970 , that would make them one of the only major big party that didnt have any links or sympathy with nazis

was a tough slog but we got there in the end , another fine mess you got yourself into lol

So do you agree, the current version of Sinn Fein has was created in 1970's with no link back?

Blanch was just pointing out that people cannot have it both ways, trying to link SF to 1916 but then refusing to accept the link to the Nazi.

As I have already said I don't see a link between the Provisional Sinn Fein and any other versions. They got created in 1970 and that is end of it.

In terms of the other conversations about Nazi, well maybe start up a thread on the subject, this is current affairs forum and nothing about nazi is current affairs from what I can see.

im commenting on posts in this thread ,

blanch 152 "This is the problem for Sinn Fein. They want to claim lineage back to 1916, but they want to deny the Nazi collaboration bit in the middle. It turns them into liars."

blanch 152 "If Sinn Fein drop the claim to lineage back to 1916 and the celebration of Sean Russell, I will happily link them to the Nazis."

so I'm quite entitled to comment on it thank you very much .

this exchange started because i correctly said blanch was only to happy to deny an sf lineage to 1916 , but also only to happy to maybe rethink that if he can link sf to nazis

now when i point out the realities of who exactly in dail eirrean historically aligned themselves with nazis , and sent condolences on hitler death it is so uncomfortable , that it is now off topic and I should start a new thread on it ???

you fellas love moving yourselves into some corner and holes lolol

What argument are you talking about? I was trying to discuss the HSE proposal from SF when people headed off down this rabbit hole. If you just want to make up people having arguments with you then off you go. Sorry I can't help you with that